Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAEA Assessment of Utility Condition, Line Loss Study Ouzinkie, Alaska 1990 ECO 057 Alaska Energy Authority ALASKA ENERGY AUTHORITY ASSESSMENT OF UTILITY CONDITION a FAIRBANKS ¢ ANCHORAGE ae 4) OUZINKIE ae , LINE LOSS STUDY OUZINKIE, ALASKA LIBRARY COPY ECO 057 N oO ISSUED TO a TABLE OF CONTENTS LINE LOSS STUDY OUZINKIE, ALASKA Executive Summary Background System Review Conclusions and Recommendations Cost Estimates Photographs speeds A- inkie kW use records July - December 1989 “ w|A N N 18 ECO osT aa Executive Summary: The city of Ouzinkie has a diesel fired power plant and a hydro power plant, located at opposite ends of the town, tied together with a 7.2/12.5 kV overhead distribution system. The monthly power cost equalization reports indicate an average power line loss of approximately 11.5%. This loss is unreasonably high considering the excellent condition of the power distribution system. A survey of the large three phase power consumers turned up the following problems: 1. The station service for the diesel power plant is not metered. 2. The meter in the waste heat recovery facility is improperly wired leading to a 66% low reading. 3. = meter for the dock crane is out of calibration and reads approximately 27% ow. 4. The meter reader has difficulty reading dial register type meters. Addressing the metering en outlined above and providing additional training for the meter reader will in all likelihood reduce the line losses to a reasonable level (5% or less). Background: RSA Engineering, Inc. was given a work order under their open end contract with the Alaska Energy Authority to perform a line loss study for the City of Ouzinkie. RSA Engineering, Inc. hired Craig Thompson of Thompson Engineering, Inc. to perform the actual site visit and provide the initial field report. Mr. Thompson travelled to Ouzinkie on January 5, 1990. Upon arrival, he met with Mayor Zak Chichenoff who arranged for a meeting with Mr. Paul Delgado and Mr. Tom Quick. Mr. Delgado is the power plant operator, and Mr. Quick is the manager of the town store and an ex-lineman who has been assisting the town on most matters related to electrical power generation and distribution. Two basic concerns were expressed by these individuals: 1. They were concerned about the potential loss of Power Cost Equalization (PCE) due to high line losses. According to Mr. Quick, the City has been informed by the Alaska Public Utilities Commission (APUC) in the summer of 1989, that because of the line losses they were experiencing they were in danger of losing their PCE. Mr. Quick began tracking the electrical power generation and sales via a computer — he prepared on his personal computer. He did this by using data collected monthly by the City for electrical billings. The City does not presently have a computer program to use the data they collect for this purpose (the program Mr. Quick put together is on an IBM computer and the City operates an Apple). The city requested technical assistance in getting an energy program up and running on the City computer. 2. They were also concerned about the possible loss of town businesses because of the high cost of electrical energy. They explained that the City is billing energy at a flat rate of 30 cents per kWH and that it has been at this rate for quite some time. They also said that the City needed help to review the existing rates to possibly come up with a new rate structure and assistance in figuring out ways to reduce the present high energy costs. Mr. Thompson explained that he was in Ouzinkie primarily to review the distribution system and metering to determine where the losses were occurring and to make recommendations, including cost estimates, for improvements. He agreed, however, to convey the City’s other concerns in his report. System Review: Copies of the data compiled by Mr. Quick on energy production and use in Ouzinkie for the months of July and September through December 1989 are attached in Appendix A. The data for the month of August was extracted from the July and the September data and is also included in Appendix A. System energy use and losses for July through December 1989 are summarized on the following page. KWH + +}KWH System System KWH Percent Month Production Use Loss _Loss July 48,000 41,767 6,233 12.99 August $1,360 43,589 det tl 15.13 September 52,640 45,842 6,798 12.91 October 56,240 49,871 6,369 11.32 November 57,800 52,326 5,474 9.47 December 59,040 54,827 4,213 7.14 The Ouzinkie power system consists of two power plants tied together through a 7.2/12.5 kV overhead distribution system. The power plants are located at opposite ends of the City. One plant is a single unit small hydroelectric facility (see photographs 1 through 6) located approximately one mile north of the main section of town. e other plant is a two unit modularized diesel fired facility located behind the school (See photos 7 through 10). The system peak is less than 200 kW. After a brief review of the B sad plants and distribution system, it was apparent that a line loss averaging 11.5% is unreasonable. With the low system load and the excellent distribution system (see photos 11 and 12), it was determined that a sizeable portion of the losses Ouzinkie was experiencing were most likely meterin, losses rather than line losses. Using the criteria that a line loss of less than 5% is reasonable for a system the size of Ouzinkie’s, the magnitude of metering error is estimated to average 3,400 kWH per month. Residential consumers average less than 400 kWH per month so, therefore, a review of all three phase, larger consumers, —— installations was undertaken. A discussion of each of these installations ollows: 1. Diesel Plant (see photo 7): The city load was being supplied by the hydro plant at the time the diesel plant was examined, and, therefore, a timing test could not be made to check the accuracy of operation of the plant totalizing meter. The meter multiplier was verified to be correct (200), and the meter connections were correct. The plant operator stated that he is also the meter reader, and he has some difficulty reading the dial _ registers and prefers the cyclometer type registers. e also indicated the City did not have a program for periodically checking the calibration of the plant meters or the other large power meters, and that the City does not own a substitute for every type of meter used in town. Perhaps the most significant item noted during the review of the diesel plant metering is the fact that the station service load (power plant self use) is not metered. The station service load consists of the following: a. Station Lighting: 4 each two tube fluorescent lights b. Day Tank Pump: Fractional horsepower pump that runs intermittently. c. Radiator Fan Motor: A 10 horsepower fan that runs continuously when either of the two diesel units are epee. Nameplate data taken from the fan motor indicated a full load current of 28 Amps. As shown in the following calculations, which estimate energy use for a full month’s operation, the radiator fan motor is probably a significant part of the present line losses: KVAH = (28 Amps/ph * 3ph * 120V * 720 hrs/month) 1000 KVAH = 7,258 KWH = KVAH * power factor nameplate power factor = .82 KWH = 5,952 2. Waste Heat Recovery System: As shown in photo 7 and 10, a waste heat Tecovery system has been installed inside a modular unit adjacent to the diesel power generation plant. This unit utilizes waste heat from the diesel engine’s Jacket water system. An engine driven pump circulates the jacket water through a heat exchanger located in the waste heat module and an electric circulating pump S senterg heat to the school by circulating school heating water through the secondary side of the heat exchanger. As shown in photo 10, the electrical load inside the waste heat module is metered. During the examination of this metering installation, it was found that the return leads for two of the three meter current coils were not connected to ground. In this form 6a type meter, with equal phase loading, this improper connection will result in a 66% error. As the phase loading in the waste heat module is most likely not equal, the actual error may differ. However, if the diesel power plant is supplying the town load and the waste heat Tecovery system is in operation, the aye | error due to one of the 1.5 horsepower pumps could be as high as 1,000 k per month. The waste heat module meter is listed with those read by the City every month, but because it was not operating correctly, the reading has been ignored. The proper multiplier for this meter is the current transformer ratio (200:5) of 40. It is uncertain if the City has this meter multiplier in their data records, but Mr. Quick indicated it would be added if necessary. Mr. Quick made the corrections to the metering installation and proper meter operation has been verified. 3. Hydro Plant Meter (See photo 6): The hydro plant meter installation was inspected. Current readings were taken on each phase, and the disc rotation was timed. These tests indicated the meter is operating properly. The meter multiplier of 80 being used by the City is correct as the current transformers are 400:5 ratio, there are no potential transformers in the metering circuit, and the meter has no built in multiplier. Items noted during the inspection of the hydro facility: 4. 5. 6. a. There was some vibration produced by the hydro or generator that should be checked by someone familiar with similar units and their vibration limits. b. The Voltmeter in the hydro plant was not functioning and should be replaced. This is important in setting the Voltage levels seen by the whole town. c. There is not a kW meter in the hydro plant. It would be helpful to the operator to have a meter to insure overloading of the plant does not occur. Ouzinkie Store and Ouzinkie Native Corporation: The meters for the Ouzinkie Store and the Ouzinkie Native Corporation are located inside the store’s storage area (see photo 13). Although these are direct reading meters (no current transformers), the three phase service is a 4 wire delta. This provides both three phase 240 Volts and 120 Volts single phase and is commonly referred to as a high-leg delta service. The phase Voltages at the meters were checked and are correct. The store meter has an internal multiplier of 10 and is being used by the City. Pump House and School: The services to the City pump house (water supply) and to the school are 120/208 Volt, three phase, four wire services and are directly metered (no current transformers). The metering installations were briefly inspected, but because the meter connections are not phase sensitive, no tests were conducted. Dock Crane: The dock crane is a hydraulically operated hoist that obtains hydraulic operating pressure oy an electric motor operated pump. The service to this facility is a 277/480 Volt three phase, four wire #1/10 line that extends approximately 800 feet (see photo 14). The electric motor is a 15 horsepower unit and requires 18.2 Amps per phase at full load (nameplate data). The average monthly energy use for the six month eee from July through December 1989, was 33 kWH. Current readings were taken on each phase, and the disk rotation was timed. Although the pump motor was operating, the crane was _not pulling a load at the time of the test. The test results are as follows: Current Rotation Time Phase A 8.1 Amps 1 disk revolution 37 sec Phase B_ 8.1 Amps kW = (Kh Tev Phase C 8.2 Amps 1,000 (sec) kW = 4.2 KVA = (8.1+8.1+8.2)*277V 1,000 i. KVA = 6.76 KW = KVA * pf = 6.76 * .85 KW = 5.75 The results of these tests indicate the following: 1. The no load current of the motor is lower than what would normally be expected, however, the unit is very old and may have been rewound making the nameplate data incorrect. 2. The second test indication shows that the meter is reading approximately 27% low and should be sent in for testing and calibration or should be replaced. nclusions and Recommendations: A station service meter should be installed in both the power plants. The station service load in the diesel plant is significant and is probably a large part of the reported system line losses. Although, the station service load in the hydro plant is small, it should also be metered. The meter in the waste heat module should no longer be ignored as it now is — properly. City records should reflect a meter multiplier of 40 for is meter. The meter serving the City dock crane should be replaced or recalibrated, and the new meter monitored for proper operation. The City should purchase a spare meter for each type of meter used in town and should periodically have the large power meters checked for accuracy. The new meters should have cylclometer type registers to reduce meter reader errors. The City should obtain a computer program similar to the one prepared by Mr. — to allow them to keep track of total generation, total energy sold, and ne loss. Additional training should be provided to the meter reader to insure accurate readings of all types of meters. COST ESTIMATES Cost Estimate: 1. a. Station service meter installation hydro diesel plant: Material Meter base Meter Conduit and fittings Miscellaneous Labor: Electrician: $65/hr @ 16 hours Per diem: 2 days @ $65/day Travel: (assumed available in Kodiak) Subtotal b. Station service meter installation hydro plant: Material Meter base Meter Conduit and fittings Miscellaneous Labor: Electrician: $65/hr @ 16 hours Per diem: 2 days @ $65/day Travel: (included in diesel plant meter installation) Subtotal TOTAL 2. Waste heat module meter - no cost 3. Replacement of Dock crane meter - Material: Meter 4. Spare meters for three phase metering: Diesel plant - 1 meter Hydro plant - 1 meter School, pump house - 1 meter Store - 1 meter Ouzinkie Native Corp.- 1 meter $200.00 400.00 100.00 50.00 $1,040.00 130.00 80.00 $2,000.00 $200.00 400.00 100.00 50.00 $1,040.00 130.00 $1,920.00 $3920.00 $400.00 $1,000.00 400.00 400.00 400.00 400.00 Dock crane - 1 meter 400.00 TOTAL $3,000.00 5. Computer Program and Training: Material: Software program $500.00 Training: Seminar for City Clerk 750.00 TOTAL $1,250.00 PHOTOGRAPHS -10- Photograph Two - hydro plant substation 277/480 to 7.2/12.5 kV -1ll- Photograph Three - feed from hydro plant to substation Photograph Four - interior view of hydro plant =) [92 Photograph Five - hydro plant main breaker and control panel Photograph Six - hydro plant totalizing kilowatt hour meter Photograph Seven - waste heat recovery module on left and diesel generator module on right Photograph Eight - interior view of diesel generator module ~ 14." Photograph Ten - interior view of waste heat recovery module. Note meter to the right of the disconnect switch. =15.- Photograph Eleven - 7.2/12.5 kV overhead distribution line, facing west between power plants Photograph Twelve - 7.2/12.5 kV overhead distribution line, facing east between power plants Photograph Thirteen - Kilowatt hour meters for Ouzinkie store trig t) and the Ouzinkie Native Corporation (left) Photograph Fourteen - Kilowatt hour meter for dock crane Appendix A -18- KW UkKW USE CALCULATION FILEFILE NAME KWCALC total kw generation 48000 ey total kw sold ee 41767 pewer EF/cencey fecmtcr 87.01% lLesSeS /2,99% July reading ALASCOM AMBROSIA ALEX ANDERSON ALICE ANDERSON ANDY ANDERSON ANGELINE ANDERSON FLOYD ANDERSON GENE ANDERSON JERRY ANDERSON ROBERT ANDERSON SONNY ANDERSON THELMA BENNETT VERNA BOSKOFSKY ALLEN BOSKOFSKY BILL SR. BOSKOFSKY BILLY BOSKOFSKY CABIN BOSKOFSKY CHRIS BOSKOFSKY JULIA CHERNIKOFF FRED CHERNIKOFF MIKE CHICHENOFF PETER CHICHENOFF ZACK CHRISTOFFERSON ANDY CITY APT. (NICHOLAS) CITY GFFIGE CLARION DANNY CLARION SOPHIA COMMUNITY CENTER DELGADO WILLIAM DOCK CRANE DUKE DELGADO ELLANAK DANIEL / 80930 26670 6660 SI580 FO990 11640 124 15820 37910 42560 1059 14382 33280 14720 4734 8380 7475 2299S 23070 15200 43577 Taa7 10180 10717 74210 sose 7610 72345 4612 805 10242 7550 82860 26850 7962 34010 21260 11850 134 15990 38240 42890 1093 14554 332610 14840 4821 8389 7868 -' =, 2312 22390 15340 4794 10234 10450 10923 74980 S132 7960 73613 4854 858 10504 7600 40 Ss a s a 33 = 20 16 7 44 > a 29 47 79 72 a al 63 91 69 14 60 27 89 82 73 84 So oS 70 ELLANSE LARRY FIRE HALL SARNER WILLIS GENERATOR x 200= 21600 GRAVES IRENE HAAKENSEN TIM HYDRO STATION x 80= 26400 ISLAND T.V. JOHNSON ROGER KATELNIKOFF ALEXANDRIA KATELNIKOFF POLLY KELLY MIKE LLANOS JOE MALUTIN MOSES MULLER DONALD MULLER FRED MULLER JACKIE OUZINEIE CLINIC OUZ. COMM. STORE x 10= OUZ. NATIVE PANAMAR I OFF PANAMAR IOFF PANAMARIOFF PANAMARIOFF PANAMARIOFF . PANAMARIOFF PANAMAR ILOFF PANAMAR I OFF PESTRIKOFF PUMP HOUSE PYLES BILL QUICK TOM SCHOOL SHANAGIN GE! CORF. CLIFF JOAN PAUL RHONDA TIM JR. TIM SR. VERNA VICKY ANNA ORGE L. SHANAGIN JOHN SHANAGIN WALTER SHURAVLOFF TERRIE SEONBERG JIM SMITH ALEXANDRA SMITH CARL SMITH NORMAN SODERBERS ALMA SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF ANDREW ANNTE BILL FRED MARTIN NICK NICK JR. THEQDORE STREET LIGHT kw x TEACHER BM TEACHER MA HOUSE HOUSE TORSEN CLAUDIA TOTEMOFF WAYNE TRIBAL FREEZER US FOST OFFICE VACANT NP HOUSE VACANT TB HOUSE VACANT PHS HOUSE on 420 638 240 2439 41507 22440 3582 17430 2415 4848 12563 16980 26080 4154 18400 28670 4630 20450 16110 4=75 17800 8078 7310 16998 4590 4172 21050 23160 22350 29530 12251 S1L330 2839 894 10573 7843 4998 2405 42420 17589 21075 11480 19380 46679 4X99 pay 32980 5038 55850 29404 BOSCO 31080 8150 11910 Si 37943 71050 17250 e212 25280 4934 24690 8950 16540 3050 42145 22700 E690 17340 2579 5178 14041 16240 26230 4437 18790 28910 46350 30820 16286 4884 18000 9003 8506 17251 4930 4723 21210 23450 22540 29800 12487 31460 5456 1064 11093 10785 5z06 3529 42730 17824 21735 115460 19630 47400 3590 B46i0 5205 55850 29772 20450 31450 8120 12130 94 38244 71490 17496 Bz02 25660 4954 24690 8950 16540 Pees AususT =" QUZINKIE KWH USE. AUGUST 1989 a ; SME ST ST SS - TOTAL KWH GENERATED TOTAL KWH SOLD TOTAL LOSSES a — — eee PERCENT LOSS 15.13 soo - Jur y UgUSst consumer power No. -% name ., Reading. Reading useage production rae ee = : = = = 49 AMBROSIA ALEX 26850 27130 280 SS ANDERSON ALICE _ 7062 7504 442 64 ANDERSON ANGEL INE 6S ANDERSON FLOYD - « 31260-; e 11850- 12040" “ 6 ANDERSON JERRY 15990 “16170 : 11 ANDERSON ROBERT 38240 38590 TE ST ANBERSSO , 25." ANDERSON. THELMA “4093. 1214 10 BENNETT VERNA Woe ee 14554520 14721 se < < = oe = . - 81 BOSKOFSKY — 14860 15010 . 150 - 7 + 66 BOSKOFSKY . 4821 — 4886 65 54 BOSKOFSKY “57. BOSKOFSKY “St —_— ~~ r 86 CHERNIKOFF 15340 15480 140 . 30 CHERNIKOFF 4794 4987 193 78 -CHEaNS Kort — Orr Oe “= <.52° CHRISTOFFERSON. ANDY ~ ee 10450 = 10720. 270 : pee oy, 93 CITY APT: (NICHOLAS) © PC LO9QS rs 11161 eS 238 ee rete oe err errtee pg 18 7 67 CLARION DANNY 5132 5188 — 35 CLARION SOPHIA 7960 8290 30 87 cenntun rycen ten ————-7 13-9982 35359 28 DELGADO WILLIAM So 4B54 oo oy. 5074 220 74 DOCK CRANE 858 909 51 ; ———_———t Pune Detense—— —__ tosses —_ too 18 ELLANAK DANIEL 7600 7670 70 _ 19 ELLANAK LARRY 3060 . 3470 410 RR 8 I So oo... SO GARNER WILLIS. 22700 22980 280 eR nw. 42 GENERATOR sixts d. 3690 3840 ‘See, BOOOO “ates ——F7- BRAVES RENE 17 840 —_ 18020 80 : 71 HAAKENSEN TIM 2579 2802 - 223 . ~~ 3 HYDRO STATION 5178 5445 — 21340 oe SOND Ve ee etl ie 4 ee “43 JOHNSON ROGER oe 16340 16550 PP 210 epee 37 KATELNIKOFF ALEXANDRIA 26230 26500 © oe 270 we ml oy ATF : =O7 : AUGUST f Pa 48 KELLY MIKE 18790 19040 250 = ee ee ee” UF hhh ChFC 83 MALUTIN MOSES ° oO o S MULLER DONALD 30820 31170 . S50 io. a ee hcl LL!!! Le 4 MULLER JACKIE 4884 S355 471 Si QUZINKIE CLINIC 18000 18190 190 "7e Gunman eee eee Ren 75 OUZ. NATIVE CORF. BS506 9451 945 39 PANAMARIOFF CLIFF 17251 17495 244 S6& PANAMARIOFF FAUL 4723 5144 : 421 23 FANAMARIOFF. RHONDA 23. 24210 21380 170 ——— ee > = oS <2 ve 46 PANAMARIOFF TIM SR. 22560 22760 200 62 PANAMARIOFF VERNA 29800 30070 270 7..PESTRIKOFF ANNA = 2 he 2 PUMP HOUSE ©. » 5436 71B7EE a ee - SSeS Be ri i gg 24 QUICK TOM -— 11093 11553 460 40 SCHOOL 10783 14772. 3989 =. 4 -SHANAGIN. JOHN ‘SHANAGIN WALTER 31 SKONBERG JIM ; 21735 22422 687 20 SMITH ALEXANDRA 11560 - 11620 60 = > 70° SMITH NORMA ~ 44 SODERBERG ALMA 13390 29 SQUARTSOFF ANNIE aa S596 291 . 47 SQUARTSOFF BILL S585 55850 9° $9 Sunstsape prep se sos ss 72 SQUARTSOFF MARTIN 20450 = 20600 = 150 532226 SQUARTSOFF NICK = 31450-31820. 370 aes my ———_68-S@UARFS8FF EEK RS ——@@§|_9tse—@_@ 8 80 i 36 SQUARTSOFF THEODORE 12130 12660 530 91 STREET LIGHT 94 150 2520 ———— 59 -FEABHER-BM -HauS=——_s 8 45 8 588 0 14 TEACHER MA HOUSE - 5.71490 71640... 150 : «© 60 TORSEN CLAUDIA ~~ 17490 17740 SO . 35 -F8FEMereWayNE——es=2° ——_g5912$- _——__g” -$--—-_____ 89 TRIBAL FREEZER 25660 26040 380 82 US FOST OFFICE 4954 50s9 105 = ———S-+R aN E} —————\ 99580 89580 “" 73 VACANT NP o oO. ° paws 84 VACANT FHS) ~ 16540 16540 oO . HR METER CALCULATION RECORD \FE SOLD 45842 BOUGHT 523640 READING POWER ESAKicewey 87.09% SEPTEMBER ge ee AA 2L 103 5 97 101 102 110 100 98 109 106 107 105 94 104 108 95 ; 96 99 90 ALASCOM 89100 49 AMBRCSIA ALEX 27310 55 ANDERSON ALICE 7893 12 ANDERSON ANDY 24890 64 ANDERSON ANGELINE 3i760 65 ANDERSON FLOYD 12250 63 ANDERSON GENE 164 & ANDERSON JERRY 16320 ii ANDERSON ROBERT SP000 1= ANDERSON SONNY 42580 25 ANDERSON THELMA 1453 10 BENNETT VERNA 14865 $i BOSKOFSKY ALLEN 34260 Si BOSKOFSKY BILL SR. S150 64 BOSKOFSKY BILLY 4945 €0 BOSKOFSKY CABIN 8270 54 BOSKOFSKY CHRIS 8764 57 BOSKOFSKY JULIA 23404 ©5 CHERNIKOGFF FRED 24040 @& CHERNIKOFF MIKE LE4600 3O CHICHENOFF PETER 5262 78 CHICHENOFF ZACK 10908 52 CHRISTOFFERSON ANDY 10920 93 CITY APT. (NICHOLAS) 11413 92 CITY OFFICE 765i0 67 CLARICN DANNY 5242 25 CLARION SOPHIA . 8620 87 COMMUNITY CENTER 76038 23 DELGADO WILLIAM 5276 74 DOCK CRANE 944 1 DUKE DELGADO ad 2124! 18 ELLANAK DANIEL 7690 19 ELLANAK LARRY 3860 68 FIRE HALL 3302 50 GARNER WILLIS 27240 42 GENERATOR 3988 77 GRAVES IRENE 18200 TA DIA ALR Im mnt ete Tamas mO+An READING AUGUST Sérremsen /PPRAL.IL1S*YAGFQ METER USE SEPTEMBER 86520 27130 7504 24470 31520 12040 146 * 16170 28590 43250 1214 14721 33970 15010 4886 8390 8330 23501 23730 15480 4987 10546 1072¢ 11161 73770 5188 8290 74932 5074 999 10816 7679 3470 42734 22980 3840 18020 ROAD brad 43 - 32 48 17 83 38 Si 76 75 39 33 56 23 45 46 62 Ss? 24 40 SS 34 is ss 31 = = 16 79 a4 2 ae 47 79 re 26 68 36 1 69 14 60 a ai 89 82 73 84 41 HYDRO STATI ISLAND T.V. ON JOHNSON ROGER KATELNIKOFF KATELNIKOFF KELLY MIKE LLANOS JOE MALUTIN MOS MULLER DONA! MULLER FRED MULLER JACK QUZINKIE CL 0uz. COMM. OUZ. NATIVE PANAMARIOFF PANAMAR IOFF FANAMAR IOFF FPANAMARIOFF PANAMARIOFF PANAMARIOFF PANAMAR IOFF PANAMARIOFF PESTRIKOFF FUMF HOUSE PYLES BILL QUICK TOM SCHOOL SHANAGIN SE SHANAGIN JO SHANAGIN WA SHURAVLOFF SKONBERGS JI SMITH ALEXAI SMITH CARL SMITH NORMA SODERBERG A SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF ALEXANDRIA FOLLY ES LD ny INIC STORE CORP. CLIFF JOAN PAUL RHONDA TIM JR. TIM SR. VERNA VICKY ANNA ORGE L. HN LTER ' TERRIE M NDRA N LMA ANDREW ANNIE BILL FRED MARTIN MICK NICK JR. THEODORE STREET LIGHT TEACHER DM TEACHER MA TORSEN CLAU HOUSE HCUSE DIA TOTEMOFF WAYNE TRIBAL FREEZER US POST OFFICE VACANT TB VACANT NF VACANT PS WASTE HEAT 5733 14956 16800 26790 4996 19290 29360 14 31530 16640 5730 18390 107260 T0334 L77i1 5440 S574 21510 24080 22990 30230 13114 21870 eso1 1475 12102 2UT92 5927 3806 43340 18368 23035 11700 20170 48380 12890 35690 S8é4 55850 30584 20730 29180 we LOU 8130 13510 229 S9142 720350 17760 8507 27049 5164 8939 Oo 16540 7a Reo? owt” 5445 14512 16550 26500 4704 19040 29190 8 31170 16460 33335 18190 _99190 945i 17495 $220 5144 21380 23770 22760 309070 12819 21620 7187 1232 11553 14772 S432 34656 430606 18092 22422 11620 19890 47869 13560 33060 S596 S3E350 30154 20600 F182¢ 8130 12640 150 38566 71640 17749 8291 26040 5959 B9SO, oO. 16540 7i 444 250 290 292 250 170 260 180 375 200 8070 ess 216 240 430 130 210 230 1450 295 250 1614 243 S49 6420 295 150 280 276 613 so 280 520 330 . 639 268 O 430 130 360 850 3105 376 390 20 ed 1000 ocoo 23040 SOLD BOUGHT POWER EFFreceney OES = Ah 103 97 101 102 110 100 98 109 104 107 105 94 104 108 95 94 ; 99 90 49 55 12 64 ALASCIM AMBROSIA ANDERSON ANDERSON ANDERSON 65 ANDERSON 63 ANDERSON 6 ANDERSON ii ANDERSON is ANDERSSON 25. ANDERSON i0 BENNETT V 61 BOSKOFSKY 91 BOSKOFSKY 66 BOS*OFSKY 8C BOSKOFSKY $4 BSOSMOFSKY S7 BOSKOFSKY 835 CHERNIKOF 6 CHERNI!OF| 30 CHICHENOF 78 CHICHENOF s2 9S CITY APT. 4987 S624 88.6 ALEX ALICE ANDY ANGEL INE FLOYD SENE JERRY ROBERT SONNY THELMA ERNA LIEN Pele. SF. BILLY CABIN CHRIS JULIA F FRED MIKE F PETER F ZACK CHRISTOFFERSON ANDY (NICHOLAS ) oz 67 87 23 74 DOCK CRANE 1 DUKE DELSADO 16 ELLANAK DANIEL 1° ELLANAK LARRY 68 FIRE HALL SO GARNER WILLIS 42 GENERATOR 77 GRAVES IRENE 71 HEAKENSEN TIM Sly Orrick CLARION DANNY LARION SOPHIA COMMUNITY CENTE DELGADO WILLIAM NE 1 O READING 8% OCTOBER SCTOGER /PPRAL.IL20*°AGFQ 91409 27640 8294 35310 31980 £2490 165 164230 39290 11200 11785 77390 READING METER USE SEPTEMBER OCTOBER oO 0 oO o oO o oO ° ° ° ° o ° ° ° 3 89100 2300 27310 350 7893 401 34890 420 31760 220 12259 240 166 oO 16320 110 =9000 290 42580 340 1453 281 14865 259 Z4s60 450 15150 180 4945 59 8370 0 8764 4B6 23404 7 24040 310 154600 160 S262 282 10908 B96 10920 289 11413 372 76510 680 5242 85 8620 390 76038 1444 5275 21 944 24 14121 284 7690 10 3860 £10 43302 679 23240 SEO 3938 18200 160 2914 57 8] td 39 ee 37 48 7: m4 ~ 38 Si 76 73 3? 33 56 23 45 HYDRO STATI ISLAND T.V. JOHNSON ROG KATELNIKOFF KATELNIKOFF KELLY MIKE LLANOS JOE ON ER ALEXANDRIA POLLY MALUTIN MOSES MULLER DONA MULLER FRED MULLER JACK OUZINKIE CL OUzZ. COMM. OUZ. NATIVE PANAMARIOFF PANAMARIOFF PANAMARIOFF PANAMARIOFF PANAMARIOFF PANAMARIOFF PANAMARTOFF PANAMARIOFF PESTRIKOFF PUMP HOUSE PYLES BILL QUICK TOM a QUICK TOM b STHOOL SHANAGIN GE LD Le INIC STORE CORP. GLIFF JOAN PAUL RHONDA TIM JR. TIM SR. VERNA VICKY ANNA « house - shed ORGE _. SHANAGIN JOHN SHANAGIN WA SHURAVLOFF SEONBERG JI SMITH ALEXA SMITH CARL SMITH NORMA SODERSERS ALM SQUARTSOFS SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOSF SQUARTSOF > SQUGRTSOFF SGUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF SQUARTSOFF STREET LIGH TEACHER DM TEACHER MA LTER enh. M NDRA N uM Ww mt A DRE Rie So AN - © 4 B F MART IC. NICK NICK JR. THEODORE + HOUSE HOUSE 4 TGRSEN CLAUDIA TOTEMOFSF WA YNE. TRIBAL FREEZER US POST OFF VACANT TB VACANT NE VACANT PHS WASTE HEAT ICE Y (em oO” 6171 15404 17040 27090 S369 19550 29710 14 31850 16840 61é2 isé1io 15720 11050 17947 5745 S887 214680 24780 23290 30410 13404 S2090 10199 i747 L26é7Z SP7E11i 28595 6272 3964 42660 1845681 22657 wu O 20440 48919 Anis; rae dS 36166 cg SSESO 30977 ROG 22540 130 14479 304 2978C 72469 17796 £606 28820 5258 8932 24810 146540 71 35040 SOLD 5232 ' BOUGHT 57800 RSS OK cower 90.53% AesséS U9 27a 1 DELGADO 2 * HOUSE S STATION 4 MULLER JACK 5 DONALD 6 ANDERSON JERRY 7 PESTRIKOFF ANNA 8 KATALNIKGFF NICHOLI 9 PANAMARICFF VICKY BENNETT VERNA FNDERSON ROB ANDERSON ANDY i= ANDERSON SCNNY 14 TEACHER S SHANAGIN WALTER 16 SMITH CARL 17 LLANOS JCE 13 ELLANAK DANIEL 19 ELLANAK LARRY 20 SMITH ALEXANDRA 21 SQUARTSOFF ANDREW 22 ISLAND T.V. = PANAMARIOFF RHONDA 24 QUICK TOM A HOUSE 24 QUICK TOM E SHED 25 ANDERSON THELMA 26 SQUARTSCFF NICK 27 TOTEMOFF WAYNE 28 DELGADO WILLIAM 29 SQUARTSOFF ANNIE 30 CHICHENOFF PETER Si SKONBERG JIM S2 KATELNIKOFF POLLY 33 PANAMARIOQFF JOAN 34 SHANAGIN JOHN 35 CLARION SCFPHIA 36 SQUARTSOFF THEODORE 37 KATELNIKOFF ALEXANDRIA 38 MULLER FRED 39 SSNAMARIOFF CLIFF 43 SCHOOL 41 WASTE HEAT 42 GENERATOR £3 JOHNSON RO 44 SODERBERS 435 P: oT Ne READING NOVEMBER 44000 20690 29970 7770 4679 11900 36280 15846 21910 13283 39843 2310 32870 8703 S754 632 5876 24363 3675 6070 4148 9500 L5350 27330 17150 18193 36655 Za: 4205 L740 143569 24750 25357C 35835 Le7 ao 27940 /PPRAL.IL20*AGPQ READING METER USE OCTOBER NOVEMBER oe 1287 Gi9 30 50 240 288 268 186 S20 469 9 S90 24.6! 52 3660 340 20440 250 29710 260 7700 70 4270 400 £2790 36160 220 15404 442 21680 250 12612 671 39E11 32 1734 S76 32540 330 8606 97 5492 2é2 6083 241 5544 332 23667 696 5309 366 5740 330 3964 164 9010 490 14476 e290 27090 240 14840 310 17947 246 28595 7455 7.1L QO 4004 17040 300 = 33 370 286 0 170 300 350 190 3290 400 S53 NOVEM BER 7600 40260 ss sé 57 s8 39 69 é1 62 63 64 65 6é 67 638 6&9 79 del. 72 73 74 73 76 a 78 wee 80 8i e@2 8s 84 85 86 87 8s 89 90 Fh 92 93 94 93 GE 7, 98 oo 109 101 102 i002 io4 iGs burned PANAMGRIOFF PAUL BOSKOFSKY JULIA SHURAVLOFF TERRIE PYLES BILL TORSEN CLAUDIA BOSKOFSKY ALLE FANAMARIOFFE VERNA ANDERSON GEN= ANDERSON ANGELINE ANDERSON FLOYD BOSKOFSKY EILLY ALICE ANDERSON SQUARTSCFF NICK JR. TEACHER SMITH NORMAN HAAKENSEN TIM SQUARTSOFF MARTIN MARIA PESTRIKOFF DOCK CRANE OUZ. NATIVE CORP. QUZ. COMM. STORE GRAVES IRENE CHICHENDFF ZACK SQUARTSOFF FRED BCSKOFSKY CABIN U.S. POST. OFFICE BOSKOFSKY BILL SR. MALUTIN MOSES zoYys CHERNIKOFF FRED CHERNIKOFF MIKE COMMUNITY CENTER FIRE HALL TRIBAL FREEZER ALASCOM STREET LIGHT CITY OFFICE CITY APT. (NICHOLAS) 6361 23535835 1896& 20734 17350 35270 30650 146 32260 12870 5078 5847 8131 40408 495co 3079 21150 25000 ees 11735 2352 18500 11754 31344 8400 Sr59 15540 21 16600 24640 15800 78825 44787 30620 93650 401 78450 12085 5887 23471 18621 1747 17790 34810 30410 146 31980 12490 5004 S327 €isl 39780 48910 Za7t 20930 24810 968 11050 1572 18360 11304 30977 8590 5258 153720 14 1654060 24350 15700 77482 43981 28820 91400 304 77390 11785 SOLD BOUGHT 54827 59040 ROWSE EFAcENcY 92.86% eae a2 eit ia ke ees Paps eee MWONQUS UNH NERRE BRB BEBE COVWVONGCUWPUNRFO td Nh hs PRU 3) on tJ) PHHPPAHDADHBYUHUWHHUWHWHHWYYs OQNGCuUPHNFODODNGUPHUNRFOWVON 49 50 Si 52 DUKE DELGADO PUMP HOUSE HYDRO STATION MULLER JACKIE MULLER DONALD ANDERSON JERRY PESTRIKOFF ANNA KATALNIKOFF NICHCLI PANAMARIOFF VICKY BENNETT VERNA ANDERSON ROBERT ANDERSON ANDY ANDERSON SONNY TEACHER SHANAGIN WALTER SMITH CARL LLANOS JOE ELLANAK DANIEL ELLANAK, LARRY SMITH ALEXANDRA SQUARTSOFF ANDREW ISLAND T.V. PANAMARIOFF RHONDA QUICK TOM A HOUSE QUICK TOM B SHED ANDERSON THELMA SQUARTSOFF NICK TOTEMOFF WAYNE DELGADO WILLIAM SQUARTSOFF @NNIE CHICHENOFF FETER SKONBERG JIM KATELNIKOFF POLLY PANAMARIOFF JOAN SHANAGIN JOHN CLARION SOPHIA SQUARTSOFF THECDORE KATELNIKOFF ALEXANDRIA MULLER FRED FANAMARIOFF CLIFF ScCHooL WASTE HEAT SENERATOR ; JOHNSON ROGER SODERBERG ALMA FANAMGRICFF TIM JF. PANAMARIOFF TIM SR. SQUARTSOFF BILL KELLY MIKE AMBRCSIA ALEX GAFNER WILLIS QJZINEIE CLINIC CHRISTOFFERSON ANDY NE READING DECE 16450 27680 17530 13562 42689 aie 4295 17310 14876 25150 ateeo 2sFEC S585 19910 Licer 7088 19314 /PPRAL.I1L2Z0~AGFQ DECEMBER soared READING NOVEMBER 17240 14540 nats 2475 aceF 23270 e505 19720 27940 23979 188¢ 24520 5672 S805 METER USE DECEMBER 59040 55 36 ‘37 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 6&9 79 4 af 75 es 73 74 75 76 vr 7é 79 89 e1 82 8s 84 85 86 87 88 8? 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 106 102 102 193 164 10 idé 107 103 OF 1106 LL burned PANAMARIOFF FAUL BOSKOFSEY JULIA SHURAVLOFF TERRIE PYLES BIE TORSEN CLAUDIA BCSKOFSKY ALLEN PANAMARIOFF VERNA ANDERSON GENE ANDERSON ANGELINE ANDERSON FLOYD BOSKGFSKY BILLY ALICE ANDERSON SQUARTSOFF NICK GR. TEACHER SMITH NORMAN HAAKENSEN TIM SQUARTSOFF MARTIN MARIA PESTRIKOFF DOCK CRANE OUZ. NATIVE CORP. GUZ. COMM. STORE GRAVES IRENE CHICHENOFF ZACK SQUARTSOFF FRED BOCSKOFSKY CABIN U.S. POST OFFICE BOSKOFSKY BILL SR. MALUTIN MCSES ZOYA CHERNIKOFF FRED CHERNIKGFF MIKE COMMUNITY CENTER EIRE HALL TRIBAL FREEZER ALASCOM STREET LIGHT CITY GFFICcE CITY APT. (NICHOLAS) 12 18700 12224 31718 s580 5472 15716 41 16770 25029 15926 80158 45646 32640 935850 S06 79540 12289 26960 6561 223583 18968 2054 17850 SE270 SO650 156 32260 12670 5678 5847 Sis1 40406 493506 3073 2115¢ 25009 985 11735 3=5> aoe 18500 11754 Fiz44 8400 33539 15540 21 146460 24660 15800 7882s 44787 F0éE20 F650 401i 78450 12085 120 261 90 =51 217 30 540 230