HomeMy WebLinkAbout2_NVE_costworksheet116E� ALASKA Renewable Energy Fund Round 3
4r--) ENERGY AUTHORITY Project Cost/Benefit Worksheet
Please note that some fields might not be applicable for all technologies or all project
phases. The level of information detail varies according to phase requirements.
11. Renewable Energy Source
The Applicant should demonstrate that the renewable energy resource is available on a
sustainable basis.
Annual average resource availability. Approximately 21.4 billion BTUs of biomass
Unit depends on project type (e.g. windspeed, hydropower output, biomasss fuel)
2. Existing Energy Generation and Usage
a) Basic configuration (if system is part of the Railbelt' grid, leave this section blank)
i. Number of generators/boilers/other
ii. Rated capacity of generators/boilers/other
iii. Generator/boilers/other type
iv. Age of generators/boilers/other
v. Efficiency of generators/boilers/other
5 hydro turbines, 4 diesel generators
2 x 500kW Kato/Francis turbine, 1 x 250kW
Kato/Turgo turbine, 2 x 3,000 kW Gilkes turbines, 1
x EMD generator 2,500 kW, 1 x Fairbanks/Morse
2,403 kW generator, 2 x Caterpillar generator 1,090
kW.
See above.
24 years on diesel generators. 7 years on hydro
turbines. All generators and turbines re -built in
2006.
Diesel efficiency is 13.65 kWh/gallon, 1999 — 2007
b) Annual O&M cost (if system is part of the Railbelt grid, leave this section blank)
i. Annual O&M cost for labor
ii. Annual O&M cost for non -labor
$662,390
$595,486
c) Annual electricity production and fuel usage (fill in as applicable) (if system is part of the
Railbelt grid, leave this section blank)
Electricity [kWh] 24,969,557 kWh, 2002 — 2007 average
ii. Fuel usage
Diesel [gal]
841,763 gallons without Humpback Creek in service
Other
Water
iii. Peak Load
6,136 kW (2007)
iv. Average Load
3.069 kW (2007)
v. Minimum Load
1,635 kW (five year minimum system load as of 10/5/08)
vi. Efficiency
Diesel efficiency is 13.65 kWh/gallon, 1999 — 2007 average.
vii. Future trends
Sharply increasing peak demand and kWh in summer, decreasing in winter.
d) Annual heating fuel usage (fill in as applicable)
i. Diesel [gal or MMBtu] Approx. 134,900 gallons
ii. Electricity [kWh] unknown
1 The Rail belt grid connects all customers of Chugach Electric Association, Homer Electric Association, Golden Valley Electric
Association, the City of Seward Electric Department, Matanuska Electric Association and Anchorage Municipal Light and Power.
AEAIO-015 Grant Application Page 23 of 36 10/7/2009
/j ALASKA Renewable Energy Fund Round 3
ENERGYAUTHORITY Project Cost/Benefit Worksheet
iii. Propane [gal or MMBtu] unknown
iv. Coal [tons or MMBtu] unknown
v. Wood [cords, green tons, dry tons] unknown
vi. Other
a)
Proposed renewable capacity
Biomass
(Wind, Hydro, Biomass, other)
[kWh or MMBtu/hr]
b)
Proposed Annual electricity or heat production (fill in as applicable)
i. Electricity [kWh]
ii. Heat [MMBtu]
21.4 billion BTUs
c)
Proposed Annual fuel Usage (fill in as
applicable)
i. Propane [gal or MMBtu]
ii. Coal [tons or MMBtu]
iii. Wood [cords, green tons, dry tons]
1,460 cords
iv. Other
4.
Project Cost
a)
Total capital cost of new system
unknown
b)
Development cost
unknown
c)
Annual O&M cost of new system
unknown
d)
Annual fuel cost
unknown
5. Project Benefits
a) Amount of fuel displaced for
i. Electricity
it. Heat 134,900 gallons
iii. Transportation
b) Price of displaced fuel
c) Other economic benefits
d) Amount of Alaska public benefits
Ave
jobs
$100,000
16. Power Purchase/Sales Price I
a) Price for power purchase/sale n/a
7. Project Analysis
AEA10-015 Grant Application Page 24 of 36 10/7/2009
ALASKA Renewable Energy Fund Round 3
� ENERGY AUTHORITY Project Cost/Benefit Worksheet
a) Basic Economic Analysis
Project benefit/cost ratio
Payback
n/a
n/a
AEA10-015 Grant Application Page 25 of 36 10/7/2009
&� ALASHKA
community Information
Cordova population: 2454
Households: 958
Heating Degree Days: 9565
Renewable Energy Fund
Grant Application Round 3
Existing heating systems: Mostly Oil furnace and some Electric
Cost of fuel oil in Cordova: $3.72 (ISER-UAA 8-15-09)
Cost of fuel oil: $3.28 delivered (300 gallon keep -full service -Shoreside 9/10/09)
Cost of electricity $/kWh: $.20 to .27 (residential -CEC 8/15/09)
Fuel value of Cardboard: 6,000 to 7,000 Btu/Lb Dry
Fuel Value of wood pallets: 6,000 to 8,000 Btu/Lb (dry & clean)
Fuel value of landfill wastewood: 4,500-5,000 Btu/Lb (dry & clean)
City Baler output (cardboard) 50-80 bales/yr (G. Rankin estimate)
Bales are 1.6 cu. yd. (mixed with some foam & plastics)
MSW Bales unsuitable as fuel (mixed content and very high m/c)
Heating Oil cost for City buildings (2008):
(no gallon volumes available)
Fire & EMS: $6,913
Bldg Mntnce: $75,766
Recreation: $18,790
Pool: $115,458
Ski hill: $5,153
Camper Park: $2,952
Harbor Operations: $11,666
Sewer operations: $12,506
Water operations: $18,737
Total: $267,941
Source: Public Works
AEA10-015 Grant Application Page 26 of 36 10/7/2009
ALASENERGYMTKA
Cordova School District Heating Costs
July 1M 0J En YCM4 Ban FM Yam20IX18aau9b 2006
FU Canangbn CON
ME
FY03
FY01
FY06
FY08
FYO]
FY08
Jury
3965
54W
S1.TSO
$2389
SQ942
$4,114
Ae9W1
51,109
f1,430
S0
$1442
S(803
$1m
Sept.
S0
$1,451
$3.114
52,800
$e,084
S8.693
53.01E
S7,SW
$7604
57,693
Nmm
Nanmbm
$2.033
$3,all
33,970
S5.=
$&,
58,34E
SMin
Oebmber
53,20E
$2,970
f5326
aM3
36,49E
Jemmy
$4A77
32979
54,85]
aMS
55.4a
13,687
$13,58)
FNauary
21
57.010
a506
58,570
5701E
515,559
$8,011
MmM
53,421
a
54=
SEE
57176
AM
52.96E
$3,773
aM
56,205
$9,671
39,673
SS,731
Mn
E2,9M
$3,130
$1.976
51.8]5
$8.007
f2,557
58.515
June
52,032
52]15
22,513
32907
591919
32236
TOW
590,1M
899.15E
518,255
557,340
$91,991
599,826
WIwn9
ME
FY03
FY04
FY05
FY06
FY07
"Off
Jury
b2,e10
S2,997
$4.106
$4,140
MOD7
S4,072
mpst
SS 507
S4.110
55,002
$5278
36.399
55,756
Sepanlbm
S6A52
$7,134
47,372
57,570
S7,043
S7,566
OOIaOer
SEE"
96.917
5024E
f5128
awl
57,004
NOY W
S&IS7
S8,672
58,342
39.351
$71633
59,120
Cecember
$ENQ
STMO
$7.571
S9374
S9.517
$8,874
Jmmsry
WIM
$6.437
50.323
f8,88S
$11,168
S12,107
Febuary
37180
am
39.45/
S10,146
$10.581
510,86E
Mm
$7,135
57,09E
S9.0SS
S9,774
aM
$EMS
MN
S8,331
SEE
59243
S11.172
$13,009
$11,111
May
57,281
$7,954
58,811
411,283
S9,863
S10,626
Jure
53.291
54.45]
95.pF
35.780
SS
SS495
T9
E68,W6
SBOA881
SB2.331
Slm.m
S105,184
599,660
Renewable Energy Fund
Grant Application Round 3
r FrW F.;-------------'
Y0
F0
Y039OMEOa
SWRIM
$E2O
S5.30
011381
M,ml
NnTHaOlS
51,0E
S1.SW
$1,417
521
$M
54,4E
11
558281.449E
583 47
91411
99676
el
bE8.865
59029/
5120.11113 J1
111 ]75
14308%_125mn
14353%
11580%1
r--------- ciakeCoe! ------------j
1 FY03 FY01 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY09
1 ME SB6p96 530.45E fill 3101290 510S181 MAW!
1 HS 594,058 591.410 5101717 51 748 311+ 51191�a
Tdal 3152.154 3111,85E E194,018 S207,008 $218,744 S219,015
Ixlr _rrm���__- 112.E 11281% tO80B'b 10567% 10D.13%1
FnlCeronmp481 CO41
FUN C...O nCaN
HE
mma W.
FY01
Frd
FY65
FY08
FYW
FY16
F103
FY04
FY05
Ej
FY07
FY09
Jury
$1,111
SZ11
5129E
mm
53,a5
55214
J*
W
SO
Sp
EO
s0
E0
Au9M
51.66E
$2,141
$3,036
S2,467
5012
$1,7%
Au9u41
SO
S98
$0
SO
SOD
50
Saplmeba
ST60
32,087
S2050
f29110
50296
f2,S18
SvplwMer
S$0
50
$0
SO
$O
$O
OOIObm
S2.676
$3,556
$4,395
$4.851
OdMer
50
SO
50
S230
3399
542E
NOrembar
S2,650
$%4l
5S,2H
$4,520
$COW
312104
q;%7
S1J,997
NOWnfan
570
$181
$176
590E
$462
Sm
$2,657
55,029
S4,858
$4A95
S10,82J
Oaunlber
$194
322E
3341
$M2
567E
M3
J.M
January
$4077
51,00E
1S4,6092.574
$12,574
312,595
Jewry
$181
S181
$3SO
f285
$462
$489
FeGvery
5E,857
S1,69
$5.578
55,67E
WAU
5),010
312,830
30
5405
SM5
$49]
53,&7
E6,699
WW4
$$6.M5
53,42E
Ms
MmM
$175
SIM
$174
MpsiN
31SO
SUS=7
SO
SMO
AWd
ApY
S3,356
55,26E
$4,/81
Val
$4,597
59,196
ff%WS
AMS
514E
5174
50
59SO
377E
4WD
May
SJJ72
91,1$0
$3.M
5E0%
$05R
55,882
Mry
5851
561
S273
50
$161
we
512E
June
52649
55139
Will
5671E
Jere
S89
80
60
$9
50
0
TOaI
n.612
529A/9
531.209
M
518.502
5E9,&7
8ams1,M4
E81,4B1
fW,6]6
TWI
31,830
31.30E
51.41)
32251
53,4E
54A58
Kimwancom
HS
FY03
FY04
FY06
FY06
FY07
FYOB
July
SUN
$J,781
51.15/
54,314
54,012
94A18
August
54,J21
$4314
am
E3901
56,426
55m
S"mber
S7,191
S8,442
S8,107
56,648
SO=
59.073
Oa r
S6.863
97,44E
am
$8.318
S10.122
SO.W
Nwembm
$7,522
S7.226
$6,160
$9,386
wi30
S9,610
Ca9em0e7
S8,149
57.93E
5340E
$9,408
59.073
$9,415
J.NY
$8.435
$8.10
$9,622
59,972
$12.3M
S12,W2
FOmry
S6,727
S1g747
510,890
S11,198
$13255
$15.313
March
3E,818
$8,769
59,14E
510,005
S11,310
S10,786
Apa
$9,743
99,531
510.618
$11,882
512.7M
514,369
May
30.255
S8356
$9,612
$11,W4
591,719
S13,W
Jun
53.435
56.735
551%
35814
31)76
TaW
SBq,OSB
SB1,410
IM
$101,]1]
E105,]4B $116.580 5119,15E
AEA10-015 Grant Application Page 27 of 36 10/7/2009