The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutAPA2509';"i I < " i t M a '"'>;_; I ~ 'c J), ~ -.-i -' ......... --~----------~~-~---------~----·--~----~ _, ____________ _, ______________ __ SUSITNA HYDROELECTRIC PROJECT FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION PRO-JECT No. 7114 l [}[]£[ffi~&o@:(ID£®@@ , Susitna Joint Venture I I I I I . I I . I I I I . l • I I Document Number . ALASKA POWER /~UTHORITY Please Return To DOCUMENT CONTROL RESPO,NSE TO FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION DAT~~ REQUEST OF OCTOBER 24, 1984 VOLUME I RESPONSE \ [}fl~~tZ~ =={g~~@©@ SUSITNA J·OINT VENTUR~ .I !"-'-. -~-ALASKA POWER AUTHORITY ___ __.. l ·' 1. 1 1 I. l } I i l I l I ! l I I """""'-. '· l · .. T~-.l •' J.ff''~ QUESTION Input data for the OGP-6 runs used to develop the new cost comparisons as indicated in Volume 3, Appendix I Fuel Pricing and Economics (e.g., data preparation model) • RESPONSE The requested input data to the OGP-6 model is provided in Attachments 1.1 and 1.2 to this responsee The cost comparisons contained in Volume 3, Appendix J of the Alaska ?ower Authority's (Power Authority) comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) presented two Railbelt expansion plans: the With-Susitna Plan and the Without-Susitna Plan. The input data for the With-Susitna Plan is contained in Attachment 1.1. The input data for the Without-Susitna Plan is contained in Attachment 1 .. 2. It should be noted that execution of the OGP-6 model requires four basic input models. These are; ,J. I' ·' ' 1' : ,) I I I it ,~: 1: .. i ' I I I ' I I I : . 1.1\ .. \ I I I I . • i I v ..• ;.~ i ' I 0 Data Preparation Model1 0 Generation Planning Model1 0 Existing Generation Model; and 0 Attachment 1.1 comprises the data preparation and generation planning models for the With-Gusitna Plan. The data preparation model encompasses lines 10 through 2250. The generation planning model begins at line 2260 and encompasses the remainder of the data file. Attachment 1.2 is similarly organized. The data preparation model encompasses lines 100 thro~gh 1970; the generation planning model starts at line 1980. All OGP-6 analyses use the same Existing Generation Model and Load Model. The most recent versions of these inputs are provided in Attachments 1.3 and 1.4. Both have undergone review and minor revision since the July 1983 License Application submission. 111 I I -1 It ~~~·I l -I i! I I; I I I: I I I l I J l I : ' ""' ~ ~r ,.~· ·- Attachment 1. 1 Page 1 of 7 Data Preparation/Generation Planning Model With-Susitna Case .19 aqu • 20 8[~ 1 0 , ... "0 ;f ~i 40SI~~OQRl\11CfL,-tS !OSI~~~ITSI05,10(tt1~K ~011~-~fLI~*•!~RtAQQ]OQ]/~GP&O~ 10iat~~,L101tRt!tAQQ3b~21L~NSOU !QSI~~ij'LIOitRtSeAQ~3o~21G~8QU' '~SI~1~!10lt~l!e10L tOOStOlTAat5 110St~!~OT!IO*' t20Stit!110T!t01 tlO N, PA~!te ~ 140 HA~ZAeEBASCO !USITNA JOINT VENTURI: t50 11t ~ STR[!T 1~0 A~C~O~AG!t lLl!~A 99!10 110· Jl~IUT !&0 !Oi•1S~A~'SK4 RAILAELTt t90 IJ2abC~O!ISSU3 ~2185 XN t9Q3t LOLP O,lt O&M COlL,SHCA ;AS, EBASCOALt 200 \IST4~T•1993t 210 \JTOTA~ai!, 220 ~YCOST~I~1~0~8~2~,------------------------------------------------------ 230 ""'~TJ;•1992t lb~ "8~eONV, HVOROPUMP STORAG!F.~G ST~~ _ a!NG STnR !10 Y0TjNE•3~~~U~!· eo•~ NGAS~!OIL GTDIESE~eo~C¥Ct !!O 2U~~yoqo ~!H !s~z ES•J , 290 ~~~~NY•1• JOO ~~A-tEO•lt .;1~1..;0_...;,'<..;.T-rT..;.'f._.P.;;.E.:;.•"!'""a.:..1.t..! ,;_0 .:...;t ~~•;.:f!;...;t~..:;~:...:•~t:..Jt~--------------·--·--------~20 XSlZESCltt)atSOOt 130 ~AN'¥~C1tt)•2050t !"0 XSIZESC1t2)a200t JSO ~A~'~R(1t2)•t982• 3~0 ~!IZE8(1f3lwe7t J70 ~.~,Y~f1tl1at982, !80 XSIZESC1tal•A7, !90 ~A~'~RC1•~)a,~8Zt 400 •SIZ£!Cl•!l•tO• Q10 ~·~,~~(1t!l•20SOt U20 XSIZESC1tbl•2~!, c3o ~-~,r~(1•~l·t~~z. aao O!~~Y0•0.9!,o,o,o, · 450 CiJt't1I~•O•t•, UoO ~TI-.1ES•O' -.... ---------------------.. U10 ESlZEGa333t2~0t,Ot ~"~s~o~e~s~r~z=E~P-.~3lrl~.2~~~o~.~s~o~,~---------------------------------------------·- uqo !!IZES•l130t2SOOt$00t l f -··- - t ,1 . " -. L I l l ! l I l L f l '•1 I': ~ ' ~I·: 11 I ll i ~I I I I I I Attachment 1.1 Page 2 of 7 Data Preparation/Generation Planning Model With-Susitna Case 11 !10 ~t.CA4Wa750,200t87t8'7tl0•22St to 520 •~COK~•1000t2S52t419•4''•1•9••t•• 9 !lO ·~ciJ'•o,zo.s•o, a '~ 0 "AT PC (t , I l •1 • o 0 0, 7 !50 TYCfDC:(tt2)•1fi82,1'JtJOtjCfqt,tCJq2, s !.0 ~4TPCCtt2)•1~000tt,ono,1.0DOt1a000t 5 !TO '~T~C(ttl)wt.OOOtt.OOOtleOOOtleOOOt 4 !BO t·~TitC(tt'i)r.l.OOOt 3 ~QO PAT~C(i,~ wt.OOOe1~000t1;000tt.OOOt &oo tY D.(t• l•t9!2,1qqo,tCJ9t,tq92, •to tY~JC(t,~l•1'82,t,qaot9qtt19q2t _. &20 ~ATPC(ltS)•t.OOOt ~ 3 0_._! AT -tP C ~t) ~! • 0 0 6 t.t 1 () o..Q_,J_._ . .;:.6..!:,.0-=-0-=-' .:...1 .._. -=-0~0 ..::..0 ..!-t ----------~ &40 IYR~PC~1~1)11982t1q90e1901t1q92t •50 ,.,~P~t1t2,~3•t,OOCt ~· --!!" &oO '1XCM;C1tt)8Aeqit & 1 9... 'l~ CM; (,1 •-21•.~L.&.:.•~~.:..• --------·------~--.-------~ &!0 '~~CHQ(lt])a7e29~ ~90 ,~~=~;(ttO.)~=·~'~·~!~'L'-------------------------------------------------700 '~~CH~(lt5l•7,2'~ 710 ,~XCM;t1t&l•~·''' 120 ~V,~C~(1otl•G•3•• 730 ~10'C~tltZlat&,O!t 1UO ~YO'C~Cltl)•t~.e~, 750 ~~'U!~•48~J308 LBC04LH1 TON~OAL~2 1b0 48PJ~ILM!Jt GAL0IL*2C· ;AL.N;AS1 l 110 l~~~GASll ~C,NGASU~ ~C,COALrB 180 't0P~•1t --* .~e,NGA!2A TON• ''o ,ue~sT•10o,.zo~ •• zo3 •• &3~,.o •• ,o~ •• 3*3lo;,jo2:•20l •• 800 HVTABstZ+8t152+5t1S~•St13~000t13bOOOt13bOOOtt005•~•100!+~tl005•b• 810 t00$•~·~·~1~!~·~·~·~------~---------~---------------------------!20 trTlB•tt11t1tUt.t10t 830 IP4TFC•bti_!2tltlt311t1tlt!lC6• - 840 ~lT,C(tt1)11,000tt,038Gt1.ta598t1e0312t1,030t 850 tYR,C(ttll•· t~82• 1qq3, 20.07e aooe, Joso, ' 41f_j_'-'_~_ ,.. 7! o • 2 o o ! e' , e 1 , t o , 2 2 e , _ '50 ~~O<W:~,1,!1,J~,~*'••t•,!!t11,'~~·~------------------ ,b~ o~o'=~.sos•o., · 970 O~OW~a,\1,J,~1tZ*~~A,~.Je,o,~~u~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~·~~ qeo ~•TJMC1tt)•t,ooo, ~qo DATJ~(1t2)•t,OOOtl;Q6Qt1~00gJUL~u~~O~O~•~lwtwO~O~Out~------------------------- t000 IY~O~C1•2lat9~2•t~el,t9@5tt98e,1qea, iota PATO~C1•l)•t,ooo,i,ooo,t,ooo,t,ooo,t.ooo, 1020 IV~0~!193l•\9~2•t~8l,t98!ttqe•,t98e, ;o~o PATO~Cltulat,ooo, _, .. ···-.. - ·-, .. ~··.· .. ; : , ..... ~ Attachment 1.1 Page 3 of 7 Data Preparation/Generation Planning Model With-Susitna Case tolo o~~Y0•21,J,o,o,o. tO!O O~vHYO•O,OtOtOt . 10q0 PATHO~(t,tl•t,QOOtl•OOOtl.000t1eOOOtltOOOt !100 IV~HO~Clei)•l'S2ttq83tl985tlq&,,1,88~ t tt·O p ' T M 0 ~ ( 1 ! z l • 1 ' 0 0 0 • 1120 JAT~O~(t,l)at,OOOt 2130 JATH0~(1,U)•1,Q00t ·--~----------~-----------------1140 ~YR£TaQ0,30t20,20t20,30t50t50t!Ot!Ot 11!0 '0~~~•50oe1000,1500tt!Ot200t2!0t3e8Tt80r3te?,Bo, 1z ttt.O it5e10tt50t228,250t~ 111110 'O~AT[•3•0,01t3*0:057tb*0,080t3•0.0!t!*0 0 Q8n, 1o t 180 ·~~M ... a500t1000,t§,Ott!OtZOOt250•Jt81t80,JeiT 1 !0t 9 tt90 2tSt10t!!OtZ28oZ!Ot a !200 ~oqAT!al•0,1•3•o.~eo,&•o.o32•l•o,ot,J•o.o'O• 7 tZtO x~~DBs105~0t10300,ttabOt1!0b0t11SOOtS!Oo, 6 1220 XPOW1•0eSOt0•50t3*0,zO,O,l2• s 1210 ~'1N1~o.s!,o,!!•l•o.3e,o,us, .c t2UO ~O~PR80t 3 12Q5 IPATR~(i,~t~>~•~1~2~•~1~•----------------~----------------------- t 2 § 0 ~ 1 0. 7 • ·--. t 2&0 ~ ~l '4T_•.2! •·1 t 1210 bP~I~T•2!*0~ . -· ---·---..----·-- ti!O I~~A~[•3&~UN!T TVPE 1U~IT TYPE 2U~IT TVI! lt 1290 3&~UNIY TVP! UUNIT TYPE §UNIT TV~£ ~. t!OO I"tG~•b•t• 1310· Iq~A~!•12"4AlA!(A i320 <~~~~Tat,~.~.a,5,&, t3!0 ~A ... lJAL.•t, tlao ~qi:A:>•lS t3SO SI ... PJT 13b0 I"'fAaC~.&)a1t t370 .,.~:>B(U)•le J!!O P~INDe(Q)~O,!~t tl'O '~IN09(U)a0.~5t tl400 ~~;)8(10)~:], TITo ... P~INOa c 1 o) .n. 3Z. t420 '~lNOBCtol•o.~s. 1Q!O ~~!~0•25 1qt30 SI~~>JT tUSO 14~JRCt)•t• • 14&0 ~q'B(tS)a~*~'~'3~•~t~'----------------------------------------tu70 ~~E~D•.!S tl480 SI~PUT 1·4~0 \o4~0B(ti)c3*1• \500 ~R!-J-.OS 1510 SI~PuT t520 I~AXa&, 1slo-~'~E)e~.--------------------------------------------------- t5uo 12~B~ADL!Y LA~(~ 15!0 12~BE~U;l TRA~St 15~0 12~G~ANT ~~~~ , is7o 12~C~AKAC~A~~~ t 15!0 12~N!~·~A TR~~!t 1585 l2~N~~~N· COAL1t tsqo t~sroe.se,12t.ee.t2t,t2t.tit• llbOO (l~08a7ttt7t7tlt2t 1&10 CA~DB(Zl•t , \b20 c•~D6(S)•t•• JLblO '~•xoeCZl•o,ooooont. •Lhn DWAYnat~\.n.n~~ft~~1e f I I ' ' I I -I l I d :I ,j J I ,) .J -1 11 . I ' ~~f --~! ··J I lj I -i ;! ,. ,< ",} I .;] 1 l ! --I ',1 \ t p I ' ! I j "! { f I i I 1 I ! I J I I I [ I "l I I I I I l l I l ! ! I I I l 4-~ . ..,...t I ! l I I ' . ..,. t " Attachment. 1.1 Page 4 of 7 Data Preparation/Generation Planning Model With-Susitna Case J.j!O ,_:l~DBtZla!t tie.O J»ORDBC.Sl•lt t&10 0(~08(J)cQ111t ta!O OK~OBCll•220000, tbqO O~~CS(3)a3109~ 1700 0~N08(q)wij2]0t t7t0 0(~0!(5)•111000t24lG, 1120 I('TDBCZla!~ t730 ('T0Bt5):!t1ir t733 ~PlTOB(2)•1• t73& ~D4T08(5)•1• tTl& ~R~ec•J•ttooo, t7UO ~~OB(~)•b~,ao, !7U2 CAP08(~)•150t i744 O~vOBto)a~,tOt a t1!0 ;~INO~Cl,J)atZ•O• 7 iTQO ;~AX~!(t,l)•1l*'• , _,. -~ '-:.. . -· ... • ... 6 1100 lN~Y~8(1,3)ai.O•Z~O•la0e4•2eOt2*3eOtl*2.0t s t ! 1 0 G "'1 N 0 8 C t , ~ ) •1 Z • 0 , -:.--·-..:=-: ·.:.: ·=-..:;. · - -£ 1 S 2 0 G \4 A X v J! ( 1 , " ) -.1 Z * ~ l 0 t 3 1830 !~~V08(l,U)a13],,tta,,tt3~,qs,,~"L•9•••i3~o•i2e;,,,q,,12&.t12!,,ta~., t!'tO I(~JRfaul 18!0 SI~PUT 18&0 I~AX•!t 1170 ~A'ft!O~a t!!O 7~~~~,~T-,~~-,-1-,----------------------------------~·-------------------- t!q0 l3H,!v~I~L~C~~~~~Y~O~N~1~u~----------------~----------------------------- t900 7~~iTA~l2t 1910 11~J!~IL CANYON2~ 1920 7~~ATlNA]t t930 <~EJj!(l)•cOO~t2010e2010t t9UO ~l'4Daa5•7• 1950 I~STJ8zq3,~02t102e1!0t1\0t 19e;-o5·i( .~ t'i 6 • 7 2 B 9 , 3~~..:..5~'1=-, -=-n-=-, ~0 .:::.., -!-0 .::.., ..;_;:;....:;__ ________________________ _ iq1Q ~ ... INOB(1,tl•3Q~o34212~U,t9Ut18&t ~2, t q s o 1 o r, • u 2 t , lB o , 2 & & , " o s , ~l q·o , t9q0 ;~A~CBC1,1)•U&~~~~~S~•l~5~5~·~l~3~&~•~l~0~4~•~i~S~q~,~-------------------------------- 2000 2qOt4b0•3q3,409tS57t539t 2010 !~GV08(1,t)•3Ube2•Te2b4t2Q1t22bt18bt ~0~0 215tlU2t2!3t30Ut401tUOOt ~010 ;~XNOB(t~.2)•328t327•2q2tlt7t~~Ut28], ~040 2U!tZ,7•302t229tl01t35~t ~ 0! 0 ; ~A X 0 8 ( 1 ! ~) a 3 ~! t 3 q 3 t ll u· t 3! ! t 3 2 5 t ll8 t 20&0 21&t293tl04t309t!q4tUl4t 2010 EN;V08(1,2l•cq5•2~4t2ij8t2-~2~S~•2~~~~'~2~l~S~·~----------------------·---------- !080 205~2,8•2t9,229•c83,3~3. ~090 G~IN08~1,l)•t2•0, .... , .. ,_ -- +leidii!lNJ)if'>f'trrAi&'P~~-'-'---·~· ............. w""'""'""----_,_,, l . f. <) ! l l I I I Attachment 1.1 Page 5 of 7 Data Preparation/Generation Planning Model With-Susitna Case ~ t a) •Jio ... lt ••2Bflltl•7•2S2t2Tit lb!•2'~•3~5tZ12t31tt3GJt ~Mlxo8(1,1)•"!1•4~0~J•a,3b!tJb~•3~*' 3!3~363t!b,.33!~4!1t!03t tt!o 1190 tN~Y0!(1,4)a]~Ot3n2t213t2~5t272t2~Jt 2QOtl+O~Zble249t3Zq,]74t G~IN0~(1,5)•1Z;o, -.~~~----~------------~ 2200 !210 G~AXO!(lr!)sbQ3,~67eOG3t&!9•&t~t&50t 2220 Z2JO !ZGO !250 (~0RE•11 . l2&0S ~ROG"A"1t~L,I-fS Z27D' ~~MITISOt7~<t!Kt20K 2i80S ~~MFLI~••EtQ,AGUJOql/1 GPbGP 22901 'l~EtOt,~1~tlOOL 2300S 'ILEjOi,XiRtlOL 2310S ~lLEt03,X3~t20~ 2l~OS 'lL£111,~11RtiOL. !3!01 'Il£112,~t2~t!OL ~3,01 F~LEt1ltX13~t10L !3701 'lLEt1GtW14~t!L 2l!OS FlLEtl~tXl~~.tOL ~390S O&TAt15 .,, 240 oii-~EPOTIT0& , i4tOti~!~OTEI07 to l420iaR=[~~O~TE~I~08~---~--------------------------------------------- s~U30 St~PUT a l4UO Pti~ATE•1,0350t 7 !450 P~OV!:q•50t s ~UbO ~ODOV~•t,o,o,t,t,o,t,lot91t s !470 ~Y~Ov~•28•1• 4 2480 fXCHYO•l, 3 !4q0 !XCp.ii\XI!Ot . 2500 IYqAUT(l)aUOtlOt20t20•20tl~-,~S~o~,~5~0-,~S~o-,------------------ 2510 IVCSJSC1l•tO•l• ~ 2520 ~CT~I~•b•o, ~$30 .. _5.!_~-~-§••! .o,_ ... ------------------------!540 S~CR~T,l.OtaOt,t.Gt ,l550 '1IX=1• !5b0 'w4Af0~80t ! 5 ' 0 'J ~ . .:! .... t 0 ' 2580 £x~~x~,~u~.~~~.~o~-o~,~-~-~------~==~~----------------~------- 2sqo fXOM~~·o.ooot, 2~oo ~·~,o-•~t• ~e.to <!¥£'4V=•t• ZbbO <Z~~EaqtSt8eQ;t2t12• ------· _1b 10 ~! VC ~T•• t t ---------~----------2680 -~o~O!Q~1,3,2, !bqO ~<ODE(~•~' ·~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~------~~~~~ - t I Attachment, 1.1 Page 6 of 7 Data Preparation/Generation Planning t1odel With-Susitna Case 2700 l~!~YP•bt!ttt!tt;i~ !710 S~~FORa2,0t1e~t1aOt1.0,t,Ot1t2!J 27~0 S~<PORaZ,Ott.~,l,OtlaOtl,Otlo2S• !130 J<!¥PRCe•tt ~7"0 ~RIN'iXal,Ot "',,~·,,~ :j;:;:'C~ ·: ~:::t,{ ::;;~, 2745 Y~IN~xaO,J0~,----~----~--~----------------------·---- ~7!0 ~~OL~C1l•O•t 27&0 I(J.OLP t'2la0, .~----------------------!770 <'-.OLPC£4)•1• ~7!0 RE~ENG•Suooo,uq~oo,l~ooo,uoooo,~bOOOtl3~oo. 27~0 3.000t3UOOntl7000t3SOOOo3~~00tl!~OOt l800 lCOST;teat, ~810 IFSPcOt ~820 TVC!TaOt Z 8 3 0 ~ ( 0 D [ •( 1 ) • 1 t !840 ~1(00!(4)s0t !850 'J.COD!(Slcte , ., ~8b0 K~~ER!aO,. __________________________________________________________ __ !870 ~FIRSTaO, ~8!0 ~~TP!('-1at, Z8q0 ~PA!~TZI2*0t !900 (J~El•ZS•Ot tttO <0)!2•28••1t 2920 K•~E~Val•t,n, !930 !!PR~T:!.o, 1.~"0 <OCU~Tat, l950 ~~SU'-42at, l(I&O '<PSU,.uat, ~c;Yo <!lJEC&l•t• 2~80 ~l:l1•7· 2~QO L.SP•\~!=1, JQOO IC!'fSJ~ao, ]010 ~U~1:8t J020 I'fREAOc19Q3! !OJ,Q Sl 'lPJT _u_4lo <~:>EC7l:.o, 12 JOSO Y~lN~x:aO,\Ot ,, JOilS ~~"1VJ•21,02t 10 ~~0&0 I if~E40st9QbS 9 J070 II ~PJT a 31 0 0 R! 1.£ ~ C •li+ ~ 0 0 0 t a '19 o 0 0 , 2 Z 5 0 0 0 t 1 8 10Q 0 0 t 1 8 S 0 0 o , q 2 o o o t 1 .11_1 o t 1 'on o, 31 & o o o, 31, t o o o • 2 3.b..Q o o, l 2 & on o, u n 3 o on, 6 ]~lAO IV~EA~•19Q7S s !150 5I~PUT A !15! ~"'"'"0•1~.2Gt - 3 Jt&o ~E~E~G•3u~ooooz!~non,225ono.teooon,!e!ooo~ Q200nt 1110 1t7000tl2~no0,311000•236000tlcbOOOeU0300nt Jt80 IV~EA,•19QqS J1QO Sl\iPWT 3i~-~l.E\IG•3q!_ooo. 21~noo,22~ooo.1~ooon. t e5ooo, "2noo, 1210 117000tl38D00,311000t23b000,]2bOOOt~n3POOt -:1:::..:2~2::-::0::..-.:::I:...::V:--~.;..::E~4~0=--•-2-;~0:...:;0...:0:...:;S;__ ________________ ~--....,..,--, 3230 SI'JPJT ~Z50 IV~!A0•20011 c,..: -," - ., ..... ~ .... I h.- ! ;,, 1 ,, I ; i ~ ) ( I , I l ' i \ ' i ! ') l l I I . '1 ' i i i \ I l [ ! I 1. I I ! l l .. j ! j ~ ,l u II! II { 1 I t i I il I l J I I l 1 ! I J ! ! ·I ' 1 l ! I ! I ! ! ! "') I I l ' I I I ! . l ! I I J 1 I -.fj( Attachment 1. .1 Page 7 of 7 Data Preparation/Generation Planning Model With-Susitna Case 32&0 Sl~PJT 3270 R!~ENG•34qOOOe27qno0,22!000e18Q000t\8~000t qzOOOt ,aeo tt7ooo,J47~oo,3ttooo.23•ooo.J2oono.4nlooo, ~2q0 JY~E•o•2002S , ~300 SI~PJT ~tO ~~~V0a10,2bt0t0t0t. 31~0 ~f~E~G•5l!OOOeqb1000,U&~OOOt~02000t350000e34!000t 3330 34~000t3&3000,3!0000tU5700Ct505000e585000t 3340 IV~EA~•ioo;s Jl50 SI~PUT J3bO R!(E~~~G~.~s~~-o~o-n-o-.-u-q-,-~-o-o-,-u~s~2-o_o_o-.~u~2-o~o~o-o-.~3~5~o-o_o_o_.-3-&·2~~c-o-o-,-----~--- ~31o 3;0000t3?8000,3Q8~00t41QOOOt5050oo,!9J000r 3380 I1~£AO•Zoo•s 33q0 II~PUT 1400 O~~YOa s.~7t0e0•0t 34\0 ~E~E~G•5b~ooo.snuooo,ua2ooo.~23000t35oono.3~qooo. 1c2o 3&&ooo.uotnoo,utqooo9u7aooo.soso~~.!QtOoo, JOlO IYREA0•2Q08S J£&410 SI~P;JT 1ij50 ~!~E~G•5&JOOOt50U000 1 UB20~0t423000t350000t3QjOO~t !~&o 3&&ooo,"zoooo,4~uooo.u7eoon.so~ono.~QtOOOt ! it!_O __ I tf ~! A:)• ~ 6! 0 t Jtaeo SI'4PIJT )4qO o~~Y'• !,uq,o,o.o, "-------------------------------1500 ~EL£~G=S3~000tU!lOOO,UbtOOOtU090009328000eU21000t ~sto J~eooo.uaboon,a7oo~o.suenoo,u93ooo.!&JOoo, 3520 lY~EAOa2otiS l!lO St~PUT ]Sao ~£~f'4~&53qOOOtUA300n,aetOOOeU0900~t~28000tU!100nt J55o 3 !oooiu5 noo-a~noo ,su ooo.~~l o n. J5&0 IY~EAOa OtlJ 1570 ~!~~~~~T~----------------------------------~-------------1S~O <J:>£(7)•1• ~5QO O"~OAl.•lOt 3~00 IY~E~~~2ot~l "1&\0 Sl~PUT 3~~0 R£~E~~aS3qOOOt~8lOOO,QbtOOOtU09000t!28000tU21000t J&lo l&~ono,~52non,saoooo,sue~oo,u~3ooo.5b3000• 3&12 I'f~~A~•2ot5S . 3&114 SI~PUT '3&3o -<nOE(7l~o. !o~7 PR•o•~·o~·--------------~----~~~~~~~-------------1bao lV~EAD•iOibS !bSO SI~PUT 1&oo R!~E~G~.-s~1-~-o--o-o-,-4-8~l-o-o~o-,~u&--to-o~o-,~~~o-q~o-o-o-,~l~i~8-o-o·-o-.-u-~-1~o-on-. -,-------- 3&7Q 3bg000tQ~2nOOf!3iOOOt54!000tU93000o!~3000t 3&!0 1¥~EA0•2ot8S !bqO SI~PUT 1 z 11 o o ~ E ~ E -.. G-i 51 -q o o o , ~ ~ 3 o o o-;-li o t o o o • 4 o ~ o o o , 1 z e o o o , 4lt o o o • 11 ~'i 1 o 3&~ooo, us2noo, 511 ooo, SQ8000 ,l49l~ooo, 5&3000 • to 3 7 2 0 I v ~ E ~ ~ • ~ 0 2 0 S ~ . ~~ -~~ ... . ··~· . -· - 9j7~$ KOPT•1t0tOt1tit0~1t1tit1! a l730 Sl"iPuT 7 ! 7 4 0 ~ ! \,! ~G. ! 3 ~ 0 0 0 ! 9 ~ 3 0 0 0 I " b t 0 n 0 • 4 0 ~ 0 0 0 ' 12 8 0 Q 0 I q 2 1 «tQ.!).u•~--- 6 1750 3b8000tl4S2n00,,31QOOt5Q8000;49lOe&i5·3~QSt • s 376·0 IVqEAO•Os --. ~-.. .... _..,......_ __ _ l --_ - r ~· I " I , . I J 1 I J l l il } l I j i , I J 7 ~ I !I I I :1 l :1 ,! fj 1 J l I f i I ~I f I ,, r I I I I I ' I 1 ·"'1 I J I I J r I ii I i I I 1 I I ! I . I I I I I ( I I ! J l '1· ,. c ~ ~ : : ;, ii ': ·: ;U >'' :·\· ,,_ ·. ' .. ;[ :._ Attachment 1. 2 Page 1 of S Data Preparation/Generation Planning Model Without-Susitna Case ..:t~Q~O~B~R..:;.U__;.,*------------------... ,,----------t10 !!N t20 ··~~R\4 t]O Sl•~o;qA~aqLMS J.! 0 i i L. ·I._. ITS I 0 5, '7 0 ~ , , t ~I( -·---------------- 150 SI~~~,L~HttEt~t-QGJOQ]/,SP~OP tOO Sl'~~'l101eRt5eAQ~3b.8~!.L~~~N~S~O~U--~---------------------------- ~TO SI~~M,LJ02tRtS-AQ~~&!2/w~84UP 180 II,~L!I03,~3St!Ol 190 SIO~TAI1S :!00 St'l!P-40TEIO~ !tO SD~£~0TEI01 ~20 N, PA~!Ie 230 MAqZAa!SA!C~ !USIT~A J~INT VfNTUR! 2a0 711 ~ STREET 250 A~CMO~l~!~ AlASKA 99~10 !•0 II'4,UT 210 IOts1S~A~~SKA RAtlB!LTt !80 T Ol•&0-40!1 STA?·, NS" ~A 8 leO At.~· COAL.• Be ~M t SC'it QA S, !!ASCOA L;. 290 .~ST4RT•19,3t I 'JOO 'JT~TA~aZ!, ll 0 'J Y C J 5 T n 1:; 8 2 t l20 t.JY'14TH•19!2t l30 IOfrP!•~!~~UC~!AR COl~· ST[A~NGAS TUqRINEOIL GAS TURBt J40 2a~oiE!!L1 Ieee~ eve~! cc. 350 48HeONV. HVDRoPU~' STORAG!!NG !TOR 2ENG STO~ 3.0 IOY~NEalb~~U~! COAL' NGASGTOIL GTOIE'E~eOMC~C• !10 c~~~YORO PSM !!•2 ES•l t 380 "~~ANf~it J90 'f~A~EO•l• UQO ~TTYP~••1tOt2t2t2t1t Q10 ~SIZESC1tt)a1500• 020 ~•~,~~(1•tl•~oso~ J30 XSIZESC1t2lx200, o4o ~•~,~~t1•2l•t9ez, USO ~SIZ£SC1t3l•A7t u•o ~A~,~~<1•3>•t,eaL ITO XSIZ!SC1t4)a!7e ]f 480 ~A~F~~(1t")a!Q~2~.--------------------------------------------uqo ~SIZESC1t5l•10t $00 ~·~~~~C1t5l120~0! !16 XS!ZESt1to)a228e ~20 ~·~~~~Cl•bl•tqe!, 530 OfR~YOaOe9!tOtOtOt §qO CAP~l~•O•lt J_ .. - .. )I ' n; I ' I ' - 'I ;I i ' :;J ;I ' i' I, ; ·"· :I "' ., ,I It -i -' ~~· n ,, " II ,, 1i \I . ! ~ p ,I l j l I ~ ;1 I I l f ( I 1: [ I 01 I i ! 1 I I I I I j l l I I ,I • I l .) l I l l ' '''-:'!1 Attachment 1.2 Page 2 of 5 Data Preparation/Generation Planning Model Without-Susitna Case 570 !SIZE~•llJ,250t!Ot ~80 ESIZES•llJo,2SOOt500t 12 !90 ~~ESCc)•r.&SOOt 11~00 ·~c~wa750,200e~1e87e1o~·~2~2~!~·-~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ to ~1ft JtL.COK~al·OoOt25.52t479•QY9,!&catb1&t 9jiO D~COFso,~o.s•o~ · a ~30 P4T~C(tt1)•1,000t 7 &40 tY~PCCt•2>•1q!2,19QOet9q!tt~q2t 6 ~50 'AT~C(1t2)•1,000t1,000t1.000t1,000t s •bo '~T~CC1t1):t,ooo.t.ooo.t:oooetgooo~ 4 & 10 ,. T JtC ( 1 t ~)at , 0 0 0, 3 &ao ·~TPCCtt&)•t.ooo.t~:~o~o~o~·~t~~~o~o~o~·~t~·~o~o~o~·------------------------------ ~qo yvq~cct.ll•1QS2,19~o.tq9t,tQq2, 100 IY~~CC1tbl•!QS2,19qo,nq91t19q2t 110 PATPC(tt!)at~OOOt 12.Q __ _!_A_!_-tPeJ lt! t!.1t OQ{> ~j .~OO_~t-!.t_._,-=-0~0-=.0..!..w~i ..... -=.O..:..O.:..O~t-------·------ 130 tY~~~CC1t1)a19@2,1Qq0,19q1•1q92t ?40 DAT-t~CC1t~l•3•1.000t TSO '1XCH~C1ttla4,qJ, TOO '1~CH;(lt2la5,&Q, ?70 r7XC~;C1t3l•7,!9t 180 r«~CMGC1tG)c1,2'' 790 ,~XCH~C1t5)•7.~9~ 800 '1~:H;t1tb)s!,&9t ato ~YJ,cqc1•t)sa,l&, 820 ~1~,C~Cl•2la1~.o,, 830 ~y~;c~C1•3l•tb,S&t 840 ~~FuE~•4!~J308 LBCOAlHS TO~COA~~z !50 "81140ILU2f 1 liAL01~L•2C• QAL.NtiAili 8&0 3._-t~Gl!~3A ~CF~(iASU& -..c,COAL; ! ~C,N~AS2A TON !90 ~VTlBat2+&eiS2+!t15Z+5t1!bPOOt136000tl~~OOOel00,•&•100~+t,100!+bt 'OO t00S+.t15+6t 9t0 I'fAB•lt11t7tUt~t1nt •zo t~ATFCaOt2t2t3tltltl•i•1t!t~t '10 ~ATFC(tt1)at,OOOt1 1 0384tle~b59e,t.037~t1 1 030t '40 JV~'CC1•1ll ~~ez, 1qq3y 2007t 2008t 2010, •so ••T'CCtt2)at,000tt.oto11el,Ol001tleOt019t 'J60 yyqJC(!t2)•.:.J~~z, t"Qle 2000,, zotOr 970 PAT,CC1tl)•t.OOOtt.OUOtl,Ol6' •ao IV~FCC,t3l•t~e~~~'w1~q~q~l~•~2~0~1~0~•~-----------~----------~--------------- 9qO tAV,C(1t~)at,OOOt1;01014ele0101St~,00874,t,Ot4Q1t tooo ~~~FCC1tQ)a1~~~. 1q9~• 2000, zoot, 2o;o, toto PATFCC1•5l•t.ooo,t,nles,t.2B77,,1.~372tt,o~o, 1020 IV~FCC1t5la lfJ!2e 1qqJ, 2007t 20Q!, 2010 . lOlO 0~~Wc750,200t!7e81t10t22!t tooo O~J~~·9•t•5t.3&•2*'•b1t,5!,tt,7~• tosa o~~Fao,!,s•o,, to~o O~)H~•.1tt3.bt,2•o,2!•5;3e,0;$4t 1010 ~Afu~Cl•tl•t.ooo, ioao P~TO~C1t2)at.ono.!.aoo.t.ooo,t~.o~o~o~•~t-·~o~o~o~·L---~-------------------- --~r·-"':·---·~ ·--··-· ~-~-\~ ~--· . -. --- \:;, . ' •. . -2& -..,.-~.· ... ·-··.1'.•' •--"'···--',, l--- ;I .I ~~ I .1; I ; l • I .. ., 'I· • 1 I l ' ,I I I I 1·. ·.j ' . i ' . I I I I Attachment 1. 2 Page 3 of 5 Data Preparation/Generation Planning Model Without-Susitna Case to«Jo Irt~o~c1•2l•t~az,t•s:~,t9.es.t•e•,t••e, .. ~. ~ _ J 1 o o P ' r o '-4 c 1 , 3 ' • t 1 o o o , t 1 o o o , 1 • o o ft , t • o o o , t ..._o o a 1 ··-· · · · --· .,. · · · ' · - t.llO IVR0\4(1tJ)at982t1C,53 1 t,A5e1fJ8fttl981t .:-: .:. -··· j120 ~•ro~t1•qlat,ooo. · 1130 ~ATO~(lt!)at,OOOt ~140 ~ATO~(ltblatvOOOtilcoo,t,OOOti,OOOtt,OOOt · 1150 I¥RO~C1t,lat9!'Ztlq83 1 1fi85t1q&•t1fl88t ... St~O O~~VO•Z1,3tOtOtOt 1170 O~VMYO•O,OtOtOt !180 ~iTHO~C1 2 tl•1,000 1 1,oOOtt,QOOt1,QOOt1eOOO~ !lCJO lf~MO~Cltt)at9&2tt983t1q85t198~t1988t 1200 'ATH0~(1,Z)at 1 00Q, i210 PATH0~(1,3)•t~ooo, , i220 PAT~O~Ct,o)at,ooo, 1 . . t230 ~VR!:T•40,JOtZOt20,20,30tSOt!il)t!09!0t-· · ... -12~0 .,o~~~·soo,tooo,t!OO~t!0,200•iSo~3.e7,!0lJ.sr.eo~ t2 tiSO 2t5t10t!!Ot228\2!0t 1 ,, tibO '.j~AT!•l•o,ot •3•o:osz•••o,o8o,J•o,o!,~J•o.oeo. , o t 21 o ,. o ~t ~ ~ • s o o , 1 o f.J o , t s o o , 1 s o , z o o , z! o , J , s T , u o , s , a' , eo • 9 izao i•S•1~•t5o,j28,2So, e 12qo •o~AT[•l•o.t,J•o,oso,b•o,o32,J•o.ot,3•o:o,o. '1!00 ~~qoaat05~p.to3oo.t!~•o 1 tto~o.ttiOOtB!oo. 6 tl10 x•owtao.so,o,!o•l•0,20tCe32• · · -·-. -- s t320 X'lN1a0,55t0,55tl$0,38tOoC5t "!330 IP&T~~(l 1 t)a1Z•1 1 3 t340 \111~~P~•O• t3!0 ~3~•7t .,. . . . tl~O ~P~%~~•28'1•--- 1370 ~P~l~T•2e•O• i3~0 II~A~!clb~UNIT TVP! tU~IT -~T~Y~P~f~2~U~N~I~T~-I~V-~~!~l~•~~~~~~~~~~ tl'O lb~UNIT TYP! UUNIT TY'! ~UNIT TV•! bt 1400 I~[GN•o*t• 1~10 I~~·~!at2~ALA!<A ta~o <0~-~T•ttJ,J,a.~,,, 1410 \Al'JUA1.•1 1 14UO '4"£A!)a11 t t490 '~1~Q!(1)•0.~!, 1500 l~TASCq)•lOt 1510 ~~~'BCSla~l~,~------------------------------------------- tSZO P~~~0~(5}aO,llt t!!O '~1NOB(!)a0 1 Q5 9 t5UO ~q!*O•iS ·------------------------------------------·--------~ 1550 SI~PUT t5&0 ~~OB(t)•t~--~-------------------------------------------------15'70 "1~:)8(15la3*1tlt1t _lS!~~E,.;)a3S t5q0 SI\IPUT t&OO ~q~e(t2la3*1• toto '4~!~0•01 ; ~ 2 0 S I \J ~·..J T l~lO IIAAX•T, -~------l - I I .\ ("'0 I .. i ~ I I ·--, .. ~··--·-·---·-·-··--- ~ ; ' .... - Attacrunent 1. 2 Page 4 of 5 na·::a Preparation/Generation Planning Model Without-Susitna Case 1eTO 12~G~lNT ~-K[ , tbao 12~CMA~,c~•~~' , !&QO 12iSECO~O TRA~So 1 b~2 12-tNE~·~A COAL.1., _. ,o~4 1~1NE~A~& C~A~it i100 I~ST09ase.~l.~5e121•tns,q3,9bt t7t0 Kl~DBa7t1•7•7tlt2t2t t720 CA~D3C2)at o 1110 CA~OS(5)a\t200e2~o, t1ao ~~,x~B(2)•o.ooooont, 1750 P~~XOB(!)•O~OOOOOOlt 17&0 ~0~09(2)•1• =----------··---....,....,.----- 1110 ~oqoecSl•-1• t7!0 DK~DB(l)atttte 1?90 OK~OBC2la220000t )800 0~~0Stlla370!e ~ItO 0(~08(4).~2l0t j !20 O~:NOB C5)at 1'1000, ~alo ~<,TOS(c)a!, t8GO ~••T08(2)•1• t8GS 0(~08(6.)a2*2b01t t841 <'~oacol•~•2• ,= t!!O f<'·TDBCSlllSt ~1~!~&~0~~~~~~~T~O~B.~C~Sl~•~1~·~~--------------------~---------------------------~ 121570 ~"t4IN~!(1,t)•12•0t • tt tS80 G~lXO!(le1)•12*90t~~~~~~~~~--------~~~------·-------------- 1o 1!90 !N;t~OB(l,t)•3tt21rt,1tZ!e2t23e4t2$e~tiU~.boJO,!tll,1t 9 -:t....,.:9~0....::;0--:~"'!":"'Z:'-=-:"-=-~._, -:--=-2..:.!~1 ~Q !~· l 0 1 b t ~ Q 1 & f l i 1 ' f a tfltO G1t1IN0!(1,3)•12*0t 71920 G"'.XJBC1!J>•t~•'• . 6 !930 !N.¥08(1,ll•2.0e2,0t1•0•1*2•0•2'3•0•3*2.o, s 19~0 ;At4IN08(1,fl)a12•0t • t•!o GM•xoe(t,A)ai!*l30t · .-*· ~-... =.:; .. ; • ._·--~ -·-.-·--~--· .. 3 iq&o !~GifOBC.t,fll=t33.,t14,,1tl.~'e,,qo,,q&.,tJ~ •• z2e,,t7",,1Z~ •• tae.,tutJ,, 1970 K~ORf.a1S ~ t9!0 SI~RO~R4~iRL~S t9qo sa~a~ITSa!o,72<•e~.2oK !OOO sa•~~'L•~•t!t;!&Q~3093/~;P&GP 2010 Sl,cr~!tOteX1RtiOOL ~02~0~S-~J~!I0lt~~q,10L 2030 S F~~!I03tXlqtZOL !QUO S ,a~!tOq,XQq,JOL 2050 S ,a~!l10tX10Rt2~ 20&0 S '~~~l\ttXtl~t20L 2070 S '~~!112eXt2R,50L !O!O S ~~~!t13eXt!Rt10L 2090 S F~~E11"tX1~R,~L '-100 $ '1~!11beXtbR,1QL 2110 S )ATA115 2120 S PlE"1:lT!:aO& 2130 s ~E"10T!~07 21QO S ~E~OT!ioe · 2150 S \4PUT ~tbO '~~AT!•l,Ol!Ot • .JaJiiift"•" l!/Y'it:Wwik?/ ·w'"-'t·'tt'M :!ti&·rittdt..w~M'v'•ute:t# *;, . " -. - .. -' ... Attachment 1. 2 Page 5 of 5 Data Preparation/Generation Planning Model Without-Su~itna Case Zt!O ~O,OVRai,DrOtltltOt!wltltJI· !l'O ~V~DVR•2a•t• !200 ~~="vo~l r) -• -•. ··-. ···--.... ,_ ~ 21 0 [:X : r.4 A X a 0 , . • . _ . :·' .:·· . J?ZO IV~AUT(t)•UOt30t2ntlOt20tJCt!O,!Ot50t 2230 I~C6u8(i)wto•t, 2240 ~CTI~I'4•~•0r )250 SPRES••l 1 0t . Z2&0 SRCROTut,o,,ot,t,o, Z210 ~IX•1• !280 '4•TORaOt 22'0 ~L,i'Wa10t 2300 E~~XPUct,oo, II . " ... -· 2310 !XJMnM•O,OOOlt l32.0 R4~FOR••tt ~2~l~3~o~~~!~~~E~~--v-.-.~~~,---------------------~--------.--.--.-. ----~~--------- Z3~~ KOPT•1t0t0tltlt0tt!t,1tit 2350 FAII.•Ot !3b0 ~C~C~!•trtt3tlt3t1t 2310 \ju~ZO~•&.,, !3!0 (Z0N!s4t1t.8t4t12ti2t 2390 (!'(C~T••1t !GOO ~OqOER•1,Jt!y 2 Q t 0 ~ ;( 0 0 ! .( 8 ) • 0 • .· .. !420 t~STY~ao,J,1t1t1e!t !430 !~CFOR~2sOt1e!t1eOti,Ot1eOtt.15t 2"' ~ 0 s .. ( p 0 R. 2 • 0 ' l • ! t! I 0 ! t I 0 ',;:;..1 ,.._O;;...t.._1 __ ,-...;;2;;..5."-"•-------------- 2a5o ~!1P~C••tt . !4 & 0 y ~ 1 N ~)( •O I lj ____________________________ _ 2470 ~~~N~Xat,O, 2480 ~~OL~tllao,, 2Uq0 ~LOLPC2lao,, ~500 -cLOLPC4)att HtO ~!\,E·'tG•S"ooo,ti900C,3'l000tUOOOO,llb000,33000t ~5~0 3.600t!UOOQt!7000t18000,34000r3!00Qt 1Z 253~ 1(0~f(7)&Qt n ~SI.lO (~STJtC•1, tO !$!0 I'SP•Ot 9 ~Sf»O TVCST•Ot s 2570 NPCJOECl)z'lt I-- 7~!~5~!~0_. ~~~<~0~0~~~'~4~)~•~0~·---------------------------·-· ---------------------- 6 ! 5 q 0 ._. ( 0 0 £ '( 5 ) IJ1 ' .. .... .. s 2&00 t<~~EREI!O! _ 4 2b10 ~'lRSTaO, 3 !~20 ~~TP<~•t, !&10 ~JqJ~T•12•0• !b40 !(0~E3•2!•0• 2&50 (0JEia28t•l• 2~f».Q_ ~RE ~V• !' 1_, 0 t ·--~------~----.---------------. !b70 E!PR~Ta5,0t _lf>!O I(Jt:U"1T•t, 2t;q0 !(P!U~2•1, ~a 1 o o I( ~ s u ~ a• 1 , 2710 KOOE(&)111t "2 7 2 0 .., 3 ;:) •7 ' 27!0 \.S~AQE.,1, !740 ([YSU~aO, ''"-............ ;Bi'tJJ Otc .. - I I I I . r ·~. } lr . ~ J I 11~ Attachment 1. 3 Page 1 of 2 ALASKA RAILBELT EXISTING GENERA-'T1ION MJDEL G184UP LiSTt~G OF INPUT OATA 1 ~A~ZA•EBA~CO SUStT~& JOINT VENTURE 2 111 ~ !TREET 3 A~CHORAGEtA~AS~• qq510 a ATT~ ~. ~A~SIC 5 ~INPUT . b !D1:15HAL~SKA.RAILBELTt · 7 TD~:32~EY!STJ~G GENERATtn~ ~OOEL GM8UUP, ! NEw:1t Q ~7=7!· 10 $lNPIJT 9 t..~EW:,, ·Q 'A7:7S 10 ~INPUT \1 I~A)(K18t .. 12 ~AMEf'>6a 11 ~8HA~~PO JNXT*1AM~P~ JNIT•?~~L~O U~lT$3AM~PD UNIT*~' --· _ .... lu a ~;.{A 1A1. o 0 :J N ! T t: C A u l. P 0 \.P.J t T ~ ~ 9 E L tl G A ~ T • \ B f: I. U G A G T tt ~ t ' 1 S ~bH8EI..UGA GTrt!BFI.UGA GT•C\BELtJGA ~c-~, t~ a~MBER~ICE GT~tBER~ICE GT-2REP~ICE GT~38ER~ICE GTuu, 11.. J b H l ~.J T S T A G T # 1 I t.J T S T ~ (i ,, ~ 2 I ~~ T S T A G T IW 3 , 1 9 T ~J!fT 0 B • ,. &?.teUtbBt72t7qt82t&8tb8,73t75t~2t 20 b3t72t7Bt8~t&Utb5t7Dt ?1 ~RI)g: 22 1*tunoo,12~oo,esoo.125oo.2•ssooo.2*1000o•Bsoo• 23· ~*?3aoo,t2ooo,!•1Snoo, ?u CA~DR; , ?5 ?•16e2~t1Bt32t13Q,Q0•2•tb,1,5J,SA,178t8.bt ~~ 18.q•2*2o.a,2ttaql8~ ' 7 K I t·• n A : ~~ a•3,b,5*l•b•~*3•3*3• ? It' I< FT·l') B::: 30 b,7,5*10tQ*7t3*7t '1 1(•4(H~E:Of 3 ~ ·~'INpUT .33 T\.1Ax:2:3t ~Q '-tAVE,OB: ~; LJ8HHEALV lb ~~HZ U'JIT 3 1 IJ B H z u /IJ I i -;q U~HZ U~IT 3 q lll~ "'~ C: ~·H:.*.J ~ UQ 'l)bHF~US ll1 'fi\ISTDB= STjlHEA!.':' "1CTZ UNI! t$C;;JCZ UNIT #CiiiCZ UNl'T tt3STCHENA ~1!CF'-4US iC:fl~~nPOl..E tt2CTl UNIT ~6tCi Ur.JIT fi10l'CCHENA #li:tcHE~A •~It:FMUS u~ &7t&7,76,77,71t72t7Se7S,bO&~• U] SUt52t~2tb3t70Q7btb7•&8ebSt au ~~oa= . CT*\NOFOLE •3CTZ IJNIT *7 ICzUNIT *1STCHENA *SSTCHENA $3lCe t;T#2• *~CTt •81Ct •2STt MbCTt ~s 13~oo,1osoo,2•tunoo.4•1~noo, u& b*tunu~1taooo,22ooo,22non,,soo~.t3320t1S000,3*t2t50• -· lf7"' -· t:APnA: ·-. " · ·-·· -· US 25t2e7Stb5tb~t18;~,17.u,3.5,3.~tb*3•~• aq -;,2,.5,1.5, so· 7•2t•2a.s,3•2.7S, 51· ~<INo8: ,, ~\;;\ f i I ~ ' i ~~,f ! d ~ .. 11 I ·' . I 'I :-/'· d I '• 0':1 ,·;I ; l ' I I I -'l D I 'i ! I d q I I J I ~~ •7 •:ijl ;n ;li;•) ;j I ~, .·{ ' . ~, .'• .I ·l ' I 'i , I ,, I '11 i! lj '[ :j I (1 .! tl it ,, :t I !'t rl il I' d ;i.f f I 'l i :/j jj lj li r ,, I. ll 1 I 1 l I Jl II !I j -! \ i. ..... : ,' ' 5~ 53 ~u 55 5~ 57 5! 59 &o bt b2 &! bLl bS b~ KFTOB• 2•o,u,u,u•a•&•b•3*2,u,z,a,3•~• ~lw10RE•OI' JINPUT I~Axatbt MA~£08• Attachment 1. 3 Page 2 of 2 ~8HHO~ERK[N lCPTe GR~HAMICS[LOOVIA *tSE~DOVIA ~2t 4!~!EL00VIA •lTAL~[ET~A IeeE! UNIT •t!fS UNIT 12t 3bHSES UNIT M3EKLUTNA ~V~RCOOPER LA<E, bOHUNIV A( •tSTUNIV AK •(STU~!V AK MlSTUNIV AK •tiCU~IV .ciNoB• q•5,791t Kl~D9(t2):3•2,2•5t !~STt')B• 79t71e52tb~tTOtb'7t&S,b5t6St55t&1t5*80t ----~~K~R~E~rDBC10l• ?•2o l• b'1 &8 b'i 70 '71 72 73 '~ 75 1b 77 7! 7q Ao 81 82 ~'5 ~~De• q•tsoon, H~DBC12)•3*12000t2*10500t CAPoRc ---------~~--------------------------------------·: ~~q,o,2,n.3,o,~,o.~,o.q,,,~,t.~•2a~' -~ CAPOB(t2l~2•t,Sti0t2•2.75 9 KlfTDB:: q.b, KFTOB(12j~ 3•2•2•b• G '1 I N 0 B·C 1 • t 0 l • 1 2 '' 0 t r,~Ax~rf,tO)a12*lO• ~ t~ G V' t5 8 ( 1 e 1 0 l !: 1 Ll ' 1 2 ' 1 2 t t 0 , t ~ , 1 2 , t3t1Ue13ttLleta,t~, l.~. G~INDBC1t11)~t2•o, _ ----=~___;,G~~-:A::-:-)(~1)=-=B~(~l:--•-:1~1:-:):-=....:l::..'.i·--::' '=-1~b::-•;;...':.:--~~-----------------------~ .... ~~GyDBC1t11)aa,S•3tUt«t3t3*4• r ~a ~5 8& 1<\4\0REct I I S1 SENoJOB ( I . ····· .. r·~--------------···-. !I I 1: I {) I I I I l J l I LOAD MODEL -LMNSDU 110 BRO * 120 BEN · 130i4N:R1 140$:PRO:iRAM:RI..HS l50$:LIMITS:02,32K,,10K 160$:PRMFL:H*,E,R,AQ43093/.LDMD6 170$:PRMFL:01,W,S,AQ43682/LMNSDU 180$:~:15 190$:REMOI'E:06 200$:REMOI'E:07 210 HARZA-EBASCO SUSIT~ JOIN!' VENIURE 220 711 H STREEr 230 AN:HORAGE, ALASKA 99510 24·0 ATI'N: N. PAl'CIC 250 1563.040 TASK 40 260$I~ 270 !1"'1 34HHARZA-EEASC0 SUSITm JOINr VENIURE, 28G ..r.D2=35HAIASKA RAILBELT NID UPDATE ~I 290 NIUrAL=40, 30~ mTARI=l981, 310 1~1, ·320 ~1, 3 30 NEWP=6HRAILBT, 340 !alC=6HRAILBT, Attachment 1. 4 Page 1 of 4 350 PCOI..MW=569,601,637,670,703,734,764,794,825,855, 360 876,895,915,935,955,972,989,1005,1023,1040, 370 1065,1090,1114,1140,1165,1200,1234,1269,1305,1339, 380 1373,1408,1444,1481,1519,1558,1598,1639,1681,1724, 390 AEMWH=2750000,2906000,3083000,3245000,3406000, 400 3546000,3687000,3829000,3970000,4111000, 410 4206000,4302000,4397000,4492000,4588000, 420 4670000,4751000,4833000,4915000,4996000, 430 5117000,5238000,5359000,5481000,5602000, 440 5771000,5939000,6107000,6276000,6444000r 450 6610000,678b000,6955000,7135000,7318000, 460 7507000,7701000,7899000,8103000,8312000, 465 ISPEX:=1, 466 P~.917,.867,.787,.695,.630,.600,~S96,.636, 470 .690,.794,.926,1.000, 480 PUANP=.917,.867,.787,.695,.630,.600,.596,.636, 490 .690,.794,8926,1.000, 500 PUMR(l,l)=1.0000,0.9157,0.8892,0.6322, 510 PUMR(1,2)=1.0000,0.9246,0.8977,0.6333, 520 PUMR(l,3)=1.0000,0.9335,0.9063,0.634S, 530 PUMR(1,4)=l.0000,0.9424,0.9149,0.6356, 540 PUMR(1,5)=l.0000,0.9429,0.902S,Oo6059, 550 PUMR(1,6)=1.0000,0.9433,0.8901,0.5762, 560 PUMR(1,7)=l.0000,0.9437,0.8777,0.5465, 570 PUMR(l,8)=1.0000,0.9442,0.8653,0.5168, 580 p~~(1,9)=l.0000,0.9348,0.8691,0.5454, 590 PUMR(1,f0)=l.0000,0.9225,0.B729,0.5739, 600 PUMR(1,1l)=l.0000,0.9161,0.8768,0.6025, 610 PO~rR(1,12)=1.0000,0.9068 1 0.8806,0.6310, ·-· -·1·····--·-· . -. , .. " ; I ~ I ' 11 J 1: ' , I r-c--~: LOAD MODEL -LMNSDU Attachment 1. 4 Page 2 of 4 620 ~JMWK(l,l)=1.ooooo,o.99S03,0.97999,0.97l58,o.9ss29,n.92996, 630 0.92696, 640 0.92461,0.92263,0.91884,0.91365,0.90660,0.906346 650 0.89240,0.87701,0~82231,0.80053,0&75277,0.71006, 660 0.70088,0.677I6,0.66897,0.66555,0.66323, 670 PUMWK(1,2)=1.00000,0.99341,0.98114,0.97468,0.96297,0.94207, 680 0.93890,0.93528,0.93271,0.92825,0.92210,0.91655, 690 0.91622,0.90541,0.88075,0.83249,0.79704,0.75811, 700 0.71054, 710 0.70006,0.67904,0.66986,0.66698,0;66537, 720 ~~~(1,3)=1.00000,0.99175,0.98230,0.97778,0.97064,0.95419, 730 0.95084,0.94596:0.94280,0.93765,0.93055,0.92649,. 740 0.92610,0o91841,0.88450,0.84266,0.79354,0.76345, 750 0.71102,0.69925,0.68092,0.67075,0.66242,0.66751, 760 PUMWK(l,4)=1.00000,0.9S009,0.98345,0.98089,0.97831,0.9663l, 770 0.96279,0.95664,0.95288,0.94705,0.93900,0.93644, 780 0.93599,0.93142,0.88824,0.85284,0.75004,0.76879, 790 0.71150,0.69844,0.68280,0.67165,0.66985,0.66964, 800 PUMWK(l,5}=l.00000,0.99008,0.98462¥0.97988,0.97621,0.96595, 810 0.96173,0.95518,0.95164,0. ~112,0.92685,0.92291, 820 0.92019,0.91562,0.87480,0.83360,0.77936,0.74303, 830 0.69789,0.67675,0.65955,0.64903,0.64759,0.64235, 840 PUMWK(1,6)=1.00000,0.99007,0.98578,0.97887,0.97410, 850 0.96560,0.96067,0.95372,0.95040,0.93519, 860 0.91470,0.90938, 870 0.90439,0.89983,0.86136,0.81435,0.76878,0.71727, 880 0.68427,0.65507,0.63629,0.62641,0.62534,0.61506, 890 PUMWK(1,7)=l.00000,0.99006,0.98694,0.97787,0.97199,0.96524, 900 0.95961,0.95225,0.94916,0.92926,0.90255,0.89586, 910 o.s8859,o.aa404,0.84792,v.79Slo,o.7580o,o.69151, 920 0.67065,0.63338,0.61304,0.60379,0.60308,0.58776, 930 PUMWK(l,8)=1~00000,0.99005,0.98811,0.97686,0.96988,0.96488, 940 0.95855,0.95079,0.94792,0.92332,0.89041,0.88233, 950 0.87279,0.86825,0.83447,0.77586,0.74732,0.66575, 960 0.65703,0.61169,0.58978,0.58118,0.58082,0.56047, 970 PUMWK(1,9)=1.00000,0.99173,0.98579,0.97476,0.96431,0.~5312, 980 0.94767,0.94157,0.93908,0.91985,0.89411,0.88591, 990 0.87871,0.87104,0.84417,0.78493,0.76150,0.68617, 1000 0.67017,0.63419,0.61116,0.60290,0.60164,0.58563, 1010 PUMW~(l,l0)=l.0000,0.99340,0.98347,0.97267,0.95875,0.94136, 1020 0.93678,0.93236,0.93024,0.91638,0.89781,0.88949, 1030 0.88462,0.8.7383,0.85387 ,o. 79400,0.77568,0.70659, 1040 0.68331,0.65669,0.63253,0.62463,0.62247,0.61078, 1050 PUMWK(1,11)=l.0000,0.99507,0.98115,0.97057,0.95318,0.92960, 1060 0.92590,0.92314,0.92139,0.91291,0.90150,0.89307, 1070 0.89054,0.87661,0.86357,0.80307,0.78985,0.72701, 1080 0.69644,0.67919,0.65391,0.64635,0.64329,0.63594, 1090 PUMWK(l,l2)=l.00000,0.99674,0.97883,0.96848,0.94762,0.91784, 1100 0.91502,0.91393,0.91255,0.90944,0~90520,0.89665, 1110 0.89645,0.87940,0.87327,0.81214,0.80403,0.74743, 1120 0.70958,0.70169,0.67528,0.66808,0.66412,0.66110, 1130 PUMWE(1,1)=0.93928,0.93733,0.91934,0.90359,0.89041,0.87125, 1140 0.86376,0.85890,0.85508,0.85266,0.84488,0.82874, . 1150 0.82235,0.79315,0.78208,0.73686,0.72538,0.70842, 1160 0.68216,0.67250,0.66258,0.65772,0.65127,0.64850, I - I") : ;) IJ I; ~ I I \ I] 1 ' 1 .I 1 IJ l l ' ·J ' l ' LOAD MODEL -LJ.1NSDU Attachment 1.4 Page 3 of 4 lliO PUMWE(1,2)=0.93338,0.93070,0.91381,0.89654,0.88755,0.87420, 1180 0.86586,0.86175,0.85626,0.85216,0.84686,0.83188, 1190 0.82718,0.80431,0.78961,0.74219,0.72669,0.71376, 1200 0.6~459,0.67271,0.66438,0.66081,0.65454,0.64909, 121.0 Pt.H-JE(1,.,3 )=0.92748,0. 92407,0.90429,0.88948,0.88468,0.87715, l22d 0.86796,0.86461,0.85743,0.85166,0.84885,0.83501, 1230 0.8320l,0.81547,0.79714,0.74751,0.72801,08Jl911, 1240 . 0.68703,0.67292,0.66618,0.66390,0.65780,0.~64~67' 1250 PUMWE(1,4)=0.92158,0.91743,0.89676,0.88242,0.88181,0.88p~o, 1260 0.87006,0.86746,0.85860,0.85116,0.85084,0.83815, 1270 . 0.83684,0.82663,0.80467,0.75284,0.72932,0.72445, 1280 0.68947,0.67314,0.66797,0.66700,0.66107,0.65025, 1290 PUMWE(1,5)=0.90898,0.90455,0.88695~0.87319,0.87249,C.87055, 1300 0.86173,0.85938,0.85185,0.84581,0.84303,0.83259, 1310 0.82685,0.81653,0.78454,0.74035,0.71380,0.69907, 1320 0.67098,0.65362,0.64591,0.64118,0.63456,0.62401, 1330 PUMWE(1,6}=0~89637,0.89247,0.87715,0.86396,0.86316,0.86100, 1340 0.85341,0.85129,0.84510,0.84047,0.83523,0.82704, 1350 0.81687,0.80644,0.76441,0.72786,0.69828,0.67369, 1360 0.65248,0.63410,0.62385,0.61536,0.60806,0~59777, 1370 PUMWE(1,7)=0.88377,0.87999,0.86735,0.85474,0.85383,0.85145, 1380 0.84509,0.84320,D.83834,0.83513,0.82743,0.82149, 1390 0.80688,0.79634,0.74429,0.71537,0.68277,0.64831, 1400 0~63399,0.61458,0.60180,0.58954,0.58155,0.57153, 1410 PUMWE(1,8)=0.87116,0.86751,0.85755,0.84551,0.84451,0.84189, 1420 0.83677,0.83511,0.83159,0.82978,0.81962,0.81594, 1430 0.79689,0.78625,0.72416,0.70288,0.66725,0.62293, 1440 0.61550,0.59506,0.57974,0.56373,0.55505,0.54529, 1450 PUMWE(1,9)~0.88967,0.88662,0.8748R;0•86180,0.85670,0.84849, 1460 0.84299,0.84035,Q.83717,0o83563,0.82544,0e8l836, 1470 Oo80205,0.,78518,0e~73676,0.710Q4,0e68145,Q.64296, 1480 0.63156,0.61436,0.60000,0.58645,0.57829,0.57095, 1490 PUMWE(1,10)=0.90818,0.90574,0.89221,0.87808,0.86889,0.85509, 1500 Oo84921,0.84558,0o84275,0.84147,0";.83126,0o82Q77, 1510 0.80721,0.78412,0.74936,0.71721,0.69566,0.66300, 1520 0.64761,0.63367,0.62026,0.60918,0.60153,0.59661, 1530 PUMWE(1,11)=0.92668,0.92485,0.90954,0.89437,0.88109,0.86169, 1s4o o.as544,o.8508l,o.a4e33,o.s4732,o.837o7,o.s2319, 1550 0.81237,0.78305r0.76195,0.72437,0.70986,0.68303, 1560 0.66367,0.65298,0.64053,0.63190,0.62477,0.62226, 1570 PUMWE(l,12)=0.94519,0.94397,0.92687,0.91065,0.89328,0.86829, 1580 0.86166,0~85604,0.85391,0.85316,0.84289,0.82561, 1590 0.81753,0.78199,0.77455,0.73154,0.72406,0.72307, 1600 0.67972,0.67228,0.66079,0.65463,0.64801,0.64792, 1.610 K7=7, 1~20 fwDD=O, 1630 MC.:XWK=O, 1640 IYREAD=l985$ 1650$IN?Or 1660 PU~o9l5,.866,.785,e695,.632,.607,.597 1 .637 1 1670 .689,.792,.922,1.000, . 1680 PUANP=.915,.866,.785,.695,.632,.607,.597,.637, 1690 .689,.792,.922,1~ooo, I l r ! :>: ;) .~ 0 l J} ~ • .:> 1: i I >J I • . " .. . J I ., IJ l IJ I} ' i I tJ [ ·~ '• " ' IJ I IJ IJ I ' I , I.· .. · ., ' ' 1700 IYREAD=1990$ 1710 $I~JT LOAD MODEL -LMNSDU 1720 PUANR=.915,.866,.785,.695,.630,.603,o595, 1730 .632,.685,.790,.922;1.000, 1740 PUAN?=.915,.866,.785,.695,.630v•60~,.:595, 1750 .632,.685,.790,.922,1.000, 1760 PUMR(l,1)=1.0000,0.9148,0.8859,0.6318, 1770 PtMR(l,i)=l.0000,0.9224,0.8939,0.6321, 1780 PUMR(l,3)=l.0000,0.9300,0.9020,0.6324, 1790 PUMR{1,4}=l.OOOO ,0,.9375,0 .9101,0.6328, 1800 PUMR(1,5)=1.0000,0.9395,0.8998,0.6049, 1810 Pu-ffi(l,6):;l.0000,0.9414,0.8895,0.5769, 1820 PUMR{1,7)=1.0000,0.9434,0.8792,0.5490, 1830 PUMR(l,8)=1~0000,0.9454,0.8690,0.5211, 1840 PUMR(1,9)=1.0000,0.9358,0.8712,0.5487, 1850 PUMR(1,10)=1.0000,0.9263,0.8734,0.5763, 1860 PUMR(1,11)=l.0000,0.9168,0.8756,0.6039, 1870 PUMR(1,12)=l.0000,0.9073,0.8778 1 0.6314, 1880 IYREAD=l995$ 1890$1~ 1900 PU~e914,.865,.785,.695,.633,~609;e599, 1910 .637,.689,.792,.922,1.000, 1920 PCANP=.914,.865,.785,.695,.633,.609,.599, 1930 .637,.689,.792,.922,1.000, 1940 IYREAD=2000$ 1950$IN?UT 1960 PUANR=.914,.865,.784,.696,.636,.617,.605,.644, 1910 .694,.794,.922,1.000! 1980 PUANP=.914,.865,.784,G696,.636,.617,.605,.644, 1990 .694,~794,.922,1.000, 2000 PU~(1,1)=1.0000,0.9165,0.8908,0.6266, 2010 Pli-1R(1 ,2)=1.0000.,0.9268 ,0.9000 ,0.6270, 2020 PUMR(1,3)=1.0000,"0.9371,0.9091,0.6274, 2030 PUMR(1,4)=1.0000;0r9474,0.9182,0.6278, 2040 PUMR(1,5)=1.0000,0.9473/,0.9043,0.6007 I 2050 PUMR( 1,6)=1.0000 ,o .9472,0_.8904 ,0.5737 I 2060 PUMR(1,7)=1.0000,0.9471,0.8765,0.5466, 2070 PUMR(1,8)=1.0000,0.9470,0.8626,0.5195, 2080 PUMR(1,9)=l.0000,0.9368,0.8674,0a5462, 2090 PUMR(1,10)=l.0000,0.9266,0.8722,0.5729, 2100 ~1R(.l,11)=l.0000,0.9164,0.8769,0.5~95, 2110 PUMR(l,l2}=1.0000,0.9062,0.8817,0.6262, .2120 IYREAD=2005$ 2130$IN?UT 2140 PUANR=.913,.864,.783,.696,.637,.619,.605,.643, 2150 .694,.793,.921,1.000, 2160 PUANP=.913,.864,.783,.696,.637,.619,.605,.643, · 2170 e694,.793,.92l,l.OOO, 2180 IYRF.AD=O$ 2190$:ENlJC5 Attachment 1. 4 Pc..1e 4 of 4 • ' I '. r "" ! ·~~ ' ;., ' i, :o.,. .. I __ , .,~ . '~ ( j --~ ·~ j l t '~ :11 .--...J ~~ j t ........ J I ~j ;I '• .• { ~ -i ; I !\ :::::J ,·.~I 2. QUESTION · Output results for the OGP-6 runs noted above (e.g., similar to the outputs L4Rl, LlW7, LlX7, and L275 that the APA had previously filed with the Commission). RESPONSE The requested output results for the two OGP-6 runs noted in Question 1 are provided in Volume II, Appendix 1 of this filing. The output for each run is comprised of two sections: 0 Summary OGP-6 analysis for ~993-2020, coupled with extension to year 2051; and 0 Detailed OGP-6 analysis for years 1993-2020. Part A of Appendix 1 provides the above data for the With-Susitna Plan, and Part B of Appendix 1 provides the output data for the Without-Susitna Plan. For reference, the OGP-6 job identification number for the With-Srisitna Plan is LJMS, and the Without-Susitna Plan identification is LJN1. 3. l ·- t I I I I I I I I I I. I I I I I. I I. -.- I I. i I l ~...J. , . .,, .. "'4""""'''·~·~·· 3. QUESTION a) Information and data to support tte capital costs used ];_/ in the APA revised analysis of Susitna. The informa- tion should be in sufficient detail to fully document the APA "detailed review of ac.tual equipment require- ments with present labor rates, budgetary equipment quotations, and shipping costs" and justify the capital cost changes indicated. RESPONSE The capital cost estimates prepared for the original License Application were based upon the Railbelt Electric Power Alternatives Study,!/ a reconnaissance level survey done to provide an assessment of the power alternatives in Alaska. Subsequently, because of the importance attached to the thermal alternatives, the Power Authority conunissioned a detailed review of the conceptual cost estimates for the thermal power alternatives. This ~eview included obtaining budgetary equipment estimates for the following major capital equipment: Battelle-Pacific Northwest Laboratories (1982) • 4. I I I I I I I I I I I I I -- I I I. I. I. I 0 Turbine Generator; 0 Steam Generator (Boiler); 0 Flue Gas Desulfurization (FGD) System; 0 Parti:culate Cont;r:ol Equipment; and 0 Cooling Towers The experience of Ebasco Services in designing and constructing coal-fired power plants provided a basis upon which to estimate installation and material requirements for the balance of plant systems not directly obtained from equipment quotations. Also considered in the review were union wage rates, including Workmen's Compensation, FICA and Public Liability Property Damage insurance rates. The wage rates were based on six 10-hour days, within a camp-type operation. The capital cost estimates of the initial 200 MW coal unit and the extension unit were prepared in 1983 dollars and de-escalated to January,·1982 dollars, as shown on th•e attached sununary sheet (Attachment 3a. 1) . The estimat:e entitled "Unit l" (Attachment 3a. 2), consists of the first coal-fired unit installed in Alaska. The unit 1 estimate includes all facilities that are common to coal-fired power plants.. Tl>e unit 2 ,; \, ...... T. . -~ ~· \\ •····· -~ 5. '! I I' I I I I I I I I I I I I I, I, I w I. I estimate {Attachment 3a. 3) consists of an "extension at unit at the power plant site, also rated at 200 MW. The significant difference in capital costs between the two units reflects the infrastructure and common service facili~ies necessary to support the initial installation of a power plant. The capital cost estimates provided were prepared for a Beluga power plant. A capital cost estimate for a coal-fired power plant at Nenana is under preparation. The work done to date supports the DEIS comments that the Nenana plant will have O&M costs a1: least $50/kW highe~, on an installed cost basis, than the Beluga cost. In addition to the capital cost estimates, a Basis of Estimate is also provided for each unit which presents. the assumptions used in the estimate. (Attachments 3a. 4 and 3a. 5). Selected v·endor r:;;,.~;teR, which establish the validity of t.he capital cost estimates are provided in Attachment 3a~6. Traditionally, finance charges, land, start-up services, town sites and O\IITners' services are separated from the project direct capital costs. These are described in the Basis of Estimate. In order to arrive 6. -f .. · .. r I J I I I I I I I I I at the cost basis for the DEIS comments, these additional costs must be added to the capital cost estimate. This addition is shown on the sheet entitled "Capital Cost Estimate Summary" (Attachment 3a.1). The town site costs were estimated using the same approach used for the preparation of the Susitna Hydro"electric Proje.ct cost estimates. Owners' costs, spare parts, land and maintenance equipment costs included in the estimate were base~ upon Ebasco Service's past experience in the utility industry. Labor and shipping costs are further discussed in the response to Question 3(e). 7. - ""' I I .J.~l , ~ I 1 1 ; ' .. · " '. ·~ I I ·~· ·~ I ~ ~i I '~ .. 1 ~ I ~ I , I I I I !) Attachment 3a.1 Capital Cost ~irnat~ Summary Unit 1 Estimate, APA 1707-M-1 ($1983) $554,647,987 Unit 1 Estimate; De-escalated to $1982 at 6.4% inflation rate Unit 2 Estimate, APA 1707-M-1 ($1983} $372,993,683 Unit 2 Estimate; De-escalated to $1982 at 6.4% inflation rate Subtotal Items not .included in Estimate Town Site Cost ($1982) Owners Cost (at 2~% of Direct Project) Start up, Spare Parts and Special Tools Maintenance Shop Machinery, Laboratory Equipment and Office Furniture Land (200 acres at $10,000 per acre) Subtotal Project Total Cost - Average Cost per kW -(1982) .. r $521,286,000 350,560,000 $871,846,000 16,600,000 21,800,000 10,000,000 . 2,000,000 2,000,000 $52,400,000 924,246,000 $2,310 8 .. I ~ ' 1 1 r:, l l - I l- 1 ' l . 1 4 ' i . - f i\ I .. ~, w _, .J ...) L...J U . .J l ! - ... .... c-. .. ~ - BY: dDF CHECI(E[I: ,.J[IF ... ~ --~"UNIT 1 11 (\P{) - SUSl TNA ;.:no 1-ll-J r:OAL ESTIMATE NO. APA 1707 M-1 Slli"IMARY MATERIAL ~-< IN:3H~LLATION REPORT -~ .-; lilliiill1 Ilia& ~ -,l .- ,. DATE: ·? 1·-•. IUN-:::4 TII"IE: 11:.:40:54 ,. ,_ ACCT NO DESCRIPTION UN* <GHY) (UN $ TOT) <TOTAL AMT>*<l"OT 1'1A1L) <UN $t1AT>• (TOT INST>•<TOT ESC) (MAT ESC>< INS ESC> 9~~.. _1(10000 TOTAL PRO.JECT COST LS* 100.000000 CONTINGENCY LS* 200.000000 ESCALATION LS* 300. 01"'/001)0 TOTAL COST W/0 CONT LS* ~.000000 IMPROVEMNTS TO SITE LS* 2. 000000 EARTHWOFil< & PILING LS* 3. 000(1(10 CIRC: WATER SYSTEM 4.000000 CONCRETE 5.900000 STRCT STL/LFT EQP 6.000000 BUILDINGS 7.000000 TURBINE GENERATOR 8.000000 STM GENER ~ ACCESS 9. onoooo AGJCS 10.000000 OTHER MECHAN EQUIP LS* LS* LS* LS* LS* LS* LS* LS* 11.000000 C:OAU(ASH HNDL EQUIP LS* 12.000000 PIPING LS* t. 3. 000000• I N::.ULAT I ON LS* 14.000000 INSTRUMENTATION LS* 15.000000 ELECTRIC1~L EQIJIPM£NT LS* 16.000000 !='tl'INTING LS* 17.000000 OFF-SITE FACILITIES LS* 18.000000 WATERFRONT FACILITY LS* 19.000000 SUBSTATION/T-LINE LS* 554647987* 210690570 67438000* 22573988 -25c.42565* -99008(:.8 512852552* 198017450 4076672* 1184:350 34210384* 148H:.500 817 {:.240* :;:51;::2t;:.5c) 203397:35* 376:3(100 27~:::::o950* 1 (lc.635oo 18242787* o:.:.:::::ot.so 19064900• 16400000 42900000* 24000000 53956000* ::::o 14:::-;:oo 19909906* 14724200 22802750* 13343800 28004420* 9:=:7 ~-.:~:c) c) 6880000* 5:3(1(1(1(1 7067000• 651)(1!)(1(1 57570000* 21(1(1(1(1(1(1 2224::::40• 15~i(l(l(l 134t.(1700• 60:3(1(1(1(1 7f:.:'::..:77~:·~J* 1 ::::::~:::7 t)(, 28198950* 1 ~:r) :::(I (I (I (I * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 843957417********* ******** ******** e 448640 1."2* CJ \) (I • -15741697********* -9900868 ******** 814835102*******t~ -9900868 ******** • 2891822* -21)8829 -59242 -144587 • 19893884*-1710508 -740824 -969684 419:3591),. -408804 -199132 -209672 • 1657 6 7:35*-1 01/.:..987 -188150 -8288:37 • 16667450•-1366545 -533174 -833371 12862087* -912124 -294031 -618093 • 2664900* -953245 -820000 -133245 I 1-8900000*-2145000 -1200000 -945000 23807700*-2697800 -1507415 -1190385 • 51:35706* -995480 -736210 -259270 • ~a59450*-1140136 -667165 -472971 18127620*-1400221 -493840 -906381 t 6300000* -::::44000 -2900(1 -:315000 .. 567000* -353350 -32500(1 -2E:35(1 ~ rt 36570000*-2878500 -1050000 -1828500 PJ • 0 2069340* -111217 -7750 -10:3467 g CD • 7480700* -673035 -301500 -:3715::::5 :::1 rt ~949039* -391884 -944:35 -297449 w • PJ 10118950•-1159947 -654000 -505947 ;..., • • '- '• ·I• ' .. ~ ~ ~ •• .~:: jl • "' . '"· - _"_..2:J.t ____ .~ "·. • {•:f?":,•r '"~ ('!WZ • .2:.~~~L,c.~ .L:.»:;~. -> c\i?>Jiil!viit>;:Jv;.,.> ~k~U~~~.S.'14i.~"illiWC&~t~ ..... ~;#1;~~ ... ~-~..,·;.t;~~n-.,;A,i;.:;';€~~-'t:t£; . ...;..._~ .• -'.;..'~~. i Hi!t'i'l'iil!1 ~ ! , 1 \) l '') c ! ' ·~ . ...{ I '-~ i l I , ~ 0 !, .. [ I ~1., ' l ,., I ~ rJiill •• ~ .. .. BY: .,.IDF CHECI'ED: ,.J[IF ~ ~ .. -llifllll AP{~ SUSITNA 2~0 MH COAL £:STII1ATE NO. APA 1707 M-1 SUMI1AHY MATEfUAL ~~ INSTALLATION REPORT ~ illiilrllt ~ ......: DATE! 21-••. IUN..,.:?-4 ~ ltaJii ~ ~ TIME: 1(:.: 4fl: 54 ACCT NO DESCRIPTION LIN* <QTY> <UN $ TOT) <TOTAL AMT>*<TOT MAll> (UN $MAT)*(U $ JNS) <TOT INSTHHTOT E:::c> <HAT ESC>< INS ESC> 71.000000 INDIRECT C:ONST COST LS* 72.000000 PROFESSI9N;~L SERVCS LS* • . '· 40949(179* I) 546500(10* (I * 40949079*-2047453 0 -2047453 * f.j465(1(100*-~732500 0 -2732500 · · '· .~ · · V· · · ·:s ~r..-; .. ..r ~,._QP.lt4Ll&tl$AIA 4· i 15~·4Jitt •• JfaM ······-·. y --<'\fi\W!f· i4#QY.*P8i'] • ..,.,., ..... i1&h1JliitiS¥i{ ....... ~ ,.. ~ ... -• • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • • 0 .. ; ~/ .~.. . ... ~-·,/;~~~: __ .·~-.-~~____...i.....,_~~~-~-·:~ .·· ~-! . -,~ . ~ ·~ .Q ~ • • • • ..... ' ' ~"""'--:..-~---~-~----..:~-~--·--· ......,_..:.L-~~~,_.;:~-~~~~~~-~-l;....-.~~----..,;:~M-~~~-·-----.,.....,.~ .... ~·-·----·-~··, ~!f'li ~~ ~-'1lillllilllill '·! .. ~ ~ ~-- i I ' l ~\ 1 '~ :J ~~~i BY: .JtaF CHE.G•ED: ,J(IF .. ~ ~-.. ..,. ... .. ~ I=\ I'?\ ·::;JJ~:n NA :;;:nn 11W fOAL E.:ST Il1ATE NO. APt~ 1/07 r-t-1 DFfAlLED 1"1ATEBI AL l!< 1N~:.Tt%:..LAT 1 ON f<f:J·'(IRT ftli1lliC ~ lillf1 LIATE: 7:.1-._II.II'J-:-:::4 ~~ ~ .... l • ~ _, Tll·tE: 16:40:54 iiUiillll . .. ~ ~ M Acc·r No DES(:RIPTION UN-!!!-<QTY> <UN$ TOT)(TOTAL AMT>*<TOT MAl'L><UN $MAT>*<'-'$ INS><TOT INST>*CTOT ESC><MAT ESC><INS ESC> 99. 000000 TOTAL F'RO.JECT COST LS* 554647987* 210690570 100.000000 CONTINGENCY LS* 6 7 43:3000* 2257:39€;:8 200.000000 E.3CALATJ.ON LS* -2564256!'!·~ -·~19(10868 f 300.000000 TOTAL .;OST W/0 CONT LS* 512852552 * 1 '7801 7 4 50 1. 000000 IMF'ROVEHNTS TO SITE L:3* 4076~·72it-118485(1 ti. 1.100000 SITE PREPARATION LS* 440133* 0 1.110000 CLEARING AC:* 105 4!91. 7 44013::::• (l ~. 1.200000 ROt=ms, BRDCi, WALl(S LS* t.e::3148* tc.::::::5c• il • I 1.210000 :I 1. 213fl(l(l ROADS 24" liHDE ROADS LS* 542530* SY* 400(11) 13.6 54 '25:;:(1• 1(10(1(1(1 1 (1(1(1(10 1. 240000 FENCING L.S:r 140618* t.:=t:35(l J .. 241000 PROPERTY FENCE LF* 3800 24.8 943}.3* 45(:.(1(1 ~ 1.2420(1(1 ~;ECURl TV FENCE LF* 1500 24.8 37252* 180(1(1 1.2430(1(\ GATES EA* 7 12E:4. 7 :399:=:* ~·25(1 1.3(10000 S'ITE DRAINAGE LS* 1'.32655::.':-li t·20000 1.500000 SE~!AGE FACILITIES LS• 38•;t72~:* 150000 1.700000 RA1LROAD LB* 1237116* 246(11)0 . t. 720000 STACKER RECL TRC:K LF* 600 2061~9 1237116* 24t.OOO 7.000000 E~RTHWORK & PILING LS* JJ 34210~<84* 1~:31(:.500 2.200000 f:TRCTR & E•;J,UIP EXC u::* 14:3t::E:641 jl 45:?.:(1(1(11) 2.210000 STATION AREA LS* 10776505* 45:30(11)1) , 2.21200(1 EARTH EXCAVATION CY* 1:::700 29.1 54510511: (I 2.214000 SELECT BAC:I::'F ILL l 8* 1 1)2':: 14fll)* 4:: .• :·:(J(l(ll) (" ;t· f .. __ l --·o ... .,..__ ; .. '~ l '"'6.t;p"*'"' ax• &JJYJJU~ * * * * * * 0.00* * * 2.50* * 12.00* 12.00• 750.00* * * * 410. (I(Ht * * * (1.00* * 4191.7 11. 1 1..-1 C.• L• '-' 12.8 s-=:4. 7 H:·51.9 2'?.'1 • 1 34~:957 417 ********* ******** **'**** ** f."\ 44(!64012* 0 0 (I f8j -15741697********* -9900868 ******** 314835102********* -9900868 ******** " 2891822* -203829 -59242 -144587 , 4401~:3* -22006 0 -22006 440133* -22006 0 -22006 ~ ti14298* -34155 -8442 -25713 ., 442530* -27126 -5000 -22126 442530* -27126 -5()00 -22126 .. 71768* -7029 -3442 -3587 • 48773* -4718 -2280 ·-2438 1 51252* ··1862 -900 -9(;.2 .., :3743* -449 -262 -187 w 706552* -66327 -31000 -35327 239723* -19486 -7500 -1198(:. .. 99h 116* -61855 -12300 -4S'1555 w 99111 t:·* -61E:55 -12:=:oo -4'~555 !?393884•-1710508 -740824 -969684 ""' 1(1308641• -744429 -229000 -515429 """ 1;.1 ·~Jt.5(15* -58::::825 -22';-lt)t)(t -:309825 54e.i105* -_72.55 (I -27255 ..., 5651400* -511570 -229000 -282570 -- "-" .....__.._ .. ;'. I ,., ;_;-• ': il~~ ' h. ' '·.ti/'; . -1~4' ."1':::1<1 ·'.\, 't lj :_:. b •o ·f ' t • I -~ 1. !"' .... ~~~ _,;/"/ f f 1- " •J !) () ! ... -' ' :.• ! , el ~ ... J d I ; .... I • "~ ' ! . .a....!-' ' ~ • D . . . ' ~ ~ • C' y ' • ----------~ --·-~~~~=--------.-::==;:;-~-~----;;--.-·-· --~ _ • ~, _ ,. 0 _"t;,.. _ ~ ---~r ~· ~ ~ ~ . .,..__,.._-.....,.r I , :' rtl • \ .., , \ " .. _· -~ _. .. ,~.' l, _ ) o---.. .. , --~ ---:---:~-·~{ .. ~ ~ - ~ --=-~ .,._.. . -j.. . . . . -·--~-. -'} ., ~ . '.. .. . . , -"" ,_ : ~ Q ' "" • ~~ .··:, •• ·~ .. ~· ~ • • .. : !._ . -r:-~---" . . . ...;.~' ¢'\ • •. 0 ~~-~ .... ' -~ .. '-' '. f'-.c ~ .... ..,, ,., (_I I;\ (_ ·;:-.1 J .. :\~~ . ..,~';~---,~._~~J.k.___,_--"-"-~~--~ q ~ 0 ~----~~-::_~t;: .. <:J. '-;\-... _·c ___ ._,.} ~....-..---.~:......~,___.J~; -~ .. w. •• 1~~~---~r::~2»f,'.:~; ... ,i~~L~i:i-~~k~:~,..~~~~r2v~~~ ;,)\ .. : · ~-> · • .;2---~~~~~-~~:\,~~:~~~;,._~~=~---~-~~: ''· G ~--.. ~ :L,L :JIM ,_,... .. flY: JDF CHECI~ED: .JDF ~ .. •• -i- f\F'{; SUSITNA 200 MW ~OAI ESTIMATE NO. APA 1707 M-1 DETAILED 1"1ATER1AL ~{ IN::>TALLATICtN REI:·uBT .. -11111 flrHE: 21-.JUN-::.:4 ~"' -~ ~ ~ ~ .~~ TIME: 1 {:.: 40:54 .. "' ~ .. AC:C:T NO DESCRIPTION UN* <OTY> (UN t. TOT> (TOTAL AMn*<TOT MATL> <UN $NAT>* <TOT INST>*<TOT ESC) <MAT ESC> ( !N~: ESC) 2.214100 7" GRAVEL PAD CY* 510000 2 .. 214200 INSULATION BRD ~;f* 2000000 2.22(1(1(11) STACk FOUNDATIONS LS~ 2.222000 EARTH EXCAVATION C:Y* 2::::oo' 2.223000 ROCK EXCAVATION C:Y* 2000 . 2 .. 2300(H) COAL HAND FDN LS* 2. 2:::2(10(1 EARTH EXCAVATION C:Y* 4:=:4(10 '· 2. 23:::(1(11) ROCK EXCP~~~TION CY* 112CJO 2.240(100 OUTL V T!:,t.t; f)~~ !STR LS• 2.24200C; EARTH EXCAVATION C~* e.9oo 2.250001) AOCS FrtNS LS-K- 2.252(100 EARTH EXCAVATION CY* 279(1(1 2.253(1(10 ROCK EXCAVATION CY* 1 (lf:.(l(l 2. 30(1(1(,(1 TRENCHING LS* 2. 31(1(1(10 CIRC WATER COND LS:-tt 2.~112(l(H) EARTH EXCAVATION CY• 1 ~:7(1(1 2. ::a :=:ooo ROCK EXCAVATION CY* 180 ~ 2.3200(1(1 YARD PIF;ING LS* 2.322(1(1(1 EARTH EXCAVATION C'f* 4'HOO 2~ :::3(10(H) SEWERS l!( [IRA INS LS* 2.332(1(1(1 EARTH E><C:AVATiOI\f CY* 81000 2.4000(11) E AHTH :::TRIJC:Tl.IRES J.:Y-R 5500 2. 500('00 PILES <H F'ILES) LSi! 16.9 O.E: 2~~: .. ~! 84.1 2'~J~ 1 73.3 2~1. l 29.1 74.5 ·-:··=--.. A:-~'• L 79.7 :=:(1. 7 :;:rt. 7 :;·~'. (l E:(:.:;:9400 * 1592(1(1(1-1! 2218H:·* ~·3t.3~·* 1·~·8180* 2(186470* 1265110* 821~:(:.0* 2011~:5* 2011'35* 1602715* 81328~5* 7894:::0* 2:.::1 ~.:=::;: 1 * 529478* :;::::6(1'?,11 * 143~::::7* 13.342:39* t8.::42f!'~* 9!:03064-11 '753064* 1 ~596'71 :;: t< 14 77''iJ/;.:~:]-~ 40E:O(IOO 5(1(1(1(1(1 I) (I (I (I (I (I (I I) (I (I (I (I 0 0 (I 0 (I 0 (I (I 97til)(ll)(l E:. (H)* e:411 ·;' 4559400* -431970 -204000 -227970 •• 1.1.25* 0.5 1 (1';12(11.U)* -7 ~J.!•,(I(I -2500(1 -'546(1(1 •• * 22181(:·* -11090 (I -1109(1 53C.~:f:..* -2681 (I 0.00* ,.J":• ~ L·-•• ,._t -2681 • O.t>O* E:4.1 1 (:.81 :3(1* -8409 0 -840S'1 • * 2086470* -104323 (I -104323 (1.00* 2';t. 1 1265110* -63255 0 -c.~3255 • 0.00* 73.8 E:21 :;:(:.(HI' -41 068 0 -41068 • * 201135* -10056 ·l) -10056 (1.00* 29.1 2011 ~:5* -1 005t. 0 -10056 • * 1602715* -80135 (I -80135 • 0.00* 29.1 8132:::5* -40664 (I -40664 (1.(1(1-!t 74.5 78'~'4:3(1-tl· -39471 (l . -3'~471 • * 2816881* -140840 ·o -140840 • * 529478it -26473 (I -26473 o. (•0* : ~3. 2 38c.CI91 * -1 ·~'304 (I -19:;:(14 • 143:387* -7169 o. 00-t<· 7~1 ~ 7 .-. ,..,., -7H:.'?,1 t1 * 1384289* -66714 0 -<!.·6714 o. (1(1* ~:(l. 7 1384289~ -o6714 (I -66714 • '?5:=:(1(:.4-tl· -4 7 ·653 • * (i -47e.S:3 0.0(1* :30.7 ';J5:3064* -4 7 653 (I -4765:3 O.I)O~t 29.(1 1 5•;)t,.·:.J:::i!r --7S"J:::4 (I -79:::4 • * 5029687* -738983 -487500 -251483 .. .. .. ~~---,~~--:::.'\':"IT"":"..)-._.. ;;at~~7·~~KifiiiiilMl·JC•.tt:••"liiii'!iiii'W..iWif~----~IIIII'!'K:i.:::lii*i,lilli1ii'lll!8r:diliS'W1%Z .... ,, .. , .• ~ ....... ~·· · __..alilu-ar'-· ·.,-· ·. t ' ~'' '-~- ~ I( r ... :· ·u·.i , I. J!l'_ . ·~ l~ ~ ~~,~ ,---., 1_ .. 1 ~JJI 1M'S BY: .JDF CHEC:f:'ED: ,J(IF ... ~ .. .. APf~ ~:::.u::: I TNA 20(1 Mt.-J t :uAL l:STH'IATE NO. APA 1707 1'1-1 DElAILE[I t'!ATER I AL ~t I N•:;Tf"~L LAT I ON HEPCIF<T :-. IIIII. 'Iiiii: .. .. ..... I· • .• DATE: ~·1-. IUN-84 TIME: 1~.: 40:54 ACCT NO DESCRIPTION LIN* (QTY> (ll,\l $ TOT) <TOTAL AHT>*CTOT l1ATL.> <UN $MAT>*<LI ii INS> <TOT INSTHHTOT ESC> <MAT ESC> C INS ESC> :;.51(10(10 2.520000 2.700000 2.710000 ~ , .. ----·1££VVU 2.712000 2.7130(1(1 2.7200(10 2.721000 2.722000 2. 72:3000 2.730000 2.731000 2.732000 2.733000 2.74(1(1(1(1 STATION AREA LF * 1 E:(u)(l(l AGtC:S AREA LF~ 70000 C:ECI -EXC:V-ERTH STR L~:* CL f'L SEEF'~~RO C:TR LS* PVC LTNER SF* 300000 SAND CY* GRAVEL CY* ... WST WTR TRMT AREA LS* . PVC LINER EXCAVATION BACKFILL SF* C:Y* CY* SLD WST STK PILE LS* PVC LINER EXCAVATION BACl<FILL EMER WST BASIN SF* C:Y* CY* . LS* 17000 170(:0 4~!(100 19000 :38(10 47000 5300 1800 3.(100000 CIRC WATER SYSTEM LS* 3.,200000 INTK & DISC PIPING LS• ~3. 2 f.OOOO CONCR PIPE: 60" LF* 3400 3.26000(1 BEDDING MATERIAL C:Y* 2(1(1(1 3.270000 CONCRET STRUCTURE LS-tt 3.271000 THRST ~ TRNS BLK CY* 75(1 3.272000 CGNDENS BLOCKS CY* 400 59.1 10641375* 7020(1(11) 59.1 413:3312* 2780(1(1(1 1565527* 4865(11) 91(1(152* 4410(10 ('~..: 5 151002* 1:35000 24.4 41395(UI· 170000 20.3 345100* 1 ~:6(1(1(1 463279* t•:J:350 (1 .. 5 211:-43* 19350 17.9 :33'772(1* (I 26.8 1019H·* (I 166696* 2115(1 0.5 23656* 21150 17.9 94764* 0 26 .. 8 48276* (I 25500* 5000 8176240* 3':l$2(:.5(1 2141914* 894550 35~i. 8 12t)9822* 64~.(1(1(1 30.5 f:..1000M-20000 e::2179E:* 2(1:395(1 4~:(1.(1 32251E:* 9::::750 90:::.4 361372• :316(11) ~:·;>. 00* 20.1 8621375*.-532068 -851000 -181068 :39. 00* 2(1 .• 1 1408312* -206915 -13(:.5(11) -70415 * 1079027* -78272 -24324 -53948 * 4~·9052* -45502 -22050 -23452 0.45* 0.1 1 (:,(10:2* -a>C!"c:"" ..... -,;:.t • ..)\,.1 -6750 -800 10.00* 14.4 24:!l950* ·-201:./~7 -8500 -12197 8.00* 12. :;: 209100* -17255 -6800 -i0455 * 443929* -23162 -9/:..7 -22195 0.45* (1.1 2293* -1081 -967 -114 (1.00* 17.9 3:=:9720* -16986 (I -16986 0.00* 26.8 101916* -50'~5 0 -5095 * 145546* -8333 -1057 -7276 o. 45-M· 0.1 2506·\t -1182 -1057 -125 0.00* 17.9 94UA* -4738 (I -473:3 0.00* 26.8 4827~·* -2413 (I -2413 * 20500* -1275 -250 -1025 * 4193590* -408804 -199132 -20'~672 * 1247364* -107093 -44727 -623~.6 19(1. (ll}if' tt.5. ::: 5t.~:E:22* -t:.Ct-491 -~:22:(1(, -28191 10.00* 20.5 41000* -3(1!30 -1(10(1 -2050 * 61284:3* -41 o:=:E: -10447 -30~·41 125.00* 305.0 22:?.7 t.8* -1 /:..1 25 -4687 -11438 204.00* /:..·;·~~. 4 279Tl2* -1 :=:06:3 -4080 -1~~988 .. .- ,. ,. .. .. • • • • • • · ... , • • • • • • • • • ... -- i . . . . ' • .~ ~ ~ • ~' -··'i ~·-;,-_try~ ·-.::::-;.-~-~.; ., --~w ......... ": ...... ~-.;.~----~:_?·6 ----~~----~-·~;~--~ ·i~•·-·~-i:.,~~~~-· .". -~ l~-~,-~,. .. ~, ·-e~::.:-;~~L.~~~~~~~~:~. :;; Atf~inWf~.~ ~~-~:t~:e:ttliif~~l~ .... ~~ ~~,.·~~"~~""~:~-~.· i ilt.IJ4r'lf.rinf;r~ I j f I ! () ! h i f \ I 1 !, \ i ;, I I il ' l " " ! . ·--·....1 !. ,., .I . , ; j j • , ~·· . l i j !' I, !, I U'}, t 1 l ! ~ .;._.,,-~ .,.,. ·----~ ~h.·-· . le·-···"· ~ ·-o,; ___ ~ . ..-~-~ BY: • .JDF CHECKED: ,J(IF Jll_ .. .. .. .. .. .~F'f' ~aJ~:3I TNA 21.11.1 NW CO?'I ESTIMAT~ NO. APA 1707 M-1 DEl AILED MATERIAL & INSTALLATION REPORT .. .. ... .. .. .. I -... , ,. DATE: 21-.JUN-84 TII1E: 16:40:54 ,. ~ ACCT NO DESCRIPTION UN• <t;HY) <UN $ TOT> <TOTAL AHT>*<TOT f'1ATL) <LIN $HAT)*(U $ INS~ <TOT lNST)*(TOT E:::c> (l<IAT ESC)< INS ESC) :3. 273000 3.280000 3.400000 3.410000 3. 411000 3.412000 3.420000 3.422000 3.423000 3r424000 3.430000 3.433000 3~435000 3.43601)(1 3.440000 3.441000 3..,442000 ~:. 45(1000 PITOT TUBE PIT CY* 200 HISCELLAN STEEL TN* COOL TOWER FACIL LS* TOWER BASIN LS* EXCAVATION CY* CONC CW COOL TWR CY* PliHP CHAMBER EXCAVATION CONCRETE MISC STEEL LS* .. • CV* C.Y* TN* INTA~~E Ef1UIPMENT LS* SCREENS :::F• STOP LOGS SF* CRANE BR I [tOE 15T EA* PMP HS SPR STRLICT LS* CRANE & HST SUPP TN* 7 ~.5(10 1500 4501) ~500 ., 5(10. 500 1 75 BUILDING SPRSTR 8Ft ·• 6000 TOWER SPR STRLICT LS* 4.010000 CONCRETE u::* 4.1000(10 TURBINE BLDG CONCR C:Y* 4700 4. 20000(1 BOlLER AREA CONCRT CY* 1 ~71(1(1 4. ::::oooou SILO AREA CONCRETE CV* 1700 4.400000 AG!CS CONCRETE CV* 91(1(1 c.;::·;;. 5 1::::790::: * 3::::~.(10 1~.8. 00* 7042.0 49294* 1'~600 2800.00* 6(1:3432~·* 30E:8100 * 7724~·5* 196500 * 22.4 145275* (I (1.00* 418.1 62719(1-l .. 196500 131.00* 848470* 220(:.(1(1 * 22.4 100575* (I (1.00* 465.7 69:360111· 201000 134.00* 7042.0 49294* 19(:.(1(1 28(1(1. 00* ~:97160* ::::::::5(100 * 58.3 29140* 15(1(1(1 ::::o. oo* 74.1 :3707(1* 30000 e.o. OO* (1.(1 330950* 29(1(1(10 ----* 757743* 3::::6(1(1(1 * 3155.4 ~~:3.!,(:.55* 120000 1600.00* :=:t .• e: 521(t8:::* 216000 :36. (I(H~· 325:34E::::* 20(1(1(1(1(1 * 2');;::;:·~7:::5* :37 63(1(1(1 * :=::::4. 4 :351215'?-lt.* 667400 142.00* 7:::5. e: 1397~176* 2/:..'~I:::(JC) 1.ti2.00* 7 (:.f{. 7 1306€:4011-24 t 4tl() 142. (1(111- 7/:.7.4 t. •;H::291:.·'~'* 129;!20(1 142.00* 521.5 104308* -c.E:95 -16E:(l -5215 .. 4242.(1 29t.94• -24e.4 -98(1 -148·4 • 2946226• -301711 -154405 -147306 57596f.* -38622 -9825 -28797 • 22.4 145275* -7263 (l -;2~·3 • 287.1 430/.:.9(Hi--31359 -9825 -21534 627870* -42422 -·11030 -31392 • 22.4 100575* -5(128 0 -5028 • 331.7 497601 * -34'~30 -10050 -24880 4242.0 296';'4* -2464 -980 -1484 • 62160* -19:357 -16750 -3107 • 28.3 14140* -1457 -750 -707 14. 1 7070* -185:3 -1500 -35:3 • (1.0 ··19::iO* -1654 7 -145(10 -2047 • 421; -~~:~ -37886 -1t·800 -21086 1555.4 116655* -1113::::2 -6000 -5:332 • 50.8 305088* -26054 -10800 -15254 • 1258488* -162924 -100000 -6:2924 1 (:.57 67:?.5*-1 01 (:.987 -18!3150 -828:3:37 • 692.4 :32541 9~·* -19/:..079 -33::::70 -16270'~' • 593~~ E~ 1128176* -69898 -13490 -56408 62(: .• 7 1065440* -65342 -12070 -53272 • t.25. 4 5690769* -349148 -64610 -2:34538 • .. ~ I ::::::;:;- / f f I I \.w ""' I l ~1 I J~ l I l I U ! i· . t- . ~ . . . ~. . ' . ' .. • -, ~ d.' 0 ,"f ._<,~ ~~~~-----,_.;._]( c u~ -· ---·-~ ~,--__......~ --~~ __ :,.. ,~ ·~~~~_...~-~ ·,._.. __ '"~~-~-~~~~:·:~ ..... ~;r':;-~~~~~~~~~~~~~u~~~ :i;:~;,~W4·;.·~'~J;.:~~li~-· ~--~~~ ~:~ ~::~~':';l -~-.-..., -r.---~ -·· EtY: •• mF r:HEO<fD: .JDF .,._ ~ ·- (.1f'{.\ SUS 11 NA :·OCI I'IW U 1{)1. l£'3T1Ml-'\TE NO. f·IPA ·llOl 11-1 DETAILED MATE'fU AL ~( I NS:l ALLAT I ON HEPOHT ~ ~ -. ~ £•m E: 21-.JUN-:?.4 __, ~ ' . TIME: H.: 40:54 .,_.. --l ACCT NO DESCRIPTION LIN* (QTY) (I_IN $ TOl) <TOrAL AMTHHTOT MATL> <UN $11AT>* (INS ESC) 4 • .'500000 COAL HANDLG C:ONC:RT C:Y* 5600 872 .. 8 48:=:7924* 7952(1(1 142.00* 73C). :3 4092724* -244396 -~:97(:.(1 -204636 4.900000 MISCELL CONCRETE C:Yit ~:500 !32(: .• 4 1842480* 497000 142.00* 384.4 1345480* -92124 -24850 -67274 5,000000 STRCT STL/LFT EQP LS* 273~:t)950* ! (16(:.:~:5(1(1 * 16667450•-1366545 -533174 -833371 5.100000 TURBINE BUILDING U:•* 41952~1 0* 204 7;1(11) * 2147890* -209764 -102395 -107369 5.110(1(1(1 MAIN STEEL TN* 1200 2440.0 2928000* 1500000 1250.00* 1190.0 1428000* -146400 -75000 -71400 5. 1:;-!00(1(1 :372750* * 18:3750* -186:37 -9450 -9187 FRAMING LS* 189000 !:i.121000 WALL FRAMING TN* 105 :355(•.0 372750* 189000 1800.00* 1750.0 183750* -18637 -9450 -';1187 5.130000 M!SC: STEEL LS* 56-3740* !28~1 00 * 4:";:4840* -28187 -t.445 -21742 5.131000 1200(1 28.0 336000* 21.0 4''52•)00* -16800 . ·4201) --12600 84(1(11) 7.00* GRATING 1-3/4 11 SF* !:i. 1320(1(1 6(10 57.9 34740* 46.9 28140* -17:37 -3:30 -1407 CHECKERED PLATE SF* 6600 11 • (1(1-11 5.138000 1000 103.0 1030(11)* 87.5 87500* -5150 -775 ··4375 HAI\IDRA I L LF* 15500 15.50* 5. 134000 LADDERS & STRWYS TN* 12 750(1.0 90000* 22:300 1900. 00* 5600.0 67200* -45.00 -1140 -3360 5.140000 3::::08(11)* * -11500 -5040 LIFTING Ef!l.ll P LS* 2:::: (I (I (I (I 1 (1(1800* -1 6540 5.141000 :3::::0800* * -11500 -5040 100800* -16540 CRANE: 4() T CAP J_S* 2:30000 5.2(1(1(1(1(1 STEAM (;ENERATOR LS* 12073520* 4595:35(1 * 7478170* -603675 -229767 -373908 5.2100CO MAIN STEEL TN'*-2~:(1(1 2440.(1 5612000* 2875(1(1(1 1250.00* 1190.0 2737000* -280600 -143750 -136850 5.220000 1 9::::::::000* * -:33300 -(:.:3350 FRAMING LS* 666,[11)\.1 1267000* -96650 5.221000 330 53(10.0 1 7 4':i-'0(11)* ::::5(11). (I -297(1(1 -57750 WALL FRAMING TN* 594000 1800.00* 1155000* -87450 5.222000 40 4600.0 1 ~34000* 2:::oo. (I -:3600 -5/.:.00 ELEV FRAMING TN* 72ooo 1 :::oo. oo• 112000* -92(1(1 5.230000 MISC: STEEL LS* 42:::~:82(t* 92•;.r::~,l) * 3354470* -214190 -464/.:.7 -167723 5.231000 70000 2E:.o 1 96(11)(1(1* 21.0 -7350(1 !470000* -98000 -24500 GRATING <1-3/4") Sf.'* 49(1(1C'I(I 7.00* 5.232000 16(10 57.9 92(:.~0* 4'-:•. ·~I 75040* -4682 -880 -3752 CHECkERED PLATE SF* 17t.(IIJ 11 • 1)(1* 5.23:3000 1251)(1 1 (l~ •• 5 13:::11t::n* 91. (1 i137430* -665~8 -9687 --~f(:.:::7 1 HANDRAIL LF* 1. ·~~:::750 1~.51)11- ,..., .. .. ,.. ,. • ... • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ·~ .. w ~r:t; >vt ;) ::-( e.'•trt;nett~-· I f "' I I I ! ! i l ·~ f 1 •. I ''l:J<(-:;~' ! ' ,! f ' t ~. ---~ ·. ~~~·~"-~ ... 1!"-~ -...-- B'f: .J[IF CHECi~.ED: ,JDF ·-~ - (\F'A ::.;us I TNA :.:·no t-Il~ r nAI t:·:;fiMATE' ~'-10. AP/) 1707 M-1 DClAILfD MATERIAL & IN~TALLATinN REPORT ~~ -,._ ~ D/.nC: 2J-,JIJN-t)4 .... ~ ~ I • TIME: 16:40:54 .._ -; ACCT NO DESC:R!PTION LIN* U:HY > (LIN $ TOT> <TOTAL AHT> ~ <1 OT I'IATL > (UN $l1AT Hd U $ INS:> (TOT I NST) * (TOT ES.:C > (MAT ESC) (INS ESC:> 5600.0 -11400 5. 234 (1(1{1 --3:;:/:..l)() LADDERS ~< STRWY TN* 120 7500.0 900000* 228000 1900.00* 672000* -45000 ~· -6250 5.240000 LIFTING EQUIP LS* 244700* 125(1(1(1 11'~700* -12235 --5S~85 it· -2500 5.242000 ELEV EQUIPMENT LS* 1445(1(U! ~50 (I (I (I 94!:i(ll)* -7225 -4725 * -3750 5.243(1(1(1 OTHER LIFT EQUIP LS* 100200* 75000 25200* -5(11(1 -1260 * -3750 5.243100 (3) 15 TON HST LS* 1 (102(1(Hl 750(1(1 25200* -5010 -126(1 * -93037 5.300000 SILO BLW LS* ::::626640* 1f:.U.075(1 1 7 65890* -181 ~:;;: 1 -:382S't4 5.310000 MAIN STEEL TN* 225 2440.0 54'?.'J(l(I(H!· 28125(1 1250. (11)·11-119(1.0 2~.7750* -27449 -14062 -1 :,!)·:::::7 * -5:::5() 5.320000 344500* 1170(10 FRAMING LS* 227500* -17225 -11:375 ::::500. (I -5850 5.321000· 344500* 117000 1800.00* 227500* -17225 WALL FRAMING t""i s::::oo. (I TN* -11375 -1(1(1(1(1 5.330000 :34](11)(1~ 20000(1 ----* 14 7000* -17:::5(1 MlSC STEEL L:3* -7:~:5(1 * -3000 5.340000 77640~ 60000 171.:.40* -3882 LIFTING EOUIPMENT L!::* -882 * -:3(1(1(1 5.343000 77640* (:.(1(1(1(1 17640* -3882 OTHER LIFT EQUIP LS* -882 * -1325l) 5.350000 755000* 2/.:.5(1(1(1 :::JJPF'ORT STEEL L!3* 490000* -37750 -24500 4 ·;1(1(1. (I -1~1250 5.351(1(1(1 7550(11)* 265000 2650.00* Et;!ll I P !::UPPORTS TN* 1(1(1 7550.0 490000* -37750 -24500 * -46875 5.360000 155·:::500* 9::::7500 /:..t/.:.(!0(1-11--77 675 STL SILO 8c CVR PL u::* -:;:(IE:(I(I 2:300.0 -~::5275 5. 3(:·1 (1(1(1 1181500* 705500 4150.u0* 476000* -59075 STEEL SILOS TN* 17(1 6950.(1 -2:3:3(1() ::::::.oo. o -11 6(10 5. ::::62(100 . ::::7 2000* 232000 5800.00* 140000* -18600 :::s PLATES TN* 40 93(11). (I -7(10(1 5.5(1(1(1(1(1 CONCRETE STACKS u::* 70:::7000* 2(ll)(l(l(l(l * 5087000* -354350 -10000(1 -254850 * -19(1(1 5.7(1(1(1(1(1 /.:.95(•0* ::::;.:(1(11) C:ECI STEEL LS* -1575 :31500* -:~:475 ::::50(1. (I -6075 5.90000(1 27•:11)(1(1* 121 ~·(I (I ,;:7(1(1. 00* UI'ICLASS STEEL TN* !l5 /.:.200.(1 -78n5 157500* -1 ;:9~.(1 6.000000 BUILDINGS LS* i :::;2 £127:::7 * ~··:::::;::()t, ~.t) * 1~862087* -912124 -294081 -618098 * -4·:::,(1(1 21 ~· ::(;.t-:!lJ * ::oon• ,., t:...J(I(l(ll)(l L':'* TURBINE BUILDING -f.:.2t.;:::3 1.2':•:::,:.:::4Att--1 c)~~·l ::r::: * -1~(1(1(1 ·:.:o t4::::=:-~: ;:tl(lt II II~> (:..1!(10(10 AI~C:Hl TECT FEATUkE' 1~:::* /:..714:::::-11 -i}:-:::'571 -~;:~:571 fi} ~ fll• • G • • • • • • • • • • fW ~ & • 61 ... • ~ w ·-~-----_"'_ ·:> .~ "'-----........,·-"; ., ...,.....,~. , • ,.,.........,.. "'""' ·'QIP"' 2fli!IP'>lll:'!f'ii • Ae)l ""*"P"l"'~t·'tl'! .p.;;:z;;;:;;aspJ&tJ,M!l"'-,_LiJi¥ii!I6...WM ;gq ..., .. ':' . -~----1 ,. . \ . ., r'-·J ____ _.~.J.(.J.J..-......_~.-~---""" ......... ~+.--~-~~-""-"~='""-'· J !>!~?ii!Ol!!"'!!;i.,i;o;,l;filo:~ 111111111!1 I ~~-,..,.--,-~ l j ' l I i i ! E«Y: ..JDF CHECI(£[1: ,J[IF ~ ~ ~ r-" ~ " ....;~._.:_-~~----'~~~~···''\ .. ~;~.:....~&~~~ .... ~·,_.:; __ __ --~ .,._,.,. ___, l~f·'(o\ ~~;ry=:; I '1 NA ·.~' 111 NW f fiAI l··:nlM(iTF t-1(1. AF'A 11117 1·1-1 [II:. lt4 Il t= ll MATFJH Al ~~ I WHALl AlI 1'11'1 Ht:Pi.tH I .._ '_, ._.. .._ ~ ~ ..._~ ~ ....., I " ,.. ... (IA'l E: ~ 1 -.JUN-84-TIME:: H .. : 40: 5/l .. • ACCT NO [tESCR1 F'TION LIN* <tHY> <UN $ ll"IT) <TOTAL AMTHHTOT t1Al'L) (IJI\1 $1'1AT>* 01AT E~.C) (INS: ESC) J f 1~ l l ·~ 1 .... "" lllilNI·~ 1 : I t ·. ' • l, '• , ; .~ -~ l I 'I ' Ut l' ' . ,. ~., (:.. 17(1(1(1(1 HVAC LS* t_ •• 180000 f'l.UMB & DRAINAGE LS* 6.190000 l'llSCELLANEOIJS LS* 6. 200(11)(1 STEAM GEN BUILDING t.:=:* 6.210000 ARCHTITECT FEATRS U~;* 6.270000 HVAC L~3* 6.280000 PLUMB L DRAINAGE LS* 6.290000 MISCELLANEOUS L"3* 6.300000 SILO BAY LS* 6.310000 ARCHITECT FEATR:3 L8* 6.3700(10 HVAC: LS* 6.380000 PLUMB ~< DRA I NAQE LS* 6.890000 M I S:CELLANEOUS LS* 6.400000 AQCS BUILDINGS LS* 6.410000 AQC:S SWGR BLDG ::;F* (: •• 4200(11) AOC:::: CTRL BLDG ~;F• /:. .• 4 :;:(1(1(1(1 Dl E::;EL GEN BLDG SF* c.. 4400(1(1 PUI"1F' HOU~::E SF* 6.450(1(10 LlMESTN PREP E•LDG SF* 6. '700000 • M I SC BIJ 1 LDI NG!3 LS* 1; •• 9:::0000 ADMIN BUILDING ::.F* l:. •• 94(11)(1(1 CONTROL BUILDING u:;* /:...950000 WTR TRTMT BLDG SF* .. _ ...... ----~--~--=-----_____,..,.--~ .... E:~i'7540* 4 !;:(11)1)(1 22936t)* 1 (1(1(1(1(1 6534(: .• 20000 25~·15'?.1(:,* 9 ~;i (I (I (I (I 126~·0E:O* :::::::(1(11)(1 1 1-3 1400* 500(1(1(1 71160~· ::::oooo 9:395/:..lt 40000 77:3890* 2:.::15(1(1 2/:..~:tt:.::·tt-:=:oooo ::::491:..00* 120(1(1(1 151440* 75000 147::=:2* (:.!)(l(l 355187:3* :::8(:.700 1:350 137.3 185409* 47250 :31;,.(1(1 17~:. 4 6~~4251* 169200 :350 14::::.2 12"5949* 2'7'750 14000 149.2 2(a8:::41:.·4* 504(1(l(l /.:.500 :31.2 52780(Ht 13(:.51)(1 92:26~··::1 411-2:::~:.':245Ct 4(1(1(1 2~.:~:.1;.. 1074600* 2'?.12(1(11) 12465::.:(1# 4 7(1(1(1(1 ;:25(1 2;~4. 5 7'2.•-nti':i It :21.1 l':H.H"I * 407540* -42877 -22501) -20377 • * 129:360* -1146::: -5000 -6468 • * 45::::46* -321;.7 -1000 -2267 * 1611596* -128079 -47500 -:::0579 • * E;:85l);::(l* -63254 -19000 -44254 • * (:.:31400* -56570 -25000 -3157(1 • -2C)5:3 -1500 -:3558 41160* * * 53956* -4/:..97 -2000 -21;.•:.J7 • * 497390* -3:3943 -14075 -24:368 • -9155 -40(1(1 t:::::::t1E:* -13155 * * 229600* -17480 -(:.(1(1(1 -11480 • * 76440* -7572 -:.::'750 -3822 * 8232* -736 -~125 -411 • * 26651 T3* -1 77590 -41:334 -1:::::325(:. • 35.00* 102.3 1 ::::::: 159 * -9:269 -23~·2 -(;.";1(17 47.00* 126.4 455051* -31212 -8460 -22752 • -4~::c)9 -1487 9619'~* -/:..291;. 11 ~3. 2 :35. (I (lit • ::::/.:. • (II)* 11~:. 2 1584464* -1 044::!3 -252(U) -7'5;22:3 21.00* (:.(1.2 ::::91:300* -zc..-:::s-,o -~.E:25 -1 ';)5C·5 • * (:.:3:34244·11--4(:.1::::29 -144622 -316707 • ·r:.:. (II)* 1':.15. 6 782t.OO* -5·:::7:::lo -146(11) -a·:' 1 ::::o * 7 71:-5:::(•·~ -/:..2:::2';1 -2:::5(U) -:;:::::::2'~1 • (:.:2. (1(111-162.5 ~i2:.:~.;~~-5it· -·;:1_ ... 4 :::7 -101)7.5 -2(:.412 • • bV / C) • I 4'Gili&l'fl!iiW~1,Jif .. .. 1'._'\., "\ ' •. :,, !' _) "' // L' ·~ i .. s ,·-~· ••.• :YM t .. I I r· ., ""'' , .. .. J ..J. "' ,1 ~~(ttl I i I f / ............ ) \ ., \..;~ <'' I ·u ! ... l ., ' . ,.-,I -: .';. ,_; ~' ;-••.;;· . . . . ' , . . 0 _,-I-,,-; • ,,,,,, ,., -.. ~ 'ilf -' ~" ~~ ~ ~ l'~ ... ~ v;:.~~ .. ,.. ''"" ·!"" -"r BY: .J[IF C:H 1iCl(E[I: ,J[IF (il~t~ ·:.a_t!=:: I TNA :·'1111 J·1W r illil. E:=·TH1A1L 1~0. 1-iPA 1707 11-1 DE fAILED MATERIAL & INSrALLATlON REPORT _, I DATE:. 21-.JUN-f~4 TIMF: 16:40:54 ACCT NO [IESC:RIPTION LIN* (l;tTY) (LIN $ TOT> <TOTAL AMT>*<TOT 11ATL> <UN $MATHHU $ !N:::> fTOT IN!3T)*(TOT ESC) <MAT E:::c> <INS ESC> f:.,. 990000 ALL OTHER LS* 1;,.. 991(1(11) PLANT HAINT SF* l;. •• $\92000 AUX BOILER SF* /:. .• 993000 YD EQP MAINT BLD SF* f:. •• 994000 CHLORINE BLDG SF* 6.995000 FIRE/SRV PUMP HS SF* 6.996001) GUARD HOUSE SF* ~. 6.997000 WAREHOUSE NO. 1 SF* 6.998000 BULK GAS STR BLD SF* 6.999000 OTHER BLIILDIN1.1S LS* /:... 9991(11) SWTH YD C:TRL BL SF* CONTRCIL & :=:WGR SF* 6.999201) 6. 9993(11) £,dfR TRTHT BLDG SF* 6.999500 6.999400 [IEWTR !< FIXTN SF* SWTCH YD CTRL :=:F* 6.999600 C:RSHING ~ SAMPL SF* 6. 9·:>::noo WASTEWTR l·RTMT SF* LS* 7.000000 TURBINE GENERATOR 7.100000 TURBINE GENERATOR LS* 8.000000 STM GENER ~ ACCESS LS* 8.100000 STEAM GENERATOR LS* 9. 000000 A~K:S L::;* 9.100000 BAGHOUSE L:=:* :3000 1000 1200. 1000 800· 225 2:"::(1(10 1200 800 2000 3000 8000 700 2000 7000 16':).3 240.6 151.3 151.4 160.4 250.6 .&3. 1 14~9. 4 l4/.:..4 14:?.. 3 147.4 135.:::: 148.4 149.4 1:?-5. ::.: 61757ti911-1 ';'2:::•-;J5(a * 1.:,.7. 00* 66.00* 52.00* 40.00* 46-.00* 70.00* 27.00* :3:3. (II)* :38. 00* 41.00* :3(:.. (I (Ill- :3:3. 00* 40.00* :3:3. (1(1·• 36.00• 1Ct2. 3 174.l:.· 99.:3 111.4 114.4 180.6 :36. 1 111.4 * 108.4 102.3 111.4 102.3 108.4 111.4 9'7'.3 * * * * * * 4 241.:..809* -808783 :::07020* -25401 174580* -12029 119196* -907'';; -10050 -96447 -212:386 -1~·351 -3300 -3120 -2000 -1840 -787 -31050 -2280 -8729 -5959 -55l:.(C -4575 -2(1:31 -41'538 -6682 -42020 -12190:3 -43~:4 -1520 -4100 -5400 -13200 -1400 --3800 -12600 -10234 -16705 -4093(:. -3792 -11137 -:3476'5 695310* -47:::65 '2664900* -953245 -820000 -133245 50802011-201 (1(10 24058(1* 1.:,.(:.(1(10 1E:1596* 62'400 151370* 4(1fl(l0 1~~8804-11 :::t.800 56885* 15750 1451760* 621000 179244-11 45600 :~:278500* 8•l0400 11.708:=:* :~:0400 286680* 82000 442110* 1 o:::noo 10:32720* 264000 108852* 28000 298740* 7t.OOO 947~:1 0* 252000 19064900* 16400000 19064900* 16400000 42900000• 24000000 42900000* 24000000 5:;:·:.'~·60(11)* 3014:::t:~:cll.l :3006E:OO* 400onnn 111370* -751.:..8 91504* -6.415 40635* -2818 E::3076·0*· -725E:8 1336.4'4* -8962 2438100* -163923 8(:.6.88* -5:354 204680* -14334 :3:341 1 (I* -221 (15 818720* -54136 75852* -5192 222740* -149:37 2664900* -953245 -820000 -133245 18900000*-2145000 -1200000 -945000 18900000*-2145000 -1200000 -945000 28807700*-2697800 -1507415 -1190385 4006800* -400340 -200000 -200340 ~ ..... ~ • • • e • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • .. ./.~~ ''} *r ! ~{ i I :_. I .J j t ' f "!# f •• ,.~. I ,. I I ,I \·--, i !! l, 1 .. il i t t i s U ;; ' 1; I I ! ~~.,~--:'.:"!~-- ..........,._ . . . . . . ' ,.. -. . =~ t~ ~ - ... r r rw: .Jt•F CHE.C¥ED: ,J(IF d (ol···(.\ SUSilNA 200 MW COAL E:.STIMATE NO. Af:·~' l7C•7 1'1-1 DETAILED MATERIAL & INSTALLATION R~PORT . . ~. I ' DATE : 21-.JIJN-84 TIME: 11.:.: 40:54 ACCT NO DESCRIPTION UN* (QTY> <UN$ TOT>CTOTAL AMT>•<TOT MATL><UN $MAT>•<TOT INST>~<TOT ESC><MAT ESC><INS ESC> ~~. 2000(11) FLUE GAS DE SULFUR LS* 37475700* 20157(100 * 17318700*-1873785 -1007850 -::::(:.5$"135 C:01'1PON£NTS LS* 9.210000 17318700*-1873785 -1007850 -865935 37475700~ 2015700(1 * 9. 2t 1000 OLICTWORt< FOR FGD LS* * 1890000* -170900 -76400 -94500 3418000* 1528(1(1(1 9.2131.100 802 ABSORB MODUlE LS* 12694500*-1384725 -750000 -634725 27 694500* 1 !::o(l(l(l(ll)(l * 9.215000 LM::>T ULD. STR~RECL t.::;* 14 :::::::ooo 1638000* -153800 -71900 -:31900 3076000* * 9. 21 e.ooo LIMESTN PREOENER LS* 3287200iE-2191000 1096200* -164360 -10~550 * .-54810 u::* 9.300000 WASTE DISPOSAL 6229(1(11)* 4276000 195::.:000* -311450 -213800 -97650 * wASTE DISPOS SVS LS* 9.310000 •. 6229000* -97650 42760(10 1953000* -311450 -213800 * 9.311000 WA:::TE PROCESS EC"~ L'E;~ c·229000* -97650 4276000 * 1953000* -311450 -213800 9.400000 FANS i.S* 2244501)* -.26460 1715:300 * 529200* -112225 -85765 LS* 9. 410000 I. [1, FANS · 139:3900* -1c:.695 1 0(:.5000 :333S"I00* -69945 -53250 * SILENCERS LS* ~.420000 845600* -9765 (:.5(1:3(10 1953(l(Hfo -42280 -32515 * 10.000000 OTHER MECHAN EftUif' LS* 1990990/.:.* 14724200 * 5185706* -995480 -736210 -259270 * 499968* -174342 -149350 -24992 10.100000 PUMPS LS* 348(:.9t·8* 29:37000 10.110000 BOILER PUMPS LS* r-----19498 30::.:8370* 2648400 389970* -151918 -132420 * 10.111000 BOILER FEED PUMPS EAtr. 2 40042(1.(). -7812 8(1(1840* 644600 ----* 78120.0 156240* -40042 -32230 10.112000 BF PUMP TURBINES EA~ 2 865001).(1 -t.-300 1 7::.:(1(100* 1604000 ----* 63000.0 126000* -86500 -:30200 10. 113000 -2::::35 BF BOOSTER PUMPS EA* 2 . 121750.0 24:~:500* 18(:.800 93400.00* 28350.0 56700* -12175 -9340 10.114000 -2551 BF STRT UP/STD BV LS* 21:.40:~:(1* 21:3(1(1(1 st o:=:o* -1 :::c:;!o1 -10650 * 10 .. 120000 -97 FEEDWTR SVS PUMP!3 LS* 975:3* 780(1 * 1':15::::• -487 -:390 10.1211)(1(1 -97 CONDEN TRANSFER LS* 975:3• 7:::(1(1 1 ·~15::.:* -487 -390 * 10.130000 -1:347 SRV & COOL WTR PMP LS* C,:3(164:t 41100 * 2(:.9(:.4* -:3402 -2C)55 10.131000 -5·~2 SERVICE f!Jt'HER EA* 4 (:.8(:.1 • (I 27444• 15600 '39(1(1. (IC)* 2961.0 11El44* -1:372 -7:3(1 ~· . . 1 .- ,.. ,. • • • • • • • • • • • .. • • • • w • ----·~-·"'<rv·r" n -~-·~xz---,er;;;-.-ac-··--'h~~~~:s~-.-~--~"1.: ___ : ~· ~ .. .,:."-:~t: 'w~.:... .~~~:. :~. ~:;;;r, ::_._;~:'". -~ .. :;-:::; __ .,-:-:.-_ ., •• :-·::-:~-----... "-: ~ . ~ :;:~~S: -~:-:-:::c~---~ ,-:·~~~~~~;~~~~~~:c=~~~~:·~::~-~.,~;:: -~-~--··:~·-"_-_-~.... ..~-____ _ " " r .. Q ' i!i·~Ji'i.!li'i( ~ f r-r j l ! l l. j i I. l ¥ i') '\ • i~ ~-.. ~~~s I " I ' ! • ~,., \-' Ul~ [ ! . . J i ...,.;..____ -·~ - ·.· . . . ' . " . . ,. ..... . . . ,-J ~,~..;-~-..)....,.,..........,..___....... -. .. -~ ---~:.....--~...,, ...... ~~~.:......:..d--: _,..,_· -.-_,..:::.~ _ _...,_;. •. ,,.J;~:.....:...~;:.;w4:•'' ~:~/~j~. · .; • ._.~~-·-,..,.':--=-~--·· ... ,·----'~ .... -· -·-~ . ..........,~;__~.,__"~~.-._,,_ •. -.....-..~(:~~~~ ,. r r BY: ,.JDF CHE:CLED: ,JLIF --- APA !~;U:;ITNA 2011 1'1l..J I 0?'~1. ESTIMATl NO. APA 1707 M-1 [II:.TAllFD MATER 1 Al ~. I N~3TALLAT I ON REPORT IIATIE: 21-.JI.IN-84 TIME: 1 (:.: 4(t: 54 ACCT NO DESCRIPTION LIN* HHY> <UN $ TOT) <TOTAL AMT)-tt(TOT NATL> <UN cJ>MAT>• <TOT INST>*<TCtT ESC) <HAT ESC:> (INS ESC} 1 o. 1 ~:21)0(1 10.133000 10.140000 10.141000 10.142000 ·to. 1480oo 10.145000 10.150000 10.160000 10. 1e·1000 10.162000 10.163000 10.164000 AIR HTR WASH PMPS LS* CL.3D CYC COOL WSP EA* OIL PUMPS LS* LGT OIL UNLD PMPS EA* lGNITER OIL PUMPS EA* TURB LO T~ANS PMP LS* LO C:OND PUMP LS* SUMP PUMPS EA* OTHER PUMPS LS* COOLING TOWER MU LS* OP CVC CLO WTR EA* FIRE PROTECT PMPS EA* AIR PREHTR GLV EA* 10.200000· CONDENSING PLANT LS* 10.210000 CONDEN~:ER 8c All X I L LS* 1 0. 22000(1 Ef!LIIPMENT LS* 10.~21000 C:W PUMPS EA¥ 10.222000 CONDENSATE PUMPS EA* 10. 22:::(11)(1 VACUUM PUMPS EA* 1 o. 226(!')0 COND CLEAN :3YS u::* 10.227000 COND C:OLL PUMP LS* 10.300000 HEAT EXCHANGERS L:3* 10.310000 FEEDWATER HEATERS EA* 1'~1 112* 2 10754.0 215fl:3* !;:;·~171 * . 2 7258.0 14506* 3 1 025:3. (I :;:0759* t.953* 695:3* 6 20t.C,(I. (I 128960* 187650* :353::.:2* 2 24420.0 48840* 3. 24252.0 72756* 2 15361.0 ::::0722* 24783'79* 15859(10* :::~12 4 ·:.'9* 2 14::::8~!2 .• (I 297664* 2 :39624.0 17924:::* '2 :34667.0 1{:.'7834* 2485(1(1* 275:"-::* 1 •'iJ•-;J331 :::* 7 1. :::c•;:r::::::. «) 1265::::~-·'=··lj· 11 ::::oo * 7812* -955 -51.:·5 -890 14200 71 oo. (10* 31:.54. (I 7808* -1075 -710 -365 45500 ----* t3t.71* -2956 -2275 -681 1 0600 !'5::::oo. O(H~ 1953.0 8906* -725 -530 -195 :;-4900 :::::::oo. 00* 1958.0 5859* -1537 -1245 -292 5000 * 1953* -347 -25(1 -97 5000 * 195:3* -847 -250 -97 1164fl0 19400.00* 1260.0 7560* -6198 .. -5E:2(J -37·8 127800 * 59850* -9381 -6390 -2991 18700 * 11;.1;.32* -1766 -935 -8:31 :;: 1200 1 !';i~.(ll). 00* E:E\2(» .. (I 17640* -2442 -tst.o -882 ~.:31 (1(1 17700. 00* ~.552. 0 1';i656* -:3637 -2655 -982 24800 12400. (l(l* 2961. (I 5722* -1536 -1240 -296 1 7:::o:::oo * 6915';1'9* -12:3918 -89040 -84878 10000(1(1 * 5859(10* -79295 -50(100 -29295 780::::oo * '111699* "44623 -3•;;(140 -5583 21.:.4400 ----* tl.:../:..:32. (I 832cA* -14883 -13220 -1663 148000 74000.00* 15624.0 ::::~:248-~<--8'7t·2 -741)(1 -1562 155~00 77800.00* 1;..:::1;. 7 • (1 t::·o:34* --:::46t· -77:30 -6:3(:. :;'t ~-onn * :::.:1500* -121~/5 -10600 -t575 :::oo * 195:.::-rr .... 1:'":.:7 -40 -97 1 :~: 11 "500 .. n-t::H 818* -'79665 -90575 -909(1 11.66:200 -----* : 42::::~:. (;· •?.)9l:u!:•l.:•* -t.32':.1~: -~s:::3t c) -4988 .- ,.-. I ' .-. .. ....... ·' ..... ' ..... . !._, c ' """ - 'OJ .... .... '- .... ,. ~ ···"··---~--·-----=-... ----""''!!I'~-'-.';' ....... ~\"'O·~~.,._,_~~-;Jr"<,;,,._.;;-:-·~,-~ .... -~;: ...... ~-:::""7!"';7. ::':._...,.,;;;~-~:..-.~.::--.~;~;0.:,·: ...... J_.,. ~~,.......--~~ ~?~~~-~~.--~~~-~-"---' ,, (j .. f ) " . i :"' ' ·''*'•·:~ I ' . !_; '> ,., l j.,..l ~ ~ { U j..J l ' ,..1 l I d / / ·. . -r -., I . . . • . . . .. .~ '1. ' ,.' ~ ' ~t -·~' ' ~-;:;,;; * , .:: ,-• IP .. ,l \ .._ "~.;.;., L......:.~->· ,....~._.,~ ....... -~,~"" ~--,.;:li;EI,t ·~~,~~~...:..~~.;;..;. ... ~~.:::.~.~:·i ·~"~.;&~"'~"'"'~(;j;~;..,i~~io J'~~,., .. , .... g •. ~~~~~.ii~-;~:-~/'.,;~ ~ ~ ,"_"-!:'"' -·· "-Pet ~ ~ ,_ ., t" BY: ,JDF C HEC.l~ED: .JllF ,~ ... ,...._, .Mc!r-.- Af:·A !~;u::.r TNA ...:"Ot"l NW r (1~\1. ESTlMATL NO. APA 1707 M-1 DbTA 1L FD MATERIAL ~. INSTALLATION REPORT I!All::: 21-,JI.IN-84 TIME: lt!:.=40='::i4 ACC:T NO DESCRIPTION LIN* HHY> <LIN $ Tt)T) <TOTAL AMT>-~t <TOT l"tATL) (UN $MAT>*<LI io INS) (TOT INSTHHTOT ESC> <MAY ESC:) {INS ESC) 10.132000 AIR HTR WASH PMPS LS* 1 o. 13:=:ooo C:L'3D C:YC: COOL WSP EA* 10.140000 OIL PLIMF'S LS* 10.141000 LC;T 01 L UNLD PMPS EA* 10.142000 IGNITER OIL PUMPS EA* ·to. t4sooo TLIRB LO T~ANS PMP L$* 10.145000 LO COND PUMP LS* ~0.15GOIJ0 SUMP PLIHPS EA* 1(1.160000 OTHER PUMPS LS* 10. lt-10(10 COOLING TOWER MIJ LS* 10.162000 OP CYC C:LG WTR EA* 1 (1. 1 63(100 FIRE PROTECT PMPS EA* 10.164000 AIR PREHTR GLY EA* 10.200000· CONDENSING PLANT LS* 10.210000 CONDENSER ~( <All X IL LS* 10.22(1(1(1(1 Ef71UIPHENT LS* 10.~21000 C:W f'LIMPS EA* 10.222(1(1(1 CONDENSATE PUMPS EA* 1 o. 22::::ooo VACUUM PUMPS EA* 10.226000 CCIND CLEAN SYS L8* 10.227000 COND COLL PUMP LS* 10.300000 HEAT EXCHANGERS LS* 10.310000 FEEfll-IATER HEATERS EA* 2 10754.0 2 7253.0 ~. .:;.. 1025:3. (I b 2ot.c.o. o 2 24420.0 :3. 24252. (I ,..., "-15361.0 2 14==:e::;:2. c, 2 8'i624. (l z 846/.:.7. (I 7 l :::(u:r:::::. (J 1 S'1 112* 2150:3-tt !:i9171 * 14506* :;:0759* 6953* 6':153* 1239/:.0* 187650* 3532i2* 48840* 7275t·* :30722* 2478899* 1585900* 8•;1249.~* 297 t./.:.4 * 17924:3* 169334* '24350fl* 2752-* lS''';-381 :?.* 121:.·5:::/:./;..~· 11 :3(10 * 'l812* -95~i -5/:..5 -39(1 14200 7100.00* 3654.0 7308* -1075 -710 -365 45500 * 13~·71* -2956 -2275 -681 1 ot.:.oo 5:;:oo. cu)* 1953.0 :39(:6* -725 -530 -195 24900 :::::.:oo. 00~ 1 95:'.::. (I 5859* -11537 -1245 -292 5C:·OO * !953* -347 -250 -97 5(1(10 * 195:3* -347 -250 -97 116400 19400.00* 1260.0 7560* -1;.198 -5820 -·378 127800 * 59850* -9381 -639(1 -2991 18700 * 16632* -1766 -935 -8:31 :;_: 1 200 15HII). 00* E:82(1. (I 17i.40* -2442 -1560 -882 ~·31 (1(1 177(1(1. 00* ~.552.0 19~.56* -:3637 -2655 -982 24:::(11) 12400. 00* 2961.(1 5922* -1536 -1240 -296 1780E:(I(I * 6S'I7599* -12:3918 -89040 -34878 1000000 * 585900* -79295 -50(100 -29295 * "111699* -44623 -39040 7:?,(1800 -5583 264400 ----* 16632.0 33264* -14E:83 -13220 -1663 148000 74000.00* 15624.0 :31248* -8':J62 -7400 -15t·2 155600 77800.00* 6867.0 137:34* -:::4/.:o/.:. -7780 -c.:3(:. ::? 1 :;'(Inn * ::.:1500* -12175 -1 (ll;.(l(l -1575 80(1 * 1 95:=:• -1 ::.o -40 -97 1::: 1 1 '300 * 1:3181 ::nt -9'?,"!/.:.C.~:i -90575 -9090 1166:200 __ .. __ * 142::::::. t) '"51~1/:..!;,~.* -t-.3~~·;,:::: -·5::::31 C) -4';'1:3:3 '"~ ,... ..... r: ,-, '"' .; .; .... . ... ' .. ' c ' \....;,ot .... ..... ... .... ..,. .... .... ., " """ ;\ ~-~ ,_,_, -·--" ~·~·rttC·*;o,-~"-'*'"'-'"'-~~":.-J<.~",;.:-:~-••'7__;._.;'·7",.'"V-.: .. :":~ .. --~~.--~-·":~.w-•'-::.::;::: .... ::~..,"'"~ ~]', . .,_--~·~···¥' -:/~~~;" .. ',. :7~ .... .-4 ~"'?7'~~ ..... -~~-:__-.r-... ~; ....... ~~~~=· --· ~ ~~~=~ --~~~~-~-~: ~----·--···-···r-~_,.-r··--·~·: .. ~-·:~"r,~ ' ( s:t .W.:sJr~JtiaTs\t~l~ i i t f (; I ' ) ! , .. I ') \-,. ~~ .... l t i ... , ..., .. , ltJ I. i '11 f -~ 1 .. w "' Ill ., ., w! •• ! ' ! j., U: ' . iJj I .; ' -' ..._ ~· ~ I ,. 't.~....-.-G ""' '-·-·-~·~ / ¥ .~ ,:"..-~ "' .. j ~ ~ ::---. r~ ~ ~ ~ ~v::;~ --- BY: .JDF CHEC.{E[I: ._l[lf o·.'r"'",.- AM SUSilNA 200 MW ~OAL ESTIMAlE NO. APA 1707 M-1 DETAlLEI) t1ATERIAL ~< INSTALLATlON REF'I)JH ~ (1. f.IATE: 21-.JI.IN-:::4 TIME: 16:40:5.1! ACGT NO DESCRIPTION LIN* <OTY) <LIN $ TOTHTOTAL AMTl*CTOT t<IATLHIJN $MAT)*(LI $ INSHTOT lNST>*<TOT Ec;CHMAT E~:G) (INS ESC) 1 (1. :::21:)(11)0 DEAER/ VENT CONDEN LS* ---- 1 f). 330(1(10 cum CYC COOL WHE EA* 10.340000 AIR PRHTR GLY HE EA* 10.400000 TANKS LS:* 10.410000 WATER TANI<S LS* 10.412000 CONDEN STRG TANK LS* 10.414000 FIRE~SRV WTR STRG LS* •. 10.430000 LOT OIL STRG TANK LS* 10.44001)0 OTHER FL OIL STRG EA* 1 (1. 45(1(1(11) OTHER OIL TANI<S LS* 10.452000 BATCH OIL TANK LS* 10.453000 CONl' BLWDWN FL TK LS* 10.454000 INT BLWDWN FLH TK LS* 10.455000 COND C:OLL TANK LS* 10.456000 C:LSD C:YC C:L WHT LS~ 10.457000 AIR PREHT CL EX LS* • 1 0. 50000(1 MI SCELLANEOLIS EG!U 1 P LS* 10. 51000(1 CONPRESSED AIR EQP LS* 10.512001) .0.513000 10.520000 10.521000 10.522000 STAT AIR COMPRESS EA* AIR DRYERS LS* WTR TREAT EQUIP LS* MKUP WTR TRTMT LS* C:OND POL DEMINER LS* 2 171250.0 -, .._ 721(1(: .• (I 8. 14352. (I 2 115060.0 240740*· :;:42500* 144212* 721815* 44$315* 200175* 248140* "12t~232* 4305b* 104212* :35600* 6550* 235~i9* 9753* 9950* 1 88(11)* 32:08706* 274026* 2:~:0120* 43906* 3084680* 112(1f,;;,(! !!- 1 OE:9560* 197900 * 42840* -12~)37 -9895 -2142 311 (l(l(l --·--* 15750. (I 3 .)0* <>•17125 -15550 -1575 136400 68200.00* 390~ .• l) 7$12* -7210 -~820 -;.:)90 2T/-::.:oo * 444515* -3t:.08b -··13$65 -22221 145~.(1(1 * 302715* <-22~15 -7280 -15135 58700 * 14c.~7t;* -!l'oooa -2685 -7823 91';l(l(l * 156240*" -124(!7 --4595 -7812 4(13(10 ----* :=:5·~3~2* -t.:311 -2(1.15 --4296 2::::400 7800. 00* 6552.0 1'~656* -2152 -1170 -982 681)(1(1 * 36212* -5208 -3400 -1808 19:300 * 15800* -1780 -990 -790 3400 * 3150* -327 -170 -157 17700 * 585·9* -i177 -885 -29:2 7800 * 195:$*" -487 -39(1 -97 6800 * 3150* -4'5''7 -340 -157 12500 * 6300* -940 -625 -<::t ~~ 21:../:..2200 * 646506* -165434 -133110 -32:324 192(1(10 * 82026* -1370J -9600 -4101 152000 7 (:.(1(1(1. 00* :39060. 0 78120* -11506 -7600 -3906 40000 * 3906* -2195 -2000 -195 2470200 * 564480* -151733 -123510 -28223 88(:..~:00 * 2:34360* -56033 -44315 -11718 8552(1(1 * 234360* -54478 -42760 -U718 ,. "' • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • .. -, _____ ,..._" ..... ~~""' ...... ...., ..... ,.,.. ~.~.~-.. __,".#""''""'~·.._.,. ~.0-~~ .;';::'~ « ... ~ '~~·:-,. -· ._-:-·::~;,,'!--: ::: ~~;,~;·:-;,.~. :-::-:-:-:;:~:_::-~~-.·-:-:-::-:::~-::?:~~ ~·... w -. ~-· -·~ -· ...,, ,. • • -• :.. ..,-,.-••• ,.;:."-~~~E:":-:-: r.:-~-:' :. ':. $.~~~:?~ ~-~.~~~-~~--:~ :~~---~~~~·,--=~:~~~~· ·-' ..... ,..~. ~': -. -·~ -~~--~---~ .. ~ --- (, -'~·-·-·· . = 4,--... • • • .. ... " • ... .. ..... • .'· • ' ;, ,; j • • ~ •• -~--. . ) Q"• ...., .. ·"1 ,., - l' it ,.,.,.~ ] ~ I I i ' ! \ .. t.,.• '..J '-' i'-J j !lwl I.,.; j I~J j l lt.,j l U i..., ! 1 l-- ............. ~ ~ _...~ ~ ~ ~~ BY: ..J[IF GHECI<ED: .J[IF "' ...:::- -· '.~ < ~~~ APA SUSITNA 200 MW COAL ESTIMATE NO. APA 1707 M-1 DETAILED MATERIAL ~ INSTALLATION REPORT [J DATE: 21-.JUN-84 TIME: 16:40:54 ACCT NO DESCRIPTION UN* HHY> (UN $ TOT) (TOTAL AMT>•CTOT MAlL) <UN $MAT>*< INS ESC) 10.523000 -1953 CHLORINAl" EQUIP LS* :3 ~ 9(lt.t)* 28(1(1(1(1 * 39060* -J~953 -14000 10.524000 BOILER CHEN FEED LS* 70670* 587(10 i1970* -3538 . -2935 * -598 10.525000 S.AMPLINO SYSTEM LS* 195~:.40* 1780(1(1 'It 1764v* -9782 -8900 -882 1 o. 52600(1 BLK GA~: STR!<DISTR LS* 239090* 21200(1 * ----27090* -!1954 -10600 -1:354 LS* 7'32901)* 10.600000 AUXILIARY BOILER 575400 * 157500* -36645 -28770 -7875 10.700000 C:ECI LS* 2982000* 2100000 * 882000* -149100 -105000 -44100 1 ~:56000-M-tz:::oooo 10.800000 EQUIP UNLOAD FACIL LS* * 12(:.(100* -67800 -1:..1500 -6300 2849800* 1300000 ~ 10. 9()0000 TURBINE BYPASS LS* 1549800* -142490 -65000 -77490 * 11.000000 COAL&ASH HNDL EQUIP LS* 22802750• 13343300 * 9459450il--1140136 -667165 -472971 11.100000 COAL HANDLING LS* 18(170090* i0627900 * 7442190* -903504 -531395 -372109 THAWING FACILITY LS* 2~:56800* 20418(1(1 11.110000 -15750 * 315000* -117840 -102090 11. 120000 UNLOADING FACILITY LS* 912500* 44000(1 472500* -45625 -22000 * -23625 11.122000 440000 C:ONVEVOR NO 1 LS* ·~112500* * 472500* -45625 -22000 -23625 11.130000 12(:.(1(1(1(1 STACKOUT SYS\EM LS* 2532600* * 1272600* -126630 -63(1(1(1 -1.:.3630 11.131000 l;tt:.OOOO CONVEYOR NO 2 LS* 2532600* * 1272600* -126630 -630(1(1 -6363(1 11.140000 RECLAIM SYSTEM LS*· 67775(1(1* :;::::2';11 t)() * ·----' 2948400* -338875 -191455 -1474?0 11.141000 2590000 -85(15(1 1~01000* -214550 -129500 * STACKER RECLAIMER LS* 4291000* 11.142000 401600 * 415800* -40E:70 -20080 CONVEYOR NO 5 LS* 817400* -20790 11.1430(1(1 14700 * 12600* -t::::t.5 EMER RECLM HOPPER LS* 27:"::00* -7~:5 -t.,.:;:l) .11.144000 :;:(14 E: (I (I * 340200* -::::2250 CONVEYOR NO 6 LS* 1-;.45(1(1(111--15240 -1701(1 11 .. 145000 5180(1(1 * 239400.0 4 78:300• -4':>840 -259(10 -23940 CONVEYOR NO 7A~7B EA* 2 4984(10.0 996:::00* 11. 1 t.(l(l(l(l 1/:. ti.(II)O * 1707300* -166165 -E:(I:~:oo -853C.5 CRUSH ~ TRANSF SYS LS* :::::::2:;: .. ::c)l)il· 11. 1 61 (l(l(l :~:lie t(JIIr"l * 42:::4(1(1. 0 :::5t:..:~:c)t)* -E:2:::4t) -4(1(1(1(1 -4284(1 CONVEYOR NO E:A~(8B EA* 2 E:2:34(,t). c~ 165(:.::,:(10* •;.,..._ .~Jj ,--"',-...--. ._....,__,__~+---c -~,~~ :• "~c -~~---"" ... - ' • • ~ • • • • • • • I I I ? / ' J I ' , • , , • .J' ·,. -. ,..:-,, .. ·---~----"-----''-----. ~·-~ t ·~ ·~-~,_--.cl_. .. .____~~---1~-~·~·~·/~;·,-~~".;~h-~~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~~--~~~; ~.t../~._~ .. ~~.~L--~-~ l . ""'\ ~:) :":) ;'1 """ ~ \ itl ,.j '""' wJ _, : .,., wl ...1 , ... l l lw .I" I!. LJ . 1_. ~ ....... .~ -~ 'if?Wri ~ .- BY: ~lfiF CHECl<ED: ,J[IF ..,.,_ ~ .. ~ .. ,~~·~ (-if!' A ~.u~~: rrN?\ 1•oo MU r fiAt. ESTIMATE' r~O. APA 1107 t·l··t nr-TA u.rn ~ ~1ATER I Al & IN:;:l AL 1.?\ f HlN REPOR f -~,..c.=too DATE: ·2J-.JUN··:34 TIME: H,.: 40:54 At.:CT NO DESCRIPTION LIN* ((!TV> <LIN $ TOT) nOTAL AMn*nOT HAn.) <I.IN $MAT>*•<TC•T ESC) <MAT ESt::>< INS ES•::> 11.162000 SURGE BIN LS* ';' (:.(1(100* 10250(1 157500* -1 ;"1-000 -5125 -7E:7~ * 11.16300(1 SAMPLING SYSTEM LS* 59!5000* ~·:::::nooo * 315000* -29750 -14000 -!5750 11.164000 COAL CRUSHERS LS* 1141(H)* -3500 -22(15 70000 441f.ll)* -57(1~i * 11.165000 CONVEYOR NO 9A LS* 6974()0* -tE:175 -16c.95 3(:.8500 38390(1* -34::::70 * 11."170000 t1 I SC $ '(~:TEMS LS* 21 (:.7390* -72050 -31.:.319 1441000 72c.::::90* -to83t:s * i1.172000 FIRE PROTECTION LS* E:81 ~.(1(1* -24550 -195::::0 491(1(11) 390600* -440!30 * 11 • 1 7:3000 TUNNEL VENT LS* 27:~::30* -39.0 -97(-: 7:3(1(1 1'1530* -1:3(:.6 * 1l '174000 INSTRLIM & CONTROL LS* '· 6822l ... (l-li--32160 -1.953 (:. 4 :?, 2 (I (I 39(1(:.0* -3411 :3 * 11.176000 MISC EQUIPMENT LS* 5762(t{l* -14950 -13860 299(1(11) 27720(HI· -28810 * 11.200000 BTM ASH HNDL SYSTEM LS* 3021560* 161540(1 * 1406160* -151077 -80770 -7o:::o7 FURN BTM ASH SYS LS* !1 .. 210000 1150800* -33600 -23940 672000 478:::00* -57540 * 11.220(100 PYRITE HNDL SVSTEM LS* 114630* -3180 -2551 .s::::6oo 5J.o:::::o• -5731 * 11.230000 ECONOMIZER ASH SYS LS* :3163(1(1* -9200 -6615 1 :::41)0(1 1:32300* -15815 * 11.240000 DEWTW BIN~(SET TKS LS* 1129(:.00* -2435(1 -:32130 4:370(1(1 642600* -56480 * 11 • 25(1000 MA.JOR PUMPS EA* 3 t.4390. (l 19:3170* -6540 -311:3 130800 43600.00* 20790.0 6237011--9658 11 • 2/:.(I(H)(l Btl-1 A~:H 1 NSTRLIM LS* 117060* -3900 -1 ~15':;: 780(10 39(l~.(HI· -5853 * 11.400000 FLY ASH INST & C:TL LS* 17111 00* 110(1(1(11) * 1;.111 (l01f -:::5555 -55000 -:30555 12.000000 PIPING LS* 28(1(14420-li· ';Jf:_:7 6:=:(U) * 18127620*-1400221 -493840 -906381 12.100eJO LARGE BORE PIPING TN*-5120 1 '1711 • (I 1::: 1 :::41 2fl* 84~480(1 9190.(10~ 105?1.0 9679820* -9(16706 -422740 -483966 12.200000 SMALL BORE PIPING LF* 9(11)(11) 1fl9. 7 9:?:70:7:(LJ* 1 '!'22(1(1() ts.:::ott •;18. 9 8448300* -493515 -71100 -422415 13. 00000(1 INSULATION LS* (:,:?,:8(1(1(10* ~381.1(1(1(1 it· h~OOOOO* -344000 -·:;::';"1(1(1(1 -:~ 15(1(1(1 13.100000 INSULATION L~·*" 1-.r::?.nnno* -2':/(lfl(l -<: t 5(1(1(1 ~•:=-a·H H 10 * t-. :::onnc,n• -~~:44nnn 14.000000 INSTRUMENTATION L-S* 70(:.7(11.1(! * 5~.7(1CII) l} -·?,~:::-:::5(1 -:::2'3(1(11) -~~:38'=.(t ,:,5Cifh)ll(l * _,_.,.... .. ~,~-~~-------. ~______,.. .:._,., ... ;:, ~~--- -4\' ~ t--· ~ ---~~~:::.-:·~:~-·~ -_.#<~----~-~-·--:-·7~~~~-.-----~~..--,..---'""---~ .. ,. • • • • • • 4 t • • • • 4 • • ' ' • ' ' ( O!Ol!O!~'ll!l"i!-"''·'i!!~i'>·IE'iE'~~~~- ' 't .r I '/ f -- 1'7l J I :~ ' t :f"l ,, \""') - - ;,-,._ -M. ~1i!I,!L.i 1 J I ~ 1 rJ c ~~ ~ '\.,.I \.jl '-' ~ ..., ' I I l...., u~ i ' •• .., _, l< ';~ ....... --.... --,.;-. ., ~- . ! "J·~~~ ... .-".--~·--~----~·-·~:;...~~ ·· ... ,,., 0_,~..,;:~-~;;!d~:-,-,~ .•.• .,.,_,,~~~··.,, ._.-., ~t.t·,,~·,.;:.,,;,;,.: .. s.,..,.,,;,;,r~~;..J;.,"'~~,.Jiilii~-t~•• ·" . ...,;··.,• ., . ...,n,.y~_.;;··~x •.. ,;,;·.;:,r""'' ::t:cc~;,:.'""_.~·--~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ --............... ,---....... --~ C-'·"""""' BY: . .JDF CHEC:l::.ED: ,JDF AP!·' ~;u:;: l TNA :-~nn MW rnA I ESTIMAlE NO. APA 17117 M-1 liETAJLETt MATEf·HAL t< INmALLAllfiN REPOfn fiAlT! 21-.JUN-84 TIME": H:·.: 40:54 ACC:T NO DESCRIPTION UN* (PTV) (UN$ TOT><TOTAL AMT)*(TOT t1ATLl(UN $MAT)<\(IJ $ IN!7:}(T0T INST)*(TOT F.SC><MAT F:::C)!(INS E:::;C) 14.100000 INSTRUMENTATION LS* 15. 00(1(1(10 ELECTRICAL Ef~LH PHENT LS* 16.000000 PAINTING LS* 16.100000 TURBINE BUILDING LS* 16.200(100 STEAM GEN BLDG LS* 16.300000 SILO BAY LS* 16.900000 MISCELLANEOUS LS* !7.0(100(10 OFF-SITE FACILITIES LS* 17. 1 0000(1 RANNEY WELL SYSTEM LS* HI* 17.200000 ACCESS ROADS 18.000000 WATERFRONT FACILITY LS* 18o1(l(l(l(l(l BARGE UNLOADNG FAC LS~t DREDGING C:Yif-18.110000 1E:.200000 MOOR/DOCK FACILiTY LS* CY* 18.210000 EXCAVATION 18.220000 FILL CV* 18 .. 230000 H PILES LF* SHEET PILh\lG TN* 18.240000 18 ~ 25(11)(10 STRUCTURAL STF-EL TN* 18. z•: . .:.ooo CONCRETE CV* LS* 18.270000 Ml SC:ELLAI'iiOIJS. 19.000000 SIJBSTATION/T-LINE Lf:* 1 9. 1 Q(l(lc)n Sl.IBSTAT I ON L~·* 20 518850.0 32000 18.1 45000 8.3 27500 9.7 lE:OO 58.6 2100 2~18. E: :::s 24'5:3.0 1200 471.9 7067000* t;.SI)(I(I(I(I it 57.57(1(10(1* 21 (l(l(ltl(H) 155000 * 2224::::40* 65061.10* 1167000* 118200* 28:=:540* t:;:460700* ::::(188700* 1 (1:377000* 7:337789* 577920*- 577920* 7259:319* :372487* 2c.60'=·2* 105435* 52E:·~r·,::75* 2C)8•):3(a* 5t.(:.280* 4512~·0* * 5(l(l(lfl * 7500(1 * 9(1(11) * '2 t (1(10 * (:.(18(11)fl(l * 570(1(1(1 * 54/;.fl(l(l(l * 24!:'\850.(1 1 ~:E:E:7 t)c) * (I * 0 0.00* 18.1 1 ::::,::t_:7(H) * (I 0~00* 8.3 (I (1.00* 9.7 70200 39.00* 19.6 147(1(1(1(1 700.00* t:=ne.::< •;."1 ::!:.()(1 1 t 1)(1. (H)* 1 35;::. (") 1 ::,:(11)(1(1 150.00* ~~21. •:;t 7~i(ll)(l * 2: ·: 1 9:=:9":•(1 * 1 ::=aw:c ICHH) * :-=:'71455(111--=:(1(1(11 11)1.1 * -282:5t) 567000* -358350 -325000 36570000*-2878500 -1050000 -1828500 2069340* -111217 (:.(1(1600* -82530 l 092000* -5~.::350 109200* -5910 267540* -14427 -7750 -103467 -2500 -·:::oo:::c, -3750 -546fl0 -450 -5460 -1050 -1:3377 7 4:.::(1700* -6730.35 -:.::01500 -:.::715:35 2513700* -154185 -28500 -125685 491 7(1(;0* -51 E:85(1 -273000 -245:=:5(1 5949089* -391884 577920·1E--28896 577920* -:2889£:. s:;:71119* -362988 372487* -18~.24 26606211-.~ 13303 35235* -5:271 :3819:2:75* -264468 115430* --1 (1441.:. 2~E:62E:t)* -28~: 1 4 ~:71:.-25(!* -~2251::.·2 -94435 -297449 (I -28896 (I -2:?-t3'7J/.. ... -944::::5 -:2£-.855:=: (I -18624 (I -1 3:::o::: -<3510 -17C..t -7:35(1(1 ·-190968 -4675 --5771 -9(l(lfl ·-19:314 -::::750 -1€:812 10118950*-1159947 -654000 -50~947 714550* -185727 -150000 -35727 lA ~ • f • • 4 c t • • • ' ,._, ~. -~~~::~~·.~::.~<"":7~:= ·~·.:~:~M; "' "'"'~ ·---~~ ~~-=~==~.r-7-~>¥~.~-~~~:-~-=:-~.JQC. :~~.--~'._,#~~,--.~=·~~~-.-:.~=~~~.,~:~~~. ·-~~-~~---?~--~----.--· .. :~-·---=~--~-~-~~~-·~··~?''. -. ~ :• ~ . ~ , • ... /', ._ I t ~ 51 ~~ ,.,-.... ' • • <l~ ~!:).,.. tr .. ,_, ... • ~(} ' ~ 0 ___ ..§ f ·~-.........,_.1 I ] . .\ 'l ~ 1 >"<~ I " i { ,' 'v, (.) ,, "'~ ,.-,~ ~. . " j -~~,_,._.,...;.~----~----l-....... _J:____~i~~~~_.-~.;,~~.,.... .. " .• -... . ....;..-·-·-~-=--__..:.~~h.~.,.;.;;--. ~: ·-· ·.·'i$lii·l::"i'"t·~'L--"'~~~-........._ ~·-··· ............... ,.ij_A. ...Lt._~·-~~----~-"--... -~.~-, 1ll !II ~ )I .. Jl • I Ji .lid .,;I ~ ~ I • I I ·.II • .Iii II .. 1iPf\ av: JDF CHECKED: .JDF ·:;IJSlTNA ?01"1 MW r(IAI F~::T HIHTE' Nrt. I~PA 1707 1'1· 1 TIME: 16: 4(H ~i4 [lATE: ;-1-.. IUN-:::4 [If' fiH LEO MATE"F<IAL ~< IN8TALLA f[1:1N. m:porff ACCT NO DESCRIPTION UN* (lHY) <UN $ T(ll) (TOTAL AMT>*<TOT MATL > (IJN $MAT>* <TOT INST}*(TOT ESC> <MAT E:::C) <INS ESC> 19.200000 230KV T-LlNE:~ C:IR Ml* 71.000000 INDIRECT CONST COST LS* 71.100000 71.200000 71.210000 71.220000 71.300000 71.310000 71.400000 71.410000 71.420000 71.421000 71.422000 71.423000 71.423100 71.424000 71 • i;.OOOOO 71.610000 71. 620000 71.630000 i. 71. 640000 71 "70001)0 71.800000 FIEL:[t L>JCAL HIRES LS* CRAFT P/R FRINGES LS* PREM PAY-CASUAL LS* PREM PAY-SCHED LS* O::JI\ISTR EQLIIPT LS* ~. AUlOMOT~VE<CIM> LS* CONSTRt~~:::-r ..(ON PLANT LS* CONSTRIJC:TN BLDGS LS* TEMP FACILITIES LS* LABOR CAMP LS* FOOD SERVICE LS* TEMPORARY POWER LS* 69KV T-LINE Mil OTHER TEMP FACIL LS• OFFICE/LABOR EXP LSit OFFICE EXPENSE LS* LABOR EXPENSE LS* IESTlNG l8* SECURITY GUARDS L~:* OFF-SlTE UNL[IG/HLG LS* CONSTRLICTN CLEANUP u::* 48 4tl592~-(I 19484400~ 10080000 4(1949(r79* (I 4472325* (I 30000(10* (I 2(1(1(1(1(1(1* (I 1onoooo* I) 1 :::0000* (I 180000* (I 26B713844 0 1626000* (I 252453B4* (I 10000000* (I 11fl00000* (I 2205(11)2* (I 10 220500.2 2205(102* (I 2040382* (I ~·)t.9E:7(l* (I 155000* (I l:.N1(170* (I 71.:·1 E:OO* (I 462000* (I 40:.:::3800* 0 2~·6100* (l * 195'12~. (I 94(144(1(1* -'717 4220 -5(14(100 -4 7(12.20 * 40949079*-2047453 (I -2047453 * 4472325·1l -223616 (I -22::::/.:.16 * 3000000* -150000 (I -1 ~it) (I (I (I -!..--* 2000000* -1000() (I -100000 * 1000000* -50000 (I -5(1(1(1(1 * 18(1(100* -9(100 (l -9(1(1(1 * lE:OOOO* -9000 () -9000 .,:. 2/:..87i384•-1343569 0 -1343569 * 1626000* -81300 (I -81300 .. 25245384*-1262269 0 -1262269 * 10000000* -500000 0 -500000 * 110(1(1000* -550000 (I -55(1(1(1(1 * 2205002* -1102:=i(l (I -110250 (1. (10* '2205(1(1. 2 2205002* -110250 C) -110250 * 2(14(1:382* -1 (1?019 (! -1(12(119 * 2(169870* -1 (1'2:493 (l -·1 o:;:4o;r3 * 155000* -7750 0 -7750 * 691 070* -:3455:::: (l -3455::: 0 -38090 7 /:.. 1':'::00* -3809(1 * * 462000* -2:;: 1 (I(J (I -2:3100 * 4CH::s:::OO* -204440 (I -20444(1 (I -1 :;:~:~:~. 2l:·c·7(1(UI· -1:;:.3:::5 * ~, ,..... ,.,.. C"'' «" ,.. ~ ,, " n " • ... ., w w w .., ·~ ~- "" ~ ::~ ,;;;~:~1' -.:,9':,:' ~-) '-~::y··-:. .·~ '· ! ... ~:, o :-1.,, -, •.· 1~· &> ~:.;~<_,-•.: , f' ~P -~ .: ~:• ·~:· ~ •• ;-."'" '· ' 0 ,. ';~--= "I! 0 • J]' <:= Y ~ <> .... ~-·. :.J ':o~~--.·. ·: ;:.> _:;~~·> :. ,_ ' '-. • '( ';· • I '", -:;;-" i ' () J r Cl :~ r· ,.. :~' )(¢_10* ··-~ •J I '· i~J } . ._) l. w L· 1...• L.l v \,..... '-'' 1 I j ! l.Jv ........ -:.I)! :: ... -~-··---...... -- f~ ,_-.-liS BY: ,_1[1~ -~l !1¥¥ CHEC·~·Eo: • .JDF tnis liiiii -~ l--- -') J' _....____.~-~--·-· .~ ... "'--...........,"--':..'."'"'xL-~------.......c;:__,_:__::__~,_, . .::..__.- i!iiiiil iiiiia1 *.liiifili 0 iiiliil ..,...,.__~ --- ?1~'1\ S:IJ::.t J NA 21111 1'-lW I 'I_ 1!41 ESr!NAlE Nt:. (4PA 17(17 11-1 D~IAIL~D MATERIAL & INSTALLATION REPORT .-,_~ ~! ;~ .. nAn=: 2J -.JUN-:::4 ~ ~ Riiill ... T I ME: 16: 411: 54 ACCT NO DESCR i PT .1 ON UN* (tj:!TY) (IJN $ TOT>CTOTAL AMT>*<l'OT MATL><UN $MAT)*(IJ lii IN!!;:}(TOT IN~:THHTOT ESC)(MAT ESC)(!NS: ESC> 72. 0~10000 PROFESS!ONA: SERVCS LS* $ '· • 546501J(I(I* (I * 5465(10(10*-27825(1(1 (I -2732500 • -~-' ~··~-····-Au:. :w::w:: _.,...~...,......-.&2iilll!!>i a!WICil:a>t~ ... mw.nnw~f'i n~.HLC.tm, .~~~~UMiiilll. r.zilll'llll:a~.~~~-·~~..,~~;~1;;," ... "&"-~~ .... -cr~~..;;~-., --~ f , • • f ~ t; ,:, ~ .. ~ \""" I • .~, ;""'- /: ,< !(~ ;,..-,. '" (4· -l ·~¥4''!1!!Yi ~ .... .,, . ' I I ci :.·; .,JI '" j ....;, ;v - l ~ .....- _, \ -911 \ ..., -u_-----~~-...., l 'l -'. ! '- -~· r·,..-; ;-_..,---.;;-c-., ..... -•~-~;• --·- ' ---~--C:• ,.-~--~"'~ ~..::-• -_.._:,;;._;.;:.,~, ---·~h·--'~)-~· __ ......,__j\....:.._......,...........:..........,_,,.,,_,~..,---~.,..,..-~----.-. .... .........,_.._,,r:_• _,.,,__H~---~"',..,.J '-~---~·----'--:OJ\._, __ ~---•••-~------------0..---·-·••--•-•-·····•-'~';:;:_ ___ ~,, iliii -!£~ :wAil ... liiiii _F~tii Iiiii BY: WI"./-' C:HECI<i:TU ,..f(IF lilii iilli iiillif -'f5iS "UNIT 2" f~PA SUSITNA 200MW UNIT2 ESTiMATE NO. APA 1707 M-1 :;:;UMMARV MATERIAL & INSTALLATION REPt)RT liiilli liriiil1 ~ DATE: 23-CICT-84 --~-----'--<.,..,,..._,___,..._.~---~·.,....,,. ........ ._.,..,_,._,..., ... _,_> ---A ~ 'iiiiiill liiilll -P. 1 .. TIME: 18: 04:.: 1 S' AC.::-: NO [IESCRIPTI0N UN* (i.?!TV> <UN S TOT> <TOTAL AMT)*(TOT MATL> <UN sMAT>**<TOT ESC> CHAT ESC>< IN::: ESC) 99. (1(1(1000 TOTAL F'nO,JEC:T COST LS* :372993~.83* 160570971 * 100.000000 CONTINGENCY LS* 44911:.::44-11-172(14032 * 300.000000 TOTAL COST W/0 CONT LS* 32€)082339* t4:=:3t.e.9:39 * 1. 0(1(1000 IMPROVE:MNTS TO SITE LS.• 321140* 168000 * 2. 000000 EARTHWORi< & PI L 1 NG LS* 13641083* 7410000 * 3 •. 000000 ClRC ~~TER SYSTEM LS* 7404345* 3!.98942 * 4.000000 CONCRETE .. LS• 1 :3(136040* 2529175 * 5.000(100 ST~CT STL/LFT EQP LS* 18866183* 8220120 * 6 .. 000000 BUILDINGS LS* 9030239«· ~ll577':32 * 7 .. OOOOC:iO TURBINE GENERATOR LS* 18264278* 15619048 * . 8. 000000 STM GENER !( ACCESS LS* 42445644* 22857144 * ~ 9. 000000 AG!C:S LS* 39715660* 21184103 * AO. 000000 OTHER MECHAN EC:UI~ I' ,r-..~ LOW 13762i03* 9957312 * 11.000000 COAU<ASH HNDL EQUIP LS-* 553026f·* 3399907 * 12.000000 PIPING LS* 251 7551:·0* ::::926.217 * 13 .. 000000 INSULATION LS* 6'l7433P, 552:381 * 14.000000 INSTRUMENTATlON LS* ~.730093* 6190476 * 15.000000 ELECTRICAL EG!UIPHENT LS* 4~t916E:57* 17904762 " 16.0QOOOO PAINTING LS* 2100475• 127620 * 17~000000 OFF-SITE FACILITIES LS* 3484604* 542857 * 19.000000 SUB~;TATION/T-LINE LS* 17997823* 10921143 * 71 • OCIOOOO INDIRECT CCINST c:o::;T LS* 26285615~ u * 72. (1(1(1000 PHOFES::; I ONAL SERVC:S L:;* 1 ::::6(1(11)(10* (I if· 212422712* 0 27707312* 0 184715400* 0 153140* 0 e·231083il 0 3705403-Jt 0 11)506865* 0 10646063• 0 5872507* (I 2645230* (I 19588500* (I 18531557• (I 3804791* (I 2130359-R-(I 1624934:3* 0 6221950* (\ 5:39617* tl 26012095* (I 1972855* (I 2'~1 41747* 0 70766E:O* (I 262(<5615* 0 t .~:6(1(1(1(1(1~ (I (I (I (I (I (I 0 0 0 (I (I (I (I (I (I (I 0 (I (I (I (I (I (I (I 0 0 (I 0 (I 0 0 (I (I (I (I 0 I) (I (I 0 (I ~ (I rt "rt PJ t (I () (I § . CD (I ~ n w -PJ • (I W I ---~~~"-·'"·"·~-"--·-~----. """"'.__.., __ -~ ... ~"""·""!i&<l:".;a')).._~;r:_......... L(,:\i!'~\i.~~ ... --'"-ii-:-~--..--_.c.~,:.., r ~-""'~~iit':'"=-"~·-4jr··.._~~=-·~· ...... ·-·--4::.--~~r-ir--:r-,"C,--~~----~.------·~~~~~..-... .JLU:?Wia.__, _____ ...., ___ _ AI f ~ -~ ~ ~ .. II -.. l. " . ~-. .. ~ ... ·.-(' ·\(f . 0 • ' • .... " ••• ,~ • e 0 ' ,.. . • "' -,_ , 1 .. , • i ..... • .. • 9 • -• ~1\Mil-tJF~ r. [ ~f f t f f. f: ' ,'1 ........ ' ....\ .... ~ ~ "' t'\ '" . ., #., t .. I 1 .... .-. ·) '~' l ·~ ~ ,'# , w ! .. , . . ;:. ! ··! ITil I .I""'~ -·; . . • . ! ~-.~; ~ f ·-· ~ t•J ·,-,,.«,~----------~ .. ,~,..a -JJiiii 1iii illil - BY: WMP CHECKED: ,J[IF ·illi ililil -llilll iilll AF'(~ ss_o·:; I TNA ::•O:)i1W liN I 12 ESf!MATE NO. APA 17Ul M-1 (IE.TAILED MATERIAL s.~ IN'.:-TALLATlON REPOR f .... ----------~..,....._ ..... , ·-~---...... ~"~--~,...-.... -~,_.__; ----~-J.:-.... ,__.,.~ liiiiii iilll --J DATE: 23-oc:r -E:4 ---~~·-"--=~-· -·----,,._ .... ~...._---~------....... -.--.~-·-~ ~ ~ 'trW ..... 1 I'. TIME: 18:04: 19 .... ,. I~ • • ACCT NO· DESCRIPTION LIN* (~HY> (UN $ lOT) {TOTAL AMTHHTOT HAll.> <UN $MAT>* <TOT INSi)*(TOT E::;C) (J1AT ESC) (IN::; ESC:) • 99.000000 TOTAL PROJECT COST LS* :372993~·83* 1 C,.(l5705'71 * 21.2422712* 0 (I (I 100.000000 CONTINGENCY LS* 44911344* 17204032 * 27707312* 0 (I (I • 300. 0000(11) TOTAL COST W/0 CONT LS* 328082339* 14~::366$'139 1t 184715400* 0 (I (I • 1. 000000 IMPROVEMNTS TO SITE U>* ~:2114(Ut 168(100 * 153140* (I (I (I 1.3(10000 SITE DRAINAGE LS* 279580* 1501)(1(1 * 129580* (I (I (I • 1. 5000(10 SEWAGE FACILITIES LS* (I 41560* 1:::ooo * 235f.:.(l* (I (I • 2.000000 EARTHWOHk :!< PILING 4 LS* t3l:.4t oa:=:* 7410000 * 6231(183* 0 (I 0 2. 2{10000 STRCTR ~ EQUIP EXC LS* 1295429* 0 * 129542'7'* (I 0 (I • 2. 21000(1 STATION AREA LS* 0 4867:36* (I * 48~·736* (I (I • 2.212000 EARTH EXCAVATION C:Y• 1870(1 26.0 486736* 0 0. (1(1·11-26.0 4867:36* (I (I 0 2.250000 AQC:S FDNS LS* :::oa.c-.. ;~:=: * (I * 808693* (I (I 0 •• 2. 2520(10 (I EARTH EXCAVATION C:Y* 172(10 26.(1 447i:o';>4* 0 0.00* 26.0 447t.94* 0 (I e 2.253000 ROCK EXCAVATION CY* 5400 /:..6.9 3609~~9* (I (1.00* 1.:.6.9 360999* 0 0 (I 2. 30000(1 TRENCHING LS* 1518789* (I * 1518789* 0 (I (I • 2.3£0000 (I 1 •. .: :~c WATER COND LS* ::::14(:41 * 0 * .314841* (I (I • 2.312001) EARTH EXCAVATION CY* 126(1(1 25.,() 314841* (I (1.00* 25. C) :314841* (I (I (I 2.320000 YARD PIPING LS* 817776* (I * 81777~. * (I (I (I • 2,.322000 EARTH EXCAVA!ION CY* :_3(1(1(1(1 27.:3 017776* (I (1. (II)* 27.:3 E:17TU: .. * (I 0 (I • 2.. 33(U)(ll) !3Et..JERS & DRAINS LS* :;::3C;.172* (I * :3861 72* (I (I (I :2. 33200(1 EARTH EXCAVATION CY* 100(11) ::::::. (:. ::::SC.172il (I 0.00* :~::3.1:.· 38£.172* 0 (I (I • 2.500000 2.510000 (I (I PILES <H PILES> LS* LF* 140000 !3TATION Af<EA 57.0 1 c):32/:.E:/:..5* 7977 6':.'1) I} 7410(1(1(1 * 5'!.(:.(1(100 39.00* 18.0 341 ~.:::/;.5* 0 (I 2!:517690* (I 0 4 2.520(1(1(1 AC!CS AREA LF* 50000 57. (I 2849175* 195(1(100 ::.:·~. (Jt)* 1:::. (a ::=:·~~)~i 1 75* (I 0 (I ' • .. ~?~··:,~ ,.f. ,'(.:.' ) ._\) I. '\.\ t. ' l ; t (· \ t I l ·~r -;,: .. -:lliili - BY: WMF' ~;_:Hl:Ct<ED: .JDF ACCT N:t DESCRIPTION . ....o~--..""'"'"-'-->......,_-,~1.. ............ ~------ 111111 --iilil --- AF'A SIJSITNA 2C:J01'1W UNIT2 ESTIMATE NO. APA 1707 1"1-1 DETAILED MATI::RIAL ~< IN::.TALLATION REPORT iiiiii .. PM aJilll1 181 ffilWi '. . . .... DATE: :;:·:3-0C:T -E:4 TIME: 1::::04: 1·~ UN* ((ilTYl (LIN $ TOT) CTOTAL AMT>*CTOT MATL> CUN $MAT)-1HU $ INS> CTOT INST}*(TCIT ESC} (MAT E::::c> C INS ESC:> lilil i'f't .. , • • ' ' ! 3. 000000 Gl RC: WATER SYSTEt1 LS* 740434!::i* 3698942 * :3705403-lf (l (I • (I . , . t t '1 'ltJ!lt•" !Jtlil+l$;@1!!1~ I ,t :' <J ... -!, ·' \ ,.IJ ft ), • J l' ) ., ' ::' '1 !'I [ '-,J _;UI ": l' :3.200(1(1(1 3.210000 3.260000 3.270000 3.271000 :).272000 3.273000 3.280000 3. 4(1(1(100 3 .. 41(10(10 3.411000 3. qj2(;00 3.420000 3.422000 3. 4281)(1(1 :3.424000 3. 4301J(II) 3.4331)1)(1 3.435000 3.43,::.ouo 3.440000 3. 4411);(1(> ~·--·--·.--·-~~-----rw a . .ncliiLz ........... -'-~~ INn: ~ DISC PIPING L8* 1 8668(1$'1* 778552 * 1088257* (I (I (I • C:ONC:R PIPE: 6(1 11 LF * :31)(1(1 3:37.4 10!211:3* 54:3(1(1(1 181. (II) It 156.4 469113* 0 (I 0 BEDDING MATERIAL C:Y* 185(1 28.9 5:35(1:::* 17~·12 9.52* 19.4 358S''C·* (I (I (I • CONCRET STRUCTURE LS* 758$.40* 1';;9250 * 559590* (I (I 0 • T·~ST ~ TRNS BLK CY* 751) 397.4 29:3(147• :::·~25() 119.00* 278.4 2(18797* (I (I (I CONDENS BLOCt<S ~CY* 400 8:3:::.4 :::3.33tS3·tt-78000 195.00* • t.38. 4 255:3~·3* (I (I 0 PITOT TUBE PIT CY* 20(; 637.2 12743(H~ '32000 1~.(1. 00* 477.1 95430* 0 0 (I • MISCELLAN STEEL TN* 7 6049.7 423481t H3e-90 26 70. 00* 3379.7 23~.58* 0 (I '=! COOL TOWER FACIL LS* 55375!;:~.* 2920:390 ----* 2t.17146* • (I 0 (I TOWER BASIN LStl-707(103* 1 :?,7500 * 519503* (I (I (I • EXCAVATION CY* 6500 t·~. 4 12626(1* (I 0.00* 19.4 126260* 0 (I C) • C:ONC CW COOL TWR CY* 1500 3E:7. 2 58074:::::* 187500 125.00* 262.2 :E:·:;.~:24:3* 0 (I 0 PUMP CHAMBER LS* 7760S''t·* 210690 * t:•6540t·* (I (I 0 • EXCAVATION CY* 4500 19.4 87412* (I 0.00* 19.4 87412* 0 0 (I CONCRETE . CY* 150(1 4:.::o. 9 .~;.4 ~.3::::t. * ::.:02.9 (I .. 192000 128.00* 45433l·* (I (I MISC STEEL TN* 7 6049.7 4234€:* 1 ::::t;.'~(l 26 70. 00* 3::::7S'I. '7 23658* (I (I (I • • INTAKE Ef!.:JIPMENT LS* :369911-it 316400 * 53511* (I (l 0 SCREENS ::;:F* 500 51.5 257(:.5-!t 145(1(1 29.00* ...... -... I.: LLw ·-· 11265* 0 (I ., (I STOP LOGS !:;F* 500 (:.:::. 3 341 ::.:tit 2:::5(1(1 57.00* 11.:3 56::::1* (I (I (I -CRANE BRIDGE 15T EA* 1 (1.(1 31 (II) 1 ~ilt 27340(1 ----* o.o :36615* 0 (I 0 ?MP HS SPR STRIJCT LS* c.~::=?.A 4 ::* :32fiJ. (II) * ::.:/.-,_.:~::34:;:* (I (I (I .., CRANE ~! HST SIJPP TN* 7!:· 271.:.:::. ;;: 20724711-11480U 1524.00* 12:=:·~/. ::.: 92947·11-(I (I (I Ci. til. "t:• ~:_,-£:1ir;:J ki _¢££4i9\.~* • 14 ie9!4 & 1 i:NA .. ll ·:t&!lll!~f~Wti.-fl1'P"!!rf(,.Yd&:MI:w'M..Ufofa-lriir): kJ:io!MIIIlllkwililli::olliW "" e··=~.:<'-....~ . ...,_ .-.. ·--...... ~_.....___._~--.~··-'-~---""--'··-··-- ',1-, . l ~~,.w~ t ! ' ''l ,· """' ~ ~ , ·n j f'\ i (""\ .,. :~ ; "'""'I#Y»'!_ ... -,~ 1 :0. I '~,: It, j ,.., )\w; I...,! ,I 'W ' ·,..._ '-' twJ !' '!".2·· i~ .. ~' .... ,... II!T .. BY~ WNP CHECKED: ,JDF --.,-;:o·-;:, --,;,:;--;::;:·,-r---,_-.:,.-·.--;c--,--------;;:---,------:;:;~-!"fl -.-~'Z __ ,_ ::;:-~•-,·~ •"!'!""'"'!"_·--· ""!'"-----------,•-~~ ._ -i .. -IIIli ,-,, ~-~~·'1·\ SIJS I TNA 2(11 11'1W 1.11\1 l T <.: E:::;T!MATE Nl.l. At··A 1707 1'1-t DETAILEfl MATERIAL 8< INSTALLATIUN F<fi-'ORf •• Iiiii iiil1 (lATE: ~~.;:-OCT-84 ,~:;'! ~-, '('fit I :arerra T 1 ME: 1 B :fl4: 1 9 itfit ACCT NCI tiESC:RIPTION ~N* (QTY) <UN$ TQT)CTOTAL AMl>•CTOT MATL)CUN $MATl*CU $ INS)(TOT INST>•<TOT E~:>CMAT ESC>(INS ESC) 3.442000 BUILDING SPRSTR S\-~* 6000 79.4 476196* 205E:OO :34. ~:(1* 4!5. 1 270:396* (I (I (I 3.450000 TOWER SPR STf\LICT LS* 3001(18:3* 1115383* 0 (I (I .tE:85700 * 4.000000 CONCRETE LS* 13036040* 2529175 * 1 050(:.8t.5* (I (I 0 T~lRBINE BLDG CONCR CY* 4.1000(;(1 4500 766.2 3447777* (:.30. 9 608625 135.25* 2839152* 0 (I I) 4.200000 BOILER AREA CONCRT CY* 1900 676.1 128451'~* 25(;.975 135.25* 540.8 1027544* 0 (l (l 4.300000 SILO AREA CONCRETE CY'* 1700 706.2 12005::::5-tt 570.9 22'~925 135.25* '?7(1/:..10* 0 (I (I 4.40000(1 AQ.CS CONCRETE ~ CY* 8800 71)5. :3 o206308* 570.0 11902(H) 13~ln 2~3* !j.l) 161 08* (I (I 0 4.900000 MlSCELL CONCRETE CY* 18(10 4~1:3. ~: :39~··?01• 24845{1 1:35. 25* 363.0 653451* (I 0 0 5. 000000 STRCT STLJI'LFT E~~p LS* 18::::6618::::* 8220120 * 1 06460/.:.:3* (I (I 0 TURBINE B~ILDING LS* 5.100000 39:36778* 1951495 * 19:35283* (I (I 0 5. 110000 MAIN STEEL TN* 1201) 2285.5 2742552* 1429200 1l91 •. 00* 1094.5 1313:352* 0 0 0 5.120000 FRAMING LS* 349072* 180075 * 16:3997* (I (I 0 5. l21l-,OO WALL FRAMING TN* 1'05 3324.5 349072* 180075 1715.00* 1609.5 16(3997* (I i) n 5o130i)(ll) MISC: STEEL Lf.-~ 523096* 123170 • 3'~1 ·:i'·~2b* (I (I (I 5.131000 ORATING 1-3/4 11 SF* 12000 26.0 ::::t21t·8* E'~)4(1(1 6.70* 19.:3 2:31768* (I ·o I) 5.13.200(1 CHECKERED PLATE SF-1t e. (I (I 5:3.1:.· 3217?* 6300 10.50* 43.1 2587';.t* 0 0 (l 5.133000 1000 515.2 95225* (I HANDRAIL LF1t 14750 14.75* 80.5 80475* 0 (I 5.134000 12 69/:.·0.:::: 82524* (I LADDERS ~ STRWYS TN* 21720 1810.00* 515(1. 3 c.t:304il (I (I 5.140000 ::::22058* (I LIFT\ING"iEOIJIP LS* 21':">'050 * 103008* (I 0 5.141000 :.::22058-11 (I CRANF: 40 T CAP LS* :?19050 * 1 o:=:ooa-11 0 (I 5. 2(11)(11)(1 11270284-11 (I STEAM GENERATOR LS* 4:::£:4)275 * t.8~1(l(h)9* (I (I 5.210000 2300 22:::5.5 5256~558* 0 MAIN STEEL TN* 278930(1 1191.00* 1094 .. 5 2517~25:3* I) (; 5.220(11)1) FI7<AMING LS* 17'':,1'';1:::2:::* 634550 ----* lt (:.527::::• (I 0 (I f tf • ~ f f •• 4 • 4 • • c ~ ' t ' ' • ' U:· "' . '-·=' .. l >IIIOIIIa .. IBEM._Ri~~~~ .. ~ .. MI .. IIIIIIIIDi._,-•. ,.,lleiiiii .. ~IRBII91m~ .. IB~IBIE .. IB .... IB .... aiiR .... aawana .. &lla~ •. i· ----"'· /, { , . &&ZCIJ..,_llJIIII!;\:;a:JIMil&&i-lliiiLI 11 ·-·-~-"""'·--~--... _.w1L~_o;c:aagz - ' ~ 7~ ~~ ! ~~ I ! All j - I i ~ 1-. ·:,.. ,.r~ ..... ,!/ -: '-.:!'~ .. • • I 1 • -· • • ,; '• • -~ :. I) ... ~- LJ~-~ t . ...., ·,.-~ .. ' ,. ' ~ . . . /. "' l . • -! . ~ . . • c ~ -• • .j '· . ', ~ . . ) · .. ~ ,;,. ... '"" ~ ~-.. ... .. BY: WMP C:HEC.<ED: JDF ~ ~ .. -.. API~ SU::: I TNA 2001'1W liN I T2 ESTlMAlE NO. APA 1707 M-1 [lET AILED MATERIAL & INSTALLATION Rf:POR'f' C] iilill we iiFif ., 'iii'14 itd •• . ~·. 't ;~~ ~ • • DATE: 23-0C:l-84 TIME; 1 :3: 04 : 1 9 • • ACC:T NO DESCRIPTION LIN* ((;'!TV> <LIN $ l'OT> <TOTAL AMT>~HTOT MATL> <UN $MAT)*(U $ INS) <TCil INST)-~t <TOT ESC:> <MAT r:.~:C) <INS E~:C:) t 5. 2210(10 5.222000 5.230000 5.231000 5.232000 5. ''-.'33000 5.234000 5.2400(10 5.242000 5.243000 5.243100 5.300000 5.310000 5.320000 5.321000 5.330000 5. 3400(1(1 5.343000 5. ~:50(100 0. ~:51 (1(10 5.360000 5.361000 5.362000 WALL rRAHING TN* ELEV FRAMING TN* MISC STEEL LS* GRATING (1-3/4") SF* CHECKERED PLATE SF• HANDRAIL LF* LADDERS & STRWY .. TN* LIFTING EQUIP LS* ELEV EQUIPMENT LS* OTHER LIFT EQUIP LS* (3) 15 TON HST LS* SILO BAY MAlN STEEL FRAMING WALL FRAMING HISC STEEL LS* TN* LS* TN* ' LS* LIFTING EQUIPMENT LS* OTHER LIFT EOUIP LS* SUPPORT STEEL LS* El!lU I P SUPPORTS TN* STL SILO ~~ CVR PL LS* STEEL SILOS TN* ~:s PLATES TN* 8~:0 :t)9:)4. 0 40 4290.2 7(1(1(10 26.n 1t.oo ~53. 6 12500 98.4 120 69/:.1). 4 225 2285.5 ~·5 4934.0 100 7(1~:1.1:.· 170 e.5:;~a. 2 40 E:744. 0 ·~! 1t.28220* 565950 1715.00* 171608* 6E:600 17 15. 00* 397252(:.11-887375 ----* 1820980* 469000 6.70* 85:::!4* 16800 10.50* 1230484* 184:.375 14.75• :?.35248* 217200 1810.00* 241372* 119050 * 144190* 47620 * '77182-* 714:=:(1 * 97182* 71430 * 33'~8526* 1772610 * 51422E~* 2b7975 1191.00* 320710* 111475 * 820710* 1114 75 1 715. 00* :;:25C· ~~:::* 190500 ----* 7517(:·* 57150 * 75171; •• 57150 * 7031t·O* 252500 * 7(12: 1 (:.(1* 252500 2~25.00* 1459554lt-E:9:::ot o * 1109794* 672010 3953.00* :)497 60* 221000 5525.00* ::::219. (I 1062270* 0 (I (I 2575.2 103008* (I 0 (I t ;;:(18515 1 * 0 (I (I t 19.3 1 :;:!:i 1 S"J:3()* 0 0 (I 43.1 t.9(114* (I 0 (I c 83.7 1046109* 0 0 I) c !5150. 4 618048* (I 0 (I 1:;~2322* (I 0 (I c 96570* (I 0 0 c 25752* (I (I 0 25752* 0 0 0 • 1625916* 0 0 (I • 1094.5 246253* 0 0 (I 209235* (I (I 0 4 3219.0 209235* 0 0 0 • 135198* (l 0 (I 18026* 0 (I (I c 18026* 0 0 0 t 45(1660* (I 0 0 450(: .• 6 450660* (I (I 0 t !'566544* 0 0 (I 4 ~·~·75. 2 4~:77E:4·M-0 (I (I 2:219. (I 12E:760* 0 0 (I f • A ,c"" w , '"' .., i -.-;~ .. • ~ 0 ; ' , 1 t , :,-t , ~ ... ,l ... .. ;~ "' l) ---.. ' . " . • "' t: c ~ I . • • • • . • ... ·r> ... ( """Mtnlli!!lirwlx"""~~-~~·~!l!'fl'l ~. ' "· t , t.~ ~ ~ ,._ :-. _. ._ -~· .. .. ·.~ IIIII iiill\ iiil1 jj6ijf iliilii1 iliill1 !tr?riil 4 A j , ~ ••• • '.:• II i ··! I~~ I l ~~ '\ ! l~ i • ~~ :~ ""' ·~ ..,... •i<!•U~iJ!rrl!'Wl ... ''''"""'"''"'"'~·· .... 1:' ..... - ~- :IW ·w ... ., ;~ \fll •, LJ . !- ' . ..... ~ ·.-.f . . 't I BY: WMP CHECl(ED: .JDF APA SUS I fNA Zc'IOI'IW IJN I T2 ESTIMAlE NO. APA 1707 M-1 DET~ILED MATERIAL L INSTALLATION R~PORT DATE: 23-0CT-84 TIME: 18:04: 19 AC:CT NO DESCRIPTION UN* (QTY> <UN$ TOT><TOTAL AMT)*(TOT MATL><UN $MAT>*<TOT INST>*(TOT ESC><MAT ESC><INS ESC) 5.9000(10 UNCLASS STEEL TN* 45 5791.0 260595* 6~000000 BUILDINGS LS-t~ 90:30239* 6.100000 TURBINE BUILDING LS* 2(1i;.769/.:.* 6. 110000 ARCHITECT FEATURE LS* 9:32009* 6. 1.70000 HVAC LS* 845725* 6.180000 PLLIHB 8c DRAINAGE LS* 224498-M 6.190000 t1 I SCELLANEOLIS ~ LS* 654(:.411- 6.200000 STEAM GEN BUILDING LS~ 249934:3* 6.210000 ARGHTITECT FEATRS LS·~t-12.1 ~n::3:::* 6 .. 270000 HVAC LS* 1122484* 6.28~-:"1)(1 PLUMB !c DRAINAGE LS* 69699* 6 .. 290000 MISCfL.LAN£0US LS* 93:.::22* 6.300000 SILO BAY LS* 763977* 6.310000 ARCHITECT FEATRS LS* 252452*· 6.:370000 HVAC LS* 349302* 6.380000 PLUMB !c DRAINAGE LS* 147809* f:... 39(1(1(1(1 MISCELl-ANEOUS LS* 14414·1* 6.4(10(10(1 AflCS BLilUHNGS LS* 2182t.04* 6.410000 A•:dCS SWGR BLIJG SF* t': ') 133.:3 114622* 6.42(1(1(1(1 AG~CS CTRL BLDG :=:F* 228Gt 1 (:.8. 1 :3:33::::4.3* 6. 4:3(1(1(1(1 £:.1 I ESEL GEN 1:\·' I)(; :::F* 541) 14:Z:. 8 77/:..70* 6.440000 PUI'iP HOUS:E SF* 88(:.1) 144.::3 1L82504* '=·. 450000 LJMESTN PREP BLDG SF* 4120 7:3. :~: :324465* 11~·7Lf0 2572.00* 3219.0 3157732 E:28577 :~:35715 42E:572 95240 19050 9047(:.2 :';:61905 4761'~0 28572 38095 268095 76190 114286 71429 (;.190 5:35t):3(~ 2:::724 1 o2o::::o 1 CH):;:(:, ·;:c):~::::·~:3 :~:241.11) * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ---- * * 33.40* 44.75* :::3. 4(1* :34. :;:(l* 2(1. (II)* 99.9 12~:. 4 110.4 110.5 C':t;a •:t .......... -.:.o• 144855* 5872507* 1239119* 6'16294* 417153* 12925E:il 46414* 15';14581* 85193::~* 646294* 41127* 50227* 4'~5:382* 176262* 235016* 76380* 8224* 1647516* 85898* 2:=: 1 :;:'13if 59634* 978/.:..06* 242065* (I (I (I (I 0 (I 0 (I (I (I (I (I -(I (I 0 (I (I (I 0 0 (I 0 (I (I (I 0 (I 0 (I 0 (I (I 0 () (I 0 (I 0 0 (I (I 0 (I (I (I ';7 (I 0 (I (I (I (I (I (I (I (I (I 0 (I I) (I (I (I (I 0 (I 1) (I (I (I •• "' •• :rrrz, ·ma •· •ww ... rMM Milt!' wr--: • t • t • • • • t t t 4 t • ~ t • t t 4 • r"· •· __ ..:.._-o-,_. ~ .. ~ ~ , "-, ,... ... '\..' I .. ~ 0 ,· ._ • . • ., .... " ... ·a ' ... .. • ~ ::: ----~----· ---·~--~-----'---~--_________:____,_____·~-/ ( • r.!{i.:>tt:!lrt~ ~ ~ i I L f I t i ; \,) l :.! J '.-:\ /f /rl ! '-l {) ! t i~ i • ;~ \ . \ ·..-, ,... ,... ! (' (• ,.--••...C r~ ,., .._,' ; , ... '"" ,., ·, '"" v -..,.. :~ 1 ......, l ' v ! . l -.._; t ..,..---~ - BY: WMP CHEC.<ED: ..JDF d .:; 1" ~ .._ -~ ..,. .,.... . ._ APA SUSITNA 200MW UNIT2 ESTIMATE NO. APA 1707 M-1 DETAILED . MATERIAL ~ INSTALLATION HEPORT ._ ._ ... ..... ..... .--'] -I • 1_, DATE: Z:::H:tCT -E:4 TIME: 1 E.:: 04 : 1 '7 ACCT NO DESCRIPTION UN* <CHY> (IJN $ TOT> <TOTAL AMT>*<TOT MATL> <UN $MAT)*(ll $ IN!3) (TOT INST)·M-<TOT ESC> <MAT ESC)< INS ESC> ~.2121 (I * 895409·11-0 (I LS* 1516619* 6. 900(100 MISC BUILDINGS (I 621210 * e:95409* (I 0 .6.990000 ALL OTHER LS* 1516619* (I 6.997000 WAREHOUSE NO. 1 SF* 23000 61.(1 14031)55* 592250 25.75* 35.3 810805* (I (I (I ~:::9t.o * 84604* 0 (I 113564::t c·. 999000 OTHER BUILDINGS LS* (I 6.999100 S~nH YD CTRL BL SF* 80(1 142.0 113564* 2896(1 3c •• 20* 105.8 84604* 0 (I (I 7.000000 TURBINE GENERATOR LS* 18264278* 15619048 * 2(:.45230* (I 0 0 18264278* 15619048 * 2~:.45230* 0 (I 7. _100000 TURBINE GENERATOR .. LS* (I 8. 0000(10 STM GENER & ACCESS LS* 42445644* 22857144 19588500* (I (I * (I 42445644* 22857144 * 19588500* 0 0 B. 1~·,,:,000 STEAM OEt11tRATOR LS* o· 9 & OOO(l(H) AQC:S LS* 39715660* 21184103 18531557* 0 0 * (I 9. 1 000(10 DAOHOUSE LS* 7692908* :3809524 3:=:83384* (I (I * • (I 9~200000 FLUE GAS DESULFUR LS* 29:371-.}227* 15740953 14135274* 0 0 * (I 14135274* (I (I 2987/:..227* 15740953 * 9. 2100(1(1 COMPONENTS LS* (I 9 .• 211000 DUCTWORt( FOR FGD LS* 3287023* 14S5238 1831785* 0 (I * (I 9.213000 S02 ABSORB MODULE LS* 26589204~ 14285715 123fl3J; .;:cr i* 0 (l * 0 512899* (I (I 1 t.:3~:~.2c. * 9.400000 FANS LS* 2146525* (i 9. 41 0000 I • D. F L ' ~ LS* 1 :337901 ·M-1014·286 323615* (I (I * (I 9.420000 SILENC".t:R::; LS* 808624* 619:340 189284* (I (I * (I 3804791* (I (I ·:.r·~S73!2 * 1 0. (100000 OTHER MECH:"N EG~IJ I P LS* 137 621 o:~:* (I 10.100000 PUMPS LS·II, 3:337605* 2:::4 4 7 (:.8 4S"'2E:37* (I (I * (I 10.110000 BOILER PUMPS LS* 2906706* :2r5222:37 * 3:::441'Y* (I (I (I 154011:.·* (I (I 10.111000 BOILER FEED F'UKF'S EA* 2 3:3:3•7t..c). (1 7~.792(1* 61.?.904 ----* 77(11):3. (I (I 10.112000 BF PUMP TURBINES EA* 2 e:255' 13.5 1651 t.:27 it· 1527 e·:7'0 ---· * 621 (1:3. 5 124207* (I (I (I :71 !*~ f?9.1'f• 'i~)ii J '""· '" 0! l ~ ~ I I 1.·· f' c.d t . :., -~ ... l ·; ~ i -n . ' • .,.. I --..;.;.J .......• I I• I . :. 1" ····• ' -~.,· ~: ..;;·,! '"" 1 !. d\1 ,• ! •• • .l_, l •1 l ~i~ "-l I ,....., . - "' . "' . . - • \ -' ' • • 'it , • _:'. ___ ~· . . , -- .. • • • _'f_ __ . ·----• ,.,. -~-·-' -J":io' ,... b BY: WMP CHECI<ED: ,J[IF ---,.. - AI''A SIJ8ITNA ~onMW liN1T2 E8TIMA1f NO. AF'A 1707 M-1 DETAILE.D NATERIAL ~ INSTALLATION REPORT - I·'. DATE: 23-0CT-84 TIME: 18:CI4: 19 ACCT NO DESCRIPTION UN* (QTY> <UN$ lOT><TOTAL AHT)•CTOT MATL)CUN $MATl*CU $ INS>CTOT INST>*CTOT ESC>CMAT ESC>CINS ESC) 10.113000 233799* 177906 88953.00* 27946.5 (I 5585'3* (I (I BF BOOSTER PUMPS EA* 2 1168'~1 9. 5 10.114000 253160* 202857 * BF STRT UP/STD BY LS* 50303* (I (I (I 10.1200(10 935:3* 7429 * FEEDWTR SYS PUMPS LS* 19:24* 0 (I (I 10.121000 9853* 7429 * ~ONDEN TRANSFER LS* 1924* (I 0 (I 10.130000 65723* 0 39146 * Sr<V ~« COOL WTR PMP LS* 26577* 0 (I 10.131000 26535* (I 14€:6(1 3715. 00* 2918.8 SERVICE WATER EA* 4 6t.:3:3. ::: 11675* I) (I 10.132000 10.133000 18461* 20727* 0 I) 10762 ----* t::::524 6762.00* :3601.5 AIR HTR WASH PHP~ LS* ~ C:LSD C:'v'C COOL WSP EA* ~ 103t.:3.5 7699* 0 (I 720.:1* 0 (I 10.140000 56E:07* 0 43~:35 * OIL PIJMPS LSi! 13472* (I (I 10.141000 13945* (I 10096 5048.00* 1924.5 LOT OIL UNLD PMPS EA* 2 6972.5 3849* 0 0 10.142000 29490* 0 23715 7905.00* 1925.0 IGNITER OIL PUMPS EA* 3 98~:(1. (I 5775* 0 0 10.143000 6686* 0 4762 * TURB LO TRANS PMP LS* 1924* (I (I 10.145000 61;.:'3(: •• 0 4762 ~ .. LO COND PUMP LS* 1924* (I 0 10.150000 ! iB~:07* 0 110:356 i8476.C::J• 1241.8 SLIMP PUMPS EA* 6 19717.8 7451* 0 (I 10.160000 180709* (I 121715 * OTHER PUMPS l.S* 58$'94* 0 (I 10.16100(1 :34205* 0 17810 * COOLING TOWER HU LS• 16395* (I (I 1 o. 1 t.zooo 47102* (I 2''51714 14857. 00* 8694.0 OP CYC: CLO WTR EA* 2 23551.0 17888* (I (I 10.163000 69945* (I 5(1571 16857"00* ~:-458.0 FIRE PROTECT PMPS EA* 3 23815. C) 19374* (I (I 10.164000 29457* (I 2362(1 11810.00* 2918.5 AIR PREHTR GLV EA* 2 14728.5 5837* (I (I 10.200000 CONDENSING PLANT 2383~·M:·* 0 169600(1 * LS* 687666* (I (I CONDENSER & AUXIL LS* 10.210000 15295'43* (I 9523:::1 * 577562* (I (I 10.220000 85372:3* I) 74:3619 * EQUIPMENT LS* 110104* (I (I 10.221000 2::::4600. 0 251810 ----* 16395.(1 C:W PUMPS EA* 2 142:300. (I 82790* (I (I <.,.;' J --~--·-··"' ·---· • • • • • • • • • 4 • • • t • • • • t 4 4 t. .· ~ ' \ ~·, -. ;· c.;.. ~· I ... .. ~ ' .. , ,, .... , ~ 7 ~ ~ • . ~ .._ .... • •l3J J.. ., .• tl t ~ .. -I. J . ·., t ,. . ~ • • .. • '= • ,.! ~ --,.. 'rl -· .. ' ' l' ~ ,. ,. I ' ~~ --· - ~ BY: WMP CHECKED~ .JDF ACCT NO DESCRIPTION 10.222000 CONDENSATE PUMPS 10.223000 VACUUM PUMPS 10.226000 COND CLEAN SVS 10.227000 COND C:OLL PUMP 10.300000 HEAT EXCHANGERS LIN* (QTY> EA* EA* LS* LS* LS• -· ... -.. ... - AF'I~ SUSITNA 200MW UNIT2 ESTIMATE NO. APA 1707 M-1 DETAILED MATERIAL & INSTALLATION REPORT ~} --~ ~ DATE: 2:=:-0C:T-84 ~ ~ -,, > n S>i ~ "' r··. :-1 ..-... ,... TIME: 18: 04·:t9 ~ • (UN $ TOT) <TOTAL AMT>*(TOT MATL> <UN $MAT>*(ll $ INS> (TOT INST)*<TOT ESC> (MAT ESC) (INS ESC> • e:sa77. o 171754* 140952 70476.00* 15401.0 30802* 8086:=:. 5 161727* 148190 74095.00* {:.7{:.8. 5 13537* 23295l:·* 201905 * 31051* 26E:&* 71:.·2 * 1924* 19044l:·7* 1725241 * 179226* (I 0 (I (I (I 0 (I 0 (I 0 0 (I 0 r, ...... 0 (I • • • .L. FEEDWATER HEATERS EA* 7 172702.3 -"'"4~ !0.310000 1208916* 1110669 ----* 14035~3 98247* 0 0 42229* I) (I (I • I ..... -... i 'l : v •' .: i ~ \~' ':' tl , "' rJ , ,.; 10.320000 10.330000 10.340000 DEAER/ VENT CONDEN .. LS* CLSD CYC COOL WliE EA* AIR PRHTIR GLY HE EA* 10.400000 TANKS LS* 10.410000 WATl::R TA!Nt(S LS* 10.412000 CONDEN STRO TANK LS* 10.414000 FIRE~SRV WTR STRG LS* 10.450000 OTHER 0 IlL TANKS LS* 10.453000 CONT BLJWDWN FL TK LS* 10. 454(1(10 11\iT BLWDWN FLH TK LS4 10.455000 COND C:OLL TANK LS* 10.456000 CLSD CYC: CL WHT LS* t0.457(1(1(l AIR PREHT CL EX LS* 1 (1. 50(1(100 MISCELLANEOUS EQU~P LS* 10.510000 CONPRES~:ED A I R HlP LS* 10.512000 ~;TAT AIR COMPRESS EA* to. 5t~:c,oo AIR DRYERS LS* 230705* 1E:847/:.. * 2 163620.5 327241* 296190 ----* 15525.5 31051* (I (I 0 • 137605* 2 6:3802.5 ~ 29906 64 'y53. 00* 3849~5 7699* (I 0 0 • 503094* 184'572 * 818522* (I (I (I 437072* 13€:667 * 298405* (I (I (I • 195532* 51143 144389* () (I * 0 • 241540* 87524 * 154016* (I (I 0 66022* 45905 * 20117* (I (I (I • 6:342* 3238 3104* 0 0 * (I • 22~·32* 1t.857 !!-5775-11-0 0 0 9353-A: 7429 * 1924* (I (I 0 • 9580* (:.476 * 3104* 0 0 0 • 18115* 11905 * 6210* (I (I (I 28{:.7 4~:(1* 22686:.::6 * 59:::794* (I (I 0. • 263588tt-182731 t=:•::8::5 7 * 0 0 * 0 fJ 221644* 2 110€:22. 0 144636 72318.00* 3El504. 0 77008* (I I) (I 41944* :;::::c)95 * 3849* 0 (I (I • • - ~ -· -... _ ~--..,-_..., .. ,...._ ~ ... ~_...------·-~-..... --~ ~ '"-·-·---.......... '"'""'"-·~·---....-.;;············-·-~··-->·-.. -~ ' -~-----. ~·~----· --~------·~--~<;--;:"'--,~----···---------~ ~ .i~..... ... ~ ...... \ ·'";":; {. ! l·· l !-. l t t 1 ! 1., ! ! l .. ;~ "' il\ 1 :~ ,., J: --~~~ lio.._ ! .. I i~ ·" I i• " i•a~ i .., "' .., fli • !Ill t j f ... ,,.., 'i \-.; ' L ~=:::::::::::::=====-~--~~L~.!L~--~~===~~~--~-----,_,;;,___:~--/:~:_ ________ .~-----~.;.~-~-) ... ~"-"~..::.::.,_.,~fL.~-.,;..-~-~-----""·""'-'"'~-~-~--_._,_~,..._.__. ~--------·----·--···--~~----~-~;~--;~.c . .;.....,..__~-~" "''~_, ___ ,._._,._ __ ~~-~-., ... _ -- ,.... '- BY: WMP r• CHECt(E[I: ,J[IF -·--~ AF'A ::;us I TNA 200MI..J IJN 1 T2 ESTIMATE NO. APA 1707 M-1 DETAILED MATE~UAL t-c INSTALLATION REPOJH ·-~ --......._ ~ ~----4 ~ I·'. ·~:' DATE: 2:?.-(ICT -E:4 T I M~: 18: 04: 1 9 ACCT NO DESCRIPTION LIN* (QTY> (LIN $ TOT) <TOTAL AMT>*<TOT MATL> <UN $MAT>• (INS ESC) 10.520000 WTR TREAT EOUIP LS* 2603842-11 2C•85':>C•5 * 517937* 0 (I (I 10.5210(10 MKUP ~TR TRTMT LS* 1075119* 844095 * 231024* (I (I 0 10.522000 COND POL DEt-11 NER LS* 1045500* 814476 * 231024* (I 0 0 10.524000 BOILER CHEM FEED LS* (:.7703* 55905 * 11798* 0 (I 0 10.525(1(10 SAMPLING SYSTEM LS* 186912-tt· 1.69524 * 17388* (I (I (I 10a52601)Q BLII< GAS STRt-cDISTR LS* 2286(18-tt 201905 * 26703* (I 0 0 ,. LS* 2765841* 10.900000 TURBINE BYPASS 12:38095 * 1527746* (I 0 (! .. 55302~·6* 11 • 000000 COAU<tr:\SH HNDL EQUIP LSi!-3399907 * 2130359* 0 0 (I LS* ; .::-;~: ~ c, * 11.100000 COAL HANDLING 81:::,81 (I * 175239* 0 0 (I 11.160000 CRUSH ~ TRANSF SVS LS* 483574* ._146191 * 1:3738:::* 0 0 (I 11' .. 165000 CONVEYOR NO 9A LS*-483574* .34~·191 * 137383* 0 0 (I 11.170000 MlSC SYSTEMS LS* 505475* 467619 * 37856* 0 0 C) 11.172000 FIRE PROTECTION LS* 505475~ 467t.19 * 37856* 0 (I 0 11.200000 BTM ASH HNDL SYSTEM LS* 2901321* 15:3E:478 * 1862843* (I 0 (I 11.210000 FLIRN BTM ASH SYS LS* 1104052* 640000 * 464052* 0 0 0 11.220000 PYRITE HNDL SYSTEM LS* 11 (11):30* 60572 * 49458* (I (I (I 11.230000 ECONOMIZER ASH SYS LS* 303462* 1752:38 * !28224* (I 0 (I 11.240000 DEWTW BIN~SET TKS LS* 10:366H:·• 46:?.810 * 622806* 0 0 (I 11.250000 MAJOR PUMPS EA* 3 61t.73. (I 185019• 124572 41524.00* 20149., (I 60447* 0 (I (I 11,260000 BTM ASH INSTRUM LS* 112142* 74286 * 87E:5t·* (I 0 (I ii.400000 FLY ASH lNST & C:TL LS* 11_,:3'989 b. It 1047(:.19 * 592277* (l (I 0 25175560* 12.000000 PIPING LS* 8';126217 * 16249:343* (I (I (I TN* 873 tE:t.·;",~t. 3 1 t:.2:19213* 7641869 8753.00* 12.100000 LARGE BOPE PIPING ~~·~40. :3 :::(:.77844* (I 0 (I ------"·~-·----~--"-----"'-'·-·----.-.,., ... ~ ---~ .......... ----··-,_.....-.,-.~·-·""""-~~--, ~ ,. -•• • • ' • • • • • • • • • • • • G c • c • .;·' -:~ .,. ~ .... "' . !1 "' "' ., l ~. ""~ I. I ., ,J ~ ".I '":!· -; .. l ... 1 •' .., _, ., tJI 1111. . ' I ' .., . l l ~.I . '~: i wl I i.....:::--i __, ~ .,. "BY: WMP CHECKED: ,.JDF ACCT NO .:•ESCR I PT I ON UN* <tHY) 12.200000 SMALL BORE PIPJNG LF* 85372 13.000000 INSULATION LS* 13.100000 INSULATION LS* 14.000000 INSTRUMENTATION LS* 14. 100000 I NSTRUMENTAT .iON LS* 15.000000 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT LS* 16.000000 PAINTING ~ LS·I- :lb.100000 TURBINE BUILDING LS* 16.200000 STEAM GEN BLDG LS* 16.300000 SILO BAY LS* :17.000000 OFF-SITE FACILITIES LS* 17.100000 RANNEY WELL SYSTEM LS* 19.000000 SIJBSTATION/'f-LINE LS* 19.100000 SUBSTATION LS* 19.200000 230KV T-LINE~ 1J ~~IR t11* 71.000000 INDIRECT CONS'f COST LS* 71.100000 71.200000 71.210000 71.220000 71 • 3000(10 71.310000 71.400000 FIELD LOCAL HIRES LS* CRAFT P/R FRINGES LS.* F'REM PAY-CASUAL LS* \-'~EM PAY-SC:HED LS* CONSTR 'EQUIPT LS* AUTOMOTlVE(C/KA LS* CONSTRUCTION PLANT LS* :'/ -- AF'A SIJ::<:J, · NA 20(IMW UN I T2 ESTIMATE NO. APA 1707 M-1 DETAILED 11ATERIAL ~< INSTALLATION REI'ORT -· --......... DATE: 23-0CT-84 ·~ H .. ~ -- 1'. lll ·- ,. TIME: 18:04:19 ,. - (LIN $ TOT) <TOTAL At1T)*(TOT MATL> tUN $MAT>* <MAT E~a::> <INS ESC> • to::::. 7 1 o.o 8856347* 1284848 15.05* f:)8. 7 "1'5714'~'~'* 67743:31* 5523:31 * 6221950* 6774331* 552381 * l;.22195(HI- t.73009~=* 6190476 * 5~:9t.17* 6730093* 6190476 * 539617* 43916857* 17904762 * 2~·012095* 2100475* 127620 * 1972855* 705237* 476l9 * 657t.1:3* 12/:..7099* 71429 * 1195/:..70* 128139* :3572 * 119567* 3484t.04* 542857 * 2941747'* 3484604* 542857 * __ ..__ 294!747* 17997823* 10921143 * 707/:../:..f:O* 3356863* 2857143 * 49972(1* 14640960* :301.:-4 (1(1(1 * (1.0 6576'S"I(:,(I* 2t·2:::5~·15* (I * 2t.285615* 1237500* (I * 1237500* 2220000* (I * 222(1(l(I(Ht· 1480000* 0 *. 1480000* 740000* (I * 740000* 1 :::5(100* (I * 1 ::::5000* 1:;::5000* (t * 135(1(11)* 17:3702::::~.;.* (I * 17870289* (I (I (I (I 0 0 (I 0 (I (I 0 0 (I 0 (l 0 .... '·' (I (I (I (I (I 0 (I 0 (I (I 0 (I 0 0 (I (I 0 0 (I 0 (I (I (I (I c (I (I (I (I (I (I (I (I 0 (I (I (I 0 (I 0 (I (I (I 0 (I 0 (I (I 0 (I (I 0 . ---"·-->-,..m~• .,.m-_...,.M•·----, __________ _,__,.,..,_""" __ ~.----·~~._...., • • • • t • • • • • • • • « • ' • ',d '-• ' I (b. l ~ -I .,: ! l I L l . ~ ~ ., 1:' ;! rl r:l , rJ -, " ~ ~ .. A '..... A "" • • , . w ' f l .. ~ ~ ~ ~ . ·J~ I . ~ (. , .•• • " • y~,.--f ' ,. • .. -I ~ ·~~....,..,~~_,;._;L .... ~~ )~ -~~ ~ .. ,,;;,;.~,_,..,.,~---·~-.... h<,.....J~,.--_~~--~~~~·i>~"-~~-~:=~~:~;~~.~;;.,,~".:i~~~~">~·~~:-~~~~~~;£~~~-,:'. "'.-t't ~ BY: WHP CHECKED: ,JDF ACCT NO DESCRIPTION LIN* < Q'1'c' > 71.410000 CONSTRUC:TN BLDGS LS* ---- 71.420000 TEMP FACILlTIES LS* ---- 71.421000 LABOR CAMP LS* ---- 71.422000 FOOD SERVICC LS* ----- 11.424000 OTHER TEMP FACIL LS* ---- 71.600000 OFFICE/LABOR EXP LS* ---- 71.61(1000 OFFICE EXPENSE ,.LS* ---- 4 . 71.620000 LABOR EXPENSE LS* ---- 71.630000 . TESTING LS* ---- 71.640000 SECURITY GUARDS LS* ---- 71.700000 OFF-SITE UNLDG/HLG LS* ---- 71a800000 CONSTRUCTN CLEANUP LS* ---- 72,.000000 PROFESSIONAL SERVqS LS* $ -·--;;--·- AF'i~ SUSITNA 200M~ UNIT2 ESTIMA1'E NO. APA 1707 M-1 DETAILED -- - ~ --- I·'. 1 1 DATE: z:.::-OCT-84 TIME: 18 :1)4: 19 MATERIAL ~t iNSTA~:..LATION REPORT WN $ TOTl <TOTAL AMT HHT{(f 11A TL I (LIN $111\Tl * W $ INS I <TOT I NSTl *<TOT ESC) C MAT ESC I C INS ESC) 1220000* (I 0 () ----12200(11)* (I ----* ---- --·--16650289* (I ----* ----16650289* 0 . (I (I ----7200000* 0 ----* , ____ 7200(•.)0* 0 (I t) . ----792(l(I(I(Ht-(I ----* ----7920(10(H4-(I (I (I ----15~0289* 0 __ i_.,.._ * ----15~0289* 0 (J (I ----1556201* 0 ----* ----1556201* (J 0 0 ----121)(100* (I ---·-* ----120000* (I (J 0 ! ----518301* (I ----* ----518301* 0 (I 0 . . ----571400* 0 ----* ----571400* 0 0 0 ---.... -346500* (I ----* ----:34(:.500* 0 0 0 i ----3066~·00* (I ----* ----3066600* (I 0 (I i . 200025·ll-0 * 200025* 0 0 0 ------------ ----13600000* 0 ----it ---.. ~ 13(:.(1(1(1(10* (I (I 0 '"~--~ '-, -~::--~~J:: ·;c~~~·';------·-'~:;;:-::;z:'-------~-:;.·~-·--------·-···~-~~ ~ " • • e • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • r ' r·~ I '';1!'~la ' ( .'· , .. ,.-~--: j ! '1 I J 1 I I I'" I 1. I, .l l L II ! ., I c 11· ./ ' j I '\! w • ) I ~1 II t ,J I I i j ]I J ll I ~SIS OF ESTIMAT~ GENERA~ " "UNIT 1" f ALASKA FOWER AUTHORITY Susitna Ne~d for P~wer Study 200 MW Coal-fired Plant Beluga Site Estimate No. APA 1707 M-1 Attactllllent 3a. 4 This conceptual estimate is prepared in t11e Ebasco Code of Accounts. The estimate is for a one unit facility and excludes Owner's cost (including Land and AFUDC}. This overnight estimate has a base pricing level of January, 1984, for each line item de-escalated to a January, 1983 pri c·i ng 1 eve 1 on a sunvna r~, basis. The estimate is based on a downsized ver'~ion of Ebasco•s Coal Fired Reference Plant Program (CFRP), which 1s a combination of recommended pre-engineered plant general arrangements (GA's) in building block segments, to define the plant layout. It also contains a comprehensive set of System Design Descriptions (SOD's) which define all aspects of every plant system in a standardized format. Site-related capital cost adjustments are made to the CFRP for sizing, logistics, civil site features, temporary and penmanent power connection point~. building enclosures, insulation levels, cooling requirements, ana type of coal. The estimate is based on the following: a. Wage rates applicable to Anchorage Union Agreements south of 63° latitude including Workmen's Compensation, FICA, and Public Liability Property Damage insurance rates as calculated by Ebasco. 71768 1 -~c,--~--------.... '" l -} ·~-;,, ["' ,. ;:-. "*11.>"~-•.., *-~ ~ •• ,. r,.. •-~ .• • :. ~=.::.o 1.¥,.._... .• •• '.,. ' I ' /· I ' i 1· I I ' ' ! l I i t I ; I ~ ' \ ! I J \ f ~ f ' ! ALASKA POWER AUTHORITY Susitna Need for Power Study 200 MW Coal-fired Plant Belega Site Estimate No. APA 1707 H-1 BASIS OF ESTIMATE (continued) GENERAL (continued) b. A work week consisting of 6·10 hour days. c. Sufficient craft~men available to meet project requirements housed 1n labor camps. d. Professional Services 1nc1uding Engineering, Design, Related Services and Construction Management based on a generic plant of comparable size using the CFRP concept. e. Land and Land Rights not included. f. Al1owance for Funds Used During Construction (AFUDC) not includ~d. g. Client costs not included. h. Permanent town for plant operating personnel and mine production personnel not included. i. Capital cost of mine and coal export facility not included. j. Operating and rnaintenanct costs not included. k. c~.ntingency included at the rate of 12% for material and 15% for 'Listallation. 71768 2 L.l· . " _ _:..:;. __ , __ ,__._ ...... ~---·~-··-··-...... .. . ; tj ·, ~·'·"M''?'trrttr•rluiMbm#m r ~ ......... catwm; « .. --~'({ ... _ "l !/~~ \ 1 1~ l tl I 11t l I l J 1 l A~ASKA POWER AUTHORITY Susitna Need for Power Study 200 HW Coal-fired Plant Beluga Site Estimate No. APA 1707 H-1 E~SI~ OF ESTIMATE (continu~ GEN~cont1nuc~ 1. CN1struction performed on a Contract basis. m. Project being exempt from sales tax. n. labor productivity being ~average U.S." with no Alaskan adjustment. o. Spare parts and special tools not included. p. Start-up costs not included. q. Ma·intenance ma·chinery, laboratory and office equipment not included. CIVlb. (Categories 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 16, 17, 18) Clearing is assumed based on scrub brush and trees up to 25'. Some rock: ,~~~cavathm ·ts assumed in deep cuts. No dewatering of excavated areas is assumed. No railroad or barge delivery of coal is assumed for this mine -mouth plant. Coal is assumed to be trucked from the m1ne. Twenty (20) miles of access road is assum~d. Eighty (SO) foot long piles are assumed under heavily loaded foundations. A four hundred (400) foot high concrete stack with 2-11' diameter steel flues is assumed. No ash ponds are i~cluded; a waste processing system 1s included. Waste would be trucked to a 71768 3 t) - J (j il ' _J I • j l ! • i J "1 i ) l , I I I ) l l j 'Jj . 1 i I j t j ! I I I I I I I I ( ALASKA POWER AUTHORITY Susitna Need for Power Study 200 MW Coal-fired Plant Beluga Site Estimate No. APA 1707 H-1 BAS!S OF ESTIMATE (continued) CIVIL (continued) disposal area off-site. The capital c~st of constructing the disposal area is not included. No asphalt or concrete paving is included. Cooling tower pricing is based on a Zurn budgetary quotation for a Model 3-Z-4&0 rectangular multi-cell unit rated at &6,000 gpm. A Ranney well \~ake-up water system is included. An equipment barge unloading facility is included. M~HANICAL (Categories 7, 8, 9w 10, 11, 14) E~o1a1re provided a budgetary quotation for a 105,000 ft 2 surface condenser. The condenser i$ a single-shell, single-pass, single-pressure type ~esigned for 66,000 gpm and 27°F temperature rise. Ecolaire provided a budgetary quotation for a reverse gas 662,000 ACFM Baghouse with a 300°F gas temperature. Low sulfur, sub-bituminous coal with a heating value of 7f950 btu/lb and ~ coal firing rate of 253,400 lb/hr is assumed. The quotat1on is based on design, fabrication and erection of one baghouse and auxiliary.equipment with 10 compartments/ baghouse and 368 bags per compartment. Combustion Engineering Power Systems and Foster Wh~eler provided budgetary quotations for the coal-fired steam generator and 71768 ·--t~:. ----~~--·•-"'"~···•------.-·-w·~· _. •··-····-~·-_ .. ._.. ... . .... . c ~ ~ , A!l!ltt:tn't•t "rlf.tSI:nrm·~ ,-..,~- l-·-·-~-..... ·I =-· .'i I I I I I I I I I I I ALASKA POWER AUTHORITY Susitna Need for Power Study 200 MW Coal-fired Plant Beluga Site Estimate No. APA 1707 M-1 BASIS OF ESTIMATE (continued} MECHANICAL (continue[l accessories. Pricing is based on 1,590,000 lb/hr, 2650 psig and 1008°F m~in steam; 1,351,000 lb/hr, 600 psig, 630°F (@inlet) reheat; and 525°F feedwater. The 7950 btu/lb coal analysis is as follows: Proximate Moisture Ash Volatiles Fixed Carbon Ultimate Hydrogen Carbon Oxygen Nitroge~ Sulfur Chlorine Moisture Ash Weight Percent 26.1 6.4 36.3 31.2 3.6 47.2 15.5 1.05 0.12 26.1 6.4 Combustion E~gineering provided a budgetary quotation for a •dry• so 2 scrubbing sy~tem ~tilizing multi-cell sprayer absorbers with 85% so 2 71768 5 '! \\ ; ' -• • I I I I I I ALASKA POWER AUTHORITY Susitna Need for Power Stud~ 200 MW Coal-fired Plant Beluga Site Estimate No. APA 1707 H-1 BASIS OF ESTIMATE (continued) MECHANICAL (continued} {70% guarantee) removal. The system is rated at 662,000 ACFM with a flue gas temperature of 300°F and 20% excess air. Westinghouse Electric, General Electric and Utility Power Corporation prnvided budgetary quotes for the stearn turbine generators. The quotations are based on an indoor type, tandem compound condensing turbine, two flow, single reheat, regenerative designed for operating steam conditions of 2400 psig and 1000°F/1000°F. The turbine design throttle flow will be 1,~90,000 lb/hr. The maximum gross turbine output will be 2~0,000 ~W with 2520 psig, 1000/1000°F, 2.7/4.0 in.Hg absolute back pressure. The generator is 244,,00 lVA @ 45 psig, 0.9 PF, 3 phase, 60 Hz, 24,000 V and 0.5 shortcircuit ratio complete with an e~ci,ation system. PIPING AND INSULATION (Categories 12 and 13) Large bore and small bore piping sizing and quantities are downsized based on Ebasco•s CFRP estimates. Pricing is based ofl rf~cent quotations and historical pricing data from similar un~~s. Insulation prices are based on Ebasco's CFRP estimates with an additional allowance for insulating yard systems. 71768 J,l-~-~---~~---_________ .. _____ , __ ---.----------------------·---------------------------- Hf ---- .~ ~ Miliilli&Mr~ r -, t n:awwvHexww&&exh"*" A·ttachment 3a .. 6 SELECTED VENDOR QUOTES ·····r···· ·~ ' l \ I l J I ! I j i i I I •• II l I I I I. I I I I I I I I I ·~·r·.. r··--··~·-·-······· ·-· ·;---··- . . j i :'~~~· } \, i April 25, 1984 Ebasco Services, Inc. 400 112th Avenue, N.E. Bellevue, WA 98004 Attention: Mr. Joseph J. Marshall Senior En~ineer Subject: • Cooling Tower Selection and Budgetary Pricing for the Alaska Power Authority Study Zurn Reference No. OS-84011 Dear Mr. Marshall: In response to your March 28, 1984 letter, we are pleased to submit our preliminary cooling tower selections-and budgetary pricing for your Alaska Power Authority Study. As discussed in our April 12, 1984 telephone conversation, our design wet bulb temperature is taken from the ASHRAE Handbook for the 2.5~ design wet bulb in Juneau. The Zurn cooling towers we have selected for the various design waterflows and specified on the attached data sheets are a Model 12-Z-3600 Round Multi-Fan for the 193,000 gpm wat~rf1ow, a Model 7-Z-2700 Round Multi-Fan for the 130,100 gpm waterflow and a 3Z-460 Rectangular Multi-Cell for the 66,000 gpm waterflow. These Zurn cooling towers are all counterflow units constructed mainly of reinforced precast concrete sections. The thermal exchange system is a high efficiency PVC fill pack which is supported by a network of precast concrete beams and columns and is located entirely within the confines of the tower shell. This arrangement contributes substantially to the control of ice accumulation and algae build-up. The combination of a structurally sound tower constructed of nearly inert materials and designed in stric~ compliance with the maximum thermal requirements specified, insures the delivery of a dependable system that will provide an.extended servicP life with absolute minimum op~rating and maintenance costs. An issue of major importance in your study of these cooling towers will surely be the control of ice accumulation and the towers ability to withstand the loads resulting from icing during winter oper&tion. Because of operator error and other reasons, cooling towers can and, very often do, ice up. This unavoidable icing frequently results in very expensive, major structural repair and/or fill material replacement. ZURN IHDUSTRIESi INC. COOLING TOWER DIVISION ii05 NORTH REO STREET, TAMPA, FL PHONE: 813187()-{)(UO TELEX: 52-410 MAILING ADDRESS: P.O. BOX 24718, TAMPA, FL U.S.A. 33623 Zum CooJmg Towers .. Constructec:l unc:ler license tiom BM::ke-Diirr, RatJngen, F«Jer31 Republic of Germany'' 1- I .. I ' I I I I I I Mr. Joseph J. Marshall Ebasco Services, Inc. April 25, 1984 . Page two zuRNf·-·-.,-- f i Zurn Round Multi-Fan Cooling Towers are designed with. several unique features to help prevent ice-formation and are recommended for use in locations of severe winter operating conditions such as this project. Also, the durable design and high ice load capacity of Zurn all concrete towers and fill systems insures minimum susceptability to damage due to icing. We have enclosed several copies of •cooling Tower lee Prevention Systems: Stat~~of-the-Art Designs" for your information and use. We have also enclosed several cooling tower brochures for your files. We appreciate your interest in Zurn Cooling Towers and look forward to working with you ~s this project progresses. Please feel free to contract us when we can be of further assistance. Very truly yours, ZURN INDUSTRIES, INC. ~r;;: ~~si_o __ . T~omas J. Hert?n Sales Engineer TJH:bgb Encls. , I. I I I ' I I I I I I I f : A , J . lf I 11 Jl. ! i J I l. l I I. ~ . I . • . ZURN 1·-·-., .. ,_ -• I RECTANGULAR MULTI-CELL COOLING fOWER SELECTION FOR EBASCO SERVICES, INC. ALASKA POWER AUTHORITY ZURN REFE~ENCE NO. OS-84011 DESIGN CONDITIONS WATERFLOW RATE: HOT WATER TEMPERATURE: COLD WATER TEMPERATURE: DESiGN WET BULB TEMPERATURE: RELATIVE HUMIDITY: MAXIMUM DRIFT RATE: COOLING TOWER DATA TOWER TYPE: MODEL NO.: NO. OF CELLS: TOWER LENGTH: TOWER WIDTH: TOWER HEIGHT (to top of stacks): DIAMETER OF FANS: OPERATING FAN HORSEPOWER: TOTAL OPERATING HORSEPOWER: APPROX. TOTAL DYNAMIC PUMPHEAD: BUDGETARY PRICE NOT INCLUDING BASIN AND FOUNDATIONS: , 66,000 GPM 118 DEGREES F • 90 DEGREES F. 59 DEGREES F. 50% .01% RECTANGULAR MULTI-CELL 3Z-460 3 216 FEET 68.8 FEET 41.5 FEET 40 FEET 119 .. 3 HP 357.8 HP 23.2 FEET $2.7 MILLION / h ~·" :. i 0 I I I . I I I I - ....... 'I I I I I I I I I ·J I I I . . • • . RECTANGULAR MULTI-CELL COOLING TOWER SELECTION FOR EBASCO SERVICES, INC. ALASKA POWER AUTHORITY ZURN REFERENCE NO. OS-84011 DESIGN CONDITIONS WATERFLOW RATE: HOT WATER TEMPERATURE: COLD WATER tEMPERATURE: DESIGN WET BULB TEMPERATURE: RELATIVE HUMIDITY: MAXIMUM DRIFT RATE: 66,000 GPM . 118 DEGREES F. 90 DEGREES F. 59 DEGREES F. 50% .01% COOLING TOWER DATA TOWER TYPE: MODEL NO.: NO .. OF CELLS: TOWER LENGTH: TOWER WIDTH: TOWER HEIGHT (to top of stacks}: DIAMETER OF FANS: OPERATING FAN HORSEPOWER: TOTAL OPERATING HORSEPOWER: APPROX. TOTAL 9YNAMIC PUMPHEAD: BUDGETARY PRICE NOT INCLUDING BASIN AND FOUNDATIONS: RECTANGULAR MULTI-CELL 3Z··460 3 216 FEET 68.8 FEET 41.5 FEET 40 FEET 119.3 HP 357.8 HP 23.2 FEET $2.7 MILLION / ~--~. .:---:-------~-.----·~-.~~----·-:-~-~----· .... ·~·-··· .......................... -·---·---·---....... ,.. ............. ·-··1· ;.~,------__ -----·---------... -... -.............. .. . - . . I . . . I .. I I l ! I I I I I I I I I I I 1- .li.' ' I GENERAL fj ELECTRIC LARGE STEAi~ TURBINE-GENERATOR MARKETING OPERATION GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY • SCHENECTADY, NEW YORK 123<45 • (518' July 10, 1984 Subject: Alaska Power Authority 200 ~N Power Plant Study Mr. L. J. Becker Me~hanical Engineer EBASCO 400 -ll2tb Ave. N.E. Bellevue, Wash. 9du04 .Mr. ~E!Cker~ S-221 1 Attached you will find the general outline of a tandem compound two flow jO" ~Last stage bucket ( 'J:C2:r'., 30" .LS.B) turbine. This is in response to a specific request on your behalf ~y Mr. M. Allison of .t!USD. At this time I wou~ld like. to point out tba.t a TC2F-26" LSB turbine would fulfill the '200 IDi alternative probabl~ at a higher efficiency and lower cost. Also, attached are some General Electric publications vhich should enable you to gain a gener~l idea of the inspection and maintenance for larga ateam turbine-generators. A$ is stated in GEK-63355, most utilities plan for a major outage once every five years~ Of course this frequency should be increased when a specifio unit has the potential for solid particle carryover from the boiler. , William ~. Tessaro Sales Engineer -Region I . cc : M1 J.)oELne -G.£, Schdy ~~ Allison -GE, Seattle ~T ··- r ~!i'll!l~ ' ! l ! ' "·"'-I ,-' 1*$11 wl u ~ • -0 ·' , ") -'-------~------·-----· ----------·--'---·--·-----"---~---------..:...---~-·----~---------~------'-----~-----------------<--------~~----·----·"···'loti;.. __ , _____ ~~~------__;___ _______________________ __:_._ .. ~•>----~-~~-·----~----'---·---------... -~ ~ ~ ~~iii~ L ------~ -.. -.. ~ .. liB m·:o·n rtm. ~ 55i" riifi' I Ui9C !044 I t--· "noi l-s/T !~ 1: _._3 tFT,5 fT 4t-11FT 3 --teFT ot----•e" tlr8FTI l :z:srn ·~ I Fi. 0 ~ I ~ i~_,j ~i~~ itlftGI ~~~ ~ ~,n4~ ~-"-"-·1 I tf,?lifi-t r;..-t__ • _., . . Vi!Ql...___..__ ,._~ 36 J!I~[{-~Km~~~~~~~~h~lS{~b~~~v~ 'KI'~~rni:A·~-f I ~-~ ~;~ /7 f r·v· ~ _. ' fWOM .I I I TI-GEM. -· "~Ttll . · !AS[ liNE till ..._VU I ~ 79000 24100 0000 J!'"""" 100000 ISOOOO /r::? 40000 ___?-.) I ----.J fl 6 r=J ._, tOOO 0 Ll. 189000 U ,- EA. -rv r:r~·'lOO 150000 ~ 29800 ! '-~ 40000"i • • 33000 3Ml00t. ·-.. -----· IMIS tlllJOt lt!llwtiC M lln'ltn!M II IDilllliSI IS CIMlWfllll " PIIJ'Itln m cr..:a11. nrtrtllt [DIF!lrl INil ts ~~~« "AIUIU nnt l1l Ill II(SI'IJIG lU Ill llllliiiY Ill tt•l l liD IS I PVIlltllll \'[J(d.·lll Ill P(KDIIII I CJIIJJtl lltll Qlii'Ul nltiiiC I !1 IIIli 1101 II( .PIIOJCID Ill tD'HD UUPI 10 11€ (11'011 lftl~n ID Pl!!ror.ll U Ill Ill D1 Ill UJOn 1110 ~Ill K 1t l\0l'D I*'DUJn.T '..191 ~till s•. • lfCII'UNt llll Ull Jll Jl&SOdll1 Slt.PS 10 P21JllCI IIIU !llllJOI M 11€ IWo.tliiiJt II llJit I IllS. ~ ! L 5 ean 4WJOO J . L • 1 -:s~ooo :s~ 1000 0 . 189000 ' ___ ........ !!leOOO ·~ -L-r-'1 ~-~ ,-~ 'c::J • ,I I :~ cp ~38000 oeooo 150000 MOTtS• I. STEAM COHDITIOI'tS • i~OO ftSIG -IOOU/1000 •F I'I[Ht:AT Wlllt 30 IN. lAST STAGE OOCKUS 2. HEAVIEST PIEC[ DURING ERECTION-(GENERATOR STAlOR i !10000 LBS. HEAVIEST PIEC'E A~TEN [I'IECTIOH-CUPPl:l'l HALf HP•IP TB !HELLJ 107,000 us. •1 206000 8 t!UIOOO l8 lOADINGS DO NOT OCCUR SIMULTANEWSLY BUT A"E SUPEiliMP0:~3 Oti ~OQOO t8. LOAD 208000 lB. lOAO IS ZERO FOR tmR,.AL OPERATION. FOR fULL VALUE OF 2~000 Ul LOAD 2"000 LB LOAD IS ZERO. •. THE 001118111£0 REHEAT VAlVE ARRANGEMENT INCLUDES TH[ REHEAT STOP AND INTERCEPT VALVES. 5 SHUT ROTATION IS CLOCKWISE WHEN VIEWED FROM 00\.LECTOR END Of' GE.NEnll TOR -. 1'9000 C. tOlO VALUES SHOWN ARE: FOft TURBINE-I,;ENI;RATOI'I UNIT ONLY. ADDITIONAL LOAD CONTRIBUTEO Itt CONDENSER NOT INClUDED T. DISTANCE REQUIRED TO ~EMOVE: MAJOR PARTS »NOY INCLUDING SliNGS • A. GENERATOR St'ATOR-13 FT. 0 FltOM TI-GEM. I!IASE liNE WITH TERMINAL BOX lTTACttED. II. GENERATO:ol COOlERS· 20 " 8 fftOM TIJ-GEN. liAS£ LIN£ C. Tt41S 0\JTUNE SHALL NOT BE USED FOR CONSTRUCTION PURPUS£5. THE GENE"'AL EQU1Pr.4[NT ARAANGEIIIENT DIMENSIONS AND LOADINGS ~Fl[ TO BE CON!IDtREO PRELIMINARY ANO SUCJJECT 1U LA1[R MODIFICATION. t. fiECdMMEHDED MIKIIIIIUM CRANE HOOIC ff(IGHT A!OY[ tl. GEN. IA5£ LIM[-31 Ff (} to fiEC::OIIM[HDf:l) MINIIIIUM FOONDATIDH HEIGtn-30 FtO iN. 2!100 ~lllllrF ~..,..,.._, ~·"" ~·IIi ltt>R lll'lla&.lt •Lt. U. ftt.Y. t• zrcz/TIS J•J. ••" PROPOS triON IISTMU 0'1 Q tmM IU flnJ l I SIFT 0 . utTt mFTO OUTLINE STI:AM T\MIN[ Of:NERATOtll UlttT TURICN[ i!l1711 kW • !fiOO .. , .. • TCZ:" 30°LS8 ATW·2 • Z66,600 IIIVl· liOOR,.. HT•UOOOV tP£PU!,TOPI OB!JP'F'·.~II ICR· 45 rll HI CONDUCTOA COOLED TRANS THl' 9101CW lUY AJO',fiOV[D U· II 54 DfiAWI'f IY.~J;JWllN.l:i:l! Ta tNOPI. f GIACAlDNE-!'/',. ioEN. UOR .I.J.TJ.L.i2.!!~::'. IN5''ECTlD.-4':'.: •• !!!/_-_ ••• O[N[RAL ElECTRIC ittC304~· SCH[N[CTAOY ~KS ----•1tron i _, ~~ /If> ::..~..--o:.:--_--~- t 'J i j {1~.:. l . :· t I: ... I \-· . l ''I"' ! r I II l l l 1',. . !· l l l I·· ·~ ·! II 1 II I 1 I 111 ( l . l I I. j I ~ ILLINOIS WATER TREATMENT COMPANY ~; Shepherd Trail Rockford. Illinois 61105 Phone 8151!77·3o.1 Telex 257_.., Twx t1o-631·3A3B July 18, 1984 Ebasco Services Inca 400 112th Ave. NE Bellevue. WA 98004 Attention: Mr. lawrence Becker Project Engineer • ~ AllfGHINY ~ INTERN ... T~Al ··RECE\VED JUL 2 ~ 1984 PROJECT SE'~VICES Otf'IY · EP..e.S~O SEP..'T'!LE Subject: Budget for an Alaskan 200MW Powe~ Plant Water Treatment System IWT Ref. No. SG-84·143 ( ('c;.b,~ C)' c: I~ Dear Sir: Thank you for allowing IWT the opportunity to assist you with your water treatment needs. This letter summarizes the system that was discussed during our phone conversation of 7-12-84. The supplied water analysis did not balance we11. The balanced feed water analysis is given below with ions given ~s ppm CaC03: Ca Mg Na Ictal 98 33 13 Cations 144 HC03 84 so 4 53 Cl 7 Sub --rDtal Anions 144 Free C02 17 Si02 4 ~1 Anions 165 ll ll. -~ Th£: budget price for alternate •A" is $430,000. Add $75,000 to $150,000 .. 1 : \. ~ t~ • .! c for a vacuum degas i fi er whose price is heavily dependent on feec! water ~~'! ~· temperature end desired effluent oxygen level. Estimated sulfuric ·-~cid cost is $10,000 per year based on using 200,000# of G6° 8~ HzS04 at l 1: $.05/#. Estimated caustic cost is $33,500 per year b&sed on using '[ .r 134,00~ of 100% NaOH at $.25/1. t , i l '1:.• -..,The budget price for alternate •s" is $280e000. Estimi~ted sulfuric . acid cost is $9,000 per year. Estimated caustic cost i~ $29,000 per i year. I 1 .. I . l \, 1 I J ! I' I , _j !;! '1 1 making WIIYH in Jiquid processing . . . ~ . " .. . . . . , ( .. ' . , . -,.. . ..... ... -.. .. 1---·v---........ --·. . ... .. . . -·r r? -\', I ·.~.. ,f ,ILLINOIS WATER 1/ TREATMENT COMPANY ·~ · , Ebasco Services Inc • . !.. · July 1 a. 1984 /1 Page 2 1: . ! I~· li I II I lc It .The pr·ice difference between alternate ••A•• and ••au reflects the inclusion of polishing mixed beds for alternate "A". These budget prices reflect a water treatment system designed for the power industry with options and quality normally request~d in specifications. Eguip~ent Summary A. Triplex Mu1timedia Filter System -IWT Hodel 3AMF-300S • B • Tanks: Media: Pipe: 30 11 dia. x 60'• S.S. w/ 100 psi Asme Code Interna1 P1asite 7122 epoxy lining 16" di a. manhole 3" media removal nozzle Finish Paint Skid mounted Sand, garnet and anthrafilt 2" galv. C .• S •. Service Flow: 50 g~ each Inlet flow indicators: Signet type Purpose: Red~ctio~ of particulates down to 10 micron nominal Triplex Carbon Filter System -IWT Model 3ACS-306S . Tanks: Media: Pipe: 30 11 dia. x 60" S.S. w/ 100 psi Asme Code Pl~site 7122 lining 16" dia. manhole .:;n media removal nozzle Finish paint Skid mounted ORC carbcr. 211 Ga1v. C.S. Service Flow: 50 gr~ each Purpose: Organic and chlorine reduction • I I I j l . : , ::j iLLINOIS WATER 1 I I TREATMENT COMPANY ; . · Ebasco Services Inc. . 1-,;Jj : ~·:t I· . ·' I . l 'I I \l'' \;· ',' 1 a· ~· l : : . I '~ jl J 1/ ·I jl ' ' ! i l , A.· (j l ,J l I IJ !! I. l .. J ·. !. I~ ~. " ' 1 J .•. 1 ',; I I I ~, ~ I( ~' l c . • o. Triplex Two Bed Oeionizers -l~'T Model 3ASB-3030S Tanks: Media: Pipe: 30" dia. x 96" S.S. w/ 100 psi 3/32" Korosea1 lining 16" dia. manhole 3" media removal nozzle Finish paint Skid r.-.ounted C-211 strong acid cation resin Asme Code A-464 Type 1 strong base ani on res i ., 2" PPL lined Sch. 40 C.S. w/ fail safe diaphragm valves Service Flow: 40 gpm each Cation Regenerant: Anion Regenerant: Heated caustic ~ 120°F available for silica reduction if required Chemical System: Pumped regenerants Purpose: Reduce ion load to 5-20 micromhos Reduce SiOz to ca. 0.02 ppm · Jrip1ex Polishing Mixed Bed-IWT Model AMB-2496S Tanks: r~edi a: Pipe:' 24" dia. by 96" S.S. w/ 100 psi 3/ 32" Korosea 1 1 i ni ng 16" dia .. manhole 3" media removal nozzle Finish vaint Skid mount.ed C-361 strong acid cation resin Asme Code A-464 Type 1 strong base anion resin 2" PPL lined Sch. 40 C.S. w/ fail safe diaphragm valves Catio~ Regenerant: 1-step HzS04 Anion Regenerant: Heated caustic ~ 120°F · Chemical System: Pumped regenerants common with two bed Purpose: Used with alternate itA" only ·Water quality of 10 megohm and SiOz of 0.01 ppm I ... • i • I 1. ·; (· I' ' I I I I. I I. .'( li I I ' d I; I; j IJ· I. ~~- \ .. ( f ltLINOIS WATER TREATMENT COMPANY Ebasco Services Inc. July 18, 1984 Pag~ 4 . The system price includes interconnect service piping and NEMA 12 solid state controls. Please note the attached rough block diagram for your review. I trust this info"nation wi11 assist you in the development of your project. lf there are any further questions. please feel free to contact this office or ou~ local representative~ Mr. Don Gaddiso Si nee rely. Wayne T. Bates Sales Engineer WTB/ gbs 7 /Nw Qur representative is: Northwest Process Equipment Company 300 120th N. E • Bldg. 2 Suite 210 Bellevue, WA 98005 Phone: (206) 451-8591 TWX: 910-443-2308 {Vantage Corp.) r--.1 • • .~ . .. L ___ J .I --::lj L___:_j ___ _ ,,. : -. ·- ... -· . i1 -~ -~ ....__ __ ___, -·-~-·----' . -. . . -·-.. -··. ~--,...-----~-. --. s r-4 :CIJ ~ .. . . .. \J .. ~ a "' : . . -· -·-.. ... "" . [1 ' ~ ' ~ \1 .. ~ ": .. -~ (lJ -- ·- ~ • I ~ ~ a . l ~ ~ =I ~ .\) ... -· -. e ~ • 1 \l. ~ 'l • ~ ' f( ~ ~ t5 , ~ ' T ' .tflJ ~ ~' .. ~ • ~~~ .. \) " '-·~ ~ ~ ~ .... .i: 't' ~ ~~~ . . ~ ~ ~~~ .. ' ·~ ',l\ ~ { ~~ }! ~ ~ ~ <. I I ' t I -~I ' . i .• ' .l . J 1 I ! . I .1 ., I• ;1 :·1 l I' 1 . I ' ·~ ~ I I i ,. i ' 1 1 1.· { l ~· J I (. 1 ]'I 1 j I ) I j 1 I 1 j l I ~ j J. I, I c .. E Power lpttma Combustion Engineering, Inc. 1800 South West First Avenue Portland, Oregon 97201 Tel. 503/224-9132 E!!J!I!! POWER iii& SYSTEMS Mr. Gordon Villesvik £basco Services Incorporated 400 -112th AvenYe N. E. Be11P.vue. Washington 98004 Dear Gordie: • April 13, 1984 Subject: Alaska Power Authority Nenana Coal Field -Thermal Station Negotiation No. PTD-84059-S In response to your l~tter of March 26 concerning the subject project we are pleased to respond ;n part to your request for budgetary information. SCOPE OF SUPPLY FOR EACH OF THE FOLLOWING CASES furnace Wall System Superheater Reheater Economizer Pressure Parts Support Steel Casing & Buckstays Ducts & Dampers Tilting Tangential Firing Eqpmt. Coal Piping C-E Pulverizers Stock Gravimetric Coal Feeders Sealing , Setting, Insulation & lagging Circulation Pumps, Valves & Drives Ljungstrom Air Preheaters Platf~nms & Stairways Complete Structural Steel Soot Blowers & Temperature Probe(s) Valves & Accessories Forced Draft Fan{s) & Drive(s) Primary Air Fan(s) & Drive(s) Shop Subassembly Phases I, II & III Erection Representative Service Representative •·><~····---· "'~"-· Q Mr. Gordon Villesvik Page 2 April 13 BOILERS Case I (200 MW) .. One (1) 1,590,000 1/hr •• 2650 #, 100QOf/lOOSOf unit, firing subbituminous •c .. coal: Total Approximate Present Day D&R Sell: Total Approximate Present Day Erection Sell: Estimated Erection Man-hours ~rthwe~: CASE. l ~ ( 400 MW) $28,400,000 $14,000,000 To Follow One (1) 3,158,000 1/hr., 2650#, \OQSOf/lOOSOF unit, firing subbituminous "c•• coal: Total Approximate Present Day D&R Sell: Total Approximate Present Day<Erectjp~ell: Estimated Erection M~n-hours f>rthwert : CA~ I1I (600 MW) $41,000,000 $20,500,000 To Follow One (1) 4,703,500 #/hr •• 2650 #, 1QQ80f/lOOSOF unit, firing subbituminous '"C 11 coa 1 : Total Approximate Present Day D&R Sell: Total Approximate Present Day · Sell: Estimated Erection Han-hours Northwest : ~~ END EQUIPMENT . Pricing to follow in approximately two (2) weeks. $52,000,000 $26,000,000 To Follow We trust this information will be of assistance to you and will follow up with the balance of requested information as soon as it is available. , GRD:m1f Very truly yours, COMBUSTION ENGINEERING. INC. ,J/P.~" G. R. Dahl'ifger District Manager .. ···l·~ .. ----·-........ -·-~ ............... . 't j I .. :I .I ., I :1 l ., i 1 j l ! II ·t ·1 I .. ··· j ; . 1 II ~ ,· .· l . J 1 il I• ! j I l . J I "i -l I 1 ' I. . ''! .,~ ! I Westingf]ouse Electric Corporation April f1, 1984 :.r .. Mr. Joseph J. Marshall, Senior Engineer £basco Services Inc. 400 llOth Avenue N.E. Bellevue, WA 98004 . Subject: Alaska Power Authority Estimating Prices • Steam Turbine Generators Dear Mr. Marshall: 5901 S W Macadam Avenue Ponland Oregon 97201 503-221-4430 This is a response to your letter dated March 23, 1984 and our subsequent telephone conversations regarding estimating prices on 600 MW, 400 MW and 200 MW fossil turbine generators for Alaska Power Authority. Estimating prices are as fo11ows: $38.5M ~ $28.1M ,/ $16.4M (" \../ Westinghouse would be very interested in providing this type of equipment to Alaska Power Authority. I would appreciate you keeping me informed on the progress of this project. CJY:sc Mr. T.A. Rossman Westinghouse.Electric Corporation Seattle, WA Mr. D.M. Johnson Westinghouse Electric Corporation Orlando, FL \l 1i l" ,. ,, ~~@~I (R{~ HEAT TRANSFER co. Joseph J. Marshall, Senior Engineer Ebasco Services, Inc 400-112th Ave NE Bellewe, WA 98004 Sub: Alaska Power Authority Surface Condenser Estimate Dear Mr. Marshall: 27 April 1984 1550 Lehigh Drive Easton, PA 18042 Phone 215-250-1000 Telex 84-7330 • The following is confirmation of estimated prices supplied verbally earlier this month: Item 200 MW Unit 400 MW Unit 600 MW Unit (multi-pre$ure) Price $ 861,000 l., 489 '000 3,203,000 JAC/mgb Enclosures CC Engineered ..Equipment-Northwest-D.,f.Wold T . .. -. ------~-:::1' , I "1• -~ i •. 1 '& ' I 71 ., I ~ 1 . . 1 . 'l "'I·. ;· ~ ; l ! l . l 1 1 '-·! ']I . i . I j I l I • I I . j ,,, I . I ·! 1 1 l I ~ j I I I 1 1 { ·' I ;[ l -~ I ·I 1 . f I I ~ ' f \ ! ,. ·~~ \i 1 I ~ 'l l I . I l l ~ tr 1. [ ' ' ~ PREl.JMlNARY DIM£N90NS CUSTOMER E BA .rc o /AL/rJK!t fo w~ A-~rH. . DATE I UNIT_ 6o0 ~w • • • .. • .. , l'f" l' ..... J -- • I I • 2.'1'-o ~ 9!.B" -- • .. .. . . t e'-o" l 4 13'-z." ~ I 30ft . ~- ECOL..AiRE teNDENSER INC. I l 1 .· j ' \ • j i i I I ! I I i ! l I l l I I l '\ l ,, ' I ' 1 I I I I I I I J I 'I I ! J l j I l .{ i l I 1 I l I l f I ! l l t I ~~ l t I l j ! I j ~ I l } I I ! l ~ . 1 I l I I I I ! ! ! i • •. J ~~©~IIR(~ ENVIRONMENTAL COMPANY 380 CMc On~ Pleasant Hill. CA 94523 Phone 415-676-6315 Telex 3+0314 April 13, 1984 Ebasco Services Incorporated 400 ll2th Avenue N. E. Bellevue, WA. 98004 Attention: Mr. J~~eph J. Marahall Senior Y.ugineer • Reference: Alaska Power Authority Dear Mr ~ Marshall: We are pleased to respond to your request of ~~ril 9, 1984, for budgetary cost estimates on three (~) different baghouses, sized for 600 MW (1,982,000 ACFM.), 400 MW (1,324,000 ACFM), and 200 h"W (662,000 ACFM), respectively. We .have de:scribed our selections on separate data sheets for your convenie~ce. We have also included our installations list for utility coal fired boilers, and installation reports on two recer1t projects. Your c.lient may be interesti!d to know that Ecolaire has a baghouse installed on a small coal fired boiler at Golden Valley Electric Assoc:Lation' s Bealy Station Unit 1 near Fairbanks, Alaska~ This unit bas been in operation since 1980. If you have any questions concerning the above or enclosed informa~ tion, or if you require additional data at tbis ttme, please feel free to contact our local sales representative, listed below, or this office directly. 'We would be pleased to assist in specifica- tion preparation/recommendations if your study should progress to that stage. We look forward to an opportunity to be of service. uldner ions Engineer - [) J I I I ' I I I I I I I I I I I l I. , ~~@WI~~ ENVIRONMENTAL COMPANY Ebasco 3ervices Incorporated April 13, 1984 Page ~·o cc: Engineered Equipment Northwest P. 0. Box 02252 Portland,. OR.. 97202 (503) 238-0093 Mr. Don Wold Ecolaire Environmental. Company 1868 E. Sixth Street Tempe, AZ. 85282 • (602) 897-8989 Mr. Craig Wennerholm Enclosures: CB 83 Utility Boiler Installations List Installation Reports: N-6771, N-6592 , ] ) m~@~JfR<~ ENViRONMENTAL COMPANY 1 600 MW I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Gas Volume: Gas Temp: Fuel Fired: No. of Baghouses: No. of Comp.~rtments: Baghouse Cleaning: Bag Type: Bag• Size: No. of Bags~ Air/Cloth Ratios: Gross: Net: Net-Net: Plan Area: Budget Price: 1,982,000 AOFM 3000F Low Sulfur Sub-bituminous Coal Two (2) iwelve' (12) per Baghouse, 24 Total Reverse Gas Woven Fiberglass ~th ~eflon B Finish 12"~ x 36'-9" Long 450 per Compartmert, 10,800 Total 1.70 : 1 1.94:1 including Reverse Gas 2.14:1 including Reverse Gas 163'L X 16l'W X 103'B $17,400,000 installed and insulated, P~clusive of foundations or field wiring. / Note that the baghouse we have selected for this application is virtually identical in size and arrangement to the unit Ecolaire has provided to Deseret Generation and Transmission Cooperative for their Moon Lake Station. , I 'I ( j ~··. ;,_J ' 'l II . 1 I I j i 'l ·j I l I I ! ··-· ! ; ~~@~lfR{~ ENVIRONMENTAL CO~v1PANY 600 MW Gas Volume: Gas Temp: Fuel Fired: No. of Baghouses: No. of Compartments: Baghouse Cleaning: Bag Type: Bag Size: No. of Bags: Air/Cloth Ra~ios: Gross: Net: Net-Net: Flan Area: Budget Price: 1,982,000 ACFM 3000F Low Sulfur Sub-bituminous Coal Two (2) Twelve (12) per Baghouse, 24 Total Reverse Gas ~oven Fiberglass ~th Teflon B Finish 12"~ x 36'-9" Long 450 per Compartment, 10v800 Total .1.70 : l. 1.94:1 including Reverse Gas 2.14:1 including Reverse Gas 163'L X 16l'W X 103'H $l).j)400,000 installed and insulated, exclusive of foundations or field wiring. //. Note that the baghouse we. have selected for this application is virtually identical in size and arrangement to the unit Ecolaire has provided to Dese~et Generation and Transmission Cooperative for their Moon Lake Station. , -I -:. .. . •. . I .. /: .. ~ I I I I I I I FOSTER Vv'H'EELER ENERGY CORPORATION 110 SOUTH ORANGE AVENIJ£ • LMNGSTON. NEW .JERSEY 07038 • PHONE 201·533·1100 ADDPtESS REfiiLY TO: l\1051 1.£. 2ftel, ,.0. lu 107,1el...,:t, WaltllftltDft 11009 telephone (206) U6·71SS l1t11: 15Z201 . Ebasco Services Inc. 400-ll2th Avenue N.E. Bellevue, WA. 98004 Attention: Mr. Go Villesvik Subject: Alaska Power Authority Nenana Coal Field -Ther.mal Station FWEC Ref. No.lOlS Gentlemen: In response to your inquiry letter of March 26, 1984, we herewith submit pricing for coal fired boilers of 200, 400 and 600 MW sizes. The present day, escalatable material supply budget prices are as follows: Steam flow, M Lb/Hr Pressure, psig Steam Temp. deg. F. SH/RB Material Price, FOB Seattle Deouct for FD/ID Fans and Drives MW SIZE 200 1,590 2,650 1008/1005 400 - 3,158 2,~50 1008/1005 600 - 4,703.5 2,650 1008/1005 $25,000,000 $41,500,000 $56,500,000 $ 1,400,000 $ 2,400,000 $ 3,700,000 judget prices for precipitators to follow. The scope of supply included in the above is as follo""S: Structural steel and platfor.ms: boiler pressure parts: flues and ducts {fan to fan): Air heater and steam coil: firing equipment; burner front piping; burner management system: feeders and piping, pulverizers with drives: burners; primary r.a.ir fan system with fans and drives: XD/FD fans and drives: sootblowers and piping: lagging, insulation and setting materials: normal complement of valves and fittings: nor.mal start-up services. Please note that the fl~e gas desulfurization system and precip- itator 4\re not included in the scope of supply. v I I I. t I I I• J i I I l .1. . ~ j '~ ' l . I • j I ~j. I 1 I . [ I I I .I '1 I( I I I- I I l 'I jl .• ( I .1,; ., - , ) ' -J ~U' WJIJ:&l.D ZNUG'f COJIPO~TJON • •KUT JlO. 2 lr May 21, 1984 Ebasco Services Inc. for Alaska Power Aut:hority FWEC Ref. 1015 · i . '--Erect on M~nuours -~--"-·.-. . -2- An estimate of ferect.ion manhours for each of the three sizes of boiler with the complete scope listed abov.e is as follows: Est. Manhours (Pacific N.W. area) wej.shts MW Size 200 400 600 -.._. 325,000 550,000 750,000 The steam drum is the heaviest piece of each of the boilers. Estimated weights for the drums are as shown: MW Size 200 400 --600 Est. Drum Weight, Lb. 350,000 550,000 780,000 These budget prices are predicated upon the Corporation's Standard Price Adjustment Terms and Ter.ms of Payment. TeD~s of Payment are of a progress nature consistent with the Corporation's outlay of capital. These budget prices and selection infor.mation are provided for informational purposes and for convenience only. Accordingly, all work performed and/or decisions made shall be at the entire risk and obligation of the user. Please let me know ~f I ca~ be of further assistance. f.;:C: Yours very truly, FOS~ WHE L~R~Y CORPORATION i/ ~~-. ' ll1,... Parker ~rew~n, Manager Nort-:.hwest District Sales s.G. cono~er, FWEC B.~~ Melosh, FWEC " •R _, ''"' ~··-• ---·-•""' ,, I I ,c I I I I IC I t· I I I I Utility Power Corporation [ 0] .as LexlnQton Avenue. New York. New Yortt 10174/ (212) e.G·a&OJ 1 Telex 12·5733 ?tLf -17¥' ... 7'/-0I k;.CY..! e. r UJo o d ~ -~ lThasco Services, Inc .. 400 112th Avenue N.E. Bellevue, WA 98004 Attention: Mr. Joseph J. Marshall Senior Engineer Re: Alaska Power Authority Request for Estimate of Cost for Ttirbine-Generators Dear Mr. Marshall: April 27, 1984 I refer to your request for cost estimates on furnishing of turbine~generators sized 600 ~', 400 ~' and 200 MW. In the fol1~1ng I am listing the prices based on our standard scope of supply, a copy of which is attached to this letter. 600 M\'.' 400 M\\' 200 M\\' 4-'Flow 30 4-Flow 35 4-Flow 22 4-Flow 2.7 2-Flow 22 $ 46,600,000 49,800,000 $ 34,000,000 36,100,000 $ 24,000,000 Should there be any more questions, please do not hesitate to call meo 1\M:ns encl. Very truly yours, ~ ~~·/{;< •• ~ Klaus Miller Regional Vice President ( / ('- I .. I. ·~ I I I I I I I( I ) I. i.l .. I II I I ••• I c I ) I . ~-. • 1M . rn., Utility Po""ret Corporation L. ~ ~ STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS FOSSIL • REHEAT • CONDENSING • 3-PHASE • 60 HERTZ • 3600 RPM SCOPE OF SUPPLY 12 r~"" .. I I rl·-- i I I I II I • I 1 I l . ' j I . ( I I l j l I f"gl Uti lit~)~ Power Corporation-~ :.-12 STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS FOSSIL • REHEAT e CONDENSING e 3--PHASE • 60 HERTZ • S600 RPM PAC-~ 1 OCT. 1, · 112 SCOPE OF SUPPLY TURBINE AND STANDARD TURBIN~ ACCESSORIES A. TANDEM-COMPOUND SINGLE-REHEAT TURBINE Consisting of one high .. pr~ssure section, one inter- mediate-pressul'e aection, and either one, two or three low-pressure sections. •a. STOP AND CONTROL VALVE SYSTEM 1. Two or four main valve combinations, each consist- ing of a stop \Valve and a control valve, complete with supports. Each valve has Its own hydraulic actuators. 2. Four reheat valve combinations, each consisting of a stop valve and control valve, complete with sup- ports. Each valve has its own hydraulic actuator. 3. Piping with breech-lock typa connections between main valve combinations and HP turbine casing. Pip- ing with flanged or welded connections as required . by design bet wee~ reheat valve combinations and JP turbine casing. ~. Permanent !ine-mesh st~am sotrainer complete with separate casing for each main and reheat valve combination. The six or eight casings to be located in Purchaser's main and hot reheat steam piping. !'. Provision for local and remote testing of main ~top and control valves, and of reheat stop and control valves while turbine is in operation. S. Limit switches tor the main and reheat stop v·alves with four do!Jble-pole, double-throw (DPOT) con- tacts at each end of the valve stroke and three DPDT contacts for each main and reheat control valve. 7. Position transducer for e•ch main and reheat con- trol valve. e. Temporary sealing devices for main and reheat stop valves for boiler hydrostatic test. One set for dupli- cate units. •c. TURBINE DRAINS 1. Motor-operated drain valves for turbine valves, cas- ings and steam piping as required with; a. Torque and travel limit switches. b. Manual isolating valves. 2. Piping from turbine equlpmet\t to each 1rain valve (up to 25 feet). Pipe hangers and supports not Included. • D. SEAL-STEAM SYSTEM 1. Seal-steam pressure control system with supply and ieak-off valves including a motor-operated bypass •REVISED SINCE LAST EDITION PAINTED IN U.S.A -- valve for each. The system automstically regl lates seal-steatn header pressure and has provisic. n for locaVremote manual operation. 2. Seal 8 steam condenser ~uitable for 12s• F cc ·Oiing water and 400 psig mnin'HJm pressura wit 1 one motor-driven vapor exhauster and one high · vater- level alarm. Stainl6s steel or 90-10 C1?pper· nickel tubes. 3. Corr~!i'!te seal-steam piping from turt•ine tot' 1e reg- ula',l"'' valves and to the seal-steam conde nSf r. Pipe auppo•1s ~lld hangers not ineluded. •£. EXHAUST HOOO SPRAY SYSTEM 1. Spray nozzles installed in each LP turbine t xhuu~t casing. 2. Piping between the control valve and spray JOUles. Pipe supports and hangers nl)t included. · 3. Solenoid vslve with motor-operated bypas~ valve. 4. Temperature sensors with alarn contacts ' 'ounted in the LP turbine ext~ust casings. •f. LUBRICATING Oll SYSTEM 1. Shaft-driven centrifugal main oil pump. 2. Lube oil tank (oil not included), equipped Nith: a. Oil turbine-driven vertical centrifuga: booster pump. b. Two full-capacity vertical centrifugal au ciliary oil pumps with a-c motors. t:. Vertical centrifugal emergency bearing )il pump with d·c motor and starter. d. Oil vapor ex~auster with a-c ITlotor. e. Oil mist eliminator. f. Basket-type oil strainers located at oil 1 eturn to tank. g. Float-type oil4evel indicator. t\. Float·type oil-level ;;witch with separate t igh and low-level contacts. i. Hinged and remowable access covers. j. Two 100% capacity positive displacemer t shaft- lift oil pumps with a-c motors. k. Two 100% capac(ty oil coolers with 5/S in OD 18 BWG minimum wzll. 90-10 copper-nicke or Ad- SupeBedes Page Dated Aug. 1, 1978 ' • - •' l ~, ·(40)AGE2 UtilityPowereofporation [Q] s·rEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS FOSSIL e REHEAT e CONDENSING e 3-PHASE • 60 HERTZ • 3600 RPM l ..,CT. 1, 1112 ' t:l 1 l ,j I j I . l , I I c "j · .. ·! 1. • I 1 I '·I I I SCOPE OF SUPPLY TURBINE AND STANDARD TURBINE ACCESSORiES mira tty metal integrally finned trJbes for ss• F cooling water at 125 psig mal'!imum, and a manu- all7 operated three-way transfer valve. I. Pressure switches and -solenoid valves for remote testing of aua:iliary anct emergency bearing oil pumps. 3. Duplex oil fi!te1r with transfer valve in oil piping fe~d ing the combined thrust and journal bearing, com· plete with local indication and alarm of oil-pressure drop across filters and a pressure switch for alarm of tow lube-oil pressure • .-. Complete interconnection oil piping between all pumi)S, coolers, turbine-generator bearings and tank. Pipe hangers and s~;~pports not included. All the oil ... upply piping adjacent to the turt)ine is guardt!d by spec;ial pipe enclosure. C"..onnections are provided on tank to accommodate Purchaser's ex· terrul piping for hb oil conditioning 11ystem. 5. All eJectric:al connections, except motor power sup-- plies, will be factory-wired to terminal boxes. •G. MOTOR DRIVES 1. All mo1ors are totally encioMd fan cooled with a service factor of 1.15 and Class B insulation. They are equipped vtith groundirag provision, drain de- vices. thermosta~. space heater-& and oversizt!d gasketed conduit boxes. 2. Standard a-c motors are rated 3-phase ~SO ~olts ± 10% for cor•tinuous operation and are c.pable of etarting and accelerating at 75~ rated voltage. 3. Standzrd d-e motors a!'!! rated either 120 or240 volts and sre capable of !lperating with a ± 15~ voltage variation. H. OIL-HYDRAULIC TURNING GEAR. 1. Oil-impulse turbine ~·ounted on shaft 1ystem for rotation 11t approximutely 150 rpm. 2. Piping between :~uxiliary oil pump discharge header and oil turb~not< compte'le with motor·operated con· trol vatW:. 3. Mechanical aha'tt rotAting deYice to allow turbine- genoerator s.Mft to be turned manually. TURBINE CONTROL SYSTEM 1. Electro-Hydrauitc Control .(EHC) Systern. •REVISED SINC-E L.ASl' EDITION 1\)WSMW 4 4$ a. Elflctronie control circuits, including: (1) Speed control for both speed and load opera- tion consisting of: (a} Three-channel speed meesur~ng system with shaft-mounted disc. pulse conveners and one spare transducer. (b) Lim!ting &ignals frorn the Turbine Stress ano Start·Lfp Control (TSC) S)'Stem (see Ctem J). {2} load control cor1:sisting of: (a) Two-channel electrical load measuring system. (b) Pro~isions for HP turbine admission pres· sure or control valve position feedback. (c) Remotely adju~~t~bl\! loading rate . (d) Automatic trarsster from load to speed ~ntrol. (e) Remotely sdjust2bl~ load limit set point. (f) Frequer.cy..,load r:cmtrolunit. (g) Four eoad run-beck~ (thr~H ~or Purchas· er'1 use). (h) Limiting signals from th~ TSC system. (3) ~sure cot"'trol consisth1g of: (fl) Mair• steam pressure trAnsducer. (b) Throttle pressur!!! and limit pressure con· trot (4) htm~~sion control with electro-hydraulic con· ~ner ior po:s.itioning the main and reheat control val~es. (5) 1'raeking device for Mechanical-Hydraulic Con-. trol (MHC) back-up operation. (6) ln~rface provisions for Purchaser's automatic md dispatch or coordinated boiler control. (7) Provisions for Early Valv~ Actuation. if re- quired by F•\',tChaser • . b. Speed ~aasur~rag Unit (SMU) including: (1) Speed meafotJring circuits mounted in the EHC cabinet. SuperMdills Page Dated Aug. 1, 1978 ( ( f t r 1', f I I I ! a j ,, ~ I. r i I . l l' ] J. .. ,r L fl I ll [ I I I l I J 1 ·~ I l I I l l I ! ! I I l I l I i -, ! I i I l I i I J [ I ! ' l -~ I I 1\. l •• -: ,-, .... :, Utility Power Corporation [ g] STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS FOSSIL e REHEAT e CONDENSING e 3-PHASE • 60 HERTZ • 3500 RPM 12 PAGE3 OCT. 1, 1882 SCOPE Of SUPPLY TURBINE AND STANDARD TURBINE ACCESSORIES (2) Speed signa.la conslating of: (a) Analog outputs for local and remote unit speed indication, recording and TSC. ,. (b) Limit-value monitors for TSI, An4 , ATC, TVR and genermtor condition monitoring system. (3) Speed signals for Purchaser's use consisting of: (a) Analog output (b} Umit-value monttora for. 1. Minimum apeed. 2. Automatic operation of tumlng gear. 3. Automatic operation Qf shaft-ltft oil pumps. 4. Automatic shutoff of LP exhaust hood spray valve. (c) Oigtat output from pulse converter. c. Free-standing EHC cabinets containing: (1} Solid-state control circuits. (2) Remotely operated reference aetters. (3) Alarm contacts for indicating failures within the electronic system. (4) Grounding provi,ions, conyenfence outlet. d. Control panel (Item L2} for mounting In Pur- chaser's Control Room. 2. Mechanical-Hydraulic Control (MHC) System. The MHC functions as back-up to the EHC and it includes the following: a. Turbine shaft-Qtiven impeller which provides the hydraulic sperd signal. b. Mechanical-hydraulic speed governor, Including an a--c motor·operated reference speed aetter, hydraulically in aeries wtth an tt-c motor--operated starting and load limit device. Each device has a local hanr.fwheel. Remote-control pushbuttons are located on turbine control panel (Item L.2). 3. Electro-Hydraulic and Hydraullc-HydrauUc Conver- ter• to provide a hydraulic positioning signal to the main and reheat con~tol valves. .c. Hydraulic Control Equipment Rack located at the turbine front end and Control Fluid Supply Racks located near control valves. 5. Control Fluid System with fire resistant fluid opermt· tng at •50/110 paig ineiuding the following: a. Fluid tank (fluid not included) with access door, level Indicator, high and low level alarm contacts. b. Two 1~ capacltyaubmerged centrifugal pumps with vertical a-c motor mounted on top of tank, .. ch with inlet ltrainer. c. Two 100% capacity fluid coolers with 5/8" 00,18 BWG minimum 10-10 copper-nickel tubes for e5• F cooling water at 125 psig maximum. and a manually operated transfer valve. d. Fluid conditioning equipme~t collsisting of: (1) Filter pump with a-c motor. (2) Fuller's earth filter wittl differential pressure awitch. (3) Fine-mesh filter with differential pressure switch. <•> Relief valve. (5) Interconnecting piping. e. Fluid accumulators. '· Tank-maunted fluid heaters. g. Pressure switch with solenoid valves for remote testing of fluid pump motors and for low pressurt! alarm. h. Carbon steel piping for contfol fluid Gystem. Pipe hangers and aup~orts not included. i. All electrical corm:1etions, e~cept motor power aupplies, will be factory-wired to terminal bo:r.es. •J. TURBINE STRESS AND START -UP CONTROL. (TSC) SYSTEM 1. The TSC perforrna the following functions: a. Continuoua monitoring of thermal stress cont~i tlons in turbine valves, casings and rotors. b. Computation. logging and recording of life t!x· penditure of turbine components due to le>w- cycle ~8tigu~. •REVISED SINCE LAST EDITION Pfi!INTEO IN U.S.A Supe..-des Page Dated Aug. 1. 1978 I I I l I • ( I I I • - Utility Power Corporation [ Q)] STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS FOSSIL • REHEAT • CONDENSING e 3-PHASE e 60 HERTZ • 3600 RPM SCOPE OF SUPPLY TURBINE AND STANDARD TURBINE ACCESSORIES f:. Control, in conjunction with the EHC, of maAual and automatic turbine atart-up and loading. d. Automatic Turbine-Generator Start-Up Control (ATC) from turning gear to preset load and ahut- down including the following pre-programmed functions: (1) Monitoring of unit prestart conditions. (2) Opening of atop valves. (3) Control of acce~eration to holding and/or rated apeed. (4) Synchronization with automatic aynchro- nlzer. (5) Loading and unloading. (6) Continuous tupervision of turbine thermal atress'.!s anc proper functioning of turbine auxili.i'lry aystems. 2. Sensing ·~uipment _,n tne turbine-generator: a. Special thermocouples. b. T$mperature transducers. 3. Free-standing TSC cabinet containing: a. Programmable microprocessor based solid-1tate cjreuits with memory. automatic self-testing fea- ture~ and alarm contacts. b. Grounding provisions. c. Data link to station computer for data logging. 4. Colored CRT and keyboard for mounting in Pur- chaser's control room. 5. Instruments mnd control for mounting in Purchaser's control room including: a. Cyclin; selector pushbuttons for normal/medi- um/fast turbine start-up and loading. b. Turbine Stress lndicator for graphic display of: (1) TP.~rbine apeed and permissible temperature margins. (2) Generator load and permissible load margins. c. Multi-point recorders for: (1) Turbine metal temperatures. (2) Computed rotor mean and center tempera- tures. •REVISED SINCE LAST EDITION PP!H'T£D IN U.I.A . (3) Permistible temperature and '.;Old margins. (4) Turbine speed or generator lt~&d. d. Teleprinter for: (1) Data per Item c above. (2) Life expenditure per thermal cycle. (3) Remaining life expectancy. (4) ATC program steps, operating criteria and alarms. e. Lift\ expectancy countera for each monitored turbine component. f. TSC control panel (Item L.2} for mounting in Pur- e,haser's contrQt room. 6. Programming equipmant with fixed program stor- age. •K. AUTOMATIC TURBINE TESTER (ATT} 1. The ATT provides on-line automatic functional test- ing of the following: a. All turbine stop and controf valves. ~. Protective devh:~i!S: (1) Two remote trip solenoids. (2) Two overspeed trip bolts. (3) Thrust bearing failure trip. 2. Indicating lights on the control p~!'el for: a. Malfunction of aystem(s). b. Test progl'ilrn steps. c. Criteria failures. d. Common alarms. 3. Components on the turbine including: a. Motor-operated positioner for each control valve and overspeed test device. b. Solenoid valves, pressure awitches and limit awitches for testing or check-back signals of al' atop valves. control valves or mechanical protec· tive devices. 4. Electrical overspeed back-up trips during testing of protectiwoe devices. Back-up trips are individually tested before actuation. Superaedes Page Dated Aug. 1, 197B I • ( ( ( 1~: . . ' ' ' ~,. ' . . < t ··.:. ~~;' ~ .. ~ .. ~,'/ !l>i, ;··, . ' ... , '· ~; I t . . . . ' I I I I II( _l I· I , ' ~ ' . I I ; 1• I I I I I j I I I I l l ' !J . ~Q'l Utilit}r Po~'erCorporattOI1 ~ ~ 12 STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS fOSSil e REHEAT e CONDENSING e 3-PHASE • 60 HERTZ • 3600 RPM PAGES OCT. 1,1182 SCOPE OF SUPPLY TURBINE AND STANDARD TURBINE ACCESSORIES . 5. Free-standing ATT cabinets containing digital aolid- atate control circuits, ~ontactors, g,..,unding provi- alons, and alarm contacts for monitoring internal failures. 6. Control panel for mounting in Purchaser'• control room (Item L.3). · •L. TURBINE-GENERATOR CONTROL PANELS 1. Control panels for mounting In Purchaser's control room including: a. Miniaturized control inHrts. ' b. Instruments of modular design with lamp testing. c. Up to 100 feet of flame-retardant plug-in cables. 2. T -G control panel with aystem fault indications and &amp tests including: a. Etectro-Hydraulic Control (EHC) System with: (1} Indicator for: (I) Speed (b) Load (c) Main Iteam pressure (d) Reheat steam pressure (2) Speed reference aetter and indicators for Q.. •200 rpm and 3300--4200 rpm. (3) Limited speed reference indicator. (4) Load control on/off with indicating lights. (5) Load reference setter and indicator. (6) Limited load reference indicator. (7) Automatic dispatch system on/off with iodi- cating lights and dispatch load reference indicator. (8) Load limit ntference and indicator. (9) Loading rate aetter on/off with indicating lights and indicator. • (10) Total load reference indic~:~nr. (1 1) Frequency load control on/off with indicating lights and fr.quency/load devif>tion indicator. (12) Pressure deviation indicator. (13) Throttie pressure or limit pressure mode se5ec- tor with indicating lights. . •REVISED SINCE LAST EDITION PRINTED IN U.S.A. (1.-) Master tur.':>ine trip pushbutton with c;over plate for pro~~ction from accidental activation. (15) Release pushbutton. (16) Indicating lights for: (a) Speed/load/pressure control in opere.tion. (b) EHC failure. (c) limit pressure value reached. (d) Acceleration low limit value reached. (e) Load runback switched off. (f) TSC switched off. (g) ATC switched off. b. Mechanical-Hydraulic Control (MHC) System wi~h: (1) Tracking on/off with indicating lights. (2) Hydraulic load limit setter and position indi- cator. (3} Hydraulic speed setter and position indicator. c. Turbine Stress and Start-Up Control (TSC} Sys- tem with: (1) Cycling normal/medium/fast selector. (2} Pyshbutton selector for Turbine Stress Indi- cator. (3) Life-expectancy counters. (.C) Pushbuttons for TSC test program. (5) Pushbuttons for ATC program start/stop and on/off. (6) Step and criteria indication lights. d. Valve Position Indication (VPI) with: (1) Individual stop valve open/closed indicating lights. (2} Individual control valve position indicators. e. Seai·Steem Control (SSC) Syst~m with: (1) Soal·steam r.upply and leak-off valve position aetter with position indicators. (2) Seal-steam header pressure indicator. (3) sse on/off with indicating lights and control deviation indicator. Supersedes Page Dated Aug. 1,1978 ,._.' (, r r I ' l ! I l I I I 1 I I I I ' ' l I ,, I d l i ! l 1 l I t ! l·.'l' " J I 'I " t fl I I I I I l I J j I I I I I ! I 12 ,,_,GEl ""'CT. 1; 1812 Utility Power Corporation [ g] STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS FOSSIL • REHEAT • CONDENSING • 3-PHASE • 60 HER1Z • 3600 RPM SCOr,E OF SUPPLY TURBINE AND STAN[>ARD TURBINE ACCESSORIES l 3. Automatic Turbine Tester (A TT) wlth: a. Valves/Protective d~, ices test selector with indi- cating tights. b. Individual atop and control valve test program sciector with indicating lights. c. Remote solenoid trip test program selector with indicating lights. d. Over$peed trip test progr~m selector with indicat- ing lights. •· Thrust-bearing trip test program Nlector with indicating lights. f. Visual display of program steps, criteria failures and common alarms for above tests. 4. Thyristor Voltage Regulator (TVR) ....-ith: a. Generator field current indicator. b. Reference setter for channel1 (auto) and 2 {auto/- manuaf) with deviation indicator. c. Automatic and matching contror mode selector with indicating lights. d. Exciter field breaker open/closed. •M. TURBINE-GENERA TOR SUPERVISORY INSTHI..IMEN- TATION (TSI) SYSTEM 1. Microprocessor based data acquisition system (CAS) to evaluate, display and retri~e long and short-time storage for: a. Real·time information of actual data, trend graph- ics and alarm conditions. b. Instruction messages to the operator for manuel cpntrol. c. Paging capability t~r display of systems and/or variables as selected by the operator. 2. Sensing equipment for: a. Absolute and relative shaft vibration. b. Absolute bearing vibration. c. Differential and absolute expansion. d. Shaft position at thrust bearing. e. Shaft eccentricity. f. Control val\'e position (Item ft7). •REVISED SINCE LAST EDITION fiRINTEO IN U.S.A. g. Temperature and pressure-sensing equipment lir;ted under other systems. 3. Vibration phase-angle meter and selector switch, including shaft mounted reference detector and fequired circuitry. 4. Free-standing cabinets containing analog iolid- atate and microprocessor based circuits, groun('ling provisions. alarm contacts for monitoring internal failures, etc. Including: a. Alarm contacts for indication of ex~ssive abso- tute shaft vibrations, expansions and shaft posi· tion. b. Analog signals for Purchaser's computer. c. Local indicators mounted at the amplifier face for M.2.a, b, c. d and e. 5. Recorders for mounting in Purchaser's control room for vibration, expansion, eccentricity, turbine metal temperatures a\"ld beiering metal temperatures, in- cluding one yrJ4r'l-supply of paper. 6. Colored CP. r·and teleprinter for mounting 'n Pur- chaser's cuntrol room. 11 N. TURBINE PROTECTIVE DEVICES - " ..... 1. Emergency trip devices including: a. Two mechanical-hydraulic overspeed trip de- vices with alarm contacts and provisions for local manual testinQ. b. Two-channel vacuum trip system with pressure transducers and pre-trip alarm. c. Two thrust bearing faHure trip devices: one mechanical-hydraulic de~tice with alarm contacts, and one electrical system derived from shaft posi- 'iion measuremen! with pre-trip alarm. d. Two remote trip solenoids and alarm contacts. e. Two-channel low lube-oil pressure trip system with pressure transducers and pre-trip alarm. «. High abaolute ahaft vibration trip with pre-trip alarm. · g. Manual trip devices at front of turbine with alarm contactaanl.1 remote trip pushbutton on turbine control panel, 2. Load Rejection Relay (lRR) for fast control valve closure mounted in cabinet. Superaedes Page Dated Aug. 1,1978 ( ! r ( ( ':1 ' .I ' ·' .. 'lr ; ". 'I ~ '-\ 'I f l 'I l ~ l :'l I I I l l I l i I l t ! ~·I I l l J l lr I l t-l ! f I I I I l I I I l I ··3] I, ~,11 ! I I. l ! l I i r I I ,. ;j . l""g"1 Utility Po'\\-'er CorporatiOil ~,. :. STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS FOSSIL • REHEAT • CONDENSING • 3-PHASE e 60 HERTZ • 3600 RPM SCOPE OF SUPPLY TURBINE AND STANDARD TURBINE ACCESSORIES •p. POWER SUPPlY 12 PAGE7 OCT. 1,1982 3. Atmospheric relief diaphragms mounted in each LP turbine outer cDsing. •· Three separate pressure switches actuatr,d by a hydraulic relay to operate Purchaser's extraction Free-standing cabinet(s) with power supply for all turbine-generator electronic control systems with lnputs from: non-return valves. 1. Permanent magnet genel'ator (PMG}. •o. TURBINE MONiTORING EQUIPMENT 2. Pufchaser's single-phaso or three-phase a--c power supply bus. 1. Gauges to indicate locatly: a. Main oil pump discharge pressure. b. Control fluid press~rws. c. Lubricating oil pressure. d. Shaft lift cH pressure. e. Sealsteom pressure. 2. Remote indicators for mounting in operating control panels including transducers for: a. Main steam pressure. . . b. Reheat ~team pressure. c. Turbin~enerator kW toad. 3. Dial-type thermometers to indicate locally: a. Control fluid t~mperatures at inlet and outlet of fluid coolers. b. Temperature of oil ~aving combin~d thrust and journal bearing. c. Temperature of oil leaving each main journa' bearing. d. Oil temperatures at inlet ar.d outlet of oil coole\'"S. ~-Thermocouples to measure: a. HP and I P turbine and val~ casing metal tempera- tures. b. Thrust bearing metal temperaturs. c. Journal bearing metal tem~ratures. d. Exhaust hood temperatures. •· Oil temperatures at inlet and outlet of oil cool~rs. t. Fluid temperatures at inlet and outlet of control ftuid coolers. 5. Digital speed indicator (D-4200 rpm). 6. Position indicating lights 'or stop valves and over- •P" .1 trip bolts. •REVISED SINCE LAST EDITION flfi'INTEO IN U.S.A. •a. ELECTRICAL JUNCTION BOXES NEMA 12 boxes mounted at the equipment and/or at various accessible locations adjacent to the turbine- generator to which electrical instrumentation and con- trols are wired. •R. THERMAL INSULATING MATERIAL For installation by Purchaser on HP and IP turbines, valves and strainer casings, seal steam condenser, and on all steam piping supplied with the turbine, in accor- dance with PowerCorp specifications, including the following: 1. Reusable blankets for the barrel-type HP turbine. 2. Scored block insulation for tP turbine, main and reheat valve bodies, strainer casings, end seal steam condenser. Reusable blankets or reusable block insulation for flanged joints, expansion joints and connections. 3. Pre-formed pipe insulation with ei'ther fabric or aluminum jacketing for piping furnished with the turbine. S. TURBINE METAL APPEARANCE J..AGGING For enclosing HP and IP turbin~s installed indoors. with sound·absorption material applied on all inside surfaces. Embedded support plates to be supplied by Purchar..er. T. TURBINE SUPPORT ACCESSORIES Foundation plates, shims and subsole plates. guide keys, ~s required, to set and align turbine. •u. BARRELo.rYPE TURBINE FIXTURES (One set per station with duplicate units) 1. Special assembly an,1 disassembly device for breech lock. 2. Special jigs for disassembly and assembly of HP turbine rotor and inner and outer casings including: Supersedes Page Dated Aug. 1, 1978 ·..:_:j· ; I 'I 1 I J 1.2 ,. ' ~· ' - !'Jit Utility Power Corporation l... g ..I 1 ! I ·:1 (PAGEl I CT. 1,1112 STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS FOSSIL e REHEAT e CONDENSING e 3-PHASE • SO HERlZ • 3600 RPM i I I ' ~~~ Jl 1 :.:1. ;. I , I II i !I .<.I j I .1 I ( l ' I . 'r { . i I I I I I I. 1 .. · SCOPE OF SUPPLY TURBINE ANC1 STANDARD TURBI.NE ACCESSORIES . a. Centering rings to lock HP turbine rotating and atationary parts to one another both axially and radiaUyo b. Ey~hook bolt-in extension for HP tur}lne rotor. c. Four-point supporting fixture for HP turbine. V. MAINTENANCE EQUIPMENT 1. One set of lifting slings and one lifting bearD (one set per station with duplicate units). :t. Special tools and wrenches (maximum of two sets per station with duplicate units). 3. Steam atrainer removal devices (one set per station with duplicate units). .--w. MANUALS -.. Maximum of twenty-five (25) copies of each of the following manuats (one set per station with duplicate ..nita): 1. Turbine operating instructions. 2. Generator operating instructiot.i. 3. Turbine-generator maintenance. 4. Renewal ;=rts. "X. SEISMIC RESTRAINTS Special a.eismic restraints forturbine-generatorequip- mentare not included. Where required,such restraints are to be applied by Purcha~r and suitable attachment provisions will be made where feasible. SCOPE OF SUPPLY GENERATOR AND STANDARD GENERATOR ACCESSORIES GENERATOR The synchronous generator is totally enclosed witt water-cooled stator winding, hydrogen-cooled core suspended in spring cage, hydrogen-cooled rotor winding and rotor damper winding system. •a. TERMINAL BUSHINGS 1. Six water-cooled high-voltage bushings with air- end terminals. 2. Two bushing-type current transformers per bushing (total of twelve) with c-800 felaying accuracy and 0.382 metering accuracy. Provisions for installation of one additional current transformer per bushing. •c. INSTRUMENT AT ION 1. RTO's on hydrogen coolers for gas inlet and outlet temperature indication. 2. Alarm thermostats for cooler gas inlets :nd vi.id""ts. .3. Thermocouples for cooler gas outlets. •· ~ermocouples for bearing metal temperature. 5. Liquid monltora to detoct possible liquid leakage in generator cuing and terminal bushing box. 6. Six RTO's In stator alots. 7. One thermocoJJple on each stator coil water ouUel 1. Terminal boxes wtth terminals for RTo·s. thermo- atats, thermocouples, etc. •REVISED SINCE LAST EDITION _...IHT'~ IN U.l.l\. .. ···r S. Generator conditio~ monitoring sy!Jtem. 10. Shaft vibration sensors. "0. SEAL...OIL SYSTEM 1. OM seal-oil unit assembled on a common base including: Hydrogen Side: a. Seal-oil tank with t*·~ tow oil level detectors and local level gauge. b. One seal-oil pump with a-e motor. c. One pressure relief valve for seal-oil pump. d. One seal oil cooler with 5/8" 00 18 BWG min- Imum 90-10 CuNi or Admiralty metal tubes de- signed for a cooling water temperature of ss• Fat a pressure of 125 psig. e. Dual seal-oil filters with transfer valve . f. One control valve for seal-oil pump discharge 1nessure. Air Side: a. Two main seal-oil pumps with a-e motors. b. One back-up seel·-oll purrlp with c:f-c motor and starter. c. One pressure relief valve for each main and back- up seal-oil pump. Supersedes Page Dated Aug.1, 197o ( ( 0 ··~ ,,r l r~ I ! l J' ! 1.2 •• ·;I (PAGEl CT. 1,1112 Utility Power Corporation [ Q] STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS FOSSIL • REHEAT e CONDENSING e 3-PHASE • 60 HER1Z e 3600 RPM ;I 'I i '~ i ~· ···I· II I l II J ''l ll J 1 •1 .. ( I i I I l II 1l I t . ·. I I I 1 I I I I I ! I I. I I I f I j I, ( ll I~ . SCOPE OF SUPPLY TURBINE AND STANDARD TURBINE ACCESSORIES . a. Centering rings to lock HP turbine rotating and atationary parts to one another both axially and radially. b. Eye-hook bolt-in extension for HP turbine rotor. c. Four-point aupporting fixture for HP turbine. V. MAINTENANCE EQUIPMENT 1. One set of lifting alings and one lifting beam (one aet per station with duplicate units). 2. Special tools and wrenches {maximum of two sets per station with duplicate units). 3. Steam atrainer removal devices (one set per station with duplica~" units). -.. .~-w. MANUALS Maximum of twenty-five (25} copies of each of the following manuals (one aet per atation with duplicate units): 1. Turbine operating instructions. 2. Generator operating instructions. 3. Turbine-generator maintenance. 4. Renewal parts. "X. SEISMIC RESTRAINTS Special aeismic restraints forturbine-generatorequi~ ment~re not included. Where required, auch restraints are to be applied by Purchaser and suitable attachment provisions will be made where feasible. SCOPE OF SUPPLY GENERATOR AND STANDARD GENERATOR ACCESSORIES GENERATOR The synchronous generator is totally enclosed with water-cooled stator winding, hydrogen-cooled core suspended in spring cage, hydrogen-cooled rotor winding and rotor damper winding system. •a. TERMINAL BUSHINGS 1. Six water-cooled high-voltage buahlngs with air- ttnd terminals. 2. Two bushing-type current transformers per bushing (total of twelve) with c-800 relaying accur.scy and 0.382 metering accuracy. Provisions for installation of one additional current transformer per bushJng. •c. IP~STRUMENTATION 1. RTO'a on hydrogen coolers for gas inlet and outlet temperature lndh:ation. 2. Alarm thermostats for cooler gas Inlets and outlets. ~. Thermocouples for cooler gas outlets. 411&. ~ermoeou~!es for bearing metal temperature. 5. Liquid monltot'l to detect possible liquid leakage in generator cuing and terminal bushing box. 6. Six RTO's In stator alots. 7. One thermocouple on each stator coil water ouUet. . I. Terminal boxes wtth terminals for RTD'a, thermo-- atats, thermocouples, etc. •REVISED SINCE LAST EDITION PRINTED IN U.S.A. G. Generator condition monitoring sy~~t~m. 10. Shaft vibration sensors. -D. SEAL.OIL SYSTEM - 1. One aeal-oil unit assembled on a common base including: Hydrogen Side: a. Seal-oil tank with two low oil level detectors and local level gauge. b. One seal-oil pump with a-c motor. c. One pressure relief valve for seal-oil pump. d. One seal oil cooler with 5/SH 00 18 BWG min- '.mum 90·10 CuNi or Admiratw metal tubes de- signed for a cooling water temperature of ss• Fat a pressure of 125 psig. e. Dual seal-oil filters with transfer valve. f. One control valve for seal-oil pump discharge pressure. AJr Side: a. Two main seal-oil pumps with a-e motors. o. One back-up seal-oil pump with d-e motor and starter • c. One pressure relief valve for each main and back- up aeal-oil pump. Supersedes Page Dated Aug. 1, 1975 ( ( i j I l ,.,, I :1 ! I l I .. (( I. ,, I I I I ';' I I~( I l k . ..1' !; •• . Co. • l""g"l· Utility Power rporat1on ~ AI 12 STEAM TU:RBINE -GENERATORS FOSSIL • REHEAT e CONDENSING • 3-PHASE • 60 HERTZ • 3600 RPM f:'AGE I OCT.1, 1882 SCOPE OF SUPPLY GENERATOR AND STANDARD GENERATOR ACCESSORIES d. Two ~lfferential-prelfure regulating valves for Mill-oil pressure ecntrol. -· a. Two 1 00~ eapac!ty Hal oil coolers with 518" 00 18 BWG minimum 9D-10 CuNi or Admiralty metal tubes designed for a cooling water temperature of es• F at a pressure of 125 psi g. and manual transfer valves. f. Duplex seal-oil fitter with manLaal transfer valves. Common to Hydrogen and Ait' Side: a. Check valves and ahutoff valve-s. b. Piping and fittings. excluding vent piping. 2. VatYe rack. L Two differential pressure regulating valves for hydrogen side seal-oil pressure control. b. One differential pre-ssure regulating valve in by- pass tc orifice. c. Piping~ check and ahutoff vat\'el. 3. Degassing tank with low oil level detec:tm. 4. Two oiVhydrogen v•apor exhausters with a-c motors, and one pressure transmitter. 5. lnstrumenl.ation. a. Four pump discharge pressure gauges ant1 pres· sure switches. b. One oil pressure gauge, one pressure transmitter and two pressure switches for air side seal ring inlets. c. Two differential pressure gauges for oil pressure difference between hydrogen side and air aide IM!aloil. d. One pressure gauge and pressure transmitter in each air aide si~nal line. e. One pressurtJ gauge in generator casing pressure signal line. f. Differential pressure indicators with alarm con- iacts for hydrogen and air •ide aeaf-oil fitters. g. One .pressure gauge for air aide ... 1-oilsupply. h. One pressure gauge for hydrogen side aeal on atpply. i. Two ... 1 ring relief oil pr8$Sure gauges. J. Four oil temperature RTO'a after teal-oil coolers. k. Four thermometers in oil inlet and outlet tines of ... J-oil coolers. •REVISED SINCE LAST EOJ7'10N PfUNTEO .. U.S.A. I. Two generator preehamber high liquid level de- tectors. m. Two oil temper1sture RTO's in generator pre- chamber. n. Flow meters in air aide, hydrogen side seal-oil and ual ring relie1f oil circuits. · 6. Miscellaneous. a. NEMA .. 12 junction boxes for oil electrical con- nections except for motors. b. All required piping between generator and seal- oil unit. Pipe hmngers. IL1pports and vent pipes not included. E.. HYDROGEN COOLERS Four vertical hydrogen cooleftt, located in the genera- tor casing end seetion(s), with 5/8 .. 0018 EiWG min- Imum 10-10 copper-nickel or Admiralty metal finned tubes designed for a cooling water tem-.,..erature of es• F at a pressure of 125 psi g. •f. GAS 0YSTEM 1. t')ne hydrogen/carbon dioxide supply unit consist- lt\g of: a. C02/H2 purity transducer. b.. Fan differential pressure gauge for H2 purity indication. c. One generator easing pressure gauge and one pressure transducer. d. Piping and fittings. Pipe hangers and supports not included. e. One NEMA-12 junction box for all electrical connections. f. Compressed air filter. g. Connection for Purch.eser's p·iping from central H2 and C02 gas supply includh"lg pressure regu- lator and gauges. 2. One gas drier with h1eater, thermostat and regenera~ lion blower including valve position awitch. 3. One hydrogen bottle manifold assembly. L' Bottle connectors with shutoff v•tves. b. Two pressure regulator& with gauges. c. One pressure gauge and pressure switch for bot- Ue pressure . Supersedes Page Dated Aug. 1'. 197.B : ' I I 12 ~· I I ~·it Utility Power Corporation l.. g ...1 c 'GE10 I I STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS REHEAT • CONDENSING • 3-PHASE • 60 HERlZ e 3600 RPM I I I I I I I ( I I f 1 ( . ' uCT; 1.1112 FOSSIL • SCOPE OF SUPPLY GENERATOR AND STANDARD GENERATOR ACCESSORIES 4. On' carbon dioxide bottle manifold assembly. a. Bottle connectors with shutoff valves. b. One pressure gauge to~ bottle pressure. c. One C02 flash evaporator with tteater. reiief valves. thermometer and RTO. S. One nitrogen bottle manifold assembly. a. Bottle connector with shutoff valve. b. Pressure regulator with gauge. c. Pressure gauge for bottle preuure. d. Flow meter. 6. Miscellaneous. All reQuired piping between generator. hydrogen/ carbon dioxide supply unit, gas drier and bottle H2. C02. and N2 mani1olds. Vent pipes, ~ipe hangers and supports not included. PRIMARY WATER SYSTEM Demineralized \."'later-cooling system for a generator with water-cooled stator winding. conn~or ~·d~•l"!d terminal bushing:.. 1. Primary water •upply unit mounted on t:ommon base including: a. Two 1~pacity circulating water pumps with a-e motors. b. Main filter. c. lon exchang~r. d. Fi1ne mesh filter. e. NEMA-12 junction box for all electrical connec- tions except motors. f. Check and shuta.ff valves. g. Make-up water fitter. 2. Primary water cooler untt with three 50%-capacity coolers with ~-OD 18 BWG nninimum copper or 10-10 CuNi tubes, design0d fc1r a cooling water temperature d' es•F at a pressure o1125 paig. 3. Primary water tank with 'water ktvel sight gauge mounted on top of generator with connections for waste gas ayst~m. •· NaOH injection unit 5. Waste gas pressure regulator. 6. StraineD at inlet and outlr ;.;f staten eoil. •REVISED SINCE LAST EDITION Pf.UN'Tt:.D IN U.S.A 1 I .I . "' - 7. Sight glasses in bushing circuits and waste gas ayatem. I. All required piping (stainless steel) between genera- tor, primary water suppl~ unit, cooler unit. and valve raek. Vent pipes, drain pipes, pipe hangers and sup- porta not Included. I. Instrumentation includes: a. Two conductivity measuring sensors: one in main loop, and one in lon exchanger circuit. b. Four metering orifices for primary water flow measurement. emf: ln stator outlet and three in bushing outlets. c. Eight flow transmitters with indica~ors. two at sta· tor outlet and six at bushing f)Utlets. Cl. Flow meter in I on exchanger circuit. e .. Two water pressure gauges and two pressure switches for pump discharges and one pressure gauge and transmitter for stator inlet. f. Six RTO's, four in the stator ;inlet, one in stator gMt!~1 •!'lrj ()~~ ~n ~M~hing outlet. . g. One primary water tank level monitor with low and high level alarm contacts. h. Differential pressure transmitter to indicate pres- sure drop across main and fine mesh filters. l. One dial-type thermometer for measuring prim- ary water temperatL.Jr~ in, stator coil inlet and one in common termint,;;• t :..shing outlet. J. Flew meter for mak.e-up water. k. Waste gas pressure gauge and switch. I. One differential pr~uure transmitter for primary water pressure drop in stator winding. caH. MOTOR DRIVES 1. All motors are totally enclosed fan-cooled with a •rvice factor of 1.15 and Class B insulation. They are equipped with grounding provision, drain de- vices, thermostats, apace heaters and oversized sauketed conduit boxes. 2. Standard a-c motors are rated 3-phue 460 volts ± 101!11 for continuous operation and are capable of starting and accelerating at 7S'Mt rated voltage. 3. f.;tand~rd d-e motors sr~ rated either 120 or 240 volts er.d are capable of operating with a± 1St;, voltage wriation . Supersedes Page Dated Aug. 1. 1978 ( ' \) f ( ··=r I I I I I I I I I I II I I \ \'l I I, ... ( ( ( I ll!"g"l Utility Power Corporation ~""!Jill 12 STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS PAGE 11 FOSSIL • REHEAT • CONDENSING • 3-PHASE e 60 HERTZ • 3600 RPM OCT. 1,1182 -=- SCOPE OF SUPPLY GENERATOR AND STANDARD GENERATOR ACCESSORIES -a. GENERATOR PROTECTION EQUIPMENT S. Signals for Purc;haser's use consisting of: 1. Trips with pre-trip alarms for: a. High liquid level In generator terminal box. b. High absolute generator/exciter ahatt vibration. c. Rotor ground fauiL d. Generator runback failure. 2. Runbacks with alarms for: L Low primary water flow in 1tator circuits. b. Low primary water flow in bushing circuit&. c. High primary water temperature downstream of coolers. d. High hydrogen temperature. •,j. GENERATOR AUXILIARY CABINET (GAC) Control and supervisory NEMA 12CV cabinets for the generator and for the hydrogen. primary weter and aeal oil supply systems including: 1. Control circuits with control •witches and on/off indicating lights for all motors and heaters (a--c motor starters not included}. 2. Supervisory c;ircuits with front panel-mounte,1 indi- cators for: L Percentage of C~ In air arad H2 In C02. b. Hydrogen purity. c. Hydrogen pressure. d. Primary water conductivity in main circuit. e. Primary water conductivity in lon exchanger circuit. f. Primary water flow in stator and terminal bush- ings. S. Supervisory circuits for liquid level alarm in: a. Generator terminal box. b. Generator housing. c. Generator Hal oil tank, degassing tank and prechambers. d. Primary water tank. 4. Annunciator. including alarms from generator auxil- iaries, seal-oil, gas and primary water ayatems (a-e and d-e alarm homa for external mounting included). -REVISED SINCE LAST EDITION ~Ta) IN U.s.A.. a. Analog signals for Items 2b, c. d and e. b. Alarm contacts for the following: (1) Items 2b, c, d, e and f. (2) Items 3a, b and c:. · (3) GAC failure. (4) A-c: and d-e power supply failure. (5) Items In J.4. 6. Space heaters. 7. Interior lighting and ecnvenience outlets. •te. MISCEl.LANEOUS 1. Sole plates, 1hims and, if req~tirect, sub-sole plates. Su"port plates for lagging not included. 2. Removab .. lagging from center line to floor. 3. Four generator frame grounding pads and shaft grounding brushes. 4. Terminals for testing bearing and seal ho:o~sh.i) insulation. L MAINTENANCE ~QUIPMENT 1. Necessary equipment for assembling the rotor into the armature (one set per station with duplicate units). 2. Special devices for installing end shields, bearings and sh1.f1 seals (one set per station with duplicate units). 3. lifting slings for generator rotor (one set per station with duplicate units). 4. Special tools and wrenches (maximum of two sets per station with duplicate units). •M. SEISMIC RESTRAINTS Special seismic restraints for turbine-generator equip- men\ are not included. Where required, such restraints are to be applied by Purchaser and suitable attachment provisions will be made where feasible. Supersedes Page Dated Aug. 1, 1978 n#"'T Hi ritz¢ 13ft' m hi I -:: ( I PAGE1~ ( JCT. 1, 1112 Utility Power Corporation [ Q)] STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS FOSSil • REHEAT • CONDENSING e 3--PHASE • 60 HER1Z • 3600 RPM ( SCOPE OF SUPPLY BRUSHLESS EXCITATION SYSTEM AND STANOARO AL:CESSORIES •A. EXCITER Cold air temperature thermostat provided· for emergency louver control. c Mounted on a common base plate Including: 1. Shaft-driven permanent magnet generator to excite the main a-e exciter field through a thyristor voltage regulator and provide power aupply to the control aystems. 2. Shaft-driven a-e main exciter with a rotating arma- ture and stationary field winding including special coils for sensing the main generator field current. 3. Rotatihg rectifier wheels with silicon diodes, re~il; tance-capacitive circuits and fuses with viaual fail- ure indicators. •· Sole plates including shims and. If required, aub- aole plates. 5. An exciter shaft-mounted fan for the closed-circuit air cooling system with two coolers having finned 10-10 copper-nickel or Admiralty metal 18 BWG tubes, Muntz metal tube aheets and ateel water boxes and designed for 95e F cooling water at a pressure of 1l5 psig maximum. 6. Insulated pedestal bearing(s), including Insulated oil fianges. 7. One exciter housing mounted over the rectifier wheels, main a-c ttxciter, pilot exciter, air coolers, with the following features: a. Motor-operated louvers for admitting and dis- charging ambient air for emergency cooling. t'. Observation windows. f.:, Doors with locking devices at the end of the hous- ing for access to all parts of the rotating exci1a- tion system. d. Set of internal lights, awltches and convenience outlets. e. Make-up air fitter(s). 8. Junction boJt ~ exciter base. e. Slip rings, brush holder assembly and bruahes for continuous rotor ground fault detection. 10. Instrumentation a. Duplex RTO'a and thermostats for main exciter c:o4d air temperatures, f'Nlinexciter hot air tempera· tures and rKtifier wheel hot air temperature. ~REVtSED SINCE LAST EDITION PRINTED tH U.S.A. ·me' t ,_ l --~ b. Thermocouple !or exciter bearing metal temper- atures. c. Shaft and beariflg housing vlb~tion sensors. d. Portable stroboscope for diode fuse inspection. •a. THYRISTOR VOlTAGE REGULATOR (TVR) 1. TVR cabinets containing solid-state electrical con- trol circuits for 2 channel automatic and manual control, breakers, contactors, 1\larm contacts for monitoring failures, power supply connections, grounding provisions, etc., including the following: a. Power supply for thyristors from pilot exciter with under voltage supervision. b. Three draw-out type thyristor lets (two required for operation) each with pulse amplifiers and monitoring circuits, for exciting the main exciter field. c. Automatic 2 channel vottage regulator with: (1) Voltage measuring and control circuits. (2) Reactive current compensation. (3) R~motely operated, motor-driven reference setter. (4t) Overexcltation limiter. (5) Underexcitation limiter. (6) Field forcing limiter. (7) Field forcing protection circuit~. (8) Excitation buildup circuits. (t) V/Hz limiter. {10) Continuous matching of automatic channels 1 and 2. ·(1 1) Manu~! limitation of field forcing in ett~e of rotating diode or fuse failure. d. Manual excitation control cira.~its for operation during checkout and maintenance with remote motor-operated reference setter (from channet2) adjustable from zero to full load excitation. e. Gate control units for supplying firing pulses to thyristors including ltabilized power supply. t;~peraedes P'-01! Dated Aug. 1, 1978 ( -r-.. · . . ' ~[. ' ( I 1 I I I .. . I I I I I I I I I t: • •• ' ... ( , \ . -~ Ufility PowerCorporadon [Q] STEAM TURBINE-GENERATORS fOSSil • REH[:A.~ • CONDENSING • 3-PHASE e 60 HERTZ e 3600 RPM 12 PAGE 13 OCT. 1, U82 ·' ~COPE OF SUPPLY BRUSHLESS EXCITATION SYSTEM AND STANDARD ACCESSORIES . ;. f. Runback circuits (reactive load to minimum). D· Connections for Purchaser's 125 volts d-e battery supply for control of field breaker, power supply brttakers, etc. h. M:1in exciter field breaker and field discharge res- istor with two-r.hannel trip cystem with connec· tions for Purchaser's master trip signals, includ- ing de:oexcitation circuits for inverter operation of thyristors prior to main exciter field breaker trip. I. Field breaker closing circuits with speed inter· lock to prevent excitation below ss~ speed at start-up and automatic de-excitation when speed drops below~. •REVISED SINCE LAST EDITION fiiiUNTED IH U.S.A . j. &citer field current shunts. k. Input circuits for lower/rai~ commands from automatic synchronizer. I. Automation interface for closing field breaker. m. Analog signals for exciter and generator field cur1ent. n. Digital signals for field breaker position for Pur- chaser's LiJe. • • 2. TVR control panel for mounting in Purchaser's con- trol room • Supersede~ P~ge Dated Aug. 1,1978 0 ,. ~---............ ----T----···---=·-·· .. ··: .. _________ ....... ~-.. ··--------·----"'-----------····-----······ ·--~---------~--.. ---··--:-··---~ .. --::,-~·::r·;-· . . . -·"'~~ .... . \j ! l I . r 3. b) QUESTION ..--.--- \' ) The operation and maintenance (O&~J cost data developed for the APA/Harza review of O&M cost for Alaskan based coal-fired steam electric power plants. RESPONSE The information used to estimate the O&M cost for an Alaska based coal-fired power plant was derived from an analysis of the O&M costs of a number of 200 MW power plants in the Lower 48, since no comparably sized units are currently operating in Alaska. The information obtained .from this analysis of Lower 4\, units, which is presented in response to Question 3(d), was adjusted for Alaska conditions. The adjustments are also discussed in response to Question 3(d). Also consulted in developing the O&M cost estimate was a report prepared by the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), entitled "Operating and Maintenance Cost Survey of FGD Systems", (March 19 8 3) • This report, which surveyed the widely~varying O&M costs of FGD systems in coal-fired power plants, is provided as Volume III, Appendix 2 of this response. 9. 0 I,~ I . l l I ) . t: ', ' l 1 I J I I I I 3. QUESTION c) Documentation and detailed explanation of changes in environmental regulations which trqnslate into increased O&M costs for coal-fired plants between the time the application was filed and the submittal of comments on the DEIS. RESPONSE As indicated in the DEIS comments, increased O&M costs for the FGD system were due to ·the change in regulatory requirements between EPA's 1973 New Source Performance 'standards (NSPS) and the 1979 NSPS. At the time the Railbelt study was prepared (1982) , power plants designed to the standards of the 1979 NSPS were only commencing operation, hence experience-based data did not exist and O&M costs were based on the 1973 NSPS. Experience-based data were required for the new standards in order to estimate O&M costs, since O&M costs are dependent on the reliability of the new system and reliability could only be ascertained after o~~rating experience. 10 • ..... 1---····· ··'"='"''"'"'"'""'"'" ................... ~ .. t ...,. ___ , 1 I 1 1 I t ' ! I I I. 1 i ,i .l ,. ;I The basic difference between the two standards is inclusion of a minimum percent reductio..:: requirement of so 2 emissions in the new standard. The 1973 standard lim],. ted emissions to 1. 2 lb so 2 per million Btu of heat input... The 1979 NSPS regulat:ions now in effect require a m:LnimUt."l'l of 70 percent removal ~or all controlled emissions less than 0.6 lb so 2 per million Btu.. The major effect of the new standard has been to require so 2 emissions control on low sulfur coals which under the 1973 standard would not have required any so 2 control. ~he 1979 NSPS~/ also significantly strengthened the reliability requirements for FGD systems. The 1973 regulations permitted bypass of the FGD system during malfunction of portions of the system, hence permitting continued power plant operation. The 1979 requirments allow the utility to bypass the system only if the following are true: 0 The .systen1 has a spare FGD module; ·--·------·- ~I New Stationary Source Performance Standards; Elec·tric Utility Steam Generating Units, 44 ~· Reg. 33580 (J't.tne: 11, 1979). 11 .. ~~ : .I :: ;: ' (\ -~,1··· .~-::-:;·! ________________ ·~···-~-...... -. ......... ·--····-.... . '(:, . ...... _ .. -·····-··. ;:·--·-··--·-·--. ···-'"······-"·--· . -" ................ -::1 .... ---.·. . --:~r--.--. . ~-· .;)'· (_ ~ '. ' . . ' · .e twmsrr~rr ... , .. r. I I I 0 Enough modules are not available to treat the entire flue gas generated; I All available power is being used in the power pool or "grid"; and 0 Power cannot be purchased from neighboring I utilities. I Because of these greater reliability requirements, systems are not only more expensive, but are also being maintained to a much higher level than they were in I years prior to the 1979 requirements. I I I: 12. 11 ' , :i' I I I 3. I I I I I I I I I I I "-r--"--~---_ ----------------·-·-··-::····------. ' . ' I ,_J . . . QUESTION d) A copy of the detailed Power Authority/Harza analysis of O&M cost for coal-firsd power plants in other parts of the country, including identification of the plants considered and appropriate technical plant similarities or differences. RESPONSE The Power Authority analysis of O&M cost data for coal-fired power plants reviewed utility fixed and variable costs for 200 MW nominal units in the Lower 48 states, since there are presently no operational coal-fired power plants of this size range in Alaska. The basic selection criteria was to evaluate plants not only in the 200 MW size range but also to evaluate plants burning coal with characteristics ~imilar to Alaska coals. It was also considered desirable in the selection process to evaluate coal pls~ts w~tl1 ;i~ilar flue gas particulate and sulfur removal equipment. 13. ....... ·-r· " I I I I. I I I I. I I I I l 1 I I. I. ' l •i :I 1 I . I :1 I 't t ,~ I ,,f d I· ll t\ '~{ " ~I J! li l , l ;j if l As can be seen in the attached summary table (Attachment 3d.l), the plants considered in the evaluation were as follows: 0 0 0 0 0 0 Huntington #1 (Utah Power & Light) Parish Plant (Houston Power & L:i.ght) Southwest Plant (Springfield City Utility) Asbury Plant (Empire District) Dave'Johnson (Pacific Power & Light) Hawthorne # 3 (Kansas City Pow~~r & Light) Written responses from several utiLtties, which serve as examples of the survey material from which the O&M data were drawn, are attached (Attach.'nent 3d.2). The differences between coal plants ~urveyed and the hypothetical Alaska coal powerplant are discussed below. Plant Staff and Wages Because of the higher wage rate in Alaska ($36/hr) versus the average in the Lower 48 ($26/hr) , the cost of labor is significantly higher in Alaska. In addition, due to the remote location of the plants in Alaska (central interior or in the Beluga field) , staff 14. - I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I levels were based upon the high side of the survey to account for this remoteness. FGD System Maintenance Costs The FGD system maintenance ~osts are somewhat lower for the hypothetical Alaska coal power plant because of the larger staff employed full time at the power plant. By having a larger full time permanent staff, the cost of outside labor from different servica organizations is reduced. Landfill Disposal Costs A large majority o.f the plants surveyed by Harza-.Ebasco employ on site disposal of scrubber sludge and ash in evaporation ponds. Because a majority of the plants are in arid areas of the Western United States, evaporation can be counted upon for disposal of the sludge and ash. Recent power plant designs approved by the EPA and state authorities have required a more permanent solution to the scrubber sludge and ash disposal problems. This solution has taken the form of byproduct sale or providing-stabilized sludge landfills. Harza-Ebasqo developed costs associated with an environmentally acceptable approach to 15. "l - ---.1 r--·----·~·-··-·~·----···-~·----~--- <~, I I l I ~ I I I I I I I. I i "' I I I I I' i,l I jl ' «\ H l l stabilized sludge landfill operations. The concept employed is similar to that utilized at other stabilized sludge landfills in the utility industry. It consists of excavation of a ground area, installation of an impermeable barrier to protect ground water and the disposal of a blend of stabilized sludge (a mixture of scrubber sludge, ash and lime to act as a setting agent) , which resembles low grade concrete. Chemical Make-up Costs (Lime and Limestone) The cost for FGD chemicals is a widely varying cost factor between utilities in the Lower 48. As documented in the EPRI report CS-2916, (Appendix 2), the costs vary significantly in various parts of the country. Because there is no source of lime in Alaska, Harza-Ebasco developed the costs based upon discussions with Seattle, Washington firms. These costs reflect the high transportation charge for delivery to the Cook Inlet ($300/ton). In comparison, if the powerplant were located in Seattle, Washington, the annual cost for the FGD system would be approximately $230,000, rather than the $1,102,500 Alaska estim~te. 16. -r 1 J Precipitator and Baghouse Maintenance The survey showed that a much higher cost is associated I with particulate removal system maintenance than what was initially assumed by the Power Authority. This I higher maintenance cost is still the subject of review I by Harza-Ebasco. The data contained in the DEIS was derived from estimates prepared by original equipment I manufacturers' estimates received in telephone conversations. I Boiler Maintenance Costs The boiler maintenance costs reflected in the survey conform to the values obtained f.rom boiler manufacturers for their equipment. Phe number used was based upon the data obtained from tha manufacturers. I Coal Handling Eguipment Maintenance The costs used in the Harza-Ebasco estimate of coal I. handling equipment reflect data obtained by telephone I conversations with coal handling equipment manu- facturers. This estimate compares favorabley to that I found during the utility survey. I. Turbine Generator Maintenance Costs The costs used for maintenance of the turbine generator are derived from data supplied by the original 17. <~··~~~--·-· -·--·" ____ , -·---·-~--~..._....----~· <-~---.- I I .I . I -I I I I I ' ,; I I I 'I ... I I. 's I, fj ~ .t ;[ ' [ if t' l ttl H [ 11 _[ \I ,~ . -,! J l .)1 -I -- 0 . equipment manufacturers. This estimate compares favorably to that found during the utility survey • Other Costs (Cooling Tower, Water ~reatment, and Lubricant Costs) These costs were developed by contacts with original equipment manufacturers and averages of the utility survey. They are in line with the costs found during the survey. 18. l --------:----··-;--;----:::::f' ~~ I 1- (~ ! - ' I u ' 1 \ j fl!!!lll!!!!!ll ~ ~ ~ ~ .,_ Operating Characteristics Plant Rated Capacity (MW) ~ Coal HHV Btu/lb 0 No. Total Staff ° Fixed Labor Costs $/kWlyr 0 Plant Ht. Rate Btu/kWh 0 Sulfur in Fuel (~) ° Flue Gas Desulfuriza- tion Maintenance Cost 0 J.andfill Disposal Costs ° Chem. Makeup Cost Limestone 0 Pre~ipitator & Baghouse • Boiler Maint. Costs ° Coal llandling Equip. Maint. 0 Turbine/Gen. Haint. Cost • Cooling Tower Maint. Cost • Water Treatment System Costs 0 Lubricant Cost Utah P&L Huntington 11 415 MW 11,900 125'll 21.74 9,883 .5% $ 660,000!.1 $ 200,000 $ 330,000 $ 910.000 $1,100,000 $ aoo,ooo $ 350,000 $ 100,000 $ 300,000 $ 5o,oooV ~ ... .. ·--- SPECIFIC U'flLlTY REl'OR'fEI> DATA or.M COS'£ ESTIMATE BACKUP 200 MW COAL PLANT 1983 $ -- Houston P&L Parish Plant Springfield City Utilities Southwest: Plant Empire District Asbury Plant Pacific Power and Light D. Johnson Unit 13 570 MW 415 MW 200 MW 220 MW 8,600 12,000 n.5oo 7,800 100~/ 9a?_/ 4'12./ 90'!_/ 13.30 16.45 15.92 31.02 10,400 11,008 10,542 11,101 .5% 3.5% 5.4% .45% $ soo,ooo!/ $ 500 ,ooo!.l $ 50,000~~ $ 630,000!/ N/JiJ/ N/Al_/ N/!1:!-N/AJ../ $ 250,000 $ 200,000 $ 200,000 $ 400,000 $1,200,000 $ 700,000 $ 500.000 $1,150,000 $1,000,000 $ soo.ooo $ 625,000 $3,100,000 $1,030,000 $ 200,0006,9/ ... 277,000 $ 210,000 'l $ 400,000 $ 25~.000* $ 220,000 $ 3ao,ooo I $ 100,000 $ so.t~!.'O N/AY_/ N/ill $ 343,000 $ 100,00o!Q/ $ 140 ,ooo.!Q./ $ 420,0010 $ 5o,oooJ_/ $ so.ooo7/ $ so.ooo.:U $ 80 11 00:0~?./ $4,873,000~/ $2,880,000!/ $2,062,000 $6,370,000 $.87 $1.29 $i).62 • Total Maintenance Cost • Variable Maintenance Cost ($/MW Hr) $4,800,000~./ $1.45 $1.07 1llifliiii& ~ Kansas City rower and Light Hawthorne U3 235 KW 12,000 too.?-' 32.27 ll,949 3.0% $ 550 ooo!.l 'N//JJ $ 300,000 $ 900,000 $ 500,000 $ 200,0002/ ~ 400,00011/ 'r' N/~ $ 25\l,OOO N/A $3,100,000 $1.65 1/ 2/ 3/ 4/ 51 6/ 11 8/ 9/ Costs are annualited average per unit for scrubber, fans, ducts, and breeching on site where multiple ~its exiot. Costs are annual maintenance estimate for electrostatic precipitator only. Landfill is on-site with ponding; Haulage charges were reported under $SO,OQO annually. Staffing level is per unit average for reported plant total which is higher. Hourly rate averaged $26.00 with fring••· ·. 10/ ill Til Bottom ash/FGD sludge sold at $3.50/ton. Cost estimate is per unit average, otherwise reported per unit rating. Lube oil is for turbine and generator lubrication only; bolance of plant excluded. Individual unit estimate based on multiple units at one site. Pulverizers are ball mill type. Boiler and ~ooling tower water treatment c~-t only. Plant has once through cooling from lake at site. Average o&M cost estimates include Alaska labor rates and transportation costs. __. Adjusted Alaska Annual OlloM Costs 12/ 200 M'J 123 $59.80 $ 3'~5 ,895 $1,750,000 $1,102,500 $ 500,000 $1,345,921 $ 459,500 $ 257~000 $ 93,000 $ 130,000 $ 56,000 $6,303,240 $3.93 ~ rt P1 0 §' ro H ...., rt w OJ • 1:-' ~~. clU _ " u' f) 1 -.~ -:: k:lik ,, ------·" •' "-'" EXAr.fPLES OF REPORTED UTILITY O&M DATA -T -; :.:· --. --.. Attachment 3d~2 1 'j t J l ' I I ; f I I I I [ [ [ CITY UTILITIES of SPRINGFIELD 301 E. ()!ntr11l• P.O. Box 551 • Springfield, Missouri 658.')1 • (411) 831..s311 ----~~--------------------~----------------------------------- Mr. L. J. Becker Ebasco Services, Inc . • 400, 112th Avenue, N.E. Bellevue, Washington 98004 Dear Larry: July 24, 1984 We hope that the enclosed infor~ation will be of use in the FERC Licensing hearing for the Alaska Power Authoritv, Susitna · Hydror:l ectri c Project. Sheet #1, Items 1 to 9, specifically address your 0 & M cost evaluation concerns as per your request dated July 10, 1984. Item 10 and Sheet 2 address the additional areas of concern as per your dis- cussion with Bryan Brooker on the 19th of July. If further questions should arise and you feel we could be of assistance, please feel free to contact us. ml Enclosures Sincerely, h~ Dale Hicks, P.E. Superintendent Southwest Power Station I 7 I I I J I '! ' I I l I i 'i 1 I. 1 I ' ' I J .·'I I ' ) 1 I I o! I 1 I I I ! I i I ~ ·~ll 1: I! ):.1 ! J f i 1 [ ".t tj t ! ;j 'l I r f t •G ·-. I) P~NT CAP.ACJ:r.;(... -· -· 2.) ' 3j PLANT 11£/i:"'" P.~~ .. .::. • \ 4,' FGZ Sysr£/-f'~. ' c/ 1-1 A 7· E.::/f ;,r;.:.. ( /'/i.;: .-.f vi t.. ~ 1 c .J J)) Zil .S P~>~.t. 5). 7) ' 8) . , _.£ ou.Uf I~ /1111 ;. c t?S r .s _. (co;; .t. s .. ':!' i£1-" c.--~ .. r. c. ,.... .... -rc-_,_ ,__., 1~1W 195 150 lftJ so .!Hi ·Jc,:.. /./£":" , .Z ;-,.., . .J(y/H ) / - 1"~.677 ttJ e t5 , /~ 4.1:&:. , ~ .... .., /1', 6 J'O (t-1u.t.S/KV.I r' : o·soe C· 22.0 0 ·3 7€ o·e 3 z t·eaz _£ 5•:;.:;:, I L'r:. . "" &> • r7 ._ "'I ,-;-, /~ -,.I ,l., .,.. • I . ·- I I" I~ I I I I I I I '"-' I I I! --- ~ l. SvP&,P V/.S/c,-/ . • ------_.--.. -· ·---..... I BE~r ~&P~C£/".,GIVT. __ ... II 7F E.,/ OOD It I CJOO ~ ttfO 0 3/ 000 ZEf 74.3 . .. ___ .,.. ! I i --·--· ---·-···-.. ----...-I I I f "---.,._ ... ·---· ---.. --.. ·-·- ~A~ R MAI£"R/IrLS * Ca) (b) -. f 0 2 ~ I L_.! 't 6 0 .r ..,.,_cf ] 406 1 ';? 'f 3~ ¥ w/ --:-HE I/3JV£ 1/£/ .. f..S I·~ f 7 eli'/,&;.:.. s lfl£'1' Do Nt17 p tNf c 11 r.: .:. .£ ;;;; ;'.:,:; /0 l/,f , ' -if( o) "~~-e B ~l-r b) ;I-3 8Et:. T . S'., 0'00. 5e~7:1 ZJ"(;~ ?-7'/o)e 4-Pt..t, 60o p;w w1/J 'Jdi x 1/ti /VMHA . rite& lf.£SIS'T,-?IV7 COV.£/?. c.:;. ,. ,.. ,..P" __ -"·.., .-~.· .. ' -·······:·· ----········--····· --------~--"=1! I I I I I I I I I\ I. li I I 1: I I. I I I . PACIFIC POWER & LIGHT COMPANY 920 S.W. SIXTH A VENUE • PORn.ANO. OREGON 97204 • (S!Jl) 243-1122 October 31, 1984 Mr. Lawrence J. Becker &:asco Services, Incorporated 400 112th Avenue N.E. Bellevue, ~ 98004 Dear Mx'. Becker: In regard to yoor recent request for cost estimates relative to the operation and naintenance of a typical 200 1TW rated. coal-fired ~ plant, I've enclosed a surmary pi'O'Viding a break~ of the estimates for each of the requested areas. W:S:mjs Enclosure If you have any questions, please feel free to contaCt w. C. Brauer Manager, 'lbe:I:mal Staff I I I I I I I I .· 1) 'I\lrbine namepl::te -332 gr nw Net peak demand (1 hr) -347 net DW 2) A'\."erage errp1oyees -114 3) -Net heat rate (1983) -12,140 4) Retrofit FG:> system is scheduled for ~tion, in Deceni:er 1986. Cost projections are estinat.ed in 1983 dollars. a) Labor -0.20 mil 1 /kwh • b) Energy 0.07 " II - c) ~terial -0.01 II II d) Disposal -0.12 II " e) Chenicals -0.45 • • 5) $0.02/gal. 6) Air quality 0. 06 mill/kwh. 7} enit is ~pped with an air-ccoled ccnden.ser-0.03 mills/kwh. · Sl Boller mairrtenanee cost (for p.ll.verizer arXi fuel delivexy system only) W3.S 0.36 mill/kwh. 9) Tul:bine-generator maintenance cost was 0.13 mill/kwh. Unit is ove:x:hauled unde:r a sect.ionalized maintenance ~pt: therefore, a major/minor differet1tiation is not at=Pl icable. , DSS/10<-31-84 • • - . . •., :7~ ' ·d ,, I • !I I J} [1 L '1··--v:-,:r·~~-:···--·-·· -~ ... I , .. CUES'riON e) Documentation of the differences in labor rates and transportation and construction costs which contrib~+ed to the increased costs associated with the proposed coal plants. RESPONSE Construction Costs Cost estimates developed in the original reconnaissance level study were a conceptual level estimate. At that time, no allowance was m.ade for land and land rights costs, client chargesr tempo:r:ary or permanent transmission line costs, or access road costs in the construction cost estimate. Further, waterfront and environmental mitigation co~ts were understated. Material costs were generic in the reconnaissance study and were not ba5ed on vendor Ludgetary equipment quotations. In the subsequ•ent estimate, Harza-Ebas.:::o prepared brie-f t~chnical descriptions of the equipment and obtained budgetary q\lotations for thi~ equipment.. While these values tend to verify the validity of the estimate, 19. --·--r· ..... ,;·; -J , .... I l ) I l ] j I ·1 Jl I ''I II ll 1 . ·I I ·l l 1 I I I I ~~ I·· :.! .. : •1 I I; l . I j I )I I l ) ' ! 1 1.·. '! I c.-! ' ~I.} ' j l •t i l •' ,. ~· I(, f ' ~ L '! '! ( ! I ·' lJ . this remains a conceptual estimate due to the lack of site specific data and firm equipment quotations. Labor Costs The estimate for labor costs and labor rates was based on the construction manhours reguired for constructing similar size (200 MW) coal plants. The est~:ruated con- structicn manhot.'rs were then multiplied by the developed Alaskan union wage rat~c. In the original estimate, Alaskan labor rates for each craft lo.bor category, as summarized on the Power Authority's Susitna wage rate form dated December 17, 1981 (Attachment· 3e.1) were utilized. A revised labor rate analysis, documented on the Susitna wage rate form dated November 8, 1983 (Attachment 3e.2) was used to price the payroll costs of the updated estimate. In both cases, wage rates are based on actual union rates, as stipulated in union labor agreements and as gathered by the .Power Authori,ty in its survey of all relevant crafts. Contractor indirect costs were then added to complete installation costs to both estimates. 20. l ; I i '"·-···-.·.·-·-·~"··-~. --.]"' < '· '~· ' I ' Jlllj(&L f ·."J .. · l . I 'I·. ! Transportation Cost~ The added transportation costs are based upon barge crating of equipment for Alaska delivery~ This is reflected in the equipment costs and r~presents 1-2% of the cost. These added costs are an Ebasco Services estimate, based upon preparing 50 similar estimates for Alaskan clients over the last three years. Actual equipment quotations, as compared to costs in the :r.~ower 48, were also consideredo I IJ l ,_; t,, i ~ '• ·I ''_.1 21. .· - } ---..-..~---~ ---,···-~-~ --,,.~ ·-·-~~----··--~., ·~··-""'-""'"-,....-"'-·----,.~-- ~--------~-----·---~-----;____._.~--------~--. --~----------'l......-...------~-------------~ ·~ ............. ---... ---.__ ___ J --:--.. :a:• ............. ·-- ·~ ,, ... .:~~_.ifif.",.~~~~.~ I r f '' r,.,,. . (. .. .. ,\. fM·I•U --"' l!ll!i1.Aiil E!. W(lf /ltJ£!1MIT)' __ ACTIIl ---I .$11JitNt9 li£D. - •atU tNCl.UDit ron I!'"'" PI• lAUI PI• tMI g liJ n J ~SCAlAT£1 ---· ' t;t'l'lf'/ltY:{ if I J j( tilt'/-\:'{ TJ E'A' ,(!'i:!J. 1.~,.. / w,Kj If A 0 E . RA TE S . . . . . S\K,MCE • """·" GJ " ~ ,·; :· ' bl~nii~L~~~ OAU.t_f!_/1{/8/ ·,. ev • e. )":' 1-/l/ APPROV£0 , -/ br A~_cN~C'=' ,. CRAFT . I 8 O ,,~ . . :· 1,82 • · --~ . 198~ ~il-' t ···· · ··· · ···· ·r·-~-----~--- ' ~ -_LU I j I I I I I : I I I I I I ~ I I I I ! I I I I I i I I I I I c=l I I I I I I I LJ UIOIERI -.J-1 "J. I ~:1. ;1 I ::Mi~1 _ _ _ I -~Ta 7/, CAIPEIIT£1, · I :il~.1f-.!J.S.4fJ I .:JiJ .IS I .,_,, ~ i PilE ti11Y£1S · 1. .!J4.M ! · JIJ .sr 1 1 ,..._#,.14 1 -1-1.3(, O'fUAliP.t £1811££11~ j lfiYY _ . I J~. ~~ I 4k.~r I +7..1' . . M£18• , · I ~ .21-- ' I ~f.~ _ I ft.ID UIIIY ..k -'· r.st 1 .J9.'?.' 1 f.1.2!. 1 --3 '.ff ----1-----:/{"' 1 u:f} I ~~' ~CfM!EIT F8111Hi:ll lll~MICIA~ ~------~D~u~~~~~~-£--------~~~~~--~~--~--~~--+-~~~~~~~ IIOtiWUftU£15: • -I I n. Dl I .fl.:"•·'' " I I4S.6S I 1t. '1 STilleTUIAl I I I iiY.. d4 J ---. );.;. I, .. I +· 'fS.&I I 1t.· I; 1€1:~~~1111 I IM!LL•ta"Ts ---.-l-------~Ll1-----~-l----t-~~~·~----~---:~+~~~.v~'~----~--~ I .U.lt . IOIL£MWAI£1S _ PAIIIT£~;1:-.... -· I 7. An I dl'l I .,..,._.,~, iRUSM i .. -;t~~ . i ~~Tf. __ ~~--~~ 1S.61 SPRA\'. 'lfAMSllRS I I . ! ~-~ : ~~-~I I 'fZ. .,~, fiP£FitT~S . I .#6.6r --~;s a JI.SI"' -I tf.Z/ ~~m ,___. __ I ,n,6 r 1 "Oiji.u j ~.j'-~ I 1t·~~ ._I_!'IC.K ~).!'.!'' -I Jt.71 I .?if.~J" ~--I ft.IJ~ ~S~lSTOS : ~.~1 F' 11·~1 ~ ;::. _S1.f.!__._ ll -11 --~ r, ~~,. ' ;· j .,. ~~~-~.. . ., . . , . ~~-C• ''·'/ •• ( " . ' -·~ ', 1t ''-\ I -·!~·r.£_t Mf.T~.~ __ -~---,_ ~.f.-f7 • : r.., ~ r~ ~ , _f!.S/, 1ROOF£AS . i : :~~~: : : ~ :.84 . : : ~67 ~ I Sf.;,:. • I-' , ~ . ..;4--:7~· , ".,. ':;. >-*''"";/·,~:..~t: ,ltl..;;·~~"?.:~'¥5!"7 . !!' .. '~ "\ ·t·. ·~~~~.··.'P"':""' __ ., ---r~Jr~~~'Jt~~-, -;?lf~~~~;M~~~ .. , I ·~ -~ J} '.I ,'I i" . ' 1 1: .. " '~ ~r~ ",1l l l __ ,_·-.... ~ .. ' •f . j.l ,···~· _:f. h; " L I I· -· I ,. 1 . · ..• P ,, l. --, .. r-. . . . , ~,-"~ I ,r:'' . 'I ILl ..... . t ;;:;2.;._ l .... ~~:·--1 ' . ,--,,_.....,__, :·, -~ • i)~. '= ,: ,;i~ "'>:it!'· :~f~' .:~~-·' -., J··; . c: -. . ---~ ~.; ···) !J .. _,_". - - I -~~ ' ' f \ . . •.. . . ' . - ... -... l ; li '•••,;;£"· ._ IIIII .;;~. ~ -~~--,--·:. -r 1 ~--,~ .. ~ 'iitf··. •. _·· ... ,V" /ll'''l•.:. ~"''''I.-/?Afc'.!. · 1i'· .. " ·.·::r;~ 1/P/i £~('/1t!'=7·~~·J -'·liTe ~~ ,.·_ -~1 ~: -~- A/0 71(',}tiC.L. ~IIG$1$ Tlfi</C. J" l'~f~ ' , A.t.A.S/<19 UTU INCLUPII 11-t-3 3 ":~.· ;_, ~ -~~·····---··· ·~·-· ·--. -~~ ---._ -... ;; . ' ' .· . . . j,~'~k~; <;. ..b {.,/ UA' •,v,.f\1 v ~A. {,L/t:; c.; ":-r .tH•li•JJ .f(!Jr@ ~::?.?r't.le·p it) EACJ.' 1/0el/(!. OT. F/lcro:·{:'.£0 ·- - FOIIUUN OAT£•. ~ l ,_'· ( 1: .. (G£.'YE8AL. -MJCD OF AcJC.tt'Jf\A~i) ''" 'uu 8 • ,?!.JJ( • 1 ------·"' " (J /NTO HtJU~i{."y : ~Y·~ ,.~C,.fUA! .. :.;:_ !ffl TE c _ _z_. ESCALAT~r;\---= P/11 ONI y • 1 l ~ : 1-Z~/1 ~/Jr(y/_ WAGE. RATES n 1 NOll APPROVED t ~ · l C I) . SOURCE a I*= --J /?BY CNAfT r-~----~·u~~~-------+------~~~------~----~~~--------~----~~~ l--------t"2'---------·~ ~~ JJ!.__._..II.....&....A..;~~~~-'--I__._...I......IL.-L~~-1-JL-L.....I..-L-L-'-L-L~J-L:-L-.L..L-1-.L...L-1-~_L UIOIEIS ' ., . ..e.___.. Si•·IO/ ,t.53 -·---1 • ' ' ,1·--·----.J:..a ........... llil ................ ________ L.-.~-.Jii...-... a-L-.-..-..----.... ~----------..--..-.JI ......... C11Pf:IITEII 'IJ,(,' :L _. ·-_ o/~_!1~ ~~--_L ____ ~9·_~_J ____ _l ___ 5~_0_!/, ____ L .5'7,~3 ~ ,.L£ DIIVEII ••• 1 1 1/J. ~J-J.·.::.:-~Jz_-:.-:.--:.L..-:.-:.~~-=----J.---~3.:.~~---·.;-.:..e~-~ l OP£1ATIII IIIIIEEIS: , If,,/~ t:!;.:l-!:_,,,._J. ___ ,.I'i,;,!e ___ d ___ ~;,!'f!. ___ _,, .:~t.~J .;;....j Hf:AVY Lj{,,/,1.. 9, 35' 5~.8() .$-1.,.50 60. «,4~ ... _ ~~-- II :~... -7:::::.. C: ~:;~ ~---$~~---L.--~~~----..1---·;;fl:!:; ____ L.,.a:.~-~ l_. ______________ j_ __________ _l ______ .. CENEIT fiiiiNEI9 4t£Jt:ll I ___ ,_ _________ L __ _ .L..---~~i~---J....5.2·~Z:.- J..---Z.Z:il!..---.1.-'~.:.~--- li1 EUCTIICIAIS '•IK-"~./11Nlr51DI' 4t.03 .1 ~f',i,3 _L __ St1,o3 ~?iYl? itl ~ IVeC '£;!'1'PWirJC.S 2 .BP-9J I I 9't7" ¥0 IAONWIIAK.~/IS J REIMA.. . so.s5' L -·-5"--.O_F]_ 1 57,17 j ______ .... 6/,7d,_ ___ l ,,,ilb I ITIUCTUIAL r r 50·5~:.. '·----~L----1..---~w_ ___ ..... ___ .:t:~.:z.:c.-.:..:.-.::l::..!rd,s._, MILLWI18HTS !1_5.7.~ 1 ___ ¥8_._t£. ___ _t_ ___ 5~,3.§._ ____ L._ __ .fi..'f .. l2£ ___ _,_J,2=.J.l._ IOIUINAKEIS I i q~,~O 1 __ 4_/_~"S~~ 3Z_ L---~~r_t_ ___ _l ___ ~:JJ_!i ___ L-~~~~- Jl~IA~N ------ J . U,.J_, ___ t.f:..ZP--~ 3 ~ ~ •, '---~~ ..1 hr ~nnw -mr~ 0 ::r I T£AMSTEIS I I ?'/.~ 7 ,J.__ .. ..,.:t;!.;.2.2.. ____ L __ .£.?:..?J ____ .J ___ ..E.f:.P.;2 . S'L/, '~ § . PirEFITTUS I I { 4'.7.0 I L t. ~]. S"' ~ ~I 0 ~ .s /. '16 ..a C_). 0 tt rt ~rn ltv~~~=~~=~~~ • IIICI NASOIIS . I I ' II,U.. ~ '';, I • N lsH~ETMETAL • 1/0.'Jb L 7'_~ 1 ~· H ~6.$3 J ___ ~!!.:.!.tZ.. ___ _j 6""3."1 __ ....., _______ ._-__ .._..-__________ ~ __ ._.. _______ ~ 5&·:18 .1.---~~:...V(-~---'---~_z_ ___ J. ___ .ff..J. ____ .J V..:.Z?.. $3.;3 3 L---.1!~1~--.;., _.;··----i.~.!L----L.---~!:£.§. ___ ~_,..2_ .. U! I ASI£STOS ~· IOOFEIS -v ..,._ ~ ... ~-...... ..-=--.- t...\ 6 ·----·~---------· \c ~ '' '' ,, .~-"?1 l. ' b ., < .;.· l "" t " I ., .... l i l l l. I } "-~ I I I I c ;:-, jl ~- .co, f •,' c) . "' tJ • . . 0 . . I I I ' ' I 1: I I I I. I' :' I fl. 3 .. QUESTION f) A copy of the studies and underlying data for the APA-Harza "review of auxiliary power requirements for coal fired power plants of similar size with similar equipmentn and "survey of similar operating units burning similar coal." The information should include identification of plants and units selected for both the review and the survey. RESPONSE A reviewl/ was made of the auxiliary power requirementE of the six coal-fired power plants listed below: Required Auxiliary Power Expressed as a Percentage Plant of Gross Plant Output Coal-Fired Reference Plant!/ 10% 400 MW Sub-bituminous Coal Limestone Electric Generating 10% Station ~ Houston Light and Power Company (2-750 MW Lignite Unit) nReview" and vv survey" are synonymous in the context of the quotations noted in Question 3(f). !/ Ebasco reference plant estimate, non-site specific plant developed for generic use. 22. '1 ,.1 .I "I ., ; ·~' 'I 1 I ., . j :i. I J t ~ I· f . i I I lr I f ~ ·. Clay Boswell Unit 4 -Minnesota Power and Light (500 MW Sub- bituminous Coal Unit) Killen Power Plant-2/ -Day·ton Power and Light (600 MW Bituminous Coal Unit) Somerset Plant -N.Y. State Electric and gas (625 MW Bituminous Coal Unit) Asbury Plant~/ Empire District (200 ~M Bituminous Unit) 6.4% 7.5% 11.0% 7.4% This review included power plants burning similar coal of a similar size or plants with FGD systems and with wet and dry scrubbers. There was not a separate study of the pl~nts performed. This review consisted of conversations with design engineers and power plant operators for the plants listed. The data on power pl~~ts varies significantly, due to the actual systems selected and the number of units at the station. For example, the Clay Boswell Unit 4 auxiliary power is lower than the average for other plants with FGD systems because the shared systems in the power plant are being supplied power by other units 5/ Does not have an FGD system. The energy load for FGD systems avera.ges approximately 2-3% for lime and limestone systems in the throw-away technology. The auxiliary lC>ad for wet scrubbers is 1-2%. 23. I I I J r L [ r ~ . I ~.~ 1.-,---~~ ---~~··~"\\'---·--·--·-; ~~-·-~·-·- ,, ' (e.g., make-up well water, coal handling systems, fire protection and sewage treatment, and so forth). An independent estimate of the auxiliary loads associated with a nominal 200 MW coal-fired power plant, including FGD, was made by Harza-Ebascc and is shown be: low: Auxiliary Steam Generator Turbine Generator Coal Handling System Ash Handling HVAC Systems and Lighting Circulating, Condensate, and Feedwater System Purr9s Miscell~neous Pumps Cooling Towe::, Wastewater, Make-up Water System Miscellaneous Equipment Total Power ~equirement 5,500 kW 250 kW 1,000 kW 350 kW 100 k~1 7,000 kW 1,800 kW 500 kW 500 kW 17,000 kW The total auxiliary power requirements shown above are 7.8 percent of the ~lant's gross outp~ This value of 7.8 percent is below the average of about 10 percent for the three plants (Reference Plant, Limestone and Somerset) for Hhich unshared FGD and wet 24. \) ~ i ! :1 -I , I ~I \,_ d i o,. I ~l .~! ~ I _-,'~r ···t• l ! , I 'l ~·I ·:I I! :~I ··~ ! 11 ll . l! ~~ '1' ~ '! l l! '. ! ·'i l . l l ! I l .J I, p ( 71 i t 'I I I I I ll I I r I' I' r r f f< ~ scrubber facilities are used. Since the design for the hypothetical alternative, coal-fired plant has .not been established, the value of 17 MW was used for plant heat rate calculations, (Set: r:esponse to Quest:ion 3(g)): because u~ing a low value for auxiliary power would yield a lower (better) plant heat rate and thus favor the thermal plant in a comparison with the Susitna Project. 25. (• ,, ' j _,; i' j, f I' c n i o' I ~i q l l I~ ! l i j i <I l 'l I' ' ,l ~~ I I i ,. cl 'l f I" l f • ~· j \. j n !I ~ 3. QUESTION g) Dat.a to substantiate how the coal quality and changes in auxiliary power :requirements effected a heat rate change from 10,000 Btu/kWh to the 10,300 Btu/kWh used in the APA revised analysis of Susitna. RESPONSE As ~oted previously, the basis for the License Application was the Railbelt electric power alternative study. Because this was a reconnaissance level study, an approximation of the heat rate was made for a plant of this type. In the DEIS comments analysis, actual calculations were perfo:r_-med based upon ·the turbine generator performance, coal quality and auxiliary power requirements. Tl:..e coal quality found in the Railbel t report was a · general analysis for Alaska coal~ This analysis is found below: I I I I l I ~ 'j 'l .. I .. ''! 1: \ f \ J \ '1 :~ { " I .. ~ ., f • ' I ,. - 1: I I r j ~I l! ! ll. n I }> n ii ! f \ Heating Value 8,000 Btu/lb Ash Content 8-11% Moisture 28% Sulfur .2% Nitrogen .6% Ash Softening Temperature Solium in Ash 0.1% Hardgrove Grindability Index 30. In the DEIS comments, Harza-Ebasco performec combustion calculations based upon more detailed analysis of Beluga and Nenana field coal. The detailed coal quality analyses are set ft.:>rth in Attachments 3g. 1 and 3g. 3. Analyses of the resultir.1g boiler efficiencies are found in the combu~tion calculations attached to this response (Attachm~nts 3g.2 and 3g.4). Line 30 of these attacrunents provides the boiler efficiency for burning the coal specified. For Beluga field (Diamond) coal, an efficiency of 82.70% is calculated. For Nenana field coal, an 81.62% efficiency was calculated. The auxiliary power requirements, as noted in response to Question 3(f), are based upon a projection of the power requirements of a typical 200 MW pc;wer plant. 27. "",-'""~• ~-~H--,~~· ''" ---~ -~'"'~~--~-"-" o ~-"-~~-" -~,,' ......... , .. -·-··-··-,,, " ) ',. - .· ·1 I I ··.~I -.l :t 1 !I : i ~-j I 'I -... · I l ·! II -91 i . !j l ~~ 1 I :j ' I I ; •1 I 'i I l ., i I j I I ~ I I I -~ l [ I ! i l I; The calculation of net station heat rate is defined by the formula found below: Net Station Heat Rate -Turbine Heat Rate x Gross Power Boiler Efficiency Net Power Thus, a change in the boiler efficiency and gross power (net power and auxiliary power) will cause adjustments to be made to the net station heat rate. Applying the boiler efficiency values just noted, the respective heat rates are as follows: (Beluga) (Nenana) 7850 .8270 7850 .8162 X X 217,500 kW 200,000 217,500 kW 200,000 10,322 Btu kWH 10,459 Btu kWH It should be noted that the ·net effect of this change is only a 3% difference in coal consumption for the power plant. 28. ·~-~~~,::---~--~·--··'"•·-·~·-·-····-··:,·"····---·--.... . - "·' i . I . .. 1 t ~ l .. l \i . j I. 'I. I I .. I I I . ~~ r ,. 1'. r .. f r J '1 l I ~ ... ~ l } ; ' I L"" ! / ·.\.'" FtEL -DIAMOND CDrL FIB.D-28~ !«liS DATE: 07-Nov-{~ l \EIGHT IETHJD -FOSSIL F'JEL -ST~RD AIR* (CoMplete Colbustion AssUied) Ultiute INlysis, "/."By Weight As Fired c 45.4 IE a.9 02 14.4 N2 o. 7 s 0.14 t H20 28 : Ash 7.9 t SUJ1 99.44 11-!ss 02 in fuel (deduct)H :Required (it 100% Total Air) lH Air equivelent of 02 in fuel Required For r~bustion Totil Air = 100 "/. Unit Fuel a 2000 lb/hr lb/lb Fuel lb/lb Fuel lb/Unit Fuel : 02 1.208 0.230 0.001 1.439 0.1~ 1.295 Dry Air Dr)" ~;~ ~.235 104G9.24 l 0.996 1991.72: ____ ,. l --1 0.006 12.01 : -: 6.236 12472.97 I 0.6.~ 1244.16 l S.b14 11228~81 t Required For Ct.bustion Total Air ~ 120.00 "/. --------~----------------------------------------: 102 i'nd Air, Total &Excess Air !Excess 02 02 ! .. 554 0.259 Dry Air 6.737 1 .. 123 Products of Colabustion Totil Air = 120.00 1. Dry Air 13474.57 I 2245.76 : lb/lb Fuel lb/Unit Fuel : :--------- leG: lH20 lS02 !02 Ctxcessl IN2 IWe1ght, 1Wet !Weight, Dry 1.662 0.628 0.003 0.259 5.185 7.736 7.108 * Air at 60% relitive hu.idity and 80 ~ dry bulb, or 0.0132 lb of 110isture per lb dry air • 3323.28 : !256.38 : 5.60 : 518.12 : 10369.21 l 15472.59 : 14216.21 : \ ;; ' <'I 1 ~·-·---,......--.. ------·--"-·'"··-~·--.. ---·----.. -----·-·--·- "--~-·-----t . .;• t -~· ,--'..::::, ~ ,, .::-I) I] A - Attachment 3g.l . , I .. I I I I I I i . ' I'' 1 1 J' ! I l i ~~ ' I 1 f: I t) I l I I i ~ ! I i I 1 I f l I I l .. ) I l I J J i I l I f l I H I i I fl I I I ,, I r J ;' >; '1 C-i I I , I I '1 'I I :'i ~L,, } q ,I I b - Attachment 3g ~-2 : L I i I I I N I I E I C()!BUSTION Cl-l.Cll.ATIDN l L I l I 1 l t4 I : E l BASED ~ tUWTITIES PER 10,000 BTU nEL. INPUT I 1 IFUEL-Dl~ FIELD llR I 2 I INt. YSIS AS FIRED I 3 llLTIMATE, ~ BY WT PROXIMATE, ~ BY WT l 4 I C 45. 40 KliSTURE l 5 I H2 2. 90 vtl..ATILE I 6 I D2 14.40 FIXED CARBON : 7 : N2 0. 70 ASH l 8 : S 0.14 TOTAL 1 9 I H20 28, 00 ao : ASH 7.90 111 i TOTAL 99. 44 112 IBTU PER LB, AS FIRED : 7,800 CONDITIONS DATE : a t BV SPECIFICATION 07-Nov-M l ______________ __.... _ _, __ ,_; !TOTAL AIR ~ I 0.00 lAIR TEMPERATURE TO I-£ATER F l 0. 00 I AIR TEMPERATURE FROM i£ATER F I 0.00 lFLLE 6AS TEMPE·AATURE LEAVItli ~IT F I 0. 00 I H20 PER LB 'Ji'\Y AIR LB : o.oo l II.MU~ FUEL LOSS ~ l l~TED LOSS ' "FR MARGIN ~ l l RADIATIOO LOSS <ABMA> 1 FIB. 20, ~PTER 7 ~ l 120.00 l tl : ao.oo : c 1 500.00 l d l 300.00 : e l 0.0132 l f I : A l 2.00 : h : 1.50 : i : 0.801Jl : k : H3 l Qt.Rfl'ITIES PER LB AND BTU FtE.. INPUT lUNIT RJEL/HR: 10,000 BTU li3 : i14 : Fl£1.. BURNED l 15 ITOTri.. AIR REQUIRED 116 lH20 IN AIR I 17 :WET SAS, TOTAL l 18 I H20 IN Fl.EL l 19 I H20 IN F1J.E SAS, TOTAL 120 I .al IN FLLf -?AS, TOTAL IN PERCENT l21 :DRY GAS, Ttn:AL I 2000~0 LB : : 13479.1 lB : 177.9 LB I I 15657.0 LB l 1078.5 LB : I 1256.4 LB l 8.0 ~ : I 14400.6 LB : 1.28 :14 l S.64 l15 : 0.11 116 l 10.04 :17 : 0.69 118 : 0.81 :19 : 8.02 :co l 9.23 121 : :------------------------------------------------------------------------: 122 I LOSSES PER 10 9 000 BTU FI.E.. INPUT 122 : :-·------~----------------------------------------------------------------- : 23 l UNa.IRt£D FlEL :24 ILWCD:UnED & MFR P'ARBIN 125 IRADIRTI~ BTUI 200.00 l23 : BTUl 150.00 124 : BTUI 80.00 125 I BTUI 719.01 126 l :26 :unarr I£AT, H20 IN FLEL 127 :SENSIBLE tEAT, FL~ GAS l28 I TDTA!., LOSSt:--s BTU FROM FIS. 2 @ LINE e ~D 20 = 57.84 BTUl 580.54 127 I l c':9 :TOT Fl. LOSSES IN PERCafT ll) lEFFICIENCY, BY DIFFERENCE BTUI 1729.55 128 l ~ l 17.30 129 : ~ l 82. 70 : 30 : -------------·----------------~-------------------------------------------1 131 t 132 H£AT INPUT FRt:M FUEL 133 I.ST INPUT FROM AIR l 3lt l i£AT INPUT, TOT At. OlAfliTIES PER 10,000 BTU FtE.. INPUT 135 ILESS LATENT t£AT LOSS, H20 IN FlEL 136 U£AT AVAILABLE, PIAXIM!Jt 137 lLESS LilES 24 ' 25 1 138 ll£AT AYAILAa.E 139 II£AT AVAILABLE PER LB OF FLUE GAS 140 IAD!ABATIC TEMPERATURE FROM FTt;. 2 FOR Llt£S 20 & 39 -----------~------- BTU I 1006.31 F I 3625 l31 : BTU I 10000.00 132 I BTU I 933.93 133 : BTU: 10933. 9,3 : 34 : Billl 719.01 :35 l BTU I 10214.92 {36 : BTU I 115.00 137 : BTU I 10099.92 138 : 139 l :40 : f ,rtlTE: IT IS Cl!S1'0MARY TO REOCK:E Tt£ II'AXIJIUl !tAT AYAIUUlE, Lit£ 36, BY FROM 1/3 TO 1/2 OF 1lE tmCOlJJTED I ~FR MARSIN PLUS RADI~TION LOSSES, ON THE ASStJIIPTION lli\T A PORTION OF Tt£SE LOSSES OCCUR IN THE ~BUSTlON 2lM. .-·-·~~-~~·-----· ~----~,.... ~~--~-~ ~·~ .., __ , 1 . f -~ -- .... li I ' •IJ., ~."'-' ~ ' ~ ( ' . --,- ;:r<-<-t ro ~l• .• ' ' 0 i& ' ' ' ~ . ' f:' ~· r: ~~. ' ~-! (; \1 [1 l ~. c I ' I ' i 1 I I l I l l l I, 1 ·-l ,i ,1 j ' l j I j t ! -~ I \ '"'\ i •"i I I I I ·f I ,.I 'j I I 1 l I i 1 j " ! I ; t i { • 11 ,J I 11 ' ·' I ' ' r " ' ' j ~~ ,., ,, J I J {, \! ' ~ J r ·~ R£L -tENAHA em. FIELD DATE: 07·Nov-M I ~IGHT 1£1HlD -FOSSIL FlE!. -STANDARD RIR• (Colrplete C.O.bustion AssUII!d) -----------------------------------------------·~: Ul'ti~te ~lysis, ~ By Weight As Fired :- c 45 H2 3.6 02 15a5 N2 1.05 s 0.2 : 1-Sl 26 l Ash 8.3 l Suw 99.65 ILess 02 in fuel tdeduct>H lRequh'£0 (it 1~ Total Air} :H Air equivelent of 02 in fU.2l :02 and Air, Totil :Exms Air lEi<etsS 02 I C02 Hi20 :S02 ~~ (excess) IN2 !Weight, Wft. !Weight, D-ry Required For r~bustion Totil Air = 100 ~ Unit Fuel = 2000 lb!hr lb/lb Fuel lb/lb Fuel lb/Unit Fuel l 02 Dry Aii' Dry Air 1.191 5.189 toJn.oo : 0.28G 1.236 2472'.48 l -----1 --I 0~002 0.009 17.16 : ----I --: 1.485 &.433 12866.64 ~ 0.155 0.670 1339.20 : 11'}330 ~. IWt 11527.~4 : I I Aequi\''t!d For Collbustlon I ·I Tohl Air= 1.20.00 ~ I ! 'i 02 Dry Air Dry Air 1.596 6.916 13832.93 : 1.153 2305.49 : 0.266 -: Products of CoMbustion Totil Air = 120.00 ~ lb/lb Fuel lb/Unit Fuel l 1.647 3294.00 I 0.673 1346.27 I 0.004 8.00 I 0.266 531.94 ~ 5.326 10651.61 I 7.916 15831.82 : 7.243 1~5.5/l ~ • ~ir at ~ relative hUiidity and 80 F dry bulb, or 0~0132 lh of mis~qre per lb dry air. - Attachment 3g.3 :1 :I I .,_,_ 1: ', j I: ,, '!_~-;,;:::' ,____) I \ .,D' I f , 1 I ~~/: '' Attachment 3g.4 I l l : 1 l : N I l E : BASED ON OOANTITIES PER 10, 000 BTU Aa INPUT 1----· : 1 tPJEI.. -t£NI:WA FIELD C£R. } 2 l P.NALYSIS AS FIRED ~ 3 lltT!r~ATE, '/. BV WT PROXIMATE, % BY WT I 4 ~ C .:s.oo WJISTURE : 5 i H2 :l. 60 \>'TJ.ATILE ~ 6 ; 02 1!._: 50 FIXED CARBON l 7 : N2 1.\.'lS ASH : 8 i S 0.20 TOTAL t 9 l H20 26.00 ao : ASH a.au CONDITIONS ~i SPECIFICATION rtOTJi. AIR 26.00 lAIR TEMPERATURE TG HEATER M.30 lAIR IDIPERATUP~ FRQt!l I-EATER 31.20 lFL~ fAS ID1PEAATURE LEAVING ~IT 8. 30 I H20 PER LB DRV AiR S9.80 l l Ltmi.JMD FUEL LOSS :~ LOSS l MFR MARGIN '/. l F l Fl F I I LSI ~ : ~ : l L l 1 I I I I t N l : E l DilTE : i I I 07-Nov-84 ! i.~.oo : b : 80.00 1 e : 500.00 : d : 300.QO : e l 0.013a : f : ' g : I 2..00lh~ 1.50 t i I 1 : U I iOTAI.. 99. 65 IRADIATIOO LOSS (·~lv FIS.20, ~PTER 7 ~ : 0.80 l J l I k : I : 12 : B11J PER LS, AS F! RED : 7, SOO :~--·--------------------------------------- 004NTl'flES PER LB ~ BTU F1£L INPUT IUNIT FUEL/HRl 10,000 BTU 113 I :----------~----------------------------------------------------------------~: 114 :FUEL BURte : 15 l YCITAI.. AIR REQUIRED U6 lte1 IN AIR I 17 :WEi tiiS, iOTA!, 118 lH20 IN FUEL l 19 I H20 IN FLI.E BAS, TOTfv.. 120 iH2rJ IN FLUi~ BAS, TOTAL IN PERCENT 121 lDRY GAS, TOTAL l 2000.0 LB : 1.32 ll4 : : 13841.3 L8 l 9.11 115 I 182. 7 LB l 0.12 :16 : : tGOe~.o LB i 10.54 :11 : 1163.7 LB: 0.77 l18: ~ 1346.4 LB l 0.89 l 19 : 8. 4 % : 8. 40 : 20 : l 1~77c6 LB l · 9.66 121 l 1--------·----------------------~------------~----------------------------·l leE : LO'~S PER l O, 000 BTU FlEl. INPU'l' t 23 H.MlJRNED FUEL l24 ll~COUtil'E.O & ~R MARSH~ lf.S IRADIATIO:~ 125 lU\TEN"f ..eAT, f.al IN A.EL 127 lsa\SIBLE f-EAT, FLUE GAS 128 lTOTP.l LOSSES l 29 1 TOT ft. LOSSES IN ~RCENT 130 lEFFICIENCY, DY DIFFERENCE 131 : BTU FROM FI6. 2 @ LINE e AND 20 = BTU: BTU~ :22 : 200.00 123 I 15(1.00 124 : BTUl 80.00 125 l BTU: 796.20 :26 : 58.03 BTU: 61i.71 ;27 l BTU: 1837.91:: l 28 ; % l 18.38 L~ : '/. : 81~&! ~30 : 131 : ;-------------·--------·--------------~---------------------------------------: 32 : l£AT INPJT FRCJI! FUEL l33 lt£AT INPUT FROM AIR t34 UBrt INPUT, TOT'l. :35 ll..SS LATErfl' !£AT LOSS, H20 IN RE. 136 lll:t·lT AVAilRtE, llfAX!U 137 ~LESS LINES 24 & 25 • :38 a-an AVAILru!.LE :39 1 tEAT IWA'UJIBLE PER LB OF A..UE 8AS 1.6;0 lADIABATIC TE1PF.AATIJRE FROM FIG. 2 FOR LIN:S L'G l 39 BTU : 955.51 F : 3625 BTU: 10000~00 132 : BTU: 984.26 133 : BTU: 10984.26 134 : BTU I 796.20 135 1 s-ru: 10188.06 136 : BTUl 115.00 137 : BTU: 10073.06 :38 : 139 l 140 : ~ tllTE: IT IS CUST~RV TO REOOCE Tl£ MAXIKIM ~T AVAILABLE, Lit£ 36, BY FROM 1/3 TO 1/2 ~ THE U~TED I MFR MARSH! PI..1S RADIATI~ LOSSES, 00 11£ ASSUMPTION THAT A PQRTION Of Tt£5E LOSSES OCCUR IN THE COMFAJSiiON 21M. I .:.=J l I r . l ~ .,.-.... ~ r: r l t !' l I . t t ~JI: \· \ I '---' -,, ~·, ,..,.I 'i; rl fl • \ ' ~i ' . I ...... C[ • . Attachment 3g.4 I L I I I 1 l N I ! E I I I I I I I I I BASED ON IJ.IANTITIES PER l·~, 000 BTU FW. INPUT : L: l I : I N I : E : =------------------------------------------------------------------------: l 1 lFl£L -P£NANA FiaD eM.. CONDITIONS ~ 2 : ANALYSIS AS FIRED BY SPECIFICATION I 3 lll.TIMATE, ~ BY WT PROXIMATE, ~ BY WT :TOTri.. AIR tj I : 4 : C 45. 00 tciSTURE 26.00 lAIR TEMPERATURE TO ~TER F I 1 5 l H2 3., 60 vtLATILE 34.30 lAIR TEMPERATURE FRO!II ~TER F I l 6 ! 02 15. SO FIXED CARBON 31.20 lFLUE GAS TEMPERATURE LEAVING ~IT F l : 1 I N2 1.05 ASH 8.30 lH20 PtR lB DRY AIR LB I I 8 l S 0.20 TOTri.. 99.80 : l 9 l H20 26.00 lllaURhED Fl£l LOSS 1. I IW l ASH 8.30 ~~LOSS l MFR MARGIN ~: : 11 l TOTI-1. 99. 65 l RADIATIOO LOSS tRBMAl, FIG. 20• ~PTER 7 ~ I :12 UjiU ~R LB, AS FIRED : 7,600 DHTE : i I 07-Hov-8~ ~ 120.00 : b : 80.00 : c : 500.00 : d : 300.00 : e I 0.0132 : f : : g : 2.00 : h : 1. 50 : i : 0.80 : J l : k : 113 : ~TITlES PER lB AND BTU FUEL INPUT IUNIT FUEL/H~~ 10,000 BTU 113 l H 4 :FUEL aJRt£D l1S lTOTAL AIR RE~IRED 116 IH20 IN AIR 117 IWE'f SAS, TOtAL 118 HfaO iN FUa l 19 tH20 IN FLLE GAS, TOTAL 120 IH20 IN FlJ}E SAS, TOTAL IN PER!Ec'T 121 :DRY GAS, TOTAL 12:2 : LOSSES PER 10,000 BTU A.El lNPUT : 2000.0 lB : : 13841.3 lB : 182.7 lB : l 16024.0 LB : 1163.7 lB : : 1346.4 LB l 8.4 ~ : l 14677.6 LB I · 1.32 :14 : 9.11 115 : 0.12 :16 : 10.54 a7 1 o. 77 118 : o.a9 n9 : 8.40 120 : 9.66 l21 : 12.2 : :~·------~-----------~---------------------------------------------------- :23 : lMUP.NED FUEL l 24 l l.HtCDlMED & JIFR ~REIN 125 IRADiATI~ 126 ILATENT t£AT, ~ IN rtJEL 127 :SENSIBLE l£AT, FLUE GAS :28 :TOTAL LOSSES I 29 l TOTri.. LOSSES Ifi PERCENT 130 lEFFICIENCV, BY DIFFtRENCE BTU FROM FIG. 2 @ LINE e AND 20 = 131 : &UWTITIES PER 10,000 BTU FlE. INPUT :32 II£AT INPUT FfQ FUEL 133 liST INPUT FROM AIR 134 lt£AT INPUT, TOT~ : 3S l LESS LATENT J£AT LOSS, H20 IN F1.EL 136 11£AT AVAILABLE, ~XIIUI 137 ll.ESS LINES 24 & 25 1 138 H£AT AVAIUUU: lJS lte:T A'JAII.ABLE PER lB OF FLUE 5AS 140 !ADIABATIC TEMPERATURE FROM FIG. 2 FOR LitES 20 & 39 BTU I F : BTU: BTU I BTU: BTU I 58.03 BTU: BTU I BTUl BTU I BTU I Btul BTU I BTU: BTUl 955.51 3625 200~00 123 l 15(1.00 124 : 80.00 125 : 796.20 :26 l 611.71 127 : 1837.92 :28 : 18.38 :29 : 81.62 :30 : 131 : 10000.00 :32 : 984.26 133 : 10984.26 13; : 796.20 :35 : 10188.06 136 : 115.00 137 : 10073.06 :38 : 139 : :40 : l f ! l ' I l } ' l l I j J ! I ''· ,. l ' * MlTE: IT IS CUSTIJ!IARY TO REDUCE ii£ MAXID i-EAT AYRILABU., Lit£ 36, BY FROM 1/3 TO 1/2 0t: 1'11£ ~TED I MFR t'GIRSIN PLUS RADIAii~ LOSSES, ~ 1l£ ASSUMPTION 'THAT A PORTION OF Tt£SE .LOSSES OCCUR IN THE COMBUSiiON 2f)IE. -- I =1 1 I I I I · .. · t I l J·· ! . 1 ''lll . I I j I I 4. QUESTION a) Data compiled in the APA/Harza analys~s of gas-turbine and combined-cycle Dlant O&M costs, including utility reported, equipment manufacturers, and FERC source information. RESPONSE A survey was conducted of combustion turbine gas-fired simple and combined-cycle plants to investigate O&M costs. The survey considered utility-reported data from Alaska and Lower 48 utilities. Specifically, the utilities contacted were: 0 Anchorage Municipal Light and Power (Plant Nos. 1 and 2) 0 Chugach Electric (Beluga site) 0 Houston Light and Power (T. H. Wharton plant) 0 Portland General Electric (Beaver plant) 0 Public Service of Oklahoma (Comanche station) 0 Arizona Public Service Company (Santan station) As an additional check on the utility reported data, manufacturers (GE and Westinghouse) of combustion 29. turbine equipment were contacted to develop standard overhaul and maintenance interval periods. The manufacturer's data were compared to the utility-reported O&M costs, set forth in Attachments 4a.l and 4a.2. In m~st instances, it was found that utility maintenance practices coincide directly with manufacturers standard recommendations. The values provided in Attachments 4a.l and 4ae2 are higher than those set forth in the DEIS for two reasons. First, the values in the attachments are stated in 1983 dollars, rather than the 1982 dollars used in the DEIS. Second, the attachment values are based on ISO conditions, rat~er than the site-specific conditions used in the DEis analysis. An average of costs for the Alaska utilities based on plant operating hours for inspection and overhaul periods, utilizing adjusted Alaska labor rates, was developed for the DEIS comments. Subsequent to the DEIS Conunents, Harza-Ebasco obtained an O&M cost estimate as reported by the General Electric Company in a report entitled, "STAG Combined I. I! r: ll r f Cycle Powe:L System Operation and Maintenancen (Attachment 4a.3). The GE report analyzed six indivi~ual sites representing 21 combustion turbines for the years 1975 through 1982 and was based upon FERC-reported data. The results indicate that fixed O&M costs in a combined cycle plant would range between $12.00 and $12.50 per ~w K. • This compared with the Power Autho~~ty's DEIS coro~ents estimate of $11.75 per kW. The analysis indicated the variable cost element of O&M expenses is strongly influenced by the following factors: 0 Frequency of starts per total operating hours 0 Fuel type 0 Load duty (peaking or base load) The report further analyzed the effect of individual utility operating practices and related variable maintenance expenses to the above thr~e factors in developing a reasonable cost estimate average. 31. -:::::;:;:::::: .. ~:;;.. (',;. ' --~ I . L ~ . __ .....:., • J t • "" ,. ... .. ~ . i: '·<.-, ··--~-=-..------~----.-~ ... ---~-~-----------·----· -.:._.) •·-~-----.·-· ---~ --··-----~i·L_,.,..__._ __ __.,_~,~----~l--~.w-~~~~~~-~~~-~-....... ~-•_....-.....,.,~t:~-·-·.:-~~-•-<"'• ___._1..--------~«,~r.~..,<?-n ,_,_,,.,.,....,~_,.,,..._,,,~ ""''-'"'#-<.,-1'"'~_,-;..,,_.~,_,.......,_..,-;..~,..,.._,.,._,,_ ... ...:_..,.,.,......_,~~y~ ~. ~ ::-~ Cost Destrfptfon Plant Rating (MW) Plant Staff!/ Fhed Laborl/ Cost $/kW/yrl/ Fuel Cost Plant Heat Rate OperAting Schedule Hrs/Yr. Water Costs (Injected) Major OVerhaul Cost (Annual) Minor 0\rerhaul Cost (Annual) Consun1ables l.ube, Ot1, etc. Total Maintenance tosts (Annual) Variable Costs S/Hiri/hr ~ ._ ._ L~ ·.- ._ ::--., ... ... ;!>~ •• , ,. • • ~I ... BI ·.,"/ ...... J ~ _j SPECIFIC UTILITY REPORTED DATA O&M COSY ESTIMATE BACKUP 200 MW COMBINED CYCLE ~LANT 1983 s Chugach Houston Portland Pub. Srv. ~.nchorage Elects-tc Light & Power G.£. lith. Hur.tctpa1 Beluga T.M. Wharton Beaver Comanche Plant SHe Plant (300 MW) Phnt Statton 160 MW 176 MW 300 MW 500 HW 255 MW 15 17 28 20 20 $10.93 $11.14 S7.U78 $3.033 $5.94 $1.41/106 BTU S. 25/106 BTU Sl.00/106 BTU $10,323,000 $4.~50,000 S52, 110,000 $22 15001000 $20,953,732 11 eOOO BTU 12,500 BTU 9,650 BTU 8,800 BTU 9,445 BTU KW-lir klr-lir kv:Rr l<lr-llr Klr-ltr 8,000 Hr 8,000 Hr 6,500 Hr 1,000 Hr 2,000 Hr rr rr rr rr rr $350,820 $320,000 $200,000 N/A $11,680 No Yes Yes No No $200,000 $162,500 ssoo,ooo $200,000 $400,000 $89,700 $70,000 $200,000 $250,000 $200,000 $60,000 seo,ooo $130,.000 s 90,000 s 65,000 $700,520 · SB54,500 Sl.OJO,OOO S1,oao,ooo $1,341,680 S.55 $.60 ~~53 $2.16 $2.63 , ... @ ~·-·a Art zona Pub. Srv. San tan Stat1~n 289 ,., 15 $3.93 $4.35/106 ~~ ;U S22p' ... '7·.,:<,;..; 8,860 BTU klr-Rr 2,000 Hr rr N/A No $450,000 $300,000 $110,000 Sl, 720,0001 $2.98 L_Jl -~ll '• - Adjusted Alaska Average O&M Costs 11 ;~ 217 HW a $13.13 S4.0 X 106 7000 Hr lr $354,000 yes !"75,000 sns,ooo s m,ooo $884,000 $ .65 !I Plant staffing where units are located at large \:hen-mai Jrl~tallattons was average for combined cycle plant reported by utility for the specific installation. !:_I labor cost for Alaskan ut 11 ity personne 1 average :~36-$'10/hr. lower 48 uti 11 ty average was $26-$30/hr wHh fringes. J/ Average Armual O&M Costs fndude 'laska 1ah1r and transportaHnn costs. llOTl: Information was tc!bulated fr(l(f1 ,_...,hone call" and letter correspondence with power plant personnel as documented fn Section 5 Appendices. L .. -.1 ,.. !l:=' rt rt llJ 0 g CD :::s rt ~ llJ ~ I-' tl ' I I .;• I h .. L . .. 'f, ;. r '" '='· ~' -"' ' .... '. ~ -~" • .~·;, .. ~-'-·'·~~.:""'4¥"''1 ·.·~·~.<:Jr'"#\tS~·,"·~~t}IUS<"-':·)'$5'~~ -· .... "'f?,.,-... '~r;'oi?~i'ffl*.~ ~~· ··:r:-r*·X~~~rt!~~~~«~:-~-,._..,.~.._.., r I I ~ ~ ' ~ . . ' . ,.. .. -. ,. - tJIII ~ ::-. ~ ~ .. -.. i .......... ; \ ...... _.J 1". ~,~ J 1" .... "u Cost Description Plant Ra tt ng Plant Staff Fixed labor Cost!! $/tW/yr.21 Fuel Cost (Annual) Plant Heat Rate (Btu/kWHR) Annual Operating Schedule (Hrs/Yr) Consumables Lube, Otl, etc. Major Overha~l Costs {Annual) Minor Overhaul Costs (Annual) Total M&tntenance Cost O&H Variable Cost Ul MW/hr) SPECIFIC UTILITY REPORTED DATA O&H COST ESTIMATE BACKUP 200 HW S!HPLE CYCLE COMJUSTWN TURBINE 1983 s . Arizona Public Servfce Company - Yu111a Plant 185 ... 15 $3.79 S2,391 ,ooo 14,565 1,800 $ 50,000 $200,000 $1'}5,000 $435,000 $1.31 Chugach Electric - Beluga 340 HV 7 s 4.9 $1,41.8,000 18,897 600 $ 30,000 $600,000 $250,000 $880,000 $4.313 Conmonwealth Edison Company - Crawford 208.0 MW 15 $9.375 $2,037,000 16,587 500 $ 25,000 $550,000 $250,000 $825,'000 $7.93 Florida !•ower Bartow P .l. - St. Petersburg 222.8 MW 20 $14.0 $5,489,000 13,459 600 s 30,000 $650,000 $302,700 $992,700 S7 .42 Conrnonwealth Edf son Company - Calumet 297.0 MW 20 $10.5 $2,999,000 16,897 600 s 45,000 $550,000 $250,000 $845,000 $4.74 L_.n ___ m Anchorage Muntctpa~ Power I Light Plant No. 1 77MI '7 . S11.636 $8,130,200 22,000 3,200 s 20,000 $700,000 $200,000 $920.000 $3.73 ~·--·Ji Adjusted . Alaska Average L" ... l O&M Costs ]/ 237.0 MW 14.0 $8.99 ;ooo s 30,000 $120,000 SlJO,ooo $280,000 $ o46 1/ Plant staffing where units are located at large thermal fnstallatfons was average i'eported by uttlfty for the spectftc fnstalhtton. 11 labor cost for Alaskan utility personnel average SJ6-S40/hr. lu~er 48 utility aver~ge was $26-SJO/hr w1th fringes. ~I Average O&H costs fnclude Alaska labor ~nd transportation costs. llOTE: lnformatton was tabulated from phone calls and letter correspondence wtth power plant personnel as documented in Sectfon 5 Appendices. 0731C 4-34 11L._I ~ rt" rt" PJ 0 [ CD !:1 rT ~ PJ • :-..> ~,._.,_. . ~~ .. -~ • d· . ;----,_. ·\r~.......,.~"" "'U'eP"'J' l§i~:";·'l_;~,, ., Di"~;.4·'"\"~¢·:~:r"'"',-~!t.-'J"'1iji~l',""fi'i~:>;-"'~··,r· ..... , .,,...~, ... ~. ,.,,l"'''i'~~41""'!f~'lii!!J.W,.,..,;~i'~~--~-·-l_ ........ ,. ~ . ri «G?IMBPF F..YMtfBf-.. 3 1-~ .. ~-····· -~ .. -·-'___;::;;.;---..........;..:....;·...,, ............................... ~ ... ..---..... --.. t ... il ! II 11 I ~I ~1 t• ( l . "' I I 'i \l I• I ·I· I . ! I ! \~ \ I Combined·~Cycle Power /y1ternJ· _........ STAG Combined-Cycle Power System Operation ~nd ~1aintenance Robert F. Osswald Manager-North America ProdL!~ Serv~ce Gas Turbine Projects and Customer Services Department Gas Turbine Di\lision Schenectady, New York Ronald W. Stepien Manager-STAG Market Development Gas Turbine International Department Gas Turbine Division Schenectady. New York GENERAL e ELECTRIC UaA PrintiMI In USA I Attachment 4a.3 GER-3407 GAl TURBINE REFERENCE LIBRARY CONTENTS PAGE INTRODUCTION . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . 1 STAG COMBINED-CYCLE SYSTEM O&M COSTS.................................... 4 KINDS OF INSPECTION . .. .. .. . .. .. . .. .. .. . . 7 SUMMARY. '... . . . . ................... I' . ' . . 13 I I. TASi..E OF CONVERSIOt. F,o.:;TO~S IS ttv:;J.iJDED AT Th'E END OF TrltS ?LJi5-1CA"'tON INTRODUCTION Operation and ma~ntenance (O&MJ costs tend to rece1ve significant attention when comparing alternate types of gen- eratmg equipment They ref'ect the quahty of the eqU1pme:1t purchased and the operat•onal techn•ques of a user. The fa:! ts that these costs r,~present a very srnall percentage of the total cost for generatmg power and are controllable with gooo equipment. proper attention, and good n1a1ntenance plann1ng The intent of this paper is to show the Significant expen· ence and data associated with General Electnc STAG· com· b1ned-<..)'t.~le power generat1ng s:ystems. These data perm1t a reasonabh~ pred1ct1on of the Oo~M cost of a General Electrtc STAG combined-cycle plant. This paper .also provides an averv1ew of the type of mam· tenance required to ensure the achievement. of ~conom1ca1 operation, and the high availability rehabihty tnherent in a General Electric STAG combined-cycle plant. "Tradema~ of General Electnc Co., USA lfi ( I :,: I I I i I I L.' I I I , I \•' . I .., ... ,...... I I 11 I I; I I I I I' ~ I o.tn•tion of O&M Cost from Federal Energy Regulatory ~(FERC) Rep)rtS issued each year by the United States FERC are C(lnSidered the best neutral sources available to show actual productiOn costs of US utility plan~s. Early each year every eleCtriC generating utility in th.e Unrted. Statll!s sends re~rts ao the FERC detailing the prevrous years costs for genera1Jng power for a specific site. The report includes the type of plant (fossil steam; g~s turbine simple cycle, gas turbine combined cycle or nuclear), year installed. capacity. net generation (kW hours). fuel(s) used. heat content of fuel and production expenses for fuel bumed, operating personnel. electrical. maintenance super- vision and engineenng. and total marntenance (rncluding parts and labor). Figure 1 shows a typical FERC report with costs outlined while Fig, 2 il!wstrates the method of calculatrng O&M costs from these data. O&M Cost Analysis Fuel cost is the largest smgle production expense of any tossil plant and. therefore. has a tremendous effect on the TYPICAL FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION REPORT COVERING LARGE STEAM ELECTRIC GENERATING PLANTS CALCULATION OF O&M COST FROM FERC REPORTS TOTAL 'l'lODUCTION EIJ>£NSES LESS 'UEL 0&111 COST 15.211.173 • 1,191.332 TO OETEI'llllfNE ON A IIIILI.S/IlW•Itl'liASIS DIVIDE AIOV[ 0&" IY N~T GltN[RATION 11,111 ,U21701,41t.OOO • 1,000 1.11 or 1.7 IIIILU/KW•MII Figure 2 price of electricity generated. Normally, fuel costs are rea- sonably predictable. The O&M costs of a plant are generally small relative to fuel costs, particularly for a base-loaded plant, and can be predicted by the operating personnel as- signed, based on the plant design. GT'1'1~37 Ftgure 1 2 • • • .. # • ~ ~~. .. • ... • • : '· ',, ' I f -I l f -I f I I I ' ! ! ! I -, l l i -' '1 ! ; j I \ I: ( I ., I· i I' I I I I ,,../ / I' .. • I ' I I~ I Jj l i j ·~ I ----------~------------------------------~ BUS BAR GENERATION COST ISO CONDITIOHS 1H3 LEVELIZED DOLLARS 3,000 OPERATii\IG HOURS/YEAIIt Figure 3 Figures 3 and 4 show the resutts ~fa study. done by GE, which reflect the relatively small imp 'C1 O&M costs have on piant costs. These costs are leveli2 :j over a 30-year life cycle. These data also show the relative cost advantages that a GE STAG plant has over a conventional steam plant of equivalent size with similar ~rvices. The O&M costs probably will not be large enough to de- termine what kh'd of plant (combined cycle, distmate'residual burning, or conventional steam) is selected by the pur- chasers, since efficiency has such an overriding impact. The O&M costs of alternative combined cycles may. however. determine which manufacturer's equipmen~ is finally selected. O&M data are often incorrectly applied, as when peaking gas turbine data is compared with base load fossil plants. Peaking gas turbine plants tend to be less predictable because they require more maintenance (due to thermal cycling) and in any gl·"en yem. the fired hours accumula~~ in previous years may dictate a planned inspection but system loads do not IUS 8AR G~NERA TION COST ISO COtiU>ITM)NS 1M3 LEV£L.lZ£D OOLLAM '" 1,000 ~MTMifG HCKMS/YUIIt Figure 4 l J . J~:] -" ---'---~~~·, . ! ~r~ .. ..:1 .I '---·~ req~1ire the use of the plrtnt. Therefore, net generation is low, while O&M costs are rr' ;ively high. The development of O&M costs for a GE ST~· ....Jrnbined-cycle plant requires a close look at past expe: .-nee. FERC data combine operating costs and maintenance costs into one number, as separating the two would leave the validity of both questionable. Data published in a recent paper by one of our STAG combined-cycle users (Fig. 5). illustrates the low mainte."iance costs achieva.bie with aGE STAG combined-cycle pllint over a five· year ~ eriod while op- erating in base load service and properly maintained. The higher cos~ of maintenance in 1982 reflects the impact of major inspections of the gas turbines following 24,000 hours of service. In subsequent years, lower maintenance costs are again expected. O&M Historical Data FERC data on GE's MS7000 STAG combined-cycle plan! data were examined for the years 1 975 through 1 982. The sites chosen were those where data were reported for at least six out of seven years and no other basis for selection was used. The individual srte data are sumi-narized by year and location in Tables I, II and Ill. Figure 6 illustrates these data and the relative portion of O&M cost comparE~d to production and fuel cost on a cumulative basis for these six plants. As expected, O&M is a small portion of operating cost. The cumulative O&M e0st data per site from Table IU were plotted against net kW hours generated on a ~r·unit basis . showing how O&M cost decreases as the hours per year increase (Fig. 7). This is typical of all types of power plants because relatively constant O&M costs are spread over more generation.~ very low operational hours (less than 200). ~ relationship becomes irrelevant and the data were not used. A summarization of this data is shown in Fig. 8. Despite the fact that these data represent early MS7000 STAG com· WESTERN FARMERS COOP 3 STAG 10T'S, 300 lll'l't C014111NED..CYCL.£ ll'l.ANT ., IIAQIInUICI "-&In' Gr..UTIOII COST U'f'iUZ A noll A 'fA LAIIILIT"f Y!Aa aw..-• ~c· ~~-·--,. • .. , .... ,. o.s .. M.C ,..,, .. , ... ., •• 2 •.. .,., ••• U.l .., '~-O.:l1 a.t .. .. ,., 1,Mt.1C .... ••• IM.7 -.a t,Ma.ll ..... u.c ... ., Figure 5 3 ' I l ~ •o f r l I '~' I I ··~ '") 1: 1.( I I· I I D I ' I ! r . ; J ll ( 11 I; I, I I l -~ l I. I FERC MS7000 STAG =B~NEP-CYCLE I POWER PROOUCTIC)N COST DATA ! SITES • 2 1 UNITS •.u·••·• • .. 'IIIL CDIT ot• CDIIT oW=~====~====~_: rarrflnec:a• u Figure E bined.cycle plants using a range of fuel qualities (mostly No. 2 distilla~e) wnh widely varying environmEmts and operating factors, the MS7000 STAG combined-cycle plant is a power generation plant which can be operated economically in the mid-range t'.J base-load service. It is anticipated that the GE STAG combined-cycle plant should have O&M costs, in cur- rent dollars. lower than the early plants now in operation. STAG COMBINED-CYCLE SYSTEM O&M COSTS The gas turbine is the most sigmficant 1tem of maintenance costs in any combined-cycle system and, therefore. should be put on a preventative maintenance program ;ar1d opera· tiona! format 'that will keep costs at a. minimum. Tl'tis com- ponent operates ~t high temperatures while subject to rotational stresses. General Electnc's advances in design technofogy have resulted in high efficiencies based on firing temperatures in the order of 2000 F 11093 C and metal! tem- peratures approaching , 600 F 871 C on some hot-ga~;-path parts. By comparison, the associated heat recovery steam 4 O&M COST-MS7000 STAG COMBINED CYCLE FERC DATA 1975 • 1~2/6 SITU, 27 UNITS ... • • • ---· ....... ...,. • • , • ..!!!loo. __ ... ~~ ...... -_ I'.. -r-..... -..._ J ~ ---...... ---... ·--. -,_ ., GIIIVU~""" ~ 1 10' •• _,.. - O&M COST FOR GE MS7000 STAG GAS TURBINES FEAC DATA 15175-1882 :t.GOO •• OCIC) O&M COST/MIU.S/IIW•Mit liiiiiiiMUit 0.1 o .•• t.s MAI:IMUIIII AVUAG( ~! J.OI Figure 8 1.1 1.000 1.10 1 17- CiT1•••$ generator (HRSG) and steam turbine operate at tempera- tures no higher than those exhausted from the gas turbine, around 1000 F'538 C to 1050 F;566 C. STAG combined-cycle O&M costs can be esttmated us1ng basic FERC data. Fuel type. availability. and cost have a significant influence on the O&M cost of any comtmed-cycle plant. The availability of low cost. clean. gaseous or hquid fuels is most desirable(Fcir example. our recent esttmates ..,(Ftg. 9) indicate that tor a STAG 407. the O&M co:sts. when {operated on gas fuel in base load service will be 1.5 mills 1 •wh. Crude fuel operation will result in an O&M cost of ap- /~oximately 3.0 mills'l<Wh. These numbers also reflect lower than expected O&M costs for simple-cycle peaking gas tur- lpine plants bet.3use of the relatively low O&M costs of the ..fsteam portion (unfired boiler and small steam turbine) which J provides one-th!~d of the plant output. As the quality of fuel decreases, such as going to ash-formmg or restdual fuels. decisions have to be made whether to mttt;,JIIy purchase the capability to handle SL~ch fuels or modifying the equipment in thr;; field. ESTIMATED OIY COST FORGE STAG 407 COMBINED CYCLE PLANT 1883 OOI.LARS, L.EVEL1ZED/ISO CONDITIONS ,~Mfi!Y(Afl 2.000 •.ooo 1.000 06M COST • llllU.S/IIW-'11 ... a.• 1.10 I.J 1:MIOl us 2.11 2.0 -~1. 7.00 1.13 •. o F"tgure 9 • .I ! I --.=1,•-c• • r"'"·-··· ·--..,...;,_' ' '~-- .. r ftk~.ftt'~" ' j '\_:::\ f ~~:J I ! _.....,#,.,_~ ' l I r--.. ~· (J1 ~-t :~ ·-' r:- - Utility HL&P Artzcn• P.S. Ohio Edlton· ~ttRiver JCPit - Fort. G.E. CumuleUve • Utllrty HLIP Arl1on1 P.S. Ohio !dlson Stl1 River JCPil Port. 0.!. Cumui•Uve u .... Hl&P Arlzon• P.S. Ohio Edl1on S.ll Rlv.r JCP&l Port. G.E. Cumul11lv. ---- ~ .. • I, ...__ ... ._..t'.J ,, > .,.._ __ -~~~--·--~-·,,~ __ .,_, __ ,, ~~ ~~~---iililiiiiiiiill ~; ~.,,, .. , \ ~ ~ . ,,,,l • ' ~ •• ' ---·· . .. . . .. -~ . ·t•·. .. .. ~· .. ··-· e::.:.: TABLF. I FERC DATA -MS70QO STAG PRODUCTION COSTS (INCLUDES FUEL AND O&M COSTS) ;l '(• I• ·---·-·-·-·--r---·-··--·-... . . ,. _.. ... '" --··-~--·~---' 1978 '----·--r---- No. of Net Oen. Milia Unlit kWh l' 10' kWh -· ..... _.. ___ --·- 8 9R~2 5.8 3 189 1 243 2 3034 ~24 4 4592 27 B .. H72 :16 2 6 -- 2."' ' 201 1978 No. of Net Gen. Mille Units IIWh )( 10' kWh -- ft QA22 5.1 3 189 1 228 2 :103 4 27.0 4 4592 23.8 4 177 2 306 8 --- ~.111 t 175 ·---· -- 1978 No. or Net Ger.. Mille Until kWhx tOI kWh 8 9822 07 3 tR9 1 15 2 J034 54 4 4592 4.0 4 177 5 56 6 -- 27 2,111 4 26 1177 ~---·· Het. Oen. Mlllt kWh, tO" kWh ~---~--··-- 2.7019 72 4434 243 2535 378 4778 212 2529 325 64.' 74 5 . 4,213 6 160 19711 ----··-·- Net Oen. Mill• kWh II U)1 kWh -· -···--- 3,!i83 6 8 188 7 :J;J 400 t 37 :IRS 3 35 2595 Jq 40.4 143 0 A 7 4 !; 7 4.857 7 16· 4 TABLE il 1979 Net Oen. Milia tewit • to• kWh i--· ----1-----·- 3,164 6 106 175.6 259 2~56 48 2 125 3 57.3 2640 49.2 594. 533 - 4.6195 226 - FERC DATA -MS7000 STAG FUEL COSTS 1977 19711 1979 Net. Oen. I Mill~--· Net. Gen. Mlllt Net Oen. Milia kWh M 10' kWh kWh)( 10' kWh kWh)( 10' kWh . 2,701.9 69 3.583.6 l5 3,16-4.6 8.8 443.4 22 1 fRO 7 25 n 1756 19 9 2535 32 4 •oo t 330 2558 406 477 8 23 7 3R~3 30:? t65.3 42.4 2529 289 2596 33 I 2640 408 84 1 628 4~925 594.4 482 14 ~-~;s7.7 -~~-~ 4.213 6 4,619 5 190 TABLE Ill FERC DATA -MS7000 STAG O&M COSTS . I 1gn 1978 1979 Net Gen. Mill I Nel. Oen. Mlllt Net. Gen. Mills kWhl< 101 · kWh kWhlOC 101 kWh kWhM 101 kWh 2.701 9 03 3.58!)6 0.5 3,164.6 1 8 443 4 22 tAB 7 72 175 6 60 2535 54 4001 47 2556 7.6 477 ,g 35 3853 52 165 3 14 9 . 2529 36 2596 64 ;J64 0 84 84. I 117 40.4 51 2 5!J4 4 5.1 . 4,213 6 1 6 4.857 7 22 4,619 5 36 19110 t981 Net Gen. Mille tt.t.Gen. kWhM 10• kWh kWh M 101 1-----·-· 4,18U tO 7 4,2490 670 609 24.8 ~ -29.2 880 83.3 4.1 207.1 70.2 599.3 76.3 1360 16.7 4,6198 17.6 4,923.1 1980 1981 Net Oen. Mills Mel. Gen. kWh lC 10' kWh kWh)( 10' 4,181.4 98 4.2490 67.0 44.7 24.8 --29.2 88.0 58.1 4 1 207.1 59.7 599.3 . 76.3 622 I 16.7 4.619 B 15.0 4,923.1 19110 19111 Net. Gen. Mille Net Gen. kWhx 101 kWh kWh lOC 10' . 4,181.4 OJJ 4,249.0 670 16 2 24.8 --29.2 880 252 4' 1 207.1 10'5 599.3 763 736 16 7 " 4,619 8 2.6 4.923 1 Milia kWh 15 9 94.3 1790 421.1 62.7 3593 24.5 Mills kWh 14.5 51.8 1240 228.1 58 r, 219.0 21.6 Milia kWh 1.4 42.5 550 19.3 4.1 140.3 29 1912 Net. Gen. rmna kWh)( 10' kWh 3.319.3 34.7 178 1360 17.2 262.7 42 551.8 5830 59.9 1.9 2,7800 3,943.3 41.8 1982 Net, Gen. Mills lcWhx 10' kWh 3,319.3 33.2 17.8 570 17.2 181., 42 130.8 5830 54.5 1.9 1551 0 3.943.3 38.0 19112 Net. Gen. Mills kWh x 101 kWh :.t319.3 1.5 17 8 790 17 2 81.& 42 427.0 5830 5.4 1.9 t.2290 ~.943 3 38 .. I ,; q ~l ·I #,i I j II ·'I ·.I .rl ·I ... il ;.j ~i ~ . 11 I I ~ I .. I ,.t : I : lr 1 ~~~--~~-----~ ------:-----~·------------:"'~· I I l l. ' ' I ' ' I. I I I l J ( \.. I J ~lesidual or ash-forming fuels have a relatively large effect on O&M costs The heavy ash content. contaminants (so- dium. potassium. !ead, etc.) always found in residual fuels (not necessc.trily c;rudes) require fuel treatml:!nt and periodic turbme washing and HRSG cleaning to restore power. These items add operational expenses because of additional per- sonnel. tre1atment materials. etc. It should be expecteo that when burning some residual fuels. ~he O&M cost will increase by two 'o tht·ee 'imes over burning natural gas. Overview-~~TAG Combined Cycle Plant Maintenance A planned maintenance program is essential to achieving the mherent economy. reliability and availability of the STAG combined-cycle power plant. The olan should include the following: • An understanding of the total plant environment • Proper training of O&M personnel • Regular inspect1ons • Adequate spare parts on site • Operating data-collection & analysis • Repair replacement of parts components when indi- cated by oparatmg data • Ut1hzat1on of iecommendat1ons guidelines by GE General Electric Company provides quality equipment wlth maintenance recommendat1ons for each power plant instal- la!ton However. it is the owner user who has the major impact upon the proper operatton ard mamtenar.ce of hts equipment The equipment's avatlab1hty reliability are a direct result of h1s operating and maintenance plans. A maintenance pro- gram. therefore, wh1ch opt1m1zes both matntenance costs and avatlablhty is vital to the owner. For max1mum effectiveness. the owner operator shou~d develop a general understandmg of the relationship betwes,; plant operation, types of inspections. spare parts planning. and the major factors affectmg equipment life. Maintenance Requirements-Gas Turbine Gas turbine parts reqUiring the most careful attention are the 'hot-gas-path" parts which Include combustion liners. trans1t1on pieces, crossfire tubes. turbine nozzles and buck- ets. The bas1c design and recommended maintenance of GE gas turbmes are oriented toward: • Maximum periods of operatron between overhauls • In place, on-site maintenance • Use of available labor for all disass,~mbly inspections In addition to the matntenance of the basic gas turbine. control devices and turbme auxiliaries require periodic in- spections and maintenance. The <\!quirements outlir,ed in the maintenance manual es- tablish a pattern o1 pia. med 1nspec.:tions and maintenance. 6 These start with very minor work at shorter intervals and progress to a major inspection (overhaul) after which the cycle is repeated. Operating Factors Affecting Maintenance The .-r:ajor factors having the greatest influence on the life pf gas turbine parts for any given turbine are: • Type of fuel " Starting frequency • Load cycle • Environment Type of Fuel The effect of the fuel on the life (or time between inspec- tion repair) of the combustion parts is associated with the radiant energy in the combustion process and the ability to atomize or treat various liquid fuels. Natural gas, therefore, which has the lowest level of radiant energy. will yield the longest parts life. Clean diesel fuels will yield Similar parts lives. Contaminants in a gas or distillate fuel system, however, can erode or corrode valves and fuel nozzles .• rqUJd hydro- carbons in gas fuels must be eliminated ~o ensunl! satisfactory operation and low maintenance costs. The combination of distillate fuels with ~mpuritles during transport must be avoided or provisions for treatment must be provided. The use of crude or residual fuels. which have high radtant energy and are mo;-e diffrcult to atomize. will result in somewhat shorter ·parts hves than gas or distillate fuel. Contam1nants m the form of salts (sodium, potassium, etc.) in the fuel. if not removed. will affect not only combustion parts lives but also b!Jckets and. to some degree, nozzles in the form of hot corrosion. Contaminants in the fuel will also shorten mamtenance m- tervals. Thts is particularly true for liquid fuels in wh1ch d1rt results in accelerated replacement of pumps. metenng de· vtces. fuel nozzles. etc. Clean or properly treated fuels will mvanably result tn re- duced maintenance and extended parts life. ·r:uel treatment provided by GE effectively provides protect1on and longer parts lives. The treatment method varies with the type of fuel and contammants involved but generally cons1sts of purif1· cation systems for many light crudes, water wash systems for residual and heavy oils and, when required. vanad1um inhibition systems. Fuel-handling equipment 1s designed and sized to meet the specific fuel characteristics. Fuel monitoring equiprr.·:mt is also supplied which provides simple. accurate moni1o ·1ng of fuel r~;ceived at the s1te and delivered to the turbine. Starting Frequency Atttlo~gh most of the new STAG combtned-cycle power plant applications today are applied to base load duty (one :itart per 1 00 hours or greater) because-of th9ir h1gh effi- ciency. each start and stop of a gas turb1ne subJects the hot· gas-path parts to a significant thermal cycle. The gas turbtne • II." . i I I I ' " ,) f.( I I I I I control system is designed and adjusted to minimize this effect (therefqre, these systems are less susceptible to cyclic damage than fossil plants); however, frequent starting and stopping does reduce pan.s lives. Load Cycle The load cycle of the g2s turbine, up to its continuous duty rating. will have little effect on parts life provided it does not require frequent, rapid large load changes which would have the similar effect of frequent starts and stops. Full li>ad trips should be avoided since their effect is to shorten hot-gas- path parts lives considerably. Corrective action should be taken immediately if this problem appears prevalent. Env~ronment The quality of the inlet air for the gas turbine can have a significant effect on maintenance if it contains abrasive or corrosive constituents. In the case of sbrasives in the inlet air, such as from desert sand storms, careful attention should be paid to proper maintenance of the inlet filtration system. Self-cleaning inlet air filters are a cost-effective. proven method for improved availability and lower maintenance costs for base-loaded units. If a gas turbine is to be operated in a corrosive atmos- phere, such as salt in marine, seashore. or earth deposits. close attention should be paid to the inlet arrangement to insure application of correct matenals and or protective coatings. KINDS OF INSPECTION General Electnc broadly classif•es its types of scheduled inspect1ons as "stand-by··. "operational data gathenng", and ··atsassembly.'' The "operational data-gathering·· inspections are used as indicators of the general condition of th'e equipment and as a guide for plannmg the disassembly main- tenance program. These inspections are performed during start-up and when the unrt is running. The "disassembly" inspections are ~rformed when the unit is on standstill and includes the combustion. hot-gas-path and major overhaul inspections. ihey require d1sassembly of the turbme to vary- ing degrees. depending upon the type of inspectron. Stand-by Inspections Stand-by inspections apply to gas turbines used in inter- mittent ser-vice where stand-by reliability is of primary con- cern. This maintenance includes changing filters, checking oil and water levels, and checking calibrations. A periodic test run is an essential part of the stand-by inspection and, there- tore, for continuous-duty. base4oaded applications, the stand- by inspection loses its s1gniftcance. Operational 'Oata~athering Inspections A good maintenance program starts with recording infor- mation about the equipment during installation, initial oper- OPERATING OAT A FOR OPERATIONAL INSPECTIONS ~O~F~C~O~M~B~I~N~E~O~a~C~Y~C=l~E~P~L~A~N~T~S __________ _ ....-----·--1 C OYPO .. I "' ~ P&aawr·f•' ~P(rt' LOAD l•(!iMC#._,-!J ••ro ~u·•~ Sill l&ll01111fa at&Ot";. 1llll"t•&1U'IU &1111!11 ... All&, r~o"' COII"II[UOJ: 11>AB••I .,,.ltLSli'&Cl II"&US' LUI!Il O•. •I £~(a lUll£ Ott ta•• IEA•Itf~ oa•••~ II uS£0 """ruu•n lUll o .. aull" s lt&a ... : ,.£AC..[A AII&L ;:OIIIP"fSSD• O•St .. all:.f CDOLIIo~ aH(II FU(L S &10lilll"l'": AlA II &"PL.~AI.l FtL 1£11~ fU[. Ll.llll fiC Hll.. !<~ • • '• 0\11,1.' liOL l&.:.l .... u tlll'l•ta,• ···~ fl£•:1 vo.la:.r filL: CUIIl•lltl sruo• u•rtaATUIIE 101&L LOA!: u~o .. :; o.•~ M[l(fl 01~" ..... &IIOI>j OAI& GAS 1U'II•1tf ""!: c.f•tfl&IO" a, us (;[&lu.,;; COU"L~:. [T; (;( .. £.&< LUI[ UVILS COC•L'"'L •&Tfll Ll VEL~ tf &'PtoC&tld Figure 10 ation, and after each iurbine shutdown or disassembly inspection. Data should be taken to establish normal equip- ment startup parameters, and critical benchmarks vs. t1me recorded from the initial start signal. GE STAG combined· cycle plants provide equipme:1t for the automatic pnntout of such data. reduc1ng the operational data-taking manpower requirements. A plot of these parameters will provide a bl'sis for judging the conditton of the control system. Deviations from the norm help pinpoint impending trouble. changes in calibration, or damaged components. Operatmg data of this type. shown in F1 , 0. should be recorded or printed out a nee each shitt. ~ he data should be ana- lyzed for abnormal trends. The genaral relationship between load and exhaust tem- peratures should be recorded and compared to prev1ous data. Variations in exhaust temperature spread should also be recorded. Excessive power loss. resulting from de1erioration of parts or leaks. may require disassembly of the turbine in order to restore power. Loss in performance. however, may onl~· be due to fouling of the compressor which can be restored by on-line cleaning. The vibrat1on level o.f the unit should be observed and recorded. Small changes will occur for vanous operatmg con- ditions; however, large changes, or a cont1nuous. increasing trend, are indications that corrective ac.11on is required. The fuel system sho~1ld be observed for fuel use vs load. Fuel pressure through the system should be monitored. Pe- riodic checks should be made of the fuel quality entenng the turbine to insure contaminants are not prevalent. particularly those that can cause hot corrosion of hot-gas-path parts. 7 r' !' I I·· I. I I < < I 1: I I~ I I I I r - I I t I J ' J ( ( I ' -,, Disassembly Inspections Bores coping To aid in maintenance-plann;ng and a possible reduction of mamtenance costs and longer Intervals between sched- uled turbine inspections. GE recommends borescoping of lhe turb1ne. Borescoping can be very useful in planning future parts requirements or repa1rs needed. as well as the timing for the next scheduled mspection. General Electric gas tur- bines have built-in borescope capability which consists of holes machined into the outer casing at strategic positions. This feature allows borescope examination of crit1cal parts in both the compressor and the hot-gas-path. To support these inspections, GE has published descrip- tions of the borescope technique. GE Fteld Engineers have also been tramed and equipped to pertonn borescope in· spect1ons and to report and 1nterpret the results. Borescope inspections cannot replace the need for visual inspection and nondestructive testing. Nevertheless, the ju- dicial use of th1s technique can reduce maintenance cost by extending inspection intervals and overhauls to a "need-to- do" point in time rather than on an elapsed time or fired-hours basis. The early review of the hot-gas-path parts can be helpful tn estabhsh1ng replacement part requirements in advance of need. particularly for thf· hot-gas-path a_nd major inspections. Hot-gas-path parts, visible with borescope, are described in Table IV and F1g. 1 1. Combustion Inspection The combustion 1nspect1on is a relatively short disassem· bly mspect1on of the combustion liners, transtt1on pieces, fuel nozzles, cross-ftre. tubes, and retarners, spark plug assem- blies. flame detectors and radtat1on shtelds During a com· bustion inspect1on. both a borescope and visual inspection should be made of those areas accessible by these means. B &J•c"o .. ._._ ~ ·-·-... - e -u•-6CCI1a _,- BORESCOPE INSPECTION ACCESS LOCATIONS 115700'1 HEAVY DUTY OAS TU"IINE • WCOOIOA.O• ..... &CCII Ia IAOOIT-11Af~ • llO.I:nU. Figure,, TABLE ~V BORESCOPE INSPECTiON AREAS Access Location Compressor Case ·Fuel Nozzles Hole & Combustion Wrapper Turbine Case MS 7001 and 9001 Stages 1. 12 & 17 Stator and Rotor Liner & Transition Pieces First Stage Nozzle Leading Edge 1. First-stage trailing edge & third-stage buckets leading edge. 2. First-stage t;>uckets trailing edge & second-stage nozzle lead1ng edge. 3. Second-stage nozzJf,· trailing edge & second-stage bucke•: leading edge. 4. Second-stage buck{!t trailing edge & thtrd s~age nozzle leadin 1 edge. ·use flexible fiber·-opttc borescopic only It is recommended that one complete set of repaire j new hardware be kept on site to in~ure that units can be ret· ..:med to service in the shortest possible time. Figure 12 illus 1rates the sectson of a typical unit that is disassembled for a com- bustion inspection. Figure 1 3 describes the work sco~. e as- sociated with a combustion inspection. Combustion linei '; and transitron pieces should be replaced wit.h new or re~:aired parts. Fuel nozzles should be cl&~ned or replaced. Afti •r the unit is returned to service, the removed hardware Cc: n be inspected and repaired as necessary at a qualified o~ '-site GE repair facility. Hot-Gas-Path Inspection The hot~gas-path inspection mcludes 1tte...L:ombustio• ~ in- spection and a visual insoect-" ~;,.o!..turbini nozzles and b .I.Ck.· ·ets. The top half of th tu , lQ.Lfl _ ot-gas-path inspection. Referring back to Ftg. 'i2, this i lus- trates the sectson of a typical tsnit that is dtsassemblec for hot-gas-path inspection. Figure 14 illustrates the type of Y 1ork scope required. The on-site av:ailability of a set of combustion hardware and first stage nozzle will minimize the inspection outage. The parts removed can be inspP.cted and repaired at a qt tal- ified facility and returned to the user's inventory. ' ,: • •• ·--•• • • • •• -.• • -~· • .. ,· • • •• -•• •••• , •• ., •• _ •• •• • •• _J. .. • ••• ., ••• :. -~· ••• :...·.··._·. :,-.~: 1=·~··-rl::..• - I i • (J r I I I 0 I 3 i " ) I ) :~~ Jj ) "\.1 '! I.-.-··· ~. .. !; . 1: I ' I I "?'" I I f li I ( ~w MS6001 SIMPI.E..CYCLE, SINGLE SHA" tiEAVY.OUiY GAS TURBINE Figure 12 Major Inspections Major inspections should be scheduled in accordance with General Elecinc·s recommendations or may be modifietj by the results ot previous inspections Th~ work scope of a major inspect1on (F1g. 15) includes that of a combustion tnspection and tn the laying open of the complete turbme at the honzontal joints. as ind1cated (refer 10 Ftg. 12). "fhe ftrst-stage nozzle is eltp-osed to the dtrect d1scharge from the combusttor· process and is subjected 1.0 the h:ghest temperature. Normally. nozzles can be repatred several tames t0 extend their hves Generally, the dec1sion to repair or re- place ts made at the time of the previous hot-gas-path tn· spect1on. Stm!larly. a decis1on relative to having a set of first- stage buckets on s1te for a hot-ga.s-path or major inspectton can be mad-e on the basis of past inspections. Data from previous i1'1::-;>ections help determine the rate of wear or de·. tP.'rtorat1on. thereby making part li1e predictions more accurate and allo·:-.rmg adequatt} ttme to plan for the next outage. ----------------------------------------------------~ TYPICAL COMBUSTION INSPECTION WORK SCOPE "'' • ..,., "--' ..... ......:. 114 • .c.u.u .... . ~·a.: • ..,,. aettctoal ....... , ...... ....... nc ••••' • ..,., ,~, ... ro"'•' ..-~~~ ......_.,.-:\ .. u ... ; .. , .. ,., ·-· I tiP J _._...,I .... tr(._.. ..... C1 &C.Q'I.._..I t.-: -.. ................ --· -'(IO,all!&l• ........ ..... ......... , -~~· WI..OC_!_ ~ -~ '· ~ ~-~-~-:_~_·~_· ___ = ___ =_,_~~c-'--·------------------J L_ ., .... Figure 13 , .. 0 ,..;,.,..,...,... ...... ,.--J.>-.. ~-·-:--~-~ '· I ; -•' .,;.;~:.:·~·~~i· • ' .. ··~···'-"'~\.. TYPICAL HOY GAS PATH INSPECTION WORK SCOPE ITt" • .... "' •• • c:~,_..,.e1c. 1'1• J .110 .. , ........ JaA.&.f • ,__,"-'-....=til ,...... .... Lt.AIID._. .... ._,..._. .,.. J 1&•1 a ~..rT1 K1 ... 1.-.. _,.._. C.S.lU..CCI &IC CiOI..C. C.t.laaa.ctl ~ ~· _,,WIJIA1• ..-.:C'Y.C. 1ft' • • •acYl 1S.1 11AII ai:IU ITt" t . -·-lftlt.ICT ... ftl" C-et.aaur:arTS•MY8a Itt• I • Clllc:-•• f!Ual ,,.,., ...... .... .... , ACt-_...e, ... .,.u' _,&An -c---·"' ALP CllaC& ca&QI ..... &.-. ... ...-cc.-..-..t:B:L.r ~·---K,_tf•a1 ~-10$ C&IM ·-~ .:!IJ't.l c:uc.as ••• -..cer-a cu .. ••• r:-.... ~-tc..-r -eMail / 61".1' .. "' c:r•c.• Figure 14 lnspi!ction lnterv.111s G111Ut Based upon a wide variety of actual operating experience. GE has developed inspection interval criteria to be used as gUidelines. Table V lists recommended inspection intervals and esti· mated down time ior current production gas turbines used in a STAG combined-cycle plant for base-load service:. burning gas. distillate and heavy fuels. With experience. however. the maintenance planner should take advantage of system fie>.· ibility by ad!u$ting maintenance intervals to suit system re- qUirements, work crew avai!abiiity: and ~imilar f~c;tors. A well-planned maintenance program insures ant1c1pattng the needs of the equ1pment and IS tailored to meet the re- quirements of the STAG eornbineel.-cycle system for availa- bility. reliability and maintenance cost GE technical direct ton is available to help plan and direct the maintenance work that will ultimately reduce downtime and labor costs. TYPICAL MAJOR INSPECTION WORK SCOPE l1tf '" ....... •• to-COfJii_,., .. ·~Ill( • L•t •••• ,,..,., •ec•• ~·-..·• a.~t•.-.•ac••~ CDifl•,_ '"• ) • M;.:»wt -~-' ,,.. .., ... ..cant ate ... "''~""" nrCIIIu • -.,c.,., ..... , . ., .. ,, ..... , '"c-~ .... .,,, • ..,..,"""'\c .. c. Dt ..:••.c. ~au• , .. , .... .,., ·-Q.IM~l' . .,.,._.,,. ... tC..&\1 ~ ···'-"·~ "'" C41&• _,.,,-...c ,.., c•u a _,lf'IUit ~· .. ......... ii"Mi~ ....... ... ",_ Clt-O'IIa...~ taD...._ o.-o.-:. ca&Q.I --' ec caar•' -c- ca.c ...... , .... -· ,._. .. , 6C CLLa• ....... u -IUJ IC~ ..... • ,.., "" t'lt.ltft•t c .. :. _.,&1,,,, ~...:::.:.;.;.:_ _ __;=.;.;.;.;..;;=---=~_.;.---'c;, ... u Figure 15 9 [ I t 1 ' I ·:=J I I C. I I I I I I II( ( I TABLE V RECOMMENDED INSPECTION INTERVALS AND ESTIMATED DOWN TIME Base load 1 Start Per 100 or More Fired Hours Inspection Fuel MS6001 F. H. O.T. Combustion G I 8 64 . D 8 64 Cor R l-3 30 XP-6 64 ' H·G·P G 24 160 D 24 160 Cor R 10-14 16G I Major G 48 320 D 48 320 Cor R 20·28 320 It is difficult to estimate the number of manhours required for each type of inspection. primarily because of the wide range of experience. productivity and working conditions that exist around the world. Based upon the assumptions in Fig. 16, howevei, such as use of an average crew oi work~r$ in ttle Un:ted States with trade skill, but ~ot necessarily direct gas turbine experience. all parts available, i.e., no repair tame. an estimate can be made as shown in Table V. Steam-Side Equipment The steam-side equipment in GE STAG combined·cycle plants consists of the HRSG. steam turbine, pumps. valves, ·- Fired Hours x 10 ' & Estimated Down Time-Hours =---- MS7001 MS9001 j-1. F. H. D.T. F. H. D.T. I 54 8 ' 64 8 I I I 8 64 a· I 64 I ~-3 :30 l-3 30 XP-6 64 XP-6 I 64 l -. 24 160 :!4 160 24 160 24 160 10·14 160 10-14 160 48 320 48 320 48 320 48 I 320 20-28 320 20-28 320 etc. and has maintenance requirements normally re~_,red in a fossil-fired steam plant except for the HRSG. wh:ch ts un- fired and requires substantially less maintenance ttlan a fired boiler (the major marntenance item in a convent1onal plant). Like the gas turbine. the HRSG should have regular in- spection criteria and interVal$ established. These criteria will depend upon the operating cycle, load duty, water and steam condit!Ons and environmental faclors that effect the various components. One of the most important considerations for both the HRSG and ~he steam turbine is maintaining proper water TABLE VI HRSG ·s-T SO YPE F INSPECT!~ /1.tt% Types of Inspection / Y / /,7· Systems & Components Standby Operational Voisassembly Remar~s / Economizer, Evaporator No Yes.~ Yes qo Check pumps & valves for proper Superheater No Ye~ Yes '\0 operating steam drain for proper lev- Steam Drum No Yes Yes (pO els: check circulating pumps for Pumps Yes f Yes Yes .~ cle.anliness; record operation param· Valves Yes Yes Ye.s eters; check water chemistry tW1ce Gauges Yes Yes Yes per shift: chedt. ducting & JOints for Switches Yes Yes Yes leakage: inspect tubes & repair Duct v.brk Yes Yes Yes leaks: check tubes for same & de- E::tpansion Joints Yes Yes Yes posite buildup & Flean pe~10<j,1cally: Activators Yes , Yes ~ Yes \ hydrostatiC test e•,ery two years: do Dampers . Yes~ all repairs dunnrJ gas turbtne outage . Yes Yes . -- 10 I --------------~--------~------------o-________ ....... ..a • • • (\ ! c I~ t ;~, ; ; F--j ..... ! t· I ' I 1 f l o, i \ I. j l ( -~ ! J i I ! ' l I 1 I J -I 1 II· .. 'l 'l . I 1,···~. i :. ,_ J I II-~· _j _: 'l I l -I .I I \ - • ! I I I I I • ~·~ l I I --- INSPECTION ASSUMPTIONS e OI .. EC:T L&IOfl • NO SUfiE .. VISIOIII • NO .. EP&!I'I T .. l • RE~L&CEIIiENT a~t. Y e A~ ,.&fliTS &V&~&IL! e A!.L NECESS& .. T TOOLS AYAil.&ILl • CREWS WIT" &YE"ACif TIUDf Sllll.L • FLANGE·TO•f'UUfGf ONLY • INS~£CTION tU.S IEEN "ltE,.L.ANNED Figure 1S chemistry. Successful operation of the steam generating equipment depends on the proper control of feedwater and operating variables to assure freedom from scale fo~ation and corrosion of water and steam surfaces.!'fhe pres€·nce of (-oxygen. oii, grease. high alkalinity should be contir.,uously ·-,nonitored and prompt corrective action taken to eliminate r such anomalies when they occur. Silica carryover will present 1a particular problem on superheater tubes and steam turbine • blading. Samples of water should be taken from a conttnuous i blowdown connection in addrtiOO to taking continuous samr pies of the saturated steam leaving the steam turbine. Sam- -;mng and determination of boiler water conditions can be made according to the methods in American Society for Test~ ing & Materials (ASTM) special Technical Publication No. 148. All boilers are susceptible to developing ·~ube leaks. AI· though the design of GE HRSG's minimizes this problem. if such leaks do occur. they sm1uld be corrected as soon as possible to preclude damage to tubes and other elements of the HRSG. In general, HRSG tru:.pections can be dtvided into three types-standby. operattorn.'l and disassembly. Table VI reflects the types of inspections and general mamtenance cons1derat1ons dunng these inspections Table TABLE VII HRSG PARAMETERS Ambient temperatures Relative humidity Feed water flows and temperatures Steam flows. temperatures, pressures Drum pressures Total solids in drum water Saturated ~team solids Blow down flvw Stack temperature VII indicates the type of parameter data that should be re- corded and analyzer on a regular basis on the HRSG. Stenm Turbine The proper maintenance of the steam turbine in a GE STAG combined-cycle plant is the same as that which is normally required of a steam turbine in a fossil-f1red plant. It is good pract1ce. however. as indicated in Table VIII, for a ~sassembly inspectJon after the 1•rst year of operat1on to ~ permit the internal evaluation of the unit. This inspect1on will · allow time for .corrective action (if needed} to be taken before an apnormal situation progresses to impact rehability. per- formance and or require expens1ve downtime. Table IX re- flects the operating parameters that should be recorded and analyzed on a periodiC basis for the steam turbine. Generators-Steam and Gas Turbines Although generators. in general. do not require a great deal of maintenance. there are several things that can be ~one to insure trouble-free operat1on. Shown in Table X are the ty-p~s of applicable inspections related to the maintenance of both·~ gas turbme and steam turbine-generators. Table XI provides the ~pe of operat1onal parameters wh1ch should TABLE VIII STEAM TURaiNE Types of Inspection Systems & Components Standby Operational Disassembly I Remarks Shells No Yes Yes I Check for leakage. record perform- Bolting . I No No Yes ance parameters. complete first d1s- Diaphragm No No Yes I assembly inspection at end o! f:r::.. Valves No Yes Yes years operat1on. Lube System No Yes Y~s Bear'"gs No No Yes H; Sys1em When Available No Yes Yes ,, '1•···--. ---'". I - !I /) I .·~ I . I. ( I I I I I :I I I I ' I I \ ! I I I ! I 1 ~ l I . 1 I I 1 ! I I I I I { l '· 1 ! I l I . i I J l I I 1 \ t \ \" . . ~r~."'-#~t --. . . I ·' be recorded and analyzed on a regular basis for trends that could indicate impending problems requiring corrective action at the next outage. STAG Combined-Cycle Control Systems . GE STAG plant control systems are configured to provide basic functions: • Automatic manual sequencing • Automatic manual process control .. Plant protection A wide range of plant control automation may be selected when buying a STAG combmed-cycle plant. It is possible to start up a complete STAG combined-cycle plant by pushing & single button. Numerous parameters are recorqed auto- matically, totalized and or displayed. The data acquisition system assoc1ated w1th the GE STAG combined-cycle plants will print out. upon request, those parameters which in older plants had to be recorded by hand. In order to reap the beneftts built into the automation of the plant, it is necessary Parameters TABLE IX STEAM TURBINE Bearing oil inlet and di~·:11arge terr.peratures Inlet steam pressure Steam pressure Extraction of first stage shell pressure Vibration Shell meter temperatures Differential expansion Exhaust pressure or vacuum Hydraulic pressure to have trained maintenance and operating personnel. Com- ponents such as senstng dev1ces and regulating valves should be inspected regularly and maintained properly. Control valves, pressure and temperature devices. gauges. and control panels should be checked monthly by qualified personnel. Downtime can be reduced by having adequate spare parts on hand. TABLE X Systems Gas Turbme Steam Turb1ne Controls (Panels 1Consoles) Station Gas Turbine HRSG Steam Turbine 12 \ INSPECTION TYPES AND GENERAL REMARKS FOR THE INSPECTION OF GENERATORS Types of Inspection Standby Operationnl I Disassembly I Remarks Yes Yes Yes I Check for leaks~ record performance Yes Yes Yes j parameters. After first year's opera- tion. at a minimum, the top end · shield should be removed and a bore- scope and cleanliness check made. Meggar and polarizai:!:.:i:-~ tests should also be pertormed. Some manufac- turers may recommend field removal at this ttme. Future inspections will depend upon usage and deteriora· tion of performance parameters. D1s- assembly inspections should be performed while the gas turbine or steam turbine is undergomg a,, ex- tended outage inspection. Yes Yes No Check for proper functionil"lg: replace Yes Yes No cards and'or devices not functtomng Yes Yes No properly; troubleshoot as required: Yes Yes No vacuum cabtnets periodically; check controls for r.~librat1on at least once a year and mort> often when possible. -·•~·-• •••• '"' "W'-1-" -- l I ~ . ·:' -;::_,., . • • I·· I •'-' I I I il I I ~ c ~·~ I 1. I I I I I .~ I ' I I ~~ * ~) I I I f/ l I 1 l' ~ II ,, :1 (i . • Parameters Output voltage Phase current VARs Field voltage Field current () TABLE XI GENERATORS Stator temperatures kWh total Load using kWh meter disk Vibration Data; Gas turbine and generator plus gearing. coupling, etc. General: Lube, levels Cooling water levels (if applicable) Hydraulic pressure Generator cold·gas te!Tiperature Generator armature winding temperature Generator field winding temperature Collector and excitor (if applicable) Brush wear SUMMARY An analysis of the O&M costs for a power plant provides a good indication as to the quality of the equipment purchased and, to a large degree, the operation and maintenance prac- tices of a given utility. O&M costs normally represent a small portion of the total plant operating co~t. The benefits, however, of using proper maintenance. pia• .ning, and equipment with trained person- nel and using adequate operating procedures far outweigh the cost involved. Proper matntenance will provide max1mum plant availability and reliability. General Electric STAG combined-cycle maintenance cost data show similar values to those observed for conventional fossil plants. On natural gas, STAG combined cycles typically have lower O&M cost; while on heavy fuels. the costs are somewhat higher. At the current cost of fuels, however, the efficiency and a·1ailability «dvantages of combined cycles are the dominant economic factors for consideration. This paper has described the types of recommended O&M schedules and procedures for optimum plant periormance. General Electric personnel will be pleased to provide addi- tional infoilTlation or assistance in the development of a main- tenance schedule or resolution of a maintenance problem. '" ' .. ,_.~,---.... ,,_,_$_;=·-· ·······-··--· ··-. [ 13 r-:--r - I l JJ1 "1 I. I ll I I II ~-~ I I l I ( ··~ I I I I I jl l I 1-,. i I l l l I· ; . ;,.;; i I I •. f • ! I w 1 I l I .\ I \ .... ! I f7 ~ To Convert acres atm atm bars bars Btu Btu Btu/h Btu/h Btu/h Btu/hp·h Btu/hp-h Btu/kWh Btu/kWh Btullb Btu/lb ·c ·c cm3 cm 3 •F ft ft2 ~~3 ft 3 tt-lb ft·lb ft/min ft 3/min ft3/min gal gal/min hectares hp (U.S.) -~-. ·-· -. _ .... _____ • ~ .. l CONVERSION FACTORS ~ The following is a list of conversion factors most commonly used for gas turbine performance. To Multiply By To Convert To' Multiply By hectares 4.047 X 10-1 hp (U.S.) hp (metric) 1.014 kg/cm 2 1.0333 in. em 2.540 lb/in.2 1.47 X 101 in. mm 2.54 X 101 atm 9.869 X 10-1 in.2 mm 2 6.452 X 1Q2 lb/in.2 1.45 X 10 1 in. of mercury kg/cm2 3.453 ; •. 10-2 J (joules) 1.055 X 103 in. of water ! kcal 2.52 X 10-1 (at 4 ·c) kg/cm 2 2.54 X 10-3 kcal/h 2.520 X 10-1 kJ/h 1.0548 in. of water (at 4 ·c) lb/in.2 3.613 X 10-2 W (watts) 2.931 X 10-1 kcal/kWh 3.379 X 10-1 J Btu 9.486 X 10-4 kJ/kWh 1.4148 kg Jb 2.2046 kcal/kWh 2.5198 X 10-1 kg/cm 2 lb/in.2 1.422 X 10 1 kJ/kWh 1.0548 kg-m ft·lb 7.233 kcal/kg 5.555 X 10-1 kg/m 3 lb/ft3 6.243 X 10-2 kJ/kg 2.3256 km miles (statute) 6.214 X 10-1 •F (°C X 9/5) + 32 kW hp 1.341 K ·c + 273.18 I ft 3 3.531 X 10-2 ft3 3.531 X 10-S lb kg 4.536 x ,o-, . in.3 6.102 X 10-2 Jb!in.2 kg/cm 2 7.03 x ,o-2 ·c ( •F-32) X 5/9 lb/in.2 Fa 6.8948 X 103 m 3.048 X 10-1 lb·ft2 kg-rri 2 4.214 X 10-1 m2 9.29 x ,o-2 1/min tt 3/s 5.886 x ,o-4 I {liters} 2.832 X 101 lim in galls 4.403 X 10-3 m3 2.832 X 10-2 m ft 3.281 Btu 1.286 X 10-3 m2 ft 2 1.076 X 10.1 kg-m 1.383 X 10-1 m3 tt3 3.531 X 10i km/h 1.8288 X 10-2 mile (statute) kiTl 1.6093 lis 4.720 X 10-1 tons (metric) k~l 1.0 X 103 m 3/min 2.832 X 10-2 tons (metric) lb 2.205 X 103 m3 3.785 X 10-3 w Btu/h 3.4129 1/s 6.308 X 10-2 w BtLI/min 5.688 x ,o-2 acres 2.471 w ft-lb/s 7.378 X 10-1 kW 7.457 X 10-1 w hp 1.341 X 10-3 ~ - I I I I "\ I ·i I 'J l I ,·'t I /I I I I (. j " 'C' jj ,M, !:t ~ (,' ~ _,.~ ,J '·' ' ; : ' ''· "' ' " 1983 GAS TURBINE REFERENCE LIBRARY GER-3400 ST A j Combined-Cycle Operating Experience GER-3421 Ad .. ·anced Materials and Coatings GER-3401 ST A:::; Combined-Cycle Product Une GER-3422 GE MS7001 Hta\'Y·Duty Cia$ Turbine GER-3402 ST Aw Combined-Cycle Plant Engineering and GER-3413 Electric Utility Gas Turbine AJ)plications Construction M~emmt GER-3424 Aircraft· Deri\'ath e Maintenance. Practices GER-3403 Steam Turbines for 5T AG Combined-Cycle Power GER-342.5 GE LM.5000 .-\.irc:raft-~ri..,·ath·e Ga.:; Turbine Systems System GER-3404 Heat R«ovtf)' Steam Generators for STAG Combined-Cyc:le Plari._ GER-3426 GE Mark I\' SPEEDTRONIC Control System GER-340.5 Controls for STAG Combined-Cycle Planu GER-3427 GE Data-Tronk Information and Control System GER-3406 STAG Combined-Cycle Po\:. ;!r Systems Reliability GER-3428 Fuels Flexibility in Heavy-Out) ~ Turbines OER-J407 STAG Combined-Cycle Power Systems Opera\tion GER-3429 Meeting the Quality Commitment with Experience and Maintenance and Technology GER-3408 STAG Combined-Cycle Fuel Flexibilit~ and GER-3430 Industrial ~~ Turbii!e Cogeneration Application Economic E\·aluation Considerations GER-3409 STAG Combined-Cycle Plants in Po~er Genemtion GER-3431 GE LM~SOO . .6Jrc:raft-Derh·ati .. e 9as Turbine System Planning Analysis GER-343:::! GE MS9CXX> Hta\) -Duty Ga.s Turbine GER-3410 Combined-Cycle Repo .. ering Mecham.:-!> and GER-3433 Applic-ation of Gas Turbines in the Proces!> Industry Economics GER-~411 STAG Combined-Cyck System Econom1~ GER-3412 Hea\·y-Duty ~Turbine Maintenance Pra~i~e.s GER-3413 GE MS600l -Hea\·y-Duty Gas Turbine GER-3414 Ga~ Turbine Pans and Performam:e t:pdate GER-~41.5 Gas 7urbine~ in Mechani;:a] Dri\e Appli.:a:•on~ GER-.3416 GE Compressors for Pipeline and Process Appli(:ations GER-3418 Generators for Ga~ Turbine Apphcatiom GER-3419 Gas Turbine Inlet Air Treatment CANADIAN GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY 1900 Eglinton A\,enue, East Scarborough, Ontario, Canada GER-34~ GER-~·13S GER-3436 GER-343i GER-3438 GER-3439 GER-34SI Ro."'ent De\'elopmen~ and Design Philosophy for Hta\'~·Dut~ Ga~o Turbine!. GE Gas Turbine Multiple..Combustion System!. Project Managernem Concepts Performance Chara.:terisucs Liquid Fuel Treatment Systems Coal-Fired STAG Combined-Cycle Appli~atiom Legislation and Regulatiom Aff«ting Cogeneration GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY International Trading Operations ~\70 Lexington Avenue New YSlrlt City, New York 10022 USA GAS TURBINE DIVISION GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY SCHENECTADY, NEW YORK 12345 USA 5-84 (JMl GENERAL a. v ELECTRIC --= .. ... • Q • 4. QUESTIO.E b) Basis and supporting data for the portion of O&M costs represented by "in-house parts repair" and the effect it had on total fixed O&M costs~ RESPONSE Telephone contacts of several Alaskan utilities revealed that significant in-house repair practices were being utilized in the overhaul and maintenance of their combustion turbine generators. This was most notably reflected in the Alaska utilities' practices regarding the repair and refurbishment of combustion turbine replacement parts. In the Lower 4a; utilities regularly rely on the original equipment manufacturer to provide these repairs. The Alaskan utilities contacted were Chugach Electric Association, and Golden Valley Electric Association, and Anchorage Municipal Light & Power Company. Anchorage Municipal Light & Power Company reported replacement and repair of the following combustion · turbine parts through their own in-house repair capabilities: 32. 1 I I I I I I I I I 1~. ' i J . I . I) J l ll j l ! 1 .J II J ,II I• I I li· l ' u l II t I { ~'· · .. ·-'i 0 ., . 0 Combustion liners and transition pieces 0 Compressor stationary blading componen-ts 0 Hot parts ~tationary components 0 First and second .stage nozzle repair Replacement and repair of these parts through in-house practices accounts for app~o~imately 50 percent of the total cost of each co~ustion turbine overhaul, with in=hcuse repair senerally less costly than manufacturer repair. Also, in-house repair is normally a fixed cost while ma:n\lfacturer repair is nofmally a variable cost. A comparison of the O&M costs from the License Application with those of the Power Authority DEIS comments -Appendix I show a marked shift of cost from the variable to the fixed component as a result of t k . th . . h . f . . ~ -t' a 1ng 1s 1n~ ouse repa1r unct1on ~n~~ aacoun • Assuming a simple cycle unit operates at a 20 percent plant factor, total (fixed plus variable) O&M costs would be reduced by about 27 percent due to in-house maintenance. A reduction of about 19 percent wollld occur for a combined cycle unit as!3uming an 8 0 percent plant factoro 33. J l ! { ! ! ! t ;\I I t I I j I I I I I ~~ I 1: ~ 4. QUESTION c) Equipment manufacturers data and related APA inputs used to justify the changes in the thermal cycle conditions and auxiliary power requirements which led to the changes in simple cycle gas turbine and combined cycle heat rate data. RESPONSE The calculation for plant performance used in the Power Authority's DEIS comment was based on informal contacts with turbine manufacturers. Subsequently, formal documentation was requested from GE, which resulted in some minor revisions of the original data. These revisions are found in the attached letter to Ebasco, dated October 19, 1)84. (Attachment 4c.l) In that letter, GE documents the heat rate of the simple cycle, ISO ratings and auxiliary loads for both simple and combined cycle un5ts. Since the basis of the letter .; C:" _,_ ... , expressed in lower heating values than those used in the DEIS comments, the following corrections must be made to compare the number. 34. I t f<i 1 ! 11 ~ l r 11 ! f, l . I I I I I I I I I j l i l j I j J I c '1 i . \ ', . f L L •' ~ ,· (l_ (! Heat Rate (LHV) Correction Factor Heat Rate (MHV) 10,610 X 1.11 11,777 The above number is at ISO conditions. At the average annual temperature of the Cook Inlet (33°F), the Yating would be approximateiy 11,660. The combined cycle data is taken from a GE publication entitled "STAG Combined Cycle Performance Data." In that publication, the following heat rate is given. Heat Rate (LHV) Correction Factor Heat Rate (MHV) 7,620 }!: 1.11 8,458 The actual output of a combined cycle machine is dependent upon detailed auxiliary power requirements and the condenser back pressure of the steam cycle. Because an Alaskan unit's condenser will likely be air cooled, the outpu·l:. of the power plant will not be as efficient. New performance calculations at 33°F have not been completed for the combined cyt.~le, based upon the revised data. However it is safe to assume that the valve used in the latest analysis is optimistic with respect to plant performance. Hence, it fav~rs the thermal alternatives in a comparison with the Susitna Project. 35. I ··.. .. . ·-· ~":-J' ···I·_; ~ f! fl ' "' I' .. 1 ' ] 1\' ' ' ' •' 1: ' I~ I I. I~ ,. I I l I ! I ! l [ I ~ '• .. ' l I f .. j r ! I I f ,!. ---~· l L ! I 1 L l !, \ f. 4o QUESTION d) A copy of the Alaska Public Utilities Commission ruling requiring a 20-yea~ life for combustion turbines and justification for ~ 40-year life for transmission facilities. RESPONSE There is no formal Alaska Public Utilities Commission (APUC) "ruling" requiring a 20-year useful lifa for combustion turbines. The Po~ver Authority's statement in the DEIS was based upon the fact that in recent rate filings with the APUC some Alaska electric utilities have proposed depreciating their combustion turbines over 16 2/3 years. Based on these filings, the Power Authority established the 20-year estimate noted in the DEIS. The Power Authority has confirmed the validity of its 20-year useful life estimate for combustion turbines in discussions with APUC staff engineers. In those discussions, the APUC staff has indicated that the 30-year useful life typically assigned a combustion turbine in the Lower 48 is inapplicable for Alaska, where combustion turbines are operated as base-load 36. E I K!, . I " . I / i ' ·~ I 1! .. y The Power Authority believes that the Lower 48 concensus of a 50-year economic lifetime for steel-towered transmission facilities, is inappropriate for Alaska, due to the extreme climate of Interior Alaska. Thus, the expected service of steel-towered transmission facilities has been reduced to ~0 years for use in Susitna economic analyses. I r r f 1;_, I r I • L j ~ 1 r 1 ~ ' I ~ v t I ~ r... 38. ····-···-··"' -···-·1·· .......... . . .. " .. ' I I I 1 1 .. ~· ! .. I ,. I I I . i ,. l• ~ I { II 1 ) t I. I : I . .. I 1: i .: I :::-! I• ll j I I 5. \ QUESTION Copies of the Power Authority/Harza-Ebasco detailed estimates of Susitna O&M which were used to justify the reduced Susitna O&M cost. (This pertains to the revised hydroelectric parameters as discussed in Volume 3, Appendix I of the Power Authority's comments). RESPONSE The Power Authority's original estimate of the Susitna operation and maintenance costs was presented in Table D-5 of the License Application, and is attached hereto as Attachment 5.1. The License Application scheme was based on full staffing on-site at both the Watana and Devil Canyon power plants for the life of the project. In conjunction with the project design refinements, the Power Authority has re-evaluated the Susitna operation and maintenance costs. The revised estimate is presented in Attachment 5.2. The primary reason for the reduction in cost is a revised approach to the project operating and maintenance staffing requirements. Review of current practice by the u.s. Bureau of Reclamation indicates that full staffing on-site is neither warranted nor ,• 39 .. - I I I I I I I I I ,rl,l, , I; ! _I -, I I 'l l i ' f r I I' i I , I I 1 I lil I I I f 1 ![ [ :T-----···------.~····-- desireable for Susitna. The Power Authority recognizes the need to have an adequate ~taff on-site during the initial start-up and shake-down period for the Susitna power plants. However, after an es;timated four--year break-in period, it will be desireable to move the Susitna operations center to ·a loc?tion better suited for dispatching the project power and energy. It has been suggested that Willow might serve as the ultimate control point. Since it is closer to the power purchasers and users, the Susitna operation can better respond to changes in system load requirements. Also, the costs of maintaining staff at Willow will be less than staffing a remote site such as the Watana or Devil Canyon power plants. The proposed staffing scheme which is the basis for the revised cost estimate is shown in Attachment 5.3. The initial staffing required at the powerplants has been reduced based on a more refined estimate by the Power Authority. Attachment 5.4 provides the unit prices applied to the staffing set forth in .Attachment 5.3, thus providing the labor costs presented in Attachment 5.2. 40. ,.... ... ~~ - I I I ! ·~ I I I \:'II '1-~' .. ;· ' . ' l l ' I I I I I I I I ' ' I n.··. :·-~~.-~-,~: -~~-~.----·~;-:::-··~--·~ .. -------·-.. · .. ---.-· r--~ . .. . With respect to Attachment. 5. 2, labor costs for Power Transmission and Townsite Operations a:t"e estimated based on the staffing shown in Attachment 5.3 and the annual costs shown i11 Attachment 5. 4. The expense estimates for Pow·er Transmission and Contracted Services are unchanged for the initial staffing at Watana and Devil Canyon. The eventual expense for Power Transmission is estimated to be the same as the Watana initial expense. The eventual expense for Contracted Services is estimated to be the Watana initial expense plus an additional $150,000 annually. This additional amount rep:resents an allowance for special contracted services estimated on the following basis: 0 crew of 10 workers; 0 avera9.e annual cost of $60,000; and o. services required :3 months out of the year on average .. Hence: 10 X $60,000 X 3/12 -$150,000 The estimated expenses for Townsite Operations are reduced to reflect the reductiun i'l initial staffing requirements on-site. In Attachment 5.2 eventual 41. ! . '"'""' , ........ ~,-·?~··,e··-··· -~-·-·· f{ '\ 'I ·, t I 1 ! . I ! I j i j ' \ J j I l 1 f ; l I I I ! I I \ ,1 l ,, I I ·- I I I. I I ·1 I I. 1 I ' l '] I jt I 1 I I I I 'i I· I , . ,) I I I 11 l I~ t I . I I expenses for Townsite Operations are estimated to be tb~ same as the Watana initial expense. Estimated costs of operation and maintenance related to Environmental Mitigation were not increased for addition of the Devil Canyon development. Hence, $1,000,000 annually was used for both Watana alone and combined project operation. This effectively reduces the License Application estimate by half for combined operation mitigation. Contingency on the estimate has been increased from 10 percent to 15 percent, providing a higher margin for uncertainty in the estimate. The allowance to replace community facilitias has been eliminated. Note that the Susitna O&M costs presented at the bottom of Table 8-2 (Appendix I of the Power Authority's Comments on DEIS) are in 1983 dollars (See Attachment 5.2). These 1983 values were deflated to the 1982 price level for use in the economic analysis. ' 42. (I [\. l . "~' Attachment 5.1 TABLE D.5: SUl~RY OF OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE COSTS ~ ~-.. Power & Transmission Operation/ Maintenance· Contracted Services Permanent Townsite Operations Allowance for Environmental ~1i tigation Contingency Additional Allowance from 2002 to Replace Community Facilities Total Operating and Maintenance Expenditure Estimate Power Development and Transmission Facilities (1) Incremental ~· ...... .. .. ,··---·-···· . ,. ···-··---· JIM WATANA ($000 's Omitted) Expense Labor Items Subtotal 5330 990 6320 900 900 540 340 880 1000 900 400 WATANA 10,400 .. '"2 .... .. llllll [~~-,_ ', 4T < - DEVIL CANYON! ($000 • s Omitted) Expense Labor Items Subtotal 1920 500 480 120 80 DEVIL CANYON liiliillililllt ~ IIIII - 2420 480 200 1000 500 200 4,800 lliill' ~ -~-·--.., _,_,..___...-""' ·:--·~-.v- r • t f l 1 1 I l ~-il-!fi??$ ~ 1 ':· l Jl Labor Power Transmission 3300 . 2/ Contracted Service~ . Tbwnsite Ope~ations 625 Environmental Mitigation Contingency ( 15%) Total, January 1982 dollars Escalation to 1983 dollars (6%) Total 1 January 1983 dollars SUSITNA HYDROELECI'RIC PRa:r:ocT · OPERATION AND MAINrENANCE COST ESTIMATES ($1000/yr) Initial/ Watana- Initial 21 Devil Canyon--: Expenses Subtotal Labor Expenses Subtotal 990 4920 625 500 1125 900 900 480 480 180 805 400 55 455 1000 -- 1045 310 8040 2370 480 140 8520 2510 Attachment 5. 2 Eventual Total Project Labor Expenses Subtotal 2470 990 3460 1050 1050 285 180 465 1000 895 6870 410 7280 1f For first 4 years of operation of each development. y Includes annual rr.aintenance services, major maintenance overhaul, helicopter service 1 and road maintenance. Tl-,l .· ' ' I I ! I l i ') I ,..:ri""'iMftilf J ·. I ;·. ! I f l l ~ .. .. .. ~-~ ~ .. : lflllll ]111111 .. .. ... .. ~ .. .. .. .. .. 1 .- r/ti!~ .-!-,! ~ ·-·--·---~~-~---··--· {~'"'~,-~ ~l \,'"t> - ; . '\ ,I r. I l l• ) I·· ~l . j ~' ]I I , , l I A ._· l j ,·J 1·-· 1 ' 1 : '~ I,. __ · l .• 1 J ·I' i I :1 I I" j •. 'I I ! . . j I I I 1 l l t I i Superintendent Assistant Chief Admin. Clerk/Typists Operators Maintenance Line Crew Townsite Subtotal Total PROPOSED PROJECT !~NPOWER Initial Devil Watana Canyon Willow 1 1 1 1 3 2 21 25 8 1 5 11 7 80 7 87 P .. ttachment 5. 3 Eventual Site Willow 1 1 1 l 3 14 17..!/ 1 5 5 24 25 49 ..!/ With support of 10 technicians on site about 3 months in each year included in contracted services. i I j l I I I t ! I I I I I I .. l \ ! f .. I I I I i I f I I j '1 ! I l I ,j '.,, j < I I I ~ l j l I I I l I I 1 I I I I I I ~~ I I I I I -\ l I t! , I I I I j I l I I I I I I l I ,. ) l I ( I 1 I ! I ~·· ' .. , . .. . . ~ ----------- Attac!unent 5.4 SUSI'l'NA OPERATICN AND !-~ LABeR ca;TS BASIS FOR REVISID :ES"l'J'Mr\'l'E Sta.ffjng Pequirenents ' Associated Costs Initial Eventual Position No. $1000/yr. ...,No......._. ____ .... sl...,O;..;,O.;;.O/..,.yr~· SUperintendent Assistant Chief/Mnin. Clerk/Typist ~tors Chief Shift cpe...'Cltors $561000 47'.?500 35,00~1 22,500 48,000 40,000 1/ -1:.1 1/1 1/ - 3/2 1/ - 20/- Plant Maintenance Line Crew 5o,ooo!/ 51,00~/ 26/8 51 - Townsite Security, ::ire Protection, Paraxredic, Wai.ehouse Salaries an::l wages Allowances (15%) ~.rt.in'e (10%) 45,00~/ - 58/11 1117 Salaries am Wages ll/7 Allowances (15%) CXrertilre ( 10%) Labor Total Staffing Total a7 56/- 47.5/47.5 35/- 67.5/45 48/ - 800/ - 1,300/400 255/ - 2,609/492.5 391/ 75 300/ ~ 3300/625 495/315 495/315 74/ 48 56/ 37 625/400 1 1 1 4 l 13 18 2. 44 5 5 11 Annl.lt.l costs are the same as those used in the License Application except as othel:wise nota:l. ll "!" distinguishes Watana/Devil Canyon. lf New position created for this estimate. !I. License Applicat:-.:m value • $47,250. 2,1 License Application value • $50,750. !/ License ~lication value = $47,250. 56 47c5 35 90 48 520 900 255 1957 2S~ 225 2470 225 225 34 26 - 285 f, I . ·----------·----. I I I I I I I I' I I. IJ I. I 1 .. I_ l L [ [ 6 .. r,·;' .. ~' ,r "' "-<,·. • .~. QUESTION A copy of the data (both before and after it was revised and provided) to the Anchorage Chamber of Commerce .. :o support the Cook Inlet Natural Gas usages for power generation shown in Exhibits 31 and 34, pages 70 and 75 of the "Electric Power Generation for the Alaska Railbelt Region" by KENTCO dated January, 1984. RESPONSE The Cook Inlet natural gas usage for power generation presented in the KENTCO report are essentially those values containea in Table D-1.3 of the revised License Application of July 1983. The methodology for estimat- ing gas consumption for power generation (presented in Table D-1.3 of the License Application) is described below. The basic steps are: 0 0 Estimate the projected Railbelt generation requirements for the year. This net genera- tion will compri~e sales plus some assumed losses for transmission and distribution~ Establish what portion of the generation will be served by gas-fired generation. 43. ····r· ...... . • ,. I I I I I. I I. I ·. ·)I .. I I ! I I I I. [. L L L Assume a heat rate that ~11ill apply to the gas-fired.plants (Btu/kWh). 0 Based on the assumed heat rate, the heating value of the gas being burned (Btu per unit volume) , and the amount of energy to be generated, the gas consumption is calculated. KENTCO has extended the estimates beyond year 2010 to year 2015. Also, the values presented by KENTCO for years 2003, 2004, 2005, and 2007 differ by Og1 BCF from those presented in the Application. The Power Authority does not know the methodology which KENTCO employed to extend the usage beyond year 2010, nor can the Power Authority explain the slight difference in the four years noted above. ,{; As is the case with many of the Power Authority's study parameters, the methodology for estimating gas consumption has undergone review and revision since the July 1983 License Application submission. Cnrrently, the Applicant's natural gas consumption figures are obtained directly from the OGP program analysis .. For the Without-Susitna expansion plan, the simulation of Railbelt system gross generation computes the fuel consumption each year. This is a preferred approach, 44. - I 1: I l ,. ~ J I I I r r . -< because the gas-fired units are optimally dispatched within the systf;m by OGP and the resulting consumption figures are therefore more realistic. The current estimates of natural gas constirtlp·tion a:ce presented in Attachment 6.l~ As an example of the relationship between these figures and the OGP analysis, the basis fo~ the 23.2 billion cubic feet (Bcf) assumption for the "Without-Susitna" expansion plan is found on page 7 of output LJN10206 of Appendix 1, Part B of this sutmittal. 45. J ~ !I ( ~ \\ \~ ; I. I I { '! I ·"j I 1 li ' I I I l I. ~ ! ,...... • I ' l ~ I l j l I ~., ! ,. -j ] I j I I 1 < f j l I ! r j l '4.f I j ., ! f I l l I l Year 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1996 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 20.07 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 1.1 Atta.c.!unent 6. 1 CONSUMPTION OF COOK INLET NATURAL GAS :Consumption for 11 Electric Generation - (BCF) 29.7 31.3 32 .• 6 34.2 31.3 32.8 32.9 33.8 33.3 23 .. 2 24.0 25.0 15.2 16.7 17.3 17.0 16!!7 19.6 20.5 21o5 22.6 14.5 15 •. 5 16.7 17.4 11.5 13.0 13.8 8.7 9.5 10.2 11.0 11.9 7.4 8.2 9 .. 3 10.0 Consumption for years 1993 through 2020 from OGP Without-Susitna run reported in Alaska Power Authority Comments on the DEIS, August 1984. Consumption for 19P! through 1992 based on a supplemental OGP run made for this purpose. ~-" "' ~-·--~~.,¥-·-~-"'-., ..... . . 0 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I J 1 .. · ' . ' I 7. a) QUESTION The unit cost estimate referred to in Table II for the Johnson project. Provide a site plan, geologic reports, and cross sections of major project features used to prepare the cost.estimate. RESPONSE The data requested is contained in Table 11 of Appendix II of the Power Authority's August 23, 1984 comments on the DEIS, not Table II. Available data used in preparing the Johnson site cost estimate are provided herewith as Attachments 7a.1 and 7a.2. These include the general site plan (Attachment 7a.l) and darn embankment typical cross section (Attachment 7a.2). No geologic reports are known to exist for the Johnson site. 46. ··-~r: _· -------,---------~-·---·-··------·--~-----------------·~------.. --··1· -·· -~=------.. -·--·--·---.. ··----. -·-·-·--------. :·; !1. t I I I I I I I I I I ' I I I .· ' I ..1 w 2 < ::r (,) •• ~. t 7a.l Attachmen ··--'"-~~-~ _.., --'"'''*b•····~·~~ .. r l ' ' c .~·· I I I I I I I I r::.O .. t; / r::.O ,.,; / I I I I I I I I I II J 0 Gl .. .. _; Ill ; \ ... s • c ... u. Ul ~ 0 ,_ ""' ... ..; w _; ~ 2 ;::) :! )( c 2 Attachment 7a.l w > ~ < z w 0 a: t-0 0 .. w a; ... ui 1-.. = ...1 0 .. ;::) < a: 1111 c:l I Q ~ ~ z > c 0 (.) :I: .., Cl) z : 0 ., .,,1 ___ -·,J--·-~---------~-------~-----~-------.. ··----------T-.,,--z~-~-.... ·------~ .. ---~------~--------~-----.... ··-· ----- ' -' c\ ) l 'h';atl··-~ I ~~ -; I ,..-"'"' I • I I , .. I f' , , • • . -;, ._.....,...1 ----~-----i.L ____ --~---~·.....;.·-·-· -· --.-~-·L--·-·: .. ~'~-,~~-~>h'"'-#~.,_,,..."''"-,...."">W~->.-....-.~·-~-n-~'.,__""__,&.....,.._.,._,.,,,_,,~--~·""..._,__' ______________ .....;.,_ ~~::r ......... ~-~ ........ ---... ~----------~ ..... llltllll ... ~ w ~---' -'. ·.. --~ -. ·-· ,, ~" ,._., ..,.-<-«_-'-.,.--.. ~~A~R:AL MAX. WL ~ DICATED ON PLAN) .................. ......... COMPACTED PERVIOUS FILl GRAVEL SURFACE COMPACTED PERVIOUS FILL "'------. GM)UND SURFACE -.."--- ................... ....... VARIES TOP 'OF ROCK _ ____, ..... ···TOP OF SOUND ROCK _DAM CROSS SECTION ALTERNAtiVE HYDRO SITES TYPICAL DAM SECTION FI~URE 2 0 lee> 300 l I ~ SCALE: S ''= 300 ~ rt s:u 0 [ (]) !:;j rt ...... ) s:u • N l W •r-------,--.----:--~·~,_.,..,.....,.........-~,....-----~~ - f: ' '.A._*_ l;l' ,;"', J: I _. ~ I I j I l' J .. ~"' .>' r . :_ < ~-.. :;,_~ 1,_ .... _., ~ . m-: ~ ! I I 1 l . l I .l -··t l \ I' I~ 0 QUESTION The operation simulations for the alternative hydro sites referred to on page 9-4. Include a description of the computer program, RESOP, and all input and output data • RESPONSE The RESOJ? computer model used to perform the operation simulations for the alternative hydro sites is essen- tially the Susitna simulation model described in detail in Exhibit B, Volume 1, Section 2.8 of the License Application. The Applicant has made some minor modifications to include the effects of variable tailwater elevations and variable turbine efficiencies. The model can simulate the operation of one or two reservoirs. Attachments 7b.1 through 7b.S transmit the requested operation simulation data for the Snow, Keetna" Bror.-Jne, Chakachamna, and Johnson developmer.t:.s, respectively. The attached data support Table 18 of Appendix II of the Power Authority's DEIS comments. As discussed in ' those comments, the results of the three different 47. c ~ f l I I • J ,, I I . ! \ l I 1 I ! ) I J I t ! I l [ I t: t I l \ ~l ! ·~ i 't ~ l 1 ~ l arrangements are quite similar. Hence, data for the base case only is provid~d~ The simulation data provided for each project is organized t.::: follows (refer to At:tachment 7b.l): Input Data 1. Natural Streamflow (monthly) 2. Evaporation (neglected) 3o 4. 5" 6. 7. Reservoir area-volume and tailwat.er rating Po.werplant charact,eristics Operation constraints (rule curve) .Release constraints (natural streamflow and required monthly minimum) Energy generation criteria (system demand, monthly and annual) Output Data 8. ~rurbine discharge (·total from powerhouse) 9.. Energy production 10.. Post-pr·: -~~ct flows downstream of project 11. Summary .t:'Jf: p~oj ect capability and energy -·-. ------~·~·······.:-·"~-·--···-:-·--.. -~----~-.--~..,. ---·-·····----.--·--·-----.. ---·--·-.---.,-~ .. • ... 4',_~-. 48. D "j J .. ;l ~- • 1 J ·~ I II: I ! lj :. r j ~-- I I ~ ( ---,.,_ simulation arrangements are quite similar. Hence, d~ta for the base case only is provided. The simulation data provided for each project is organized as follows (refer to Attachment 7b.1): Input Data 1. Natural Streamflow (monthly) 2. Evaporation (neglected) 3. Reservoir area-volume and tailwater rating 4. Powerplant characteristics 5. Operation constraints (rule curve) 6. Release constraints (natural streamflow and required monthly minimum} 7. Energy generation ~~iteria (system demand, monthly and annual) Outpt_;!, Data 8. 9. 10. 11 .. Turbine discharge (total from powerhouse) Energy production Post-project flows downstream of project Summary of project capability and energy 48. ' 'l: -I -~ 4 , I' ,j ~ , \... --·-.0'.--~-~-~.-·-·-" ~,~ .... ~,......J... •. -......... ,. •• ~__,...,~-oemi,_. ____ _ · . .-.. _,-•' ' it i\'l! •. :ti'Jfl\1 .,."::-·""'~·~··""'·· , ... ..._ ~ .._ ._ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'Jill!l'llll!!l ~ ..... ~-... - Attachment 7b.l Page 1 of 8 ... --. -------·· -----·-···----. -. ---.. . ---··---·------·--·----···--------------·--- lj • • . l •j ' •• I i \ . :i .t ·,. ;! ·! • l ll SNOw Al TE.RNA fl VE HVI.liW PHUJECT NSO YEAH 2010 a &444 G~H -,;, tk I 8 · ~ ,,..,,, P. I ~5~~~~-f~iEi~----·····-· -·------i~> FLO" OAfi---k~)tb-f~~lfY-tii M~W~~~~~~~~--~~~~~~~~~~~~~--~~ . ·----l~f.UT __ Q~ TA __ t:_!J!t_SNO~-·-------·--:CNPU/ . -~TURAf.: __ STREAMFLUW AT OAHSITE ___ , YEAR OCT NOV l.lEC JAN FEB MAH APH MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP -~~---~!~~----~~-·--~· 2~. b0~--q~~8~~~·l~~~q~·-----------------------------1949 4&&. 137, 33. t&. 1.2. tb, .28, 337 .. ust. t'~7t, ITue. 1509, 1950 310. 435, 173. 39, ~3. .21. 23, l04, 1639, ~108, .2219, ll38~·~-------------------------------------195l-n~--iis-;--2t. a7:--i2-.~-f2. 11. Jor.-t-uss:-2~r,rc;-;-rqrr:2us8. ___l952 110, 61, 41, ~o. 17, lb. 13, 79, 10b4, 2~n·o~a._~I4~73~.-.~7To~~'~·---------------------------------------------------------- 1953 877. 588. 195, 78, 48, 29. liB, 913, lSbU, 3018, 222&, 101.2, __l~~LJUf!..___A?~. 51 .!..~~-4 ~--2~-·--l~. l:J..L-Sb? ..L..!2~-~ -...:.!l.~~Ll.!.~~~·~-.:&;:;;&;;;7;-=·------------::-::::-----------------1955 418.. 33b, 94. lib. 23, 17 I 20, 222. I 05&, 30].1J. I &59. ens. ___ JL95& 152, ·5?, 2&, ~~~ t&, 1&. 3~~~~. 823. t97~~ 2111. ~b~9~7~·~--------------4--4~~---------------·----- 1957 10&, ~b. 78. 26, 24. 2b, 49~ 4S&, 19Jq, 1595. 1bb7, 2159, ~!I··· . . l :~ . C· l l ., -fr iJ : •; _.....,, .. ~ ! 1958 723 1 4b&w 95, &7~32. 23, 135, SOl, 2238, 2031, 1910, 417 1959. 211. 108. 55, 30. 21, 18, 59!t &&3, 2118. t&&J. 1400. 370, L I f I ·~~) •• i 11. I __j 9t~O 2.135, 17 },.. 85, ~_s..!--~~.!~-2~.. l J, lC!tH • l82!t..!....22b0 .L..!_~b4::-·=--~7:..:2:-U~, ------------------------------ 1961 298, 18o, 211., ll4, 9&, 34, 43, 775, t97o. zsqJ, 1895, 1141, . • • ta _j_9&L_1_7 0 ..____!.?.}_~ 2 I :u I 21. 15 r 7 s' 2?I.L!.~~l_L.?.!!.l8.LJ.;:.27H-i-9.:.'"-.7.-5i::o:=q.::..'---·-------------------------- 19bl 152, 359, 78e lb, 15, 41, 31, J~9. 101q, 2351. 151&. 1U55 • liM_.l~tt._____ 90,___jJ)J_.___ t.o, lt;, ___ 2~----~U~~--~b(!, 248tJ,_l995~_C!~~-Q~ 62Q~----~------·---------· 19&5 159, 197., 113, 79, 34, 53, 133,· 2&9. lllO. 20SO, 1565., 1.150, __j_9b~l1. 71, 50, ~! ... __ 2~, 2_2, 48, 247, 18!t~02l~~Ol, 2105, ~,---------------- 1967 537. 175. 5&. 30. 2&, 22. 30, l9&. 15bl, 17~7. 2051, 3q(b, _ _.1._.9-=&L-!!~.la.... 102. &8 1 &J. s&..__!J. b53, aql{t .... _J85l, lqb~2:.:&-L------------ .19&9 13q, 95. 34. t&. 22, 21, &b, s~&. 2q2s. 1q2o. 7i~. ~t&, t_g1tL..256" ... _ ___313. __ .355_.___113. __ 111. ___ en.___ 79. .,q!J. 1llfl .. _1892. lll5. _ 5 78. 1971 1q8, 658, 90. 31. 24. 23. 25. 21&. 1&b8, 29&8, 2bl9. 100&, f .. __l'UZ.._l5l. 79.--!fO. l.L___l.3. 17. IL__UL__~02. lij9~. ll~_lt.__'ll88._ __ ~---------~-----~------ 197l 288. 91, 45, 2b, 20. 20, 3~. 4U2, IOSb, 1743, 1235, b47, • l'Ha lSi, ~s. ltt. ~ 19. 18. CIS'. l92_a lqf~Oa llll......Ulla lS~ . ..oLII'----~------------------·-------- ------------------------------------· • NET RESERVOIR EVAPORATION, INCHES @ OCT NOV OEC ~iti-FEB--MAR--APH--MAY ,JUN J.UL AUG SEP 0,0 0,0 0.0 l..Q _ _L_Q __ _Q..Jl o.o u.o 0.0 td , _Q.Ou 0.0 • !-******* RESERVOIR DA[A ********* **** TAJLWAIEB PAll **•* ELEVATION VOLUME AHF.A DISChARGE ELEVATIO~ • __ lf.L.M.SLL _ _lA.CJJf!'.fllll_(ACHE~) _(.cil.L _, __ .1f.I.tJnU r I l !o 1 b I I '" f • --~~~~:~----·-____ i.oii~:-·--·· · · ri:·-· ----·-1ooooii~:···------~~~:-~-· I l~OsO ___ ..bQ..JUl.... Q.._ 0 Q,O G) J. tz 1100,0 17U&~O, 0, U, O.U \.?] t· ·:~ llif9 . .JL .4~9~1}_. ··--___ 9.._ _____________ Q. _____ 9 .. Q t': t5p 1170,0 9b000, 0, O. 0.0 ' ' 119JJ..JL_ ____ j 4_0 1! \) .Q .. -··--.. Q ._ -·------J! !!.. u -. ~··· L_._·_; __ •_z_o_o~o t79ooo. _ o. o. o.o ~ -.·-:: ·-----~.---~~---~ . ' '• -- • '0 t'- "I) i. . . .. ~g~~-· •. :. .. -~-~-~ --.• ::..-' ------~~------· ~.,::...;..~·;;::-1:;!: ~ ,___, ~ ..._ --~ ~ Jllllili!ll!lll ~ . Jlllll!llll lliJIJIIII! ' T~E RATED HEAD IS 6~0.0 FT. ~ . .\. ,., --------~·_,., _______ ____.. _________ .,._.~· .. __ ,___ . ........,.---~--· :JI!IIII -- Attachment 7b.l Page 2 of 3 --- J ' •• "' ... ___ ..... ___ •• _. ____ :_!., ____ _ • 5 _..llif_HAlEO .. CAPAClil. .. .lt.. __ fl.J .•. o_totW .. _____ --·-----·--···---~" ------------------- 4 THE HEADLOSS IS 0.04& TIMES THE HEAO 3 . ------------· <::· ·o.l • THE GENERATOR EFFICIENCY IS 0.980 THE TRANSFORMER EFFICIENCY IS 0.990 • • ******************* PO~Et~PLANT OATAr _ _ __ . _ NET HEAD PLA ;..·=r-CA pic ff =""'y ~~~.:::...._-~-=-=-=--=--=--_.,....-_·· 7i. ''t' I'll' $'-H(flV p. 2 • o.750 · 4&5.o 38.4 o.628 o.eeo o.85Q o.aoo Q9&.o qz;r----o:6q8 o~!&e o,66l------------------------------------------------------------------------- o.aso s21.o ~1.o o.7&9 o.eqq o,B67 • _ .. o.9oo 5S8~o st.6 o;84q o~9oo o.81l---------------------------------------------------------------------------- o.~5o 589.o 5&,3 o.92l o.9os o,878 r;ooo 62o.o . &t.l t.ooo o,9to o.883 !o030 638.6 ' 63,8 t.oqJ 0,908 0.881 ~.o&o 657;2 b&.q l.o6b o.Yo& o.e19 " . I s11• ' t.too 682.u 7o.o l,t4~5 ______ ~o~·=9~0~l ______ ~o~·~8~7~b----------------------------------------------------------------------------1.lSO 713.0 74.5 i;2-l'J 0,900 0.871 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------~~~--~---------------------------------------------------• • • • • • • ! • I • ---~~~-~~~~~-~ESEHYOI~.~~ATION CONSTRAINJ~S----~~~~~--~·~~~~~-~-~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~ MAXIMUM RESERVOIH ELEVATION ocf NOV ----of·c--JAN-FE-8 -r·fAH-AP-.r-MA_Y__ JIJN JUL AUG SEP . • ~200. 1200, 1200. 1200, 1200. 1200. 1200. 1200. 1200. 1200. 1200. 1200. ~ . O&T NUY U~~ JAN •tH """ APR HAY JUN JiJL AUG =-------\6} -HULE CURVE ELEVATION ------ 1198, H~3. 1183, 1171. 1157. H43~ __ Jll9LJl?~ .. __ HQ5. U1_9)1_UCil~ __ l2uo, ~~~IM~~-~ESERVOIH ELEVATION ------~O~C=T---N~O~V~--D~E~C---J~AN FEB M.R APR HAY~-,J~U~N~-.JU~L.--.Ao.UuG~--oSrfnp--------------------------------------------------------- 1050, to5o. toso, toso, to5o, toso'---aosq~_lo~q~ 105o~ _to~_o. 1oso. to5o • OCT NOV DEC RESERVOIR RELEASE CONSTRAINTS JAN FEB MAR APR MAY MINIMUM CONSUMPTIVE RELEA.SE JUN JUL AUG SEP o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o, o, ~ lO . .. . • 1 ·OCT NOV MINIMUM • o. 0 AR APR MAY • o. 0 JUN JUL • 0 AUG ,.---::::::::===~--------======= I ~-"'-I r;o."':""'f T"") _;•- j\ t' ..~, r f-. ~~ r .-<__ ..... ;, .'•· .. t't/*-..... , !l. ' \1 \ I (: I ::• ,tJ ·:~,J, ·~ ;t "~ ·~ .r :1! I 0 Ll 41 o.O. p~~ ~AN FE=ON•:OWER RELEASE ~-• o. o. ij SEP -• o. ---~---~~ ..... ~ .. ...-,_lf:ol •• 'l;'·,>:¢'.'>~-~"-~ ____ "......,_...,...--·-~~---' ,;-::-.....- I ll f l ' ' -· . l . . < ~ ---v- . ,.,..v ~' ·-~ .-.;c ~ ~ J!''IL iii ....... ~ ~ ... --Attachment 7b.l Page 3 of 8 =- ------------------------------------------------------------------·--· ·--·-···-----·-... -·· .. !!II lilllll •. po.-..~STREA.!L!!ILEASE CfHTtRIA ; PHE•PROJECT FLOWS AT BELO~ DAM .. tz YEAR OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR ' MAY JUN · JUL AUG SEP e•• 1948 640, ~9o, Job, 56~ 4o. 2s. bo. 493, 1~8~J~s~·~2~J~q~2~·~'l~o~.s~·~·~4~4~4~·~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~- to 1'49 466, 137, JJ, 16, 12, lb, 28, 317, 1181, PHI, lltt8, 1509, • 1950 310, 4]5, 171. l~. 23, 21. 21. 204, ·~~9. 2108~·~2~2~179~·~·~2=1.~8~·~~--~----~~--------·--~------~------------~--~-- • I 1951 216, 45, 21, 17, 12, 12, 31, ]06, 1055, 2]09, 1411, 2U56, 1 1952 110. 83, 41, 20, J7, Jb, 11, 79, to6q, 21101, 1471, 709, . I 1953 877. 588, 195, 78, 48, 29, 111, 913, j568, ]018, 2226, 1012, • 5 __j-~-~~ 81 ~.~~~J1 __ 5_L__.]'f_• --~~ L-·~-• _ _!~L-~b~.t_! 5~~ J10.2..!!..-l!».~~b~!,..::•~~~-~--:;;:;=:;;:;:--~--~~~~~~-------··--~~- 4 1.955 418, .Bb. 94, 4b, 21, l7., 20. 222. • 10.5&, lOJif., 1659, 'H6, ® 3 _JJ~~.?.s.__S2, 2b, 21, l!t, 1&, l~J4'1, ~~jL-l~IO.....J.Jl.l. b97~.J'!.-------t----,~~-r----------------------~ 1957 lOb. 8b. 16, 28. 24, 2b, 49. 45b, 1914. 1595, lbb1, 2359, • li. 1958 721, 4bb. 95. b1. 12. 23, 135, 502., 2238. 2011. lYlO, 417., l959 211, toa •. 55, 30. 21. 1H, 59. bbl, 2318., 1b6]., liH)O, 370, '. . 1960 28~ __ 171.!_~5. 45. 39. 2.S..! __ J_L!_!~~? ..t--..1~?6. 2~~..9~!»:;;4:-:·~-;7.:;:2·~u.!:, .. __________________________ _ 19bl 296. 180. 2ll. ]]q. 9~. 34, Q8. 775. 1970. 2547, 1895, 1tq1. t962 270..L-I?l. 112" 11. 2l, 15, 75, 277t-!}~!~~26, tle9. so~. -,;t.~ '' s.,.,(Tk) P. 3. 1963 152, 159, 78, lb., 15. 41, 31, 3H9, 1074, 2351., 151b, 1055,. l9b4 364, 90, 107,,~0, 38, 22 1 !12, 2b2, 2486, l9~9~~~~2~0~Q*U~~6~2~8~-------------------------------------------------------- 1965 159. 191, 111. 79. 34. 51, Ill, lb9, 1130. 2050, 1565, !JSO • • ~bb~!l-~1. so. ~~· 23, 22. 48, 2~7-'-!8_?~_?_923. 2101. 210~..! 1967 517. 175. 56, lO. 2b, 22. lO, l9b, 15bl, 1747, 2051. 1416. • • •• • 19b6 448, 151, 10~, 6~~blt 8~~~-~Q71Lt_b~5~j~l~1~4~:~~6~t~~~6~5~1~t~~~4~6~4~,-~5~27b·L------~------------------------------·------ I969 134. 95. 14, lb. 22. 23. 66, 556. 2425, 1920. 755~ S!b, 1970 ~SbQ, .. 373. __ 355_..___111._ _I_U._ _ _flljt~l~_~qH.__lllb, 11592,_1715. __ ',76. 1971 148, b58., 90. lie 24. 23, 25. 216, 1bb8, 29b6o 2bl9. 100b., 1972 J~t, 79, q~_J.~ll. 1], t~.!L4!.~~~. to~~..!.-ll-.5;.;:-4~·-q-:-e::-:8;-·~--~------------~--------~---- 1973 288. q1, 45,. 2'b• 20, 20 •. 35, 4tJ2, 1056, 174], 1215, b47. 1974 153, 55, l&, 25. 19, , 18, 49. l9l. l~bO, l7l~=·-=1Z=7~l~,_1~5~4~l~------~.~------~---------------------------- MINIMUM POST·~ROJECT.f'LQWS _AI t1ElUW_f:lAJL OCT NOV DEC JAN FER HAH APH MAY JUN JUL AUG 210, 210, ~to, 210, 210, 210. 21~. 210. 740, 740, 74U, _____ NSD FORECAST, YEAR 2010 ANNUAL ENERGY DEHANO • 64q4, G"'H, __ SEP 210, • ENERGY GEW~E~~~A~TUIO~N~CR~IUl~EBWIUAL_ ________________________ __ t • • • • • -----------------------=S~YS~T~E~M~f,NERGY PEMA~_~H OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR M::.:A~Y--J-;:U-:-:N:-----:J-:-:U:-L--:A:-:-U:-::G:---=s::::EP=--------------------------- Sbl, -b4(), __ 7 u. -~-S'l~~_ S~j .. _~75_, __ _991 !L~ 459, -'127, 1420, 44b, 465, OCT NOV DEC 51 ,o 51 ,o -52.0 GWH JUL AUG SEP o 49,0 5J.u 47.0 ----------------JA~O~J~U~S~T.~E~P~S~Y~3~ ENERGY ~EMAND, GhH --- OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB ~AR APk · HAY JUN JUL AUG SEP ~\2a 569, b65, 608, SJ7, 53Je 45]. 41b, 38], 17~·~·~]~9~]~,~~,.~~~8LI----------------------------~-------------------- --------MOttlHLY GENEJ!A.J.l!U~..L.fff!COO_.!lf. ANNU!~- OCT NOV OEC JAN FER MAR APR HAY JUN JUL AUG SEP ~7 o.t~o 0.111 2~1oq o.o~;o9o o.o77 o.o7t o"o65 o.o~l o.o~7 o,071 r '_;·.·· .. ·.· ---·.' c j t~l -~-;.~ ·:, . ~' l l. ! I L I H I I t- 1 l l " r I. r '"? r ~ U .• I ' ---·~-·---~---·-·--~,..-·-----,.,.-~-----· ~\~-~------:-~-~-- t-· ' ~? .,. II: f ~~ '~~~-"\!!:--·--··"~· ...... ·' -- '--.... , ...... J --~ ~ :n ····-·"-q ~ ~ .,.... . L __ _g l '/ l I ! TARGET FIRM ANNUAL ENERGY a lSb. • TARGET MONTHLY FIHM ENERGY, GwH • MAR APR MAY • • ... •• -• . • a ........... .w __ ... ---·-- ~~~ .U_~ ~·~ 1!1!1!1!!!1!! .. ·~ JUN JUL AUG SEP • '··•--a #WW'H ' , .... ~ ... ... IIIII Attachment 7b.l Page 4 of 8 END OF .INPUT ~A'"'li''··""'!' .. 4;·,~l!l"'-:w-'" H --~ -•·\Ai(Ji ii. m.M -- ,. '~' I • to ,f. ~.~:....v'' ,· .:~ ~ :·~ . fj • I ----------...-,__,...__. .... ,...~-----~ ~ .,. -~ ~ Jl!llllllll _... At.~~hme~~ 7b. Pe:t;cs5 0~ --.. -.... ~. --~ ..___ .. _,.. ____ -. ~~ ______ ..__ .... .,. ... -·--.. -·---.. '.. ... ............. .. .. ~ '"' ---"""'-t . "''I '\~~ ) . t l• i 1 f ij --~!)J!~JNE. ~~ l§J.,;~M~Gt l~fSJ -~: -..1 t• 't,J ,.:.II 'I .) '-'----------~-----------------··-----·-----------··· .. ···-""" .. (: ·l ' OCt NOV .Qt;C ___ JAN Ff:H . i4AH API-l MA '( JI.JN JlJL AUG Sl:P __ t~.!!~--.1.7 ~J.~-_li3l !3__ 7 3'1 '! l .. -'!1 H .. L._.9b~.!.! --· !!09. ti. __ .S'fh t ___ l·?.~-~--13'!~.!~._1_3~9..!.~ tB~. b 312.!_'! 19q9 3b9.4 440.4 4Hb.5 q~2.1 U~0.3 412.2 377.7 34q.~ 740.0 HU4.7 Bbl.5 lOq1.B __ !_9S.P ___ ll.li.SJ ? __ .. l ~~, > .. ··-~Ob, }. ___ '! b h !_ __ ~'!!i, ~ _ ~~H.!''! ... ·--~ 7 i?.! !;' __ } t&_i. 4 1 c! ~ ~.! ~--~ !.~-~, 2 1 3'1_~~-~1~.!..;;:2,__ _________ _ 1951 3&7.9 LI~O,l 4Bb,A 4~2,b 450,9 41l,5 379,5 347.0 7LIO.O 101&.8 82b,5 13'19.8 ~-3bH.l L140.l 41th..} Ll~~q tj5\1,5 'H~.5 HH,b 327,9 740,0 'I.Sb,S bl:i8,5 312.,0 1953 944.1 915.3 &28,1 ~~0,1 471.7 Ltl3.8 444.1 8LI3v~ 1)'1'1,8 l]9q,8 1399.8 1012.0 • _J 'l.~!L--9. q~ w5 .. __ 47 ~..]__4~~, #,!_. ~ ~JL.1 ___ 9 ~ -'-?-':H! !l . .! '!_ ___ .37 ~.!_7 4 lH • 1 1 ~~ Q.!.~--? ~ ~L_!i123 .1 312. 2 ·------------- 1955 ~44.3 b83.l ~27.1 4b8,1 44h.l 40H.9 373,1 .S42.3 740,0 1399.8 1~'19.8 b02.5 l '· ·-:-J f f ! 1 f i j __ 1J5~~--~~-~._.?_ __ ~~P.....L._~_H? ,~ ___ q?,!.b _ ~~.£..~.!)_~.!.~.!.~--~~!! ~2_tUi~_l _?_ta~!._o __ !_ttO,. 0 13~~.9 3!2 .!_ __ e 1957 3o8,9 441.a 48B.IJ ll5tt.tt 452 .. 8 4ib.5. 3b2,'1 314!).8 tY1tJ,8 7tto.o 97&.3 13Y9.o 1956 H5b,2 Hl3.3 ~28,t1 4ti9,l 4~~.7 lW~,t\ ttbhl 432 .. ~ 1399.8 13'19",8 1399,8 3 7!~2.:..•b7-------7'=~-------- 19. ~9 110.2 443,o 1490.5 45. b.8 45. ~.b tt22 •. 1 4u.o,4 3Sb ... 4 1399.8 11~8.4 a.t5.s :s11.1 ® e ~l2.!!.0 __ 370-LL __ l!'!.f...!! __ q_8~t.~ .. --'!~~-.i--.~~h-~ __ '!!.1~L_2fl!?.L~bCI.b_1~~~;"".!L_J3b4.2 979..;;;•..o;;5_--=l"=l""2:..:::•..;.o _____ -1---~o::::::!~io--J-J-------· 19b1 375,8 527.1 bbb.1 7~&.1 ~19.7 418,8 381.1 70~.5 1399~8 139'1,8 1399.8 98Sw1 ~----i•" _;/ _:. ~--j/ ' ·, . y n· f.· [ I j I I 11U"ifi'!t!*lw..4 .. ,~ l -If I 1 ! ;I I I I I \~Jl -~ I i ;' ' U ·j • • 9b2 41:1 ~ ..L_._~ 7 0 I j IHJ~ '! ? __ 4 5 ~1 __ 448,, 4 4~~-!,? __ 3~~!-~~ 1'1. 3 11}._0. 3 1022.;.. :;:.2---::-7-;-470.::.• .;:.0---;.3.::-1 ~2.::.• -::-9 ________________ _ 19&3 37o.s 442.1 t~a7.2 4~2.b q5o.4 411.2 375,B 341,2 74o.o 1~~2.1 9J1.5 569.8 J9b4 497 1 2 Q3'1,7 ~~1~6 482,1 4&1,7 40H,d 4b3,0 339,7 13~9,8 1399,8 13~~.6 b15.5 19&5· 492.2 544,3 SQb.l ~01.1 4S7,7 ttl7.6 Ubb,l 31'1,5 7ttO,O '171.2 qdO.S 884.6 e __ 1.9&b 4~!ltL__'!_l_!h~-· _li8~.~-~~!".~--4L_!!;!,~.b 409.3 37£,6 340_,H U31,0 101]..!.2 1399,8 ll9-::-9.::.•~H----------------- 19b7 b70.2 522.3 4H9.1 4~2.1 4q9,7 408.8 37~.~ 33b,H 1~24,] 741.2 13'19.8 1l99,H • --~~~~---S~l .... L_qf!j)t~--S~!~,_t-~9~-' 1 48~, 7 47Q.!.!\ ___ ;u~ .• t 5~3.5 1103,5 8tt5.2 H79:..:: .. -;:5--:;l-;;1~~;-:;;"'-::b:------------------- 19b9 370.1 443.5 491,5 458.3 457.1 42~.q 375,4 3b5,9 1399.6 1324.1 740.0 317.9 197Q 1399~8 6~7,9 7Ha,t ~35,1 ~3q~7 477,8 4l?a1 J76.S 1001,5 8Hb.2 1lqU,S 312.4 1971 3b'l.7 714,2 523,1 453~1 44H.2 406,6 172.7 34l,H 1135.& 1399.8 1399,8 10Ub,U • _1.'tiL-._l!.~9 . ..L_!!..~tt.ats __ ~~~-'-~---~~t. ... l._4'!9_!Ll lll.Y.!.L_3J?..p2 .S4~.o 74o.o 7~o.o::-~·==-'"~6~·"=--5~2~2:;-.::..•8::-------------------· 1973 421,2 439,7 ·qaS,b 4~o.a li4R,5 uo9.3 373.2 337.4 74o.o Jqo.o 740.o 111.0 ---1.9714 37..LJ. 443_.1._~i1.~--4S6, 1 4Sa_J, 42&,8 3~1,_1 __ 383,«~::._--=.7....:q:-=o.ll!,.=.u __ 7.:..q~o:::..:•~o~--=-7-=4:.:.0-=·.=.o __ 9.!_1~9~·~'~=-----------.--------• AVG 527,7 5q9,5 53'1.4 47&.7 4bO.O 416.& .390.7 . ------------- "' -------· • • --'"-·---· -------------------------- . _____________ ,.._,__ ------~------• ----------------------------------------~ • • ·---------·-------·------·------ll •n 10 ~--·-. ---· ·--. ----- 9 Q21,6 1090.9 lOb~.l 10bb .1 &87.1 V~aTT:JUT -· --·-· ... --------·--.. __ ........ --------·--· --·--------------• 8 7 e -------.. -----·------. -.- e ·: .. -· .. -- 3 • --·-···--·· '--------- ~lc:. . r .~ [I' I L 1.-Co I. f l' fY .. 1 •.· J, l ~' ·~ ;~ It: . •·.•.·. Q '· .. ,,1 ~ ' I. ;; :i. . . ·' ,·,. -·~-- ,"'~~ ~-·~--.-.. ~- -. . -·~· ~ I i . -··-·. ··-·-.. --........ . <4~' ·----, ·-""'*'"'""'·--···.' ,., " - I I ,f } j Ui. 'H ·. ' l ""--- ,. ~ ~ ~ ~ flllllll!l!!lll ~ .... .IIIJI!I! -11111 Attachment 7b.l ~ -~/,....( -~ Page 6 of 8 .a. . --·--· ·------·-.. --··---. -·-. ... ···"··---·---- ENEHGY FRUM RESEHVUIH lGWH) ------·-____ .. _________ "[p lt.:~_j~---.'":~:: -~-'1 ~--~ ---.. --· ..... -........ . JIJL HAY AUG SEP ANN _____ Qk L _ _!!I}_V ____ o~ !;._ _____ A.~_N_ ____ .£1!!__~~----A_r~ JUt~ • _1_9"~--_28 • ., _ --~'l·.a_ ~&.9 p.l ___ Jll.7 ____ 14!1 ___ 12.·1 ___ .~.s.!~ _____ 4 35~7__491_·~-~---~_1~1 _____ ~9 54_!.~--- 19tt9 13.6 1~.6 11.1 lb.l 14 • .1 1'~.1 ~~.o 11.0 2 .7 3 .v ~.,.2 j"f.e. ~3 ... ---~-------------·- 1950 16.4 27.H 2~.o lb.S 14.3 tq.t 12.0 1t.o 41.2 38.7 50.9 3b~2 301.2 • ---19~c· ... t3 .b --1 ~ :b ···-11. ·r -----~b. i · · 14.3-·-·-i "~ t ·-· __ 12. u ·--· ··11 ~ o -----iH: ?·--36. o--:ro:o--4<r;·q 2sJ;s- 19S2 13.6 1~.b 17.7 lb.l 14.3 14.1 12.0 ~.9 ~1.8 32.1 32.2 11.1 l10.b --1953 J'q~a 33.3 22:s·--··r7-:9--1s.o n.-;] ___ tii:4 21.1 tt7.5 s1.6 si.B :So .. ~ 167.2 e __ t:9SQ,_, __ 3?.·~.--J~·~--___ 11 .1_. _!_b!'~ __ _t4.!_._ !4'! t __ ~2!..0.. ___ .}~.!~---~~.!.~--~~~~-e.l U.,~L---~-~-~~·------------ 1955 lb.4 24.3 19.2 lb.H 14.3 14.1 12.0 11.0 2~.4 49.1 ~1.2 cl.5 2,~.~ 1956 13.6 15.b 17.7 16,1 tq.J 14.1 ~2.0 11.0 22.9 25.1 ~7.8 1l.l 221.3 e -1957--·-t 3.6-··· -. ':>·. ;-·--11 ~ i --·· 6 .·.---.·4: .r--i 4. i--12. o·---11 :o----45 ~-o--2{). o 3S.4 4ti;9 2fo. 7.-------------· 195H Jt,.& 2a.9 19.2 11.~ 14.~ 14.1 t5.1 14.2 4&.3 49.9 ':>t.o 11.1 313.4 1959 t3.b 15.6 17.7 16.1 14.3 lq.l 12.0 11.0 4S.9 40.1 29,b 11.1 2tf1.1 • _J.?.!>.~ ___ Jl!~ ____ 1?.!!!' _ !!.!! 1 ·-·-~~ •. 1 -· 1~~ ----~4.1 ...• .l.~.o ___ .. }! !.1 ___ '!~.!..? iH~.!-~--3~~--11.1 2?~!.9.----·--===------- 19o1 13.9 1~.7 2q.2 27.! lb.S 14.5 12.3 23.2 QS.9 49.8 51.3 35.2 332.7 _.!~-~~---!4_'!9 __ . .!.~_.7 __ l_I! 7 _____ tb_!J ... -.J~_._.i ___ Lq__~-~ ____ -~~-'!.~---1.!. o 36.!4 35.9 2b.8 11.1 2.?.?..!5 f..--(...4:_.._ ___ _ • 19b3 13.& 15.b 17.7 lb.l 14.3 14~1 12.0 11.0 23.8 43.9 33.8 ~1.0 23&.9 l9b4 18.4 15.b 19.b 17.1 14.7 14.1 15.0 11.0 45.9 ':>O.l ~1.1 22.0 294.7 19b5 1~.2------rq.q 19.9 1a:o ttJ.b 15.1 15.1 u.o 23.8 34.2 35.6 11.5 256.2 • 1966 lb.b 15.b 17.7 lb.l 14.3 14.~ 12.0 11.0 q2.8 3~.7 ~1 .. 0 so.o 296.~9;------------· --t967 ___ 2li:T--1-H.b ___ l7.a··--i1>:·2--ii;-3--1-if;i---i2:·o---.1.o 39.8 ~c.u 50.8 49.9 ~95.3 19b8 21.~ 17.7 19.5 17.& 1S.4 1b.2 12.1 1q.2 35.9 29.7 31.9 11.1 2~7.7 • ---yq·b9 ___ i3.b 1~:t;·--ir.7·--Tb;i--14:-:r--1":·i---rr:s 11.o "s.2 47 .o 2&.6 11.1 243.4 1970 51.~ lo,~ ~tl.7 1q.2 11.0 1b.S 13.3 12.4 32.b ~1.1 q3.2 11.1 ~o6.9 1971 ll.b 25.3 19.o 16.2 14.3 14.1 te..o 11.0 16.4 qq.& 51.5 lb.o 299~1 • 1972 17.9 lS.b 11.7 lb.t 14.3 1q.1 12.0 11.0 22.4 ~4.9 2b.9 18.6 2il.b -1973 1s·.s--15:&_ tt:-r·--i,;·:r--s4.3--rti:T·--,2:o ____ iT.o 211:o 25.9 2&.a u~t 2oq.J 1974 tl.b 1~~-b 17.!_ ____ t~!l 14.3 14.1 9!9 11.0 22.5 25.9 26.8 32.7 220.2 e AVG 19.4 19.5 19.4 17 .o 14.& lQ.l 12.'1 ll.t~ 35.2 37.5 3b.8 2q.5 ~66.2 • --------------• • ----. --·· -------------·-----·-------·------·------·-----------------------------------------. ---~--·---·---·--------·--------------------. ---·-···-···------. -··--------------- • IZ •"--··-10 ~ .& 7 ........ ·---- --------------------~----------------------6 ··5 ... -· - ·• 4 1 ------··-------·--------·-.--···· .. ·--·-... -·--~--- '! b' .,., (l· .;.-:, ·L·-____ ._- ~}· {If_ '. . ' fr,, ! L I r ._, f:_ .r;· ~// 0 i~ 0;::.1 ' ... ' . . ~ '. -~.-----.,..-· ji -~~-~"'"'r~~ ... be,¥~ ""•, \ '" ,.r}.,...~~ .. -,.!' ~~·.' ' Jl •-" ·-~ i,.,,,..., •. ~:"·~~-~~·~-r<;':';V:"b'~~· ... -'-P""·•--~------;r 1 - I ·"-· I -,~~~ I -l ! I I ! l I ' l I I ! 1 l I I I ! ! ~ I i I j . ....... ~~..j I I II I I • ·-I ~· l I ! U~ . ''-,) -~-· ~---~-----~ ...... ------·-~ ~ ~ "!""~ ~ ~ ..._ --• .. Bill. ~ Clll f5iil Attachment 7b_~_PC:~~-?_.~!,: a ·-. ···----··--·---·.,---·----. ·~ ~1 ..... • -• -· • • • • • P'USl•PIWJECi FLU~S lCFSl Tc.l-fr 16' s:,,.., rJ P. 6 ---·-... __ .. _.-.... -.. ·-·· _ _._.__ .. _____ ------ ·---(:..::1'!_ T ____ N~_!_ _____ _Qf":._C _ •. --~ A_N ___ ,__F_·l_B MAK APk MAY JUfi JUL AlJG SEP 1948 773.2 637.3 739.1 47~.1 Qb3.7 4o~.~ j93.1 42~.5 lj~~.6 1399.6 H33.b 512.9 --19'19 --··3t,Cf;ir·--"44o~ti ""'" liHoe~ ·-Lts2:·1 ·· · 4~o:3 --li 1~ .. 2 · ·377 .. 1 ... -3ii4;s .. -·.7uo;-u-·auiC;..,-bo3·;~--roii:f; .. u--------·-----·--- t95o 445.2 7B2.l bOb.l libi.l li4B.2 4Utl.~ 372.8 342.ij 1268.« 11U2.2 1399.8 1U15.l ---i qsc--·3bf;q LillO: f. ·-QBb .d--US2 .t) -·. 450 • 9---·q 13 .·5 -3 7'1 .5 --54 j ;o---74o:o-foJiJ-;8--H2b:5--l592 ;a 1952 3b6.1 44u.3 4Ho.1 q52.4 450.5 412.5 37H.b 327.9 7'10.0 9lb.5 b~6.5 312,0 . --r9s~ 9Qtf:1---q.:f£,.3 &2a.f ___ 5oo:"f--~1.7 4U.H 4i.fif:t 8Q:.S.5 1399.8 2771,3 222b.,O 1012.0 19~~· 949.2 471..3 485.6 tl~4.7 44~.2 tiOH.'l 372.7 461Y7 12Q0.5 74U~O 10~3.7 312,2 --1 9.;·€,--4 4 4. ~ 3 • ·-biii: 3 ---·52 1 ;r .. it b 8: 1 --·-,. 4 8; i-4 o s ~ 9 --37 ~: "i ·-·-·lit 2; :f ·--·7"4 o :o-t!cFf:-e-11 qCf;e & o 2 .,:..;5;------- _1.9~~----}.b ts ~ ? __ Ll ~Q...~ ---~HH '!.~ .. _ .. ~ s ~. ~ ___ u.??..! ~ _ ~J '·h 4_ --~!i 1 ~ ~----~~ t} ~ L_J ~ ~.! o __ .l ~.Q. o 13~?. 9 31.?.::..• .::..1 ______ _ !957 3b6.9 441.8 48H.b 454.4 q~~.B 41&.5 3~2.9 ~45.8 1J99.H 740.0 97be3 1893,6 ~56 8 ~.l!.LL_!liJ. 3 ~ ~ I!.J __ -~~ '1.._1 __ 4 ?~I 1 4 0 8. 6 4_b 1 .. 1 'il 2 '5 B 9 9. 8 139 ~ "8-B;-;9-:::9-=·~6~-;:3:..:1:..::2:..:•:..::&:.._ ______ _ 1959 370.2 4q3.0 490.5 t15b.8 qSS.b t122,3 4UU.4 35&.4 1399.8 1128.~ 815.5 313.1 __l9~.o __ ~7;~~.7. ____ q.9F.r.i ___ q_~~.o._. 4~5 ,3 _____ t~5~_5_ ---~~?.!b. ___ :3~!?.'!1! ___ ~~9!.& __ ~~~~.!~_1..!~ .2 '~?_~s __ .] 12. u 19b1 "37~.8 ~27.3 bbb.l 75b,1 Sl9.7 418.8 381.1 7~5.5 1399.8 1399.8 1399.8 985.1 __ .!9.f?? __ ~o~·~.2 ___ u?_~ !._3 __ 4_~?.! I. -~~.o !..I __ "-~~-'-L-~~~!~--_>!!~, ~-33_? .!L.JJ.}.~ !L_!.~22 .2 74Q. o 312 .~ 19b3 37o.s 442.l 487.2 4~2.b 450,4 llllw2 375.8 341.2 7llo.o 12~2.1· 9jl.5 5~9.8 . @- _!.2b4 4'17,2 _43~,7 S.H,H 482.1 ll~i>.~7 408,8 4!J3.0 339,7 13'19,8 1399,8 1399.8 &15.5 19b5 492.2 54q.3 sq&.l 501.1 457.7 437.8 4bb.1 339.5 740.0 977,2 'JH~.S .88R.8 19bb 4~0.2 43~.8 4HS.9 liS0.9 4l&H.b qo9.3 372.6 340.8 1331,8 1017.2 1399,6 19b7m0 ----r9& 1-& 7o :·l ___ s2i~3-4aq:·, ·· ··-4 si:' 1--,.;4 9 ~-7-tloe: a ---31 2:~ 3 3~: tJ12'iif, :s 14 1 • 2 1399. e 3 o.t;..,9:,..:.::..:b=------------- • 19b8 581,2 498.3 535.1 490,1 qb4.7 47~.8 ~74,1 583.5 ~!~~.5 845.2 H79.5 312.b --1 9b9--37o:-r-·-443:·s--4,H:s--·4se:~--4~7-:f-ti2'§:'i·-·--3 i~:-4--it,~:;r-r::r~q·.a 1.s2tt .1 74o·~.:..::o-~3~1-=-~..::..-=-q----------------- !97o 173b,O 8~7,9 7H6,1 ~35.1 ~:34,7 qJ7.8 4!~.: 376.5 10Ul.5 6Hb.2 li90,5 312,4 1971 3&9.7 714.2 523.1 453.1 448.2 408~8 372.7 341.6 11lS,b 1399.6 21bbeb lUUb.O • 1972 464.2 439.8 485.9 451m1 4~9.1 410.1 37~,2 349,0 140.0 7QO.O 7~8.~ 522,8 --T973--42I:-2'-ii39. 1--itls. b --· tt~o·:·t;-·44ir;;s--ii u<i·:-3--3 11:-2--3·3-7. ~ 1 q u. o 1 4o. o 1 q o. o l:.::;1:.;;3;..::.~o;.__ ___________ _ 1974 370.1 4'U.7 491.9 456.] __ 4_5a.o ll2&.8 337.1 363.9 740.0 7qo.o 740,0 919.9 • AVG Sl&0,2 549.5 53q.LS ~7b.7 llbO.O 416.b 390.7 421.8 1o9u.9 111s.9 u2s.r~--?'-~l.b • • • ----------···---------·· ------·-·---··-----------------------------------------~--~---------------- ., ________ _ __ ..._ . • . -------------------·---------------·---·--·--------------· ---- -------------.. -............ ·--------·""-----... -------~-----_ .... --·---.. --... ,_ ---.--"-.. -• 12. -~~------10 9 & --·---. . - 7 6 .5 4 3 ' ----------- ------------------------ r, "' ,,, I; ' ' f ~ t.. . l':. ' o· 'l :fJ ~-.'~ . ·. El~ f~ '1 , I 1. ' ll.. ' , ;;_·:::..:-~ t) ·c .fJ IJ:.~ c:; , rir'-' .;... v ~~; _., . ,._.._----,------, ~---;.-~----~~ /' ~, r.::::_;:J ... ,_-:; 1' • 'I I '( Q:.. • _I ~· .....,_ ~ ~ 1" ' ~ .. » :>~ ., .. }!lr ,.•~ _ ... ,.,~.t <>. ,. • " I ::>-'• -- " It I J ~-~ ~ .. ' -.. ,_.... I -~-,.__ ll 't. l 1 I -; ·1 "~ ....... <>JiW •• 'l ..... ~~~:~ .... ~Ja...,~ ....... -.~~-~----... ~14-~4~-~-:!'>"'l-rl~~'.:;;-~~-r~,.,_,....,_,.J.\_-~~---~-.-. -l.., __ ____:,__. ___ ... ~~-.. I) ~ ~ -~ ~ ...... L .. Hf,_ ~ ~--~ --iia .. ii!B =-=· A·L..t.a.\.!hmc.u-.. 7t.~ ..._ Pc...=' ....... 8 c._._ .3 .. IIIII ~ . -. ..... --··-. AVERAGE: CAPAIULI f H.S (MW) Ill --------·-·· -···-----· ---·-· ------------------______ "h6/p Ill_,; Jr<-<J-o) __ /3_ 7 ______ . _ _________ ..::.U.CT NIIV UE.C JAN .Ffh SNO~ &s:---&·7. bb. bl.!. ts3. MAR APH MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP r;,.. ~s. sa. t.l. tsb. &7. bO. . ----.. ----... ----·--· . -----·-. --·--... --·---------· ·-·-----·-·· ·-----··------··. .. -TOTAL b8u &7. bb. b4. &3.. bO. S7. 55. 56. b31. bb. ~-; -------- • -f.ti'NTM"U"M-cAPiaiLI.TIES-i'M.w)---------· -------···· .. ------.---·- ucr NOV DEC JAN FEH MAH APR MAY JUN Jlll AUG SEP ... _SNOW _______ E.7...!---~~!. ___ b5!....--t?~_. ___ _hl.!--57.!. 51, 14]. 51. 59. b5. bS. -·-----------·-- TOTAI:_ ________ b7 !.---~~.!-.. -~~~ __ !>.J~---bl. 57.!. 51. 47. 51. 59. bS. bS. ,. AVER~E_EHEHGLPHOOUCUON (GWHl . ------____ OCT NOV I>E.C JAN FEB HAk APH MAY JUf\1 i9:-q-·-r9:s-1~i:q-·-T:-, ;o··-t~~:&-·--i4:-3-12~-4--i1.& 1s:~2 JUL AUG SEP ANN.~------ 17,5 J6.8 zq,s ~~b.a SNOW ------··----• TOTAL ---:-----:-------· ------19.4 19.5 19~q 17oO ati:-3--i z. 4 14.b ll.b 35.1! :n.s 36.8 24.5 cbti~2 MINIMUM ENERGY PkOOUCTION (GWH) ' • . OCT NO·v··-0-EC jAN FER MAH APR MAY JUN JUL ~llG SEP ANN _ _,.S=N.O.t! 0973) 15,5 lS.& .11,1 lb,__L_ tl1.3 14.1 12.0 11,0 2q,o 1!5.9 2b.8 U.l 204,3 • JOTAL (1973) 15,5 l5,b !7,7 lb,l 14.3 14,1 12.0 11. (J 21.1.0 l5.9 2b.8 11 .• 1 204.3 • .. • • e -------·--- e • ft -------·--------------- 12 ~ 11 ____ , __ _ -----10 9 • 8 ; ~®-- , __ I 6 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------~- l • 5 I ! :· ... --. t-t • -t -----_, -...--, ............ -------------~------·-----------~-----~· G" ~ ~.-----~~""-1..,..... .. ~ ............. ~~...:0...,.,.~-~-4""~-·--.:_ •.• ~~:----:~~-·-~.-~ --~--~--'--<.,,..__, .. ~~--~~- " } ~ !C c ;:r \'i I I l r I ,.,_ [; f l ~. L f ' -r f'' I !I l{i ~ ~· .·, -,-.... . ;;:;' ·c.: ~"5·; ........ . u ' .. c • I • ', .. 0., / -' 9 .. l , • • .. .,r. --r. ' . " ~-_.,,_,_ ________ , ___ ~, .... ~ ..... --............ ,_..,..._,,_.,...__ -~-----.. .. , ..... _,.,._,.,_~.....,_-,.._-.~-~--·..,_,.. ___ ,__...,..,,~-.-.~---·~--.---1..--· ~-.~ ..... -' ...,._\~. --~-·-~. _________ __;;..,,...,___""'~.--,;~._-~--~~-.. ----J-----~.....-..""---~,_,...._.,~_.._,., __ .....,.J':Ii!..--.,.., ..... .-..-.._.,..__ ____ _,..._.,.,.,._ .. ~-~---.-::--"-~- ......--... ~ ... ,...._ -~ ~ ~ ~ .... ~ • • • • • • • • --- •i ..... 'I ti I ifJiR iiB iia Attachment 7b .. 2 Page 1 of. 7. -~ ~-.. ·=- ·-------------~·---------------------------- 2) KEETNA ALTEHNATIVE HYDRU PHOJECT --=R::..::E'""'SPONSE-TOPEIS---·-------:,.-, HULE CUkYE NSO YEAH i0101 &44q GWH --RATED CAPAC JTY luo;--:M":::-W~---------'"-Tt:i 61-e IG /(4.~/,D>. ·~ ' ----------------------------------~------------------~.· --~----~-------- ------------------------~INPUT D~TA FOR KEETNA ----------N=Itl'URAl STREAfl4FLUW Al DAMSITE YEAR OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP P. I __t96 !_~95. 977, ~9 2.L-9_'t 9..LJ!!~. 33~~.~!.~~.!.--6~ 11. !'341. ~~4 ef-=-. _,b;-,b;-;lr-;' ·~·=-------------------<---------------196i Z7&5, 910, 516, ~43, 328, 246, i63, IS02, 8062, ~294, b~86, 3llb~ . 1963 L~~~. 559, 467, ~~lL__1~~. 29~66, 25&~. 5786l 7851, 8Uiq. 4344 ----i 1964 li64, 781, 615, 530, 4H4, 463, 611. 5506, 8786, bq9G, 4702. 2567 1 _ 1965 1020. 515, 34bo 28b, C51J, 237, l?le 2411 t 12451! lfiil?, 2360, 1290, K ·~_, ________ _, 1966 904, 477, 366, 314. 285, 21~. 340, 2461, 4~72, 6411. 5454. 1734, ___19~7 17~5. lOlb, 687, 421, 286, 250. 313. lllJLJll8b4, 7liU,1045U, l7lle 1968 1640, 816, 340, 45], 391, 300, 323. 2191, 7914, 7496o ~96], 5q27. ·-----"-...-.' ___1!69 226l. 854, 554, 466; ~o8, 358~56, zqo~~6o~8~·~4~7~8~l~·~· ~6~1~6~6~·~i~4~U~b~·-----------------------------------~-----~---~----- t970 1126, 598, 464, 402, 146, Joo. 333. 3~38, suoa, 4832. 4801. 2968, 1971 i231. 624, 462, 412, 374, 317, 325, ?S45, 8213, 7521, 528~~4~~~6~0~------------------------------- 1972·1797, 482, 348, 327, 299, 293, 382. 2143. b59l. 562'1. 5040, 1997,.--- 1971 1157, 668, bbb, Qb3R }42, 315, 341, 2b45,Jl)9~l~t-75~8~273Lt-4~9~078~t~~)~7~l~b~t:__ _________________________________________________ _ 1974 8036. 699, 536, 465, 359, 302. lll, 1818, 46i9, 67246 4361. 33&14, I _ _ __ NEl_BESERVDHLEYAf1QRATJONt.lMCHES OCT NOV DEC JAN fEB HAR APR fl4AY o.o o.o. o.o o.o o.o o.o o.o u.o JUN o.o JUL AUG SEP o.Q OeO o,o ********* RESERVOIR DATA *********, **** TAILWATER OAT~ **** - ELEVATION VOLUME AREA DISCHARGE ELEVATION (fTrMSL) lACRE~FEET) (ACRES) (CFS) (FTrMSLJ -----· ,. e.os.o o. o. -;--------o.~-----bls.o-----~------:--~ ------~&5o,o 2oooo, o. aoooooo. 615.0 e.75~o 4oooo. o. o, o.o 1oo.~ 1oooo, o. o. o.G 750,0 145000. (),-·-u. o.o ------~eoo.o ZHO~uo. o. o. o.o !2o.o 35oooo. o. o. · o.o 850,0 480000, o. o. o.o ----qcfo.o 68oooii, o. o. o,o 945.0 850000. o. o. o.o 950,0 880GOO, 0, O. 0~0 . ---·----------~-------------------------------THE RATED HEAD IS i8b.O FT. . THE RATED CAPACITY IS 100.0 MW. • -r-HE HEADLOSS IS 0,015 liME'S THE HEAD tt THE GENERATOR EFFICIENCY l& 0;980 .,n THE TRANSFORMER EFFICIENCY IS 0,990 10 -· ............. ---· -------~-----· --------~--------------A ·--------~----~~----~· __...,._.._~;;;.,_.~ .~ ......... ~ •'-"· -~--'-··-·---~---~· ·---~ -:--....... ~ ,...:...__.~ .,.,;,..,~ .. ..,. r·: " ~;: . i I 11 . ~? ' .:\ !~: .~.·,. ' !) }:;. t' ~' l' t~ L t_,·• . .:l I II l l l -; . ~~ r f. r. r r r . . . • ;' :?i f .. ·!\. I '· ·N. .. '-:·~. '_:::: , . c (; ·") . ; ~ .. 6l' " l • • I • ~ : -·~----·-~~"~~-~::... ... ~-·-·----·---..........__ ... ~ .. -------·--·-~···-. -~-~--. _ _:::_·------~---. ·-·-------·---L·-~--~-------~--~~----·~0..-----· ----------·····-------·~·--·--·-----~--. ·r:r ~ -~ (......., .. ~ -C!::"c:;-_~ ~ ~· ~· ---liB. iiE ma ---tiili ~ ~.· Attachment 7b.2 Page 2 of 7 •• ... 7 ' es 4 J t .• J • ~ ·: l•. 1 •. .. !. . . • I ·~ • i i • ·' • I : • :; ; 1• ie i 'l . !e ! t ;e I i ·! ·:. . I I • • • • •• .. •-a• •• •• of t a -l· o •• 't ;» #!< • •t f< • t l '' 1 ••f 110-,t • ******************* POWERPLANT DATA, ! UNJlS **************'**n** NET HEAD PLANT CAPACITY EFl"lCIUn:Y___ --- (IRATEO) (F~~TJ (~~~.l HA~ED) TURBINE f'LAN!--------------------------------- 0.&50 185.9 46.& 0.480 0.858 o.slz 0.750 _2lii·.s &0. 9--0. «)2"8 o-;irso 0. tj5"4" o.eou 228.8 &7.7 0.698 0.888 0.8b2 0.850 .243.1 74o6 0.7&9 0.8911 0.8&7 0.900 257.4 81.9 0.844 0.900 0.873 0.950 27T.7 s9.q o .9~n----c,-;cros 0.878 t.ooo 286.0 97.0 1.ooo o.•HO o.88l Ta61t! 18 ~f!( .. -. ?.Z 1. 0-30 291&.& 101.1! 1.U.Q3 0.908 o.eiii 1.060 lOJ.i! 105.4 1.08& 0.90& u.a79 1.100 .314.6 111.1 l.ll&5 0.903 0.61& .W50 328.9 118.1 1.1!19 o.9uo 0.873 1.250 357.5 tiz.q 1.3&5 u.ee1 o.e·s7 RfSERYOIR ...JJPEHATIOtLCO.N8TR~1NJS ____ _ _____ _ ~AXIMUH RESERVOIR ELEVATION --------O~C~T~~N~O~V--~O~E~C--~JAN FEB MAR APR MAY~~J~U~N---J*'UML-· --~A~U~G--'S"E~P~---------------------------------------------------- 9~5. 945. 945. 945, 945. 945. ·945. 945. 9QS. 945, 9Q5. 945 • RULE CURVE ELEVATION OCT-NOVI>ECJ-AN-FEO--HAR--AP·H·-MAY--JUN JUL AUG St:P ------'9'--li.:...::s:....>,.___ 91! 2. 93&. 929. 922. 91 q. 90~·~·-...:.9.::.l.::.S.:..._9..:...o~7=--•:!..__9 . .:...:l:..:&::..!,t--....:9:..:1~-=1:...!.~-=9-='4:..:::o..:::•----------------------------- MINIMUM RESERVOIR ELEVATION OtT NOV -OE_C __ J..:...:AN ---FEB , MAR APR--MAY.--:fli'N JUL AU; SlP 8i!O I 820. 820. 820. 8i!O.L,_820. 820. .:::;8.:2:.;::.0~·-;..".:::.l.::...O~· __ S;:;..;i!=-0.:..•=-....:8::...::2::..;0;...!.:,.___;;8;;..;:2:;_;;0~·~---------------------------- RESERVOIR ~ELEASE CONSTRAINTS OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APH ' MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP ------------------~--~M~I=N~tM~U=M~CONSUMPTJVE R~E~L~E~A~S~E---,.----n----n---~.-------------------------,--------------------------- 011 o. o, o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o • MINIMUM NON•POWER RELEASE OCl~ NOV ___ DEC _ JAt:L_ FE6 __ MAR APR MAY JUN _JUL ____ AUG___Jlf.F o. o. o. o. o. Oo o. o. o. o. o. o. ~ fl.. it ,r, ~. I y ,; ._;:; j: q l i l I I' I /- ~ .~;;_ ·:::~ .. f t.~ !t '# ,11. If J .I \\ I , - ---· -·-·-~r-----------~,, ............... --.-~-~~--· ~""""·.....,__,~-"'~""--'"'~'-' .. ""'-"--<""-~"'~ ...... ~·~--~-···-·· --·-.;..------~--_J" . ' • ~ •, < " t• , "'!~/!:' ~ ' ~ ,. I' .! 1 ., ' "" 21-· roo·· J'· \ f • ' 0 .. .--.-' ,._ ~ ......_ ..,. 1IJia1l ... ~ --'!lall :- • llOWNSTREAM RELEASE tH.JTEHlA_ _ __ -~ ------·-~------,. -~-~;,-----~->. -Jill ~ ~ Attachment 7b.2 Page 3 of 7 Ela ~ ~ !""""-~· i!C!!Iiiiiil: ' I I' ..... • _ PRE•PROJ.E.Cl FlOWS AT Bfl OWu._.D...,.A.,..H...__ ____________________________________ _ • • YEAR OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR HA~ JUN JUl AUG SEP 1961 &95. 911. 692. qqq, 38&. 336, 361, 2165, Diiie ~~9la 69q8, bbll. 1962 2765. 910. 516. 443. 328. 246. 263. 1502. 8082. 6294. 6686. 3316 • .1.!ll.tl~.11ift_8__.. ___ 55_L __ qb 7_. 397. llf 0. zen. 266_._ 2~&~. 51 6b.._ "/65 1_..~ 662il._ q 341_1.__ ____ _ 1964 126q. 781. 615. S3u. 484. 463. 613. 5S08. 8786. b9q~. 4702. 2Sb79 t9&s 1 o2o., 515. ____3_Afl.._ __ 2ttb. zs o__._ __ 2l7.. 323._ 24 u. 3245 ._ 11 If 1 z_.__ z lbu.___ 1220. 19&6 904. 477. 366. Jlq. ?.85. 274. 340. 2461. 4972. 6431. 5454. 3714. 19&1 1755. I02b. 687. 92J. 286. a5u. 113. 1J37.ll8b4. 73~0.10950, 31JJ. 12 1968 1640. 616. 340. 453. 391. 300. 323. 219l. 7914. 1496. 5963. 5427. 1 eu 19&9 2262. 854. 554. l,lb6. 406. 356. lli,.__.z.::!.4.lLOS~·-:1~b~V~U:.a•-..:!.ti.~.-70~3~.~6ul~8~6~·~2't~O~b:u·~------------------------------ l 10 1970 112&. 598. 4b4. 402. 348. 300. 333. 3538. 5004~ 4632. 4801. 29&6. • 1971 1231. 621j.-482.. 432. 374. 117. !25 .. 2545. 6213. 7521. 5266. 4960. ':'"~-""::ft;· ,) ~::: ·~ t . r %\' _!.' :) i· I f\ t' j:. t I l I ! .. \1 ¥.)1< Hf,~ • ·-iiii217-97~ez. 34&. 327. Z99, 29lot 1e2. 2141. 6591. sb2~t. soqo. 1997. ~ no 7 1973 1157. 688__._ 6&b. ~l_b__l_._ ___ l~2..___l1S .. ~l~1--u2bli5 .. 1ll91 .. nS8~3 ... n 11'108._ l71b. --n---~ -u~-~-~ :;ifh.,J -~-4. rl ' 1974 8036. 699. 516. 465. 359. 302. 133. 1838. 4629. 6724. Q36l. 3344. tts __________________________________________________________________________________________ ~------------- 4 MINIMUM POST•PROJECT FLOWS ~T BELOW DAM l OCT ~OY DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUk___!~UG~~S~E~P~------------------------------------------tt 720. 720. 720. 720. 720. 720. 720. 720. 5000. sooo. 5000. 720 • . • NSD FOHECASTr YEAH 20!0 ANNUAL ENERGY OEMANU z 644Qe G~H • EtJERGY GENERATIOt~ CRITElflA Tt:.IP/e-/~ Ke./-.,q P.-3 -···---~----~~ • SYSTEM ENERGY DEMA-NO, GWH l I I OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR HAY JUN JUL AUG SEP st.3. &46. 111. &59. sez. s7s. 491. 459. 427. ~.~et-x-o-.---:q::"14r:-::,;.....--r.4~t~,..s-.--·,-----f " MONTHLY GENERATION FROM OJHEH SOURCE-~5,::--i:G!iiwii:lHr----------------------------------------I ! • OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APH HAY JUN JUL AUG SEP 10.4 1o.s ~~~-ba~s9.6 se.3 so.4 Sb;b 79.2 e6.s 91.8 11.s I ! ' l • OCT NOV AlidlJSTEO S'tSTEM ENERGY DEHAfflflliWH DEC JAN FER MAR APH MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP li4'6 • 591. 522 • 517 • 4lfi-;---1Jlr0'7"2 -. --,)n:qn7'.~T)~341r.--,3n:S:-J~q-.-3Tifi!i141r.---·-------------------------~ qqz. s~;~. • MONTHLY GENY~OF ANNU(L OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN. JUL AUG SEP o.oaa o.Iot o.us o.tos o-;lJlJJ o.o«~z o.o7«~ o.o12 o.o&2 o.os~ • ! l t I, f \ ~: ~ ~~ • TARGET FTRM ANNUAL ENER;Y z ill. ----------------~-.~~~--------..~-------------------------------~-------------------------------------------- TARGET MONTHLY FIRH ENERGY, GWH ~ ·. . -' ~ { ~. • OCT NOV DEC JAN fEB MAH APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP 4. 9 rr-;-s-~re-o--rr;q--ro ;·s--ur;4 s. rr--a-.1 1 .cr--b.:..._,.7-~7r.•t--7.,-.·-zr--------------------------- I i - U.----· ---· ";"'/ ___ . __ -~~.,--.-.---- I i ~ ~· 11-~~·~=--~~-~· -~-·-~-~·~--·--- v • ' .. . .. : \ _, ~ ~. -o r , ~-.. 1 , ,,... . .,.,.,,_,_,..._~, ...... ,_~,,_,__.. _ _,_,"""~_____..,_,-· -.--~v--"~"..-..-•·-~-.-........ -~, ........ ...,_,.,..-~---~-~---.----.~~---to--.·-~,--·· "'"",...·-· --. ..,__......._. . .........-........_~.,......_--.......,.~..-. ----.. ~,_.::.·-,-~----~~---;.,.,.-.--,."~"'..-.. -~----~~---.,._ .. ,..,..._.,.,._"'·~~--·-...,.t<..-...~,.. .•. -~,_ .• .)C.~·~--:;.~-·~---·-·--~.~~.----·-·---~•-c----·------·-··--·--·--~----· I ~ -=-~ ... ~ 11111111 ..... 1!IBI ... • IBI '-~ i#ia At~i~hml~ 7b~}ii Pa.4 oSf~ ~ """ .... ·----.... --~-.. -...-·--_ ... --"'·---~-·--• "' • -......... .<~ • • -· •• ;,. ' . . --·-... -·-------...... ----------....--__ .,.. __ 7.-.,~.!' 1,? t.f..cfn" ;:•f ·---·-------------~--·-·---~-----·· TUHBINE UlSCHAHGE (CfS) . -------··--·· .... -.. --· MAY FEU HAR JUL AUG SEt' APH JUN MlV OF C JAN UC1 e --'-~!'!. ___ 1~9._0 11~4.3 107"1,.0 .... 8!'1'!~ __ H5~'!2. ___ 82l.l ____ _?~LI!5._7?~!1l __ 48&9'!0_4~.&9~~ ll6&9u~O 4~b'1! . ..,.o __ 19&2 27bS.o ttu ... t 9o3.o tH3.o 7'17.2 731.2 12o.o '7t!O.o 4db9.o lf8b9.01lAbq_.r-3&'27.o 1'1b3 1167.0 7b2ol u~q.o 827.u H0'1.2 11H.2 7~o.o H14.i 4dbY.u 48b9.o 4b&9.o 4b~s.o • --~ 9bii--9b..s~·o· · 'IH4.~T-fooa:u ---·9bo:o ___ qs3:2--fiqd-.2 · Jooe,~5-'"3& is;~-4tJ69;o-4ah9-;o---qs6ff;O-csr-.:r-;T·------------ l'165 72o.o 12o.o 739.q 72o.tt 12u.o 120.0 7~o.o 120.0 48b"'.o qao9.o 4H&9.o 7~o.o 19&& 72H.S 817.3 997.6 95Q.ij 977.1 916.2 72S.~ 120.0 4H&Y.~·~q~6~b~9r.~u~W4VH~b9~.0~~7n2rno~.~O~---~----------.~~ • ___ 1 ~~J ..... !2 ~ !.o _ _ 12 o ..!-~-·-_9~3 ?_. a __ tts 7 3 ~ '!_ __ ? ~~. ~-173~!.~ __ 7 7 ~ o .!'.o __ 7 7 ~ ~! ~-~~~-9 !.~~.~~~.! o 4 8&~9 ~.~-! ~~! !.oll" ______ _ 19&8 1339.0 101"1.1 1 9.4 8 o.s 8&0.2 85.2 ~o.o cO.n Qdb9.u ~o&~.o 466 .u ~Hu~eo 1969 22&2.0 1057.1 941.0 69b.O 877.2 84..S.l 749.5 7~0.0 46b9.0 46b9e0 4tl&Y.o 2717.0 • -Tcf1 o--8 25 ;o--e o r;a-a5 r. o ... a Ja-;o-8 f7 ;~-1 tf5 :2--1 ~b ~ s-."B li'6 ·;9-q ts"6~r;-o-zrtf6q-;l) 4 A611-;0~26r.qrr • ...,I..--------·------ !97J 93o.o 627.1 a&~.u 8o2.o aqJ.2 ao2.2 12o.u 854.4 46b9.0 qab9.o 46b9.o 4669.o j972 1i'17;o 12o.o 74o.s 12o.o 7&s.7 7Ta.2 77s.s 72u.o 4do'1~o q8c9.o 4869.o 23oa.o ,! • J973 8~b.ll 891.1 10S3.0 893.0 811.2 600.2 73Q.5 9SS.9 4dbY.O '18&9.,0 qS69e~U 3931.9 ! --i 97 if/iab·9 ;o·~·9o 2:1-.... 923. o --8'95-. o·-828-;2--7 at. z--7 2b ~ s--;·z o;o-q 6&9. o-qa59. o 48&."'9..:... no --.2.r..9..J9\~&:....:.,_ _______________ _ I f • ·-----... ,__, ________ ---- AVG 1477.3 89&.3 905,.7 659.6 633.6 802.3 7~1.b 1055.2 46b900 48&9~0 48&9.0 322&.1 :1 • ! li I ) ' ---• • ·--· ..... _ -----· ·-----------------~------------· 4 • ----------·•". ·------·-----,-···--·------------------·----------·-------·------------------------ ---·--·---· --· --------··--·· • . -·--·--------.. --------· ---·-----·-·-------·-----------.. • --------------------. ---------·-----·--------- -··-·· -·-·-·--· --·-·--··---""·-----------------------------------• -----·---···-~ 12 .11 10. 9 .8 7 ·---------·-.. -·-·----"'. ()----~ ---· .. -----···-·------.. ·------·---- ------------. ·--.. -· --------------··-------------------------- ----------------·------------------------------------ I : • :-· ~-·· ----·-··--·-~-----.·-------., r- .,, I ~ .,, .:,1 -~ ; '! ~"'""""" \ ! I I -!(~ " ii? j f -··-----------..... ... ----~--...1-v-.J~ .. --------·~~,....~-__..,....,_.,. .. , ::::~ ...... ~._,...,..,,~-~· \.,..,~__,.,..,..._,..,_,____ __ . __ "'~ ------~--~1..--~4--~-----___,.,,._.", ....... __ ,.....- ·.:-~•x .'il@!irti! RWtil -~~1 I l I I I l 1 l ·-·~~=~ . i l ! f f I 1 I I . ,,, ,..ti, ... aij f l (j .,. • ]lliJIIR lWial .. .... .. ... IIlii -Jill ~ iii~ i;iii P"·F2fichm~ 1JF~ Pl?~~ 5 iff?'l1 ~. __..___ ----- ENERt;\' F~OM RESEHVlllk ltiWII) 7~1.-;~ /r t~cf~,,. r· s ill --·-·· ·-·----------------·----·------~-.. MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP ANN NUV OEC JAN FEh MAH OCT ----------.-----------------·--------------- • 1961 12.9 19.9 111.0 15.2 13.1 B.6 ll.d 12.0 H~.,.H 67.2 67o2 61i.Q IJ59.1 -r<i62 ____ 49;s----·· 19.2 · .. _ · 1 ~. ~-· · t ~ ;t ···· · 12.2 ---12. t -·-tt .3-----~ r;1· --at.lf--87 ;2 at;"2--ti2~ s 46s-;J- 1963 21.1 15.2 1~.o t~.5 12.~ 12.9 11.3 1~.o H3.2 67.2 H7.2 ao.2 4~1.6 • -1964--17~1----~i~o ... -n.o----ib;6·-· ·i4.6. --·is.7 ·· 1!J.a --·bJ;9--Hl.t-··a7.;2--if6-~6 "'r;o 479-;J·------------ 1965 12.6 12.4 13.0 12.4 11.0 II.~ ta.l 12.0 78.H 76.7 o9,3 9.2 310.9 1966 9.9 u.5 tJ:u---·yr:·9--fo.5 tr.ti ·1.1 H.:s--s-o 62.6 67.o I·o.7 zet.s •. _1 9~~---J-~!~---~-~!? .. __ 17!~---.. _14!..? ___ !!.!.~ ___ )~.!2 ___ !} .~ _ _!!! 7 ___ ~~.!~-~w 87,2 . ~9.b ,.~_H_~·------------ 19bH 23.H 17.6 13,0 15.0 13.1 13.0 11.3 12.0 62.e Ht.~ 87.2 o4.4 4oO.o 1969 qo.s 16.2 6,6 15~5 13.4 lqcO 11.7 12.0 63,2 86.6 H6.6 ~b.~ 445.6 • -f97o--·tq:-;--··3~8----·ts.o·---~~;q·--·1i!.:s--13:o----ii ~4----·3o;.;--ij2;c·-aij;s P3.s 3a·:2 411i-:·t-------------· 1971 lb.S 14.3 15.3 14.9 12.Q 13.3 ta.3 14,1 8],2 87.2 67,2 84.4 4S4.9 -y972 32:-2-f2.q--r3.o 12.tt u. 1 12.9 12.2 12.o 82,7 H7 .2 a7.2 19.7 q 15.7 .. • _·_1?.7. !_ ___ 15.~---· -~?!.~ --_)_1:!_.5 _____ !~,!_~ __ _1?!.~-----•--!'!..~ --_114!.? ___ ..!~.!.0 ~~!.? __ f!_].2 8!.1 67 .o ~~~~~ 1974 ao.6 ts.o 16.2 15.5 12.1 13.0 lleq 11.9 79.2 eq.z 86.0 So.a qs~.v ·-------·--·-·----• AVG 26.,1 15.2 15.b !4.5 12.~ 12.9 11.5 11,3 b0.3 84.3 84.! 55.2 429., • ----_______ , • • --··------· • • • • --~----------·----. --------------·---- -----------------·--·------------· ----·--··--·--------·-----------------------------------· • . ----------------· -------------· -------· .. ·-----·-·------·----------------------· • --·-------·--·--·-----.. --------···-·------·-· ---·----------···--.. ----·---·----·-· •· -··. ----·-. --·· .. IZ • It -----·--. ----10 9 .& 7 -------------- -..... -·· -·· -·-----------··-----·---·------·· --·-----------· ·--.... ·-· --~:..::;,_,,:::::.~~~-,_::~ u I es ' ... ~-..... ·-.. ~ ..,_ .,._ . ·- . C; ~ ~· I ~. r~ ~~ II l t ! ,, l !' l l [' [ j .·· Jl< .f! .~ (j U f ~· . ~~ .~~-•• ,,....,,>.!J.fl'i*";-*"· ¥.HQ? # .\II •·"· ._e:._~~~lf.-l'~~'--~~......,:;;;-~~--;-,..._..;.~.,,.._.;~ .. -=:-~-~,;...,.;;.,..;-~~ ........ '"':';"2~..{~1;:_::;~-:;:.:.:..r..)l1· - --------~----~----· -:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ll~llllln~~~~~~~~~ .. ~~llllllll~l!~~ .. ~~~~ .. ~ .c .. ,. '·· . .• • ~-.~ .... =--~ ~~-· . .. ·'' . .... '.. ... ·. ~ .. - • '.. ,' • iJ - ~.'O>{I;ii;IJI_j ~1 ~--... ! -,\ . i l ~I • ----·· 4 3 .._,,_, .. .,....-,:_;;,~--·---------~---""--.. -.:~..-........ .. "-··-··-··- JJI!fllii ,. 111111 11'111 .... 11111 t • 11 : =-~;;;;~:~~~~~-~~:~~: ... ~~-~-JAN FEfl MAH lCFS) iliill '•·-:".--. .... ---~--.J.......~~.-~ ,___,__,.......,__..,~--'-'• ......:-.-~J.-, ____ _,,-'.,.........,...,.,.,..,,.,.._,.,~-.....,.,..,.~t ..... .J;2......:.:;:...:.,.:....,....,..,.;_,,..,,..,_ __ ,,,_-...,,_ .... >",.~c ... ~ ~ ~ ,..,.-~ .... ..,_.- ~ 6ii.ia E:.iil . ~.iii.'""' Attachment 7b.2 E:i1tl ~ t;;.~ Page 6 of 7 ~ -..... .-. ··--· ---~---....... _ ,...,_... ______ .__. ,. ___ '"' _____ ----------·---·----.. _. ___ _ -----------··-----. ~. ti-e I 8 A.'t:-./')1 r. p, 6 APH MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP 1 ., a l9b~ 72;:0--~~~q-.-~--~~7~:~----H7-9~-ll--b~S.2 621 .. 2 ~~~.S 720~:0 b02lf.O 6343.0 &948.0 bbll.O 1 v -19o2--27b~. u--utJ·; r--9oJ.o .. ·· 673. o 797~2--731.2 · · ·12o.o--12o;o· ··b44&;zr"b2V-zr.'O-Eib81i.-u---J~27-;u · ---- 1 l9b3 1167~0 7b2.1 a~q.o B~7.o 609.2 77tt.2 12o.u ttlqo3 ~tsl.J 76~1.0 6H2q.o q&ss.o I 8 --1<Jb4--··9b~.o·-~gatf~ 1 roo2 .. o -·C)bo.o· --«is3.2 ___ 9qfj.2 100b;s ·~a1tt~-9--til51 ;J""-69!1lf~O"-sooo-;·o-2570~l---------------- l l9b5 7~u.o 720oO 739.q 120.0 72o.o 120.0 120,0 120.0 ~ooo.o souo.o 5ooo.o 72o,o -~ --Fit;.,··· · f21i.:: -irn. ~ 'i'i1'~o ---95ll .&--97? .1 9Tt:;~-z--·f2B. 2 72o. o 50Uo. o Sooo. o 5l)uil .I) 720. o I ~ a;~7 7ib.O 120,0 967,8 6~3.o 755.2 7l~.l 12o.o 120.0 101u1.9 112o.o toq~o~o 4044.0 1 --i968--1339.o-~-ioi9.T ___ 739.q-~ a1o.s--a&o:J---·785.2 --··7;ro;u-·7'lo;o -it~so~ii-7q~'b.u s9b3-;;o-suz""'7.:...o,---- . ~ ___ .l~~c: g.2~? .. ~_J9~1-! L.-~llt.o 89~ •. o __ ~1?~L._6_4l .. £._J.t•?.!~ ___ ??~!-~--~c;&~!~ou~.!.o 59.~9.0 2717 .u ----------------- .1 ft 1970 .f:\2S.o 801.1 ast.o 632.u 617.,C.. 7d5o:.2 726.5 1Hqa.9 ~ooo.o souGrO ~ooo.o 22b9.1 ., j ·• _1_9].1 __ 9)J.l.s._O_tJ27 •. _1_~p9 1 0 __ _!i~~O 8,Ql2-~-_!UJ2.2 7c!O,O 65!1 .. q 7576.3 7521.0 Sc?oU..,O 49b0.,0 "I 1972 1797,0 72o.o Jqo.s 720ao 7&5.7 77tt.a 775.5 7iO.o ~b~l~l 5624.0 ~o4o.o 2308.0 1 19 __ t'!~~-L-.. ~?~.! q __ ~'!J.,_L . .! 9~h Q .. __ a~~ .,_o __ ?.; !~£._6\!\!,.~ __ Jl~.!.L~~~.!.9_1 gi~b.!::'_582J.~•.,...o____,5::-o_o_u,.·~ ·=-o~-:;3:...;9;_;:3;_;:1;_::._9 ________________ , ~ • --~~·7"-~~~~-~~·-~-~~.t . 92l,o·--~95~~ ~za.z -~•H_:_2-~~~-5 7&-!v.o 5ooo.o 5179.b ~ooo.o 299&.8 . r)J! b703o4 b06.S.t: 339b .. '1 b17S,O 1055.2 A.VG l&_t::,~,o 8'1& • ..1 905,7 o59 1 .b 83l.~..b 802,3 751,b . -·~·· -----·---- .. l c J . -~--~------···---------·------ '•j ,, l r :;:·"7· ---~·~1 , I t1 ---···---------· ------------- ----·-... --------------------------·-----------------------------------• . -------------·---------------·· . --. --·-----·---------------------. ·----·-·------··"-... --------... ,. __ .. .. ... _____________ -----6-·----.. -~- .... --., ----------· ----------------------·----. ------...... _ -·--.. ---·--'". jt IZ .11 ____ _ ,10 L q.:----·- C~ ,,, :s:·~,.,.,-N-----:::"~~_.._.--.-.. --__._...-::.r---..----~~-----~--.-,.------.,..---~~~·---~-"·--4··--------·---·---·--· ''. -· !'' ,) i .<!' .• - 1 ! i ! " ,. I l· IY ~ "' ! !' l,. j, ., ?f l,r..t, .i Q [; . ,, 1,\ ~· - I $ -~ :if :J ::;_,, c I " \) .. ~,. '·' ""'·~'".) ---~--~-~----'-~----....... ______ ---~~---··----~---~-.. __ __~\.._~~;;.,~-------· --------··-·-··-'····-·---~---~------------~---~-----' ~~--..~ ....... ....1) t»;a ..a .,. J!\1!11 111111} 111111 .. ~iii £iii ~ .. -i::ii ( ~~ J '. ~ ·~l.tiiiM I~ ii:$ii ' .. ~.:;;_~ ~ ' r:::.:;;~ i:: iii i=:~=iii ~ ' --. --· Attachment 7b.2 M 7 of 7 I" !&L .... ~ ~· ~ "" ---------·· . -..... --·-·· ··-··--·· ··--·-. --·------···-· -·•··· ··-· --·--·-----··-·-··-····-··-------·------------------····-·-··· -----·-·-- XEETNA __ __,.ucr t"t2. NO\! ftJ. DEC uo. JAN l07. FER MAR tG.J. too. AP~ 9be MAY 101. . ---·-·-··--" --··· -----·· ···---·-.-· ------·--·-··---· ------· .. -----·-----· TOT~~ 112. 113~ 110. 107. 1&3. 100. 9b. 101~ • -"MiNTMLTM cA·P-iliiLi riEs-·cr:.wi __________ ·---------------·-------- JUN lUt\e ioa. JlJL 111. lit. 110. SEP llUe 110. Tc. ?/t!! IJ /.:eel7t« P. 7 -------...._ ___ ----~- 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1( ,. . 1: OCT NOV OEC JAN FEB MA~ APH MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP • __ K~~tNA ________ ,, _1!_. ____ lb.!-•. -~J~----1?_~..!.-.. ~~L-.J»J'..!..--~b. bl. bb.. 11. 1P_. 11:.. ·-··-- __ T..QJA't.. __________ }1 .. ____ 7b. 73. ~I!.!__ btl • ~u. Sb~ bl. bba 71. 7H. 7~. • ~f,R~GE ENERGY PRODUCTION (GWH) UCf MOV OEC JAN FEB MAk . APH MAY JUN JUL x.EEYriA ·-:--· · ·----zb': ~-rs:·z--r~-:·&-· '". s · --t2;q--·"'I2 ;·rr--·"fi ~s-·--r1'~1--a·u. 3 s4. 1 AlJC SEP A~N~N=--------------· uq.t ss.~ ~29.5 • '"" -'! • l'OTAL ----ib.1 Ts:i·-ts.& -li.:s·-12." f2:·9--i 1.5 17 .l eo.:s 84.1 84.1 55.2 429.5 0 I' I -•c.: I t 'I 1 ' ~ ,:; 1 i f t'"f1 1 MIN!MUM ENERGY PHOO~CTIUN (GWH) 9 ---~ oct--""t;ov ___ DEC.JAN--fEtf--MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP ANN __ K~ETfiA (_19bb) -~.!...L_!.L~--t.S.O 11_.9 10.5 . lO,.li 7.7 8.3 57.8 b2.8 b7o0 10.1 281.5 -.~. Cl9&6J 9,9 11.5 11,0 11.9 to.s to.4 ?.7 a.l 57.8. &2.8 b7.o 10.7 zet.s __!QT&I ~ __ .,.., ·----·----------------------------------------------------------------- -----------·-----·------··--------·------• • .. ----------· ··--------------------____ " ________ _ • . -------~---------·-·---------·-----··------------------------------------------------------ 9!1 ----------} z -------------· --------· ---------·-----------------------------·-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------t i c ------------------------·-----------------------------------------------------------------------~ • -------·---·-·-··---·· '---· ··-· --··--·-------------" ------· ------·--···--· -·- ~ ---------------· -------------·----c 12 •" 10 -;·-------·-.. ·-·--------·-·--·-·--· ·-·--·-·------------------···-·-·· --· .... ------------- L s .., 8 -- . -----. ;----·----·---......... ·~----------""'---~-... ~-·------· -·.,"1~-'"'-""·......_..'~"" .... ,....'"" ...... """"'•'"'""-"';><~~~··><-''-" ........ '<'·~·· ~-·'-•-'-........ -~. ---~ ·--~~-~ _, /j I ;i' I ·::1 ~ r: CC• r, ,~ ' t \) ~ u l [ l ! el ... r I I ! l ~- -~ - ' }~ , .. - ~ -k..,__,.,.._......,._h~---· ----------~-~---.-,.,_ ___ ,._...__,. __ _,..,.,__.......__.., ___ ,...,.~k. ___ ~----·-~---~ ~· ,.. ..... ,... ~ Will IIIII IIIII 1111 liB .. '~·-·-·~'-···-'---~---·----~-----------"-"----~--~----.---~-----...:~ f.iiii i=g it_~ ,...--,-.--·-~-~ r-·~ i . -~-u...:c.. E':ii' li.:5;aw Attachment 7b .. 3 Page 1 of 8 !Z:-,s;.ll b"';3 ~ ., o "..... .. ...... • •• I • "_:3 ____ _ ~ BROWNE ALTfRN~TlVE .• -.fESPONSElODE 1'5 HYDRO PROJECT NSO YEAR ~010: b,.~4 GWH /'a'-IC!' 18 Brtn<.,.,,e p. I WTimL~ CURVE RATED CAPACITY IOO kw :;. ' INPUT DATA FOR llHl INE , HATUHAL SfHEAMFLQW AT DAMSITE . .''M 'l . YEAR OCT Nov DEC JAN FEA MAR APR RAY JON JOl AUG SEP • . . 1951 1.733. 78_1_._ 7~3. 696. 595~~. SSo. 803. 7519. 9_~~0.IOlU6. 900le10H30. Q ·:: ... • ~ii5r21f&9;-Tl98u rm. 76a. 640. 614. 653. l0o5.12tl6Q.rzfli"S"Ir-.-.q~qf1lrzqr.-.::6:nuT("Tf-.---------------------------- 1953 3935 0 lbbQ. 10~4. 5SUe 461. 550. 1b8~ Q659.140b7ell~~S.10829e 7bS~. 1954 2179. 960. 832 .-,Jo-;--bcs-;-499. 576. 4 G1f~T5r.--vlfC::51r4 o.;_lr.2:r.ln6=-::2r.-.::6-:-77""1:J"TJ...:...-------------------------,---- 1955 3109~ 153b. 707. bQU, 589. Sbl. 486. 38l3.1~680.13773.1i717. 8U51. -1956 2378. 1056. BPI;-7o4. ·osJ. 561. 559. 54o4.14387.12813.1255o. 7684. 1957 ~831. ttzo. 915. 88~. 778. 6~8. 653. 6977.1561~. 9&93e al56. 7917 • --ri...-9S's-3T!;1-;-7~59. 117 5 e 987. 585. 472. 1 011-;qo I 0. 1:5 nJ-;-v990 ~,f0''1:5"T(TI-.--rJqmqrr7r,.---------------------------- 1~59 t924. qs4. 7o3. 1~1. ~t&. 434. stz. 5724.taq73.t4Q38. 9498. 5728. ~ ~~~~ou. 97l. BB!. Ita~ 660. 742. ·&246. IOl4 .. I0328. 9903. 18~~.----~~----------------~------ . t9&H zssq. 1010. 978. 934. set. 540. &tl. b760.t2JJ7.1l5b4.tl478,. 5614. l9e2 2826. 1':'136. 973. 781. 6o2. 538. &66. ""!i681.,19277.13901.10ZBS. 8865. ,~ 1963 3034. 146~~ 858. 691. 6~0. 602. 666. 7114*1~650.17H82el~b2Jrlr0r•~&n9~7n6r•------~---------------------~ . -[9"61rJb07;-TS'6""8-~~ -7li2;-T4;:f;---slr.-'lf61 • 646 • ll1 0.l51Tr.m-rr;-84! J • 4 62 0 • · 1965 34J3. t536Q 947. 666~ 563. 550. 762. 5265.tJ6U6.l4162~ ~152. 9175. e ---r9"&6,nH •. 1536. ::Vr.--l»Z. o-.--o-4 o. 6141. 691 :a 1 no;r5lfll~7T4";TDT29""'..:.... -6,.....3 .... 5 ...... J,....;.;__ ____ ... ~---- t9&7 3040. 947~ 799. 710o 628, 589. 576. 4991.152Q~.l9b35.l675S. bl64. --19&8 2341. 1152. 913. 945. 8oo. 161o 809,. &o79.1615~o~~~l~J•twqTI~.~7r7~6~2r.-,l~7~6~4-.-------------------------------------------r------------- O __ 1.'~.~9 tb47. 517. 335. 29~_. ~ez. 2~2. s~~. 5289. 9~,1&. 7521. 5513. cnoo. , t9,ioll24 • 8Zi4. 678. 611.. 579. 5bl. 649;-50"~-;TO(HJCJ;flf2"2T;'fJZ4. 55o7. 1971 2406. 966. 699. 69le 691. b9le 68~. 47S6.l8560.137~~.1l325. b227. ' l97i 3oS2. i&5~~17S;--B&~~~;--s9r;--556. 43oz;llrZ2Z;rlqaq;-~t~~~,7~.-s~a~nr.~---------.~------------------------------------------- l973 3~41. 21J4. 1016 •. 768. &40. 576. 671. q2o1. 7937. 98b6. 9188. 4014. , · • 1974 181~. q5~. 531. 31&. 241. ~43. 25Q. J2q6. 7323. 9394. 8236. 6396. ~ 1975 ]028. 1169. 838. 640. 640. 640. &82. 366b.l3299.12b4l. 848b. 6925~·~--------~---------------------~------------~ -i976 z6ia-:-l""i24;---To3-.--,o7·:-sla. 461. 9"13-;-iiz.i4.923&---;/51~;-69~s. 3sr6e 1917 2168. 1233. 89to 768. 640. 576. 618. ~196.15398e1~6l3.l0405~·~1~1~~~~~·------~·---r---------------------------------------------• -t918-'q"Qfiq:--l-ob5:lo8o-:-a33.-7!7. 651. tol~-;55oe;-e1io.ui77s-;-e699. 47ua. ! 19'19 2372. Ufi7. __ CfP2!L__llll_~ b4Q..___ 576.__~8$~-60'19 • 9592 .U03U. 81152. 5131. -·· ;..' ' -~-------Lj: ~-. ., ---..--..,.....,...... __ ._... _ ___,...,__ ... ___ _ ' . ~ ............ ............, .... _,...,_..,."~ ..... ~ ... _, •• .._..,_~-·o;<··-··-··-- /, '· -"''"·-~·· ..J_J L ~ I [ ' ' ,. ' t t•' f 1 .:· n . - t l r ~ II f ! I t I I l !. I ~ .d ~~ 'i> '/ - ---l i l :f' ~ '\~ ,-~} r '• ~l' 0 :~ 0 rli ·. ' ··I .. -.. ·.. I. . . . \,_,_.), •I' ' < \) .-;:. ,. ' 'i I n --~~-w,->.;<,'M,-<>'•., ..... A-_.._,_.<W', ...... .,.,~.._,_ ..... ~ ------~-.......... -,....__...,_.--~. __ , _____ ~...--...,----·--·-----<--,._._----., __ :I iJiQiili1 ... ... ,_ 11111 ~ .. ts.i· ~ Efy ~:;::::::;:;;:;;:1 ~ ~ ifi'';:;~ ~ E·-iiJ ~;=~;;; ~ ~ ~ • • • • NET RESERVOIR EVAPORATJON, !NCHE3 OCT KDV DE~ JAN~B MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP o,o o.o o.o o.o o.o o.q o.o o,o o,o o.o o,o o.o Attachment 7b.3 Page 2 of 8 -11***.!~~!'~_.REftE.B..V.Q1JLP~J~~~~~---**** _J.!l!:!IA TEILP-!!~~~** I ELEVATION VOLUME AREA DJSCHAHGE ELEVATIO~N~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ (FltHSL) UCRE...-_f.U..TJ (ACRES) lCFS) · lF.l.!J4.c::S:..::L~-~~~---~-~~~~~--~~---~---~~--- 710.0 0, -0 0, 780,0 . tz 780,0 15000, o, 1000000, 760•0 '·----------------·----------------·--------------~---------- ·4t" 3Qih .. Q .5C!Q.o.u_. ________ 9..._ -~-·-----«h!l;-----------------------~·-----------------·---- co 8 If 0 1 0 1'1 0 0 l) 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 I 0 ·~-~~~~ 2~ooo, _____ 4!~ q. o.~o ___________ ~-------~---------------------~------• • 395,0 Jqoooo, o, u. o.o 7 920.Q SOQ_(}yQ, Q, O, _ 0,0 ,_ t -fibO,O 94QOOO, · 0,-0, 0.,0 tts 9L~1 0 l!~QOOOL-Q 0, ~-~·~0--------------------------------------------------------------~ 1000,0 1401000, 0, o. c.o 3 8 __ T_H_E -R·A Jf,O ·rtEAD ·-islio:0FT, THE RATED CAPACITY IS 100,0 HW, THE ~EAOLOSS 1~ 0,015 TIMES tHE HEAD • I • lj -THE-siEN£RA fOR EFricfENCYIS 0,980 !HE TRANSFORMER EFFICIENCY lS U,990 74~/c ld' 8rAJ)te P. Z. ~-------~-----------------------------------------------------------------~------------ a . **-*\'t******** ~~~..!~* PO~~PlANT __ DA T A_, . I UN 1 T 8 * *~** •*=-:.*=-::*-:*:-:-*:--*;..;.;*;..;.;*...;.."..;...*..:...*.;_*_*_* -----------------------------------~---------NET HEAD PLANT CAPACITY EFFJCI£hCY URATED) (FEET) (MWl (X RATED) TURBINE Pa.ANY . • _o.c,5o ~to.s. '16.6 o.11eo o.sse ~o.ela 0,750 121.s &0,9 o.628 o.o8o ~.esq --~~0-,J.~O !l~.o b7~7 o,&98 · o,uo~e~----~iDL,8~b~2~-----------------------~----------------------------------------------o.eso 144.5 7q,b o.J&q o,oQq ~.8b7 I G) ----~Owtw9~00 ~~~~p 61,9 0,8~~ 0,900 1~67~3~----------------------------------------------------------------·------0,950 !blo5 89,4 0.921 0,905 ~.878 L.ono 110.0 .n .. o t,ouo 0.910 o.aa3 8 --l .. OJ~ 175,1 101,2 l .. oq) 0,908 ·0,6H1 • _ _,_" .. 1.60 l80t.l 10~?... .. 4 1,086 0,906 Ml_.,_:.__ __________________________________ _ 1,100 !87,0 111,1 1.145 0,9Ul 0,87b • ----~~~~lSi-1~5.5 IJ.~~ 1~J.~9 __ ~o~·~"~o.~o ___ ~o~B7i~l ______________________________ __ 1~250 212.5 lll,4 1.3b5 0,681 0,8S7 • _ RESERVOIR OP~~UUlli_£=0=NS~f~R=A~I~N~TS~· --------------------------------------------------------------------· • ~l~IHUR_~~E~YOIR ELEVATJ~O~~~-~~-~~-~~~~-------~~------------------------------ OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAH APH MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP -975.. ·us. •us. '975, 975. '175. 4'11..?. 975, 975. ens, ens, ~75, • • . ___ RlH~tJ!J_RVE ELE.V..!TIO_~----·· OCT NOV VEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG 9.15. 970. 9btl, 957. 952. 5~~. q"'· 9b3, Qib4, 969, ___ 9~1b:..l):;..z...___;:....t....::~----------------- t· i • ·-··· -·--·~-·-L--~'"'=..,·---·---~~,~------·---.-, ....... ". ----.::--....... ----7;-------..............,:---------·--------~ ~-----~--.,_,.,..,..,._.......,__,~~-F~'"""""~~ .... ...._."'\,"'"-'~"';' . ..-1---~, •-•· •~·~-~ ·-•~·--·· -~-. ..,• • ~~ . ·;;;:~~-.~"!· •.;~~. L ,; .·t, ~~ l t l ~~ [, 0 I· (~~ f ! . ~. I I ·L it ~r-r~ II L:·LJ. r·...-.-" I I l: I l I f l I t ~· rt () r i ,. ,.,r; ·;) - ~ ' .~ .. (_J "J I 7 (; ! 11 I t ' ! I I tJ .... , ...... ____ ..,_ • t'5ii ~--_,...,.__ ___ ._._~-.-.._,.,..,..__., ____ ~~<~· __ ,........_,,;_,\ ,;:__.....).~~·~----.·---_::::_:_"' __ . -· ........... ~---......--~ ...... ~ .. ------'~~~~---------~---~--~----'--~-.-,....._...,.-----"~" ··-··· .....,....~ .. __._--... --...... --___ ._...!.__,_,.._,_..:;:._, ..... 'lin ·JIIlll ~\~ ~:·~; ~ ,--jj r~ii i::::::';j i·-i L;:i"i £r:_;;;;;.t ~r:~~ E~ Attachment 7b.3 Page 3 of 8 ------~~---'"'··--·- ~ ~ ____ ..uH li'UMUH ... Bf.~E.R'IO I R .EL.E..V..!ll OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB !\ii'AR APR MA~V ~IJiiiuiiiN---J'iiuiiL-&iAuiiiG:;-0SC'Eii"P--·------------------------------- 8..95. 895.. 895. 895. 895. «:Vi5_.. 895. 895, 895, 895. 895, 6'il5. • ----------------------------·----~·----------RESERVOIR. ~flEASE CON6TRAINTS • OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR HAY JUN JUL AUG SEP ----------~IHUH CONSUMPTIVE RELEASE : Or. o. o. o. o. o~ o~ o, o. o. o. o. • , ,, ~;'( > ·., I I • . MINIMUM NON•POWER RELEASE I .. -I or:J Nt'\V OEC J&N FEB MAR APR HAY JUN JUL AUG SEP _ !· . I ! z o. o~ o. o. o. o. a. o. o. o. o. o. 1 . en j'• t;l ''\'-. • ; . P::~:::~:~~::s:T c::~:w DAM ' ILr . YEAR OCl NOV DEC JA~ FEB MAR APR M~Y JUN JUL AUG SEP · · liS.l_JJ.JJLe..--1.8.1...__723. "JtL_5.'l5..__550. 8QJ.,._t219. 92l!1...1~Llfl8. 9001.10UlQ. . I .. . .. ·. : 1952 2~69. !398. l0b2. 7&8. 640. ~llf. &51. lOOS.l2864.llflf5l. 9lfllf. &017. i 'S ., 4 ~_1235. 1o~11. Ul-lf. sso..__Jl~l. sso. z&e. lf&59.....lll&7.ll&?S.10829, 7b5Z.. ~~ 1954 2179. ~60Q 832. 730. &25. 499. 516~ lfUO&. 9751. 9lf54.122&2. &733. I I . 1955 _1109. 1536,_ 707. 640. 589. 563. lf8&. J8l~.l26tf'O.l3773.H717. 8051. ~ . I 195& 2.378. lOSt.. 819. _7011. &53. S&l. 559. Slf04.14387.1281l.12SSO. 1b8lf. : -. . . -···. . j (I -~1:..,:.9.:;57 2833. 1120. 'H'5. 882. 778. 658. &53. &--,77.15834. 9&93. t;t256. 7917. 1 1958 31&7. 2259. 1775. 987. 585. IH2. 704. lfcilO.l3T11-;--9990.10511. 3lf9 • . I l959_19?!f.L_'i~ll. 703. 727!. .. -~1&._ll1311._.~1?._5724.!11173.1lU6J8. 91198. __ 5728.. "1""a.6/ .. ,,. MWW!'~ P.3 ··-L 1960 32lfS. lbOO., 971. 881. 718, 6i&O. 1112. 82116. 7011f.H328. 99Ul. 7611o ;.,.:>" 1961 2554L tottl, 978~}~__?6~-·--~~qu, 813. tt7bo.t2l37.11~&",13Ci78, 5~tLS. • I , 1962 2826. 1S3b, 973, 761, &02. 538. 6b6o 5&87,19277,13901,10265. 8Hob, J J • • W .. !96J 3o3q. 1485~ 859. b9t. &4u. &oz. &&&. 7114.1265~.17662,1&~30. &976. 1 -i9ii4 36,7:156'6-. 7if2:742·.--538-. -4&f~4&:-ITfb";T5ira:t"li'3l:-8~t3. 4b·2o. j 1965 3473, 1536, 9~7. ~&&. 563. 550, 762. 5l65,llbO&~t418l, 8152, 9175. j -f9&63'7'6·ii;-is3.&,--s92-._ -t,;,o-:-64u;-;,"'·•r~-e;iii-:-ITJ6-:Is-9i"l~-9·rnr;roi2~S1. [ 19b7 30~0, 947, 799. 710. &28. S89. 57&. 4991,15245,!9&35.1&755, &1&4, · 1968 2341. 1152. 913, 645. 600, 1&1. 809. 6U79.16150,13~97, 77&2, 3764 • __ 1!69 164l.!.._5JJ. Jl·.s. 2~~~2_. -~~?~~~~~u-~.!. -~·~J-~?~?:h25!~?_~o. l 1970 1324. 844 0 b78. 6!1. 579, 563. 649. 5Ub0 8 l0089,14221, 9]24. 5507, I 1971 240&.__9&8, b99, ·~~H. 691, b91, 6Hl. 475&.185b0,137l4el332~. b227, \ --tci7z 1osi. t'bss:lt2)f.-1ab'a-. --t;9o-. -~9i,f)556:--;t~ro2. u222.ffiiaq, uqqJ. 5t'19 • • 0 • • 191~ 3241, 2!34, lOlbh 7&8, &llu, 57&r 671. 4207, 7937, 96&8, '1168, 40llf, L 197~ 1~12, ~82, 531, llb, 243. 243. 259 0 324&, 7323. 9394, 8236, b39b 0 [ __ j_'fi_L~Q?!'a_l~~.:L-838, &40, ~~1! •. -~tiO, b8b_l.~f!.~l}29_9_ill!J~3, 848&, 6925. ! 1~76 2618. 1024e 803. &07~ 512. 4ble 573. 4~q4• 9236, 7515. &958. 351&, { __jJJ.l_ll~~ .. _l238L-_69b, l~~~~t..-_~1~ &18. 4!_~~5l~Jl.! . .l~!!}~~~-5. 719~. t 1978 4494. 2065, 1060, 833. ~37, &53. 1032. 5Sb6, 8110,10775. 8b99. lf708. r' 1979 llJl, 11 (H tt 9\)i, 74le b40 t 5Jb, 685 '· 6019 t 9592,13030 1 6452, 5331 a -·-l • • -MJlU!"UM...f.Q.!!.,PRO_~,~~T FLQ~S AT .~ELO~ DAM I OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB ~AR APH MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP __l!H!.L.:..J400, 1400"' 1400. l_ill.._14vO, l&IOO, 1'400, 93oo. ~'9300. 9100, 1400, ].- NSD fOR(CAST, YEAR 2010 ANNUAL ENERGY DEMAND z 6444. GWH. . f.., . ~· I• r~ • • ~,··.-----------···------,----------~--~--~----,~------·~,..---. ----·--~--.~~-~-------........... _______ ?J--~---------~"''"""'"'f-"'"""~~ ........ ,.~ ...... ., .... ~-..... , .. ,.~.,...._~,~-~~---r:-' ..-' - /- ,... ., ~ ... '; . .. """ ... ·•. .. . ~ • • • "' ''\', • < -.. b ~ ~ '\ .. ' ' , ' -A -. f ' ! t • 0 1. , q o --...... "'..,..·, \I --~-----.,.- ~ ,_.,~·..._.,_,_~~~~~.:.....~~~~~"~"""" ... .,.,..,._ ..... _~__._,.,~-,,.,...,,.,..,.._...,....._...._..... ______ ~,_..,-._-· ___ ~_ --£··-~_,._...,._.,.....---... ..... ~-~-----·-~~.--. ...... ,.----. ...,.......,~-- 'li'i!'I~IF~ -Yek}~~ -....-..: ~ \1~ ~-'""'i! ~ ~ ' 1 ~ !~~iii~ ~ Jill .... ~ ..,_ ' . -... Jiiii ~ i~7i ~;.ii -~-----·--~·-· _______ ..,.,,...,.. ___ ~,__ _,.: .. -~ ---~---__, .,.,.,__. ~ Attachment 7b.3 Page 4 of 8 ~ ~-c:.:l ~ E?ii eil ~- ~~ ~- t d l I I ;l I I • ... • .............. ··-•• , ••• -10 '"'·· •• t • -----~~-----~ ~ ____ ENERGY GENERATION CRJlENIA If l i ,j ... I I • SYSTEM ENERGY DEMAND, G~H --------0-C_T ___ N_O_V ____ O_E_C----JA~N~~FEB MAR APR ~~~~AvY---v~~'U~N~-.J~U~l---AT-U~G~~S~E~P~------------------------------------------------------- _5_6_]..___bli_O_._ __ lllL ___ ~S__~ .. --S~2 tl 5.75!1 ___ li_«!l~. '159 ~~--'~27_.~1120__._ __ 91fta' ttbS. ----------------~----------·---------~-------------~--------------------------------------------------- MONTHLY GENERATION E~OM OTHER SUUNCES, GWH OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP ' # -~ -~ 96,5 85,7 87,0 82.5 72,0 71~ 61,9 73,9 159,5 170,8 175,9 126,7 . ' J; 0<' 'I u • !' ADJUSTED S~SIEM ENERGY DEMANQr GWH OCT NOV gee JAN FEB MAR AP~ MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP • 466. 554, &30, 577, 510, 50~~2~9~,~~l8~5~,~=-~~b~7L,~2~4~9~,~2~7~0~,--~33~~~~~-------------------------------------------------- • MONTHLY GENERATION, PERCENT OF ANN~U~A=l~~~--~~~~--------------------------------------------------------OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG 5EP Q,Q90 0,107 0,.122 O.lU_.O.,O.~ILQ_,QCJ_7_(J,()8,LQ,o7g_uo_._Q5LQ,Ott8 0(!052 o._obS • TARGET FIRM ANNUAL ENERGY • 122. • TARGET MONTHLY FIRM ENERGY, GWH tz OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP •"~ 110)0 11,1 14.8 13,b 12,0 11.9 10.1 9.! b,l 5,9 "·" 8.0 ta . I ... ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 ' • s_.._ ____ _ • .. 3 I ~· • • '· '.:! '-, ,;.-" l ,~· ~~-...,._~--· _.,.....,......~. ~ ... ·~~>W-~-~-~"'-'Jt.r"'·"'"..:...-.........._ .... .,::,--. __ .'....~----.---~.:-~~~-····....,...,.·---..~·--~-•. ,._,\•'>-· .. -·~--···-·-::·:--·::-~..:-=:c::._=~~·"-·~----:..-.. ...... -·'1""~~~~- . ' j ' ~ ~ \ ' ... <!If ., .. • ·~lii'J'!l!iO~ 1 l 1 o; •• ·::::_..._J ~.., j l 'I 1 1 I .! ~J )! 'I l ' JiGI , 4 J i5li . . [11;1 ~ ·B.;; . -----····-··----------···-·-···· TURRINE DISCHAHGE tCfS) .. ------·-··---··--· --·-··-··-·· --... - UCT NOV DEC .<,./""' •• ~ rtaa JAN FEB MAH ;·;c~ ~ ~ ~;~ '~ bjj ~.::::;J ~ r:.::::-........ 111£..~ (;':":"';, ~-- rr..._.-~-~ ~ r· ,.., .. ......_ -....... --·•'-'•· ... ···-----------..... '-· .. --.· .. --... ---.... ~ .. ---... _,,. ....... . -. ··--------··--· _._..:.______ Attgchment 7b. 3 Page 5 of 8 /(: (./~ If' 8roto·n APR MA't JUN JUL AUG SEP C..=:'::"ll'! ~ P, tf. ~::-· • __ 1_?5 __ 1 __ 17~~.0-· ~~~9_.! __ 163. ~~~-_1804.!.! _1_7?3.!..7 ___ !_658~9 .. J~l~!? ... :S~!~~--Hl_~?.~~--~~~-~---~~~~·3 81~5.-.;:3:-----------------,---- :952 24b9.0 227&.1 2172.0 1874.7 t1bH.1 1722~9 Jqbbe2 1400.0 61&5.3 8lb~.~ 6lb~.l b267.9 1953 ]692.2 2542.1 21J4.0 1&5&.7 1569.7 1b~H.9 1561.2 1400.0 61&5.3 8lb5.3 81&5.3 7902.9 • ·-·195ii·--I936: 2--1a3ti: i-iq42~·o· -i 63& ~:.;···a7s:r:-7-1 &o7 ~ 9 · ·1 tfoo: o-1 itoo·; o-·tft ,;s·;s --6i 6s.-rfiTt;s-;3-b983 ;-9 n955 2Hbb.2 2414.1 1617.0 J7qb.7 1717.7 1b71.9 1400e0 14UO.O Hlb5.J 6165.3 816~.3 81&5.3 . t95& 2267.4 1934.,1 t9-J9.o--Taio:7 ... -.7s1.7--fb7t.9-fqoo:o-iq7n.~ ot&5.3 · 81&5.3 8lbS.l 7934.9 • __ t ~s ?_.~.59.!~.! 2_!? ?.~ !.L? ~_2s !' -~ < s. 9 ~n .• ] __ ~-~ ~ b • 1 __ t ~ ~ b! 9 .. J ~-~h..!?.--~~ 1 ~!.. «_o!. b s....!.!__8 ~ bs. 11 ~ 1 ~ s5_~~ -~~-f~ ~.1~----· 1958 292Q.2 3137.1 ~86~.0 209J.7 1713.7 1580.9 1517.2 1400.0 61b5.3 6lb5. 8lb .~ ~,~7.9 1959 1661.2 1832.1 1813.0 1633.7 1744.7 15«?.9 1400.0 1751.0 61&5.3 61&5.3 &165.3 5976.9 • -i 96 0 --j 0 0 ~. 2 2476; .---2 ()8 j: u"" i 98 r; 7--.6 q &: 7'--rfbb ~ q -155~: 2--ii'Jii 5. 4-8 (65;-r-61 &5--;r-8lbS. 3 5 :n 6. 1::----------·. __1.2 ~.1__.1]1 ! 1 2 18 '! b R 1 2 0 6.8.~ .Q__ 2 Q~ !J..1 7 17 0 q • 7 1 b£4 6 • ~ 1 h 2 b • 2 2 8 59 e ~Q _6~1 6~5::-'. •:._;3:---;8~1~b~5:-:•:.;:3;..-~6~l_,.b..;:.5..:;.•-:-J-.;..5 .;..86:::..,4~• 9;..----------------- 19&2 2583.2 241«.1 2063DO Jij67.7 1730.7 16Qb.9 1«79.2 1786.4 Hlb5.3 81&5.3 8lb5.3 8165.3 e _ . .J 9~;! __ _]03~! L.1~~-3<JJ .. _! 9J>.§ ,.~._1_197 ~7__ __ 1 I~8. 7 __ .1_7 !.~ !.'~ ___ 1_4_7_9 !..? --~~!~. 4_H.ll».~. 3 61 b5. 3 ij.1 b~. !_.1226.! 1964 33bQ.2 l44be1 1852.0 l6~H.7 lbbbe7 l~b~.q 1Q~9,2 1400.0 6!65.3 8lb5e3 6lb5.3 3954.3 _19~~-~.?~Q..J!~-t]~.J '!.:r_l_?,02L_0 ___ !]1.~.!.7 lb9l. 7 !!>.?d.!.~ .. -).~?~~~--~~~-~!.-~J!!~!-3 -~.!~5.,!}_!H&5.3 81 b:-5.::.•.;;3 _____________ _ e 19&& 3597,2 2Ut4.1 2oo2.o l7Q6.7 17&6.7 174u.9 tsoq.? tQoo.o 61&5.3 81&5.3 61&5.3 &603.9 --~~~967 2797,2 1625,1 1909,0 1816.7 175&.7 16~LL~ l4o~.o t4oo.o 8165.3 81&5.3 6lbS.3 6414.9 1968 2098.2 2030.1 2023,0 1951.7 1928.7 l675.q 1&?2.2 2176.~ ~165.3 81&5.3 8lb5.3 2425.& e 19&9 1404.2 1400,0 14~7.4 1400.0 1400.0 1400.0 !400,0 1400.0 6165.3 8lb5.l b1b5,3 1400.0 --197 -o-t·~-,~:o--157 6 x-f799 ~-i -·I 1 2s~·s--n·a·H :~-rt36 ~ j --·• sso :s-rii o o; o 61 bs. 3 et &5. 3 ss &5. 3--....;~"""&~&~9,..::.-=q,_..---------------- t97t 2lb3.2 16Q&.l 1809.0 1797.7 1619.7 179~.9 1495,2 1400.0 ~1&5.3 61&5.3 81&5.3 &477.9 • -: ?7 2-2 ao q~. 2--2533 •• -22-:s-:r: o-fq 14 .-7-15 is·:r-1 69·9:·9-1ii ·o 0:01 ii o o. o 8165 .1 =8.::-t &;;;.,5::-::.;. 3::--:8~t::--:6:-.. ~:-:.:...;;3:--.-:;4~5-.;.,4...;,o...:..-=-1---------------- t973 299~,2 3012,1 2126.0 tH74.7 t7b6.7 lb6Q.9 1QH4.2 1qoo.o 81&5.3 8!&5.3 8165.3 t4oo.o 1974 14oo.o t4oo~o 1460.7 140o.o 1411.3 t4oo.o i4oo.o 140o.o 6lb5.3 6165.3 HI6S.3 140o.o e 1975 t4oo.o 140o.o Jquo.s 1415.5 t7&d.7 174H,9 1495.2 1qoo.o 8lb5.3 61&~.3 at65.3 6334.6 --~76-2~f~;~-i~.l-~1fi~.o 1iD~1~i6ij~7 ~~~:~~l~fi~o--~~~1&5;~ni~~~~&~5..:;..~3-~14~u~o~.~o~---------------- 1q77 1400.6 l4&h.7 1&37.3 15~1.7 J55b.b 14J8.3 1400.0 1400.0 81b5.3 blb5.3 . 6lb5.3 74q5.9 • --t97a-42sr:2-·294J:T2i9o~o-f93q. t-,H·&s:7--t7bi79-T64s·~~~&&7 ,4 61&5·.1 8tb5.3 6tb5.3 2521.'5 1979 2129.2 20b5.1 201~.0 1847.7 17b8.7 lb6q.9 1~96.2 2178.4 Hlb5.3 81&5.3 6lb5.3 4705.6 . ---·--··· --·--···-·--· -----····-··--·-·--.------------------·------~--~~-----~ ------~--~-~----AVG 2479.6 2119.0 1957.0 1797.5 1730.2 1&59 0 8 1493.&. 1639.7 Hlb5.3 8165.l 81b5el 5402o4 • • -----·---------... --·-·-----·---··. -------· ---------~----·--· • -------· _ ... _ ---------~ .. ---______ .. __ -------.. -...... _______ ---.. --·---------------------·· -. ---·~--~-·· ··---··· •·· -·-·--··--------~------~·---------.... ' -. -------·-... --.... --.. ---· ·---·--·-.. ·~-"--··--___ , ...... .._ --.... __ ---.... -~ ... __ 12 • 11·-··---·· '10 9 • b 1:; l- 1 'I I f, l ' l t·· .~: ;; il'-( ~ ·--------~---~~-~---·~*·~·~·-P---~···-········-.. ···---.-----------. -·-···-. --~...-,. _..,_ .... ___ ...,, -" 7r ~--------· -----· --~------------.-t-"'1,..,..... ----·-··--~-· ... . . I ~ • • l' ,. 't I .. "> , IJ _. .. go ... c .. • , '-!l> ~ ,.,_) ' '~l --~~ ,1 ···-~·~··~~~-'"'·""~""-'·~~·-"""'" -~-·-.. -"~"··--~-~,~-·-·'"~·~~~~-'"--~-~ .. -~~~.--~>~--~-~.~-~--'-~·-·-··~·-~-·--"-·--':..........-----..;::_...;._,._~-~----. ___ __;. ___ ~--~-~. \\ I ! r /111!!!!!!!! ~ lSiiil ~-·Jill ~ ~ ~. SE3 { ~ ' .. JiwlMUb; Ilia s·.a {\ ~ ~.:~ ~ r;;:-::·:~ ~ I ~ :::;; ~ .d .t. - ~:wi ~ ~ -.r.l Attachment .,b. 3 .. ~i.~~f 8 ~~~ ~ ~_.,iii ;a j .• ----·~------·-----·------··--·---·----- I ' I.il j' 'II : • __ 1 9?J. __ J ~ ~ ~---· t~! !L ___ ! 6 ~ 1_. __ ! I! H --··--t L& ~ q-__ .! ~-.!-~----· I~ !t 9----~~J ___ l~.!.~--~ ?.!.8 t! 3. 7 Eg. 2 q? 7 ~ 1952 2&,2 23,1 22,1 16,5 ·~.3 15,9 12,6 12.7 77.7 85,4 6&,5 64,0 459,9 ENEHGL£B.Q~ _R~§~~VUII{ __ .• . -~!?~!"f) ___ . ___ .• ~·'-'~ p.s-____ 18 er(lhm(l UC1 UEC JAN FEU APR JUN JIJL 5f:P ANN AUG NUV MAH MAY i Jq5] 39 0 25 6 21 7 1&,4 13,7 ~~.3 ll,b 13,1 80,& 8&,5 8&,5 80,7 492,8 1' • -. 9sq-·--2o: q----is~b---19~8---i ti. i·--· i~ ;i---rti: a·--··~ 2": .--·-rif.9 ___ 7&:s--·-79 .1 sT;2 ir:·" ~.-4 . .:::2-=-.-=7------ 1 1955 30,3 24.~ ~6,S 17,2 1~ l~,q 12,0 12,6 79,1 8&,0 8&,5 83,b 460,6 I' 195& 24,0 l'l,b 19,7 17,9 1S.4 15,4 12,1 13,9 61,3 8&,5 8&,5 61.1 473.3 1 • _.19~7 .. __ .~7 _,,3. ___ ~u, 2 ___ --~~ "'~--___ ! ~.f! __ .ll~.!.s. __ l b! 3 ____ !? !'.~--__ 2_~0 ~t!l __ ~&_!.5 85o3 __ !..!..!.~ ~6~.!.?. 1 1958 3o,9 31.8 29,4 ~o.7 1q,8 tt~,& lj.l 12.9 79,9 8&.5 Hb,5 36,3 459,2 j ___ 1.9~9 __ 17 1 7 _ L~JI~ __ Jih_5 ____ j~.! l __ !~!!.~ _____ !~~~--.J?!!0 ____ 1A!!2 __ ~!.!_3 __ j!~ .. s ~~~---~J..! 1 il~.~!.,;-1------------· 1 • 19&0 31,7 2~.1 21,2 19,& ln,O lb,l 13,q 41,0 7b.~ 17,& 79,5 52.3 470,3 ·'· .. •J , 19 b 1 2 q !! t1 l.YJ 2 c! j ,3 2 0 , 1 l t1 , H _ 15, 2 1 q, 0 27, 0 81 o 3 8 o, 5 8 b, 5. 59, 9 4 7 0 , 2 ~~~ 19b2 27,3 2'1,5 21,2 l8,b 15.0 !5,2 12.7 1&,9 81,3 66.,5 6&.5 63,7 489.3 e __ !9~:S_. __ ~~-' 1 .. -..... .£~ .. 'L_, __ 29.!~--·_j 7 !.[ ___ t~.!.~---J~!~·--·-!~!' "t ____ _.s_o,l ~.!.J. ___ ~&.s 6~,5 71,6 4?~!.-:1:--------------- i-.Q?l·.··~\ l9&Q .. ~5 .• 5 2'1.~ .1.8,.9 18 .. ~ 1ll,4 1~,5 ,12.& 12.2 7&,7 6&,5 85,4 39,9 439,7 ~I _t'!Q5_ . 11!1 L_, __ ~!h5_ .-2~!.9 ___ J_7 !..~ __ i_t~_,b ____ !~.!!.~.--13!.~ .. --il.!..? __ f11.3 6&,5 8~.1 82!2 488.~------------ . .· . ·.1 • 1 9 6 b ,j b " 0 2 q • 5 l 0 • 4 H • 2 1 5 ,l i b • l 1 ~ • 0 I 2 • 7 78 I 9 6 & • 5 8 b,. 5 & 7 • 5 4 7 6 • 5 1 · I _l9b7 ~..2..a_L_..l_t!a~ ~-'1.._4 17,9 1~.2 1~,7 12,1 15.1 81,0 6&,5 8b,5 65,5. 4b0,9 '1 19b8 22,2 2Uob 20,& 19,3 1b,7 17,] 14,0 20,b 61,] 86,5 64,7 i4,3 427,8 !'1, e __ l_'lf!.'! __ J.':!.!~ ·---l~!J.2 ____ !l!~!} __ q!._H ___ !F~.t __ !?J~.---_!~_!;! 1~ .•. ?. __ _79.2 60,0 r.~~ 11.5 lS!..=.•-:.3 _________ _ ·.~) ~ 1970 12o2 1],1 14,6 13,b 12,0 11,9 9,] 9,7 bl,l 73,0 79,4 26,2 338,3 :l ___!.97' .22,.!..!!_ __ 1!!! 7 ___ 1_~!~-·--·17. ~--·~~7. __ !~-!~ ___ !?.1!~--.!~·-·---·~"·? ~h~ 6&,5 6&,2 455,9 .J • 1972 29,7 25,7 22,7 19,5 15,7 15,7 12,1 13,0 dO,£! 6&,') 85,5 45,9 452,0 I 1973 ~l,7 30,5 21,7 1~.5 i~,l . 15.~ 12,R 12,9 75,0 7b,5 77,1 13,3 400,8 :114 1u,3 13,8 ta.s ll.b !2.0 12.1 11.1 12,3 &9,4 b9,2 b1,9 12.1 323,9 ·.·!• e __ !!lJ~S !.1...!..~-· .... JJ.!.H __ !~!_8 __ !.~.~?. __ 1~'!.! __ J.b'!!._J?!~.--.!~.!lL_r9.5 6b!.5 6~,5 b4,0 42~,0 ; 197& 2s,1 t9,J t9,s 1&,9 14.2 14.5 12.1 12.9 7b,S r&.s 11.1 a1.1 370.5 ·, -1~.~7 12,~--ll..t! 14!_6 _ _!~!.b __ !_~!..~--l.l~_9 _ _l!'_.!.~--l~!7 77,1 tib,S 6b,S 7&,1 .~2& •. -:,7 ______ _ •• ! ' 1' • ., ' 1 • 1976 qq,9 29,8 22,1 19,1 1b,t 1&,3 15,9 15~7 77,7 oo,& 8l,b 24,9 ~us,o 1979 22,5 20,9 2U,5 16,2 15,3 15,5 12,9 ~O,b 79,3 6.~.---6~5~,5~--~4~7~,~5~--~4~4~3~,~~----------------------- _,_ .. __ ,..______ -·--·-.... -----· ~VG 2b.O 21,3 'df 11.b 14c8 1~.1 12,7 17,0 78,4 83,5 83,'1 54,6 444.0 --·-------------------------------------------. --------------··-------·-·------·-----·. ----· -----------·--··------------------·--,. '• ------·-----·-·'"··----~-------------... ---------·-····----------·---··----------------------- '· _____ .4 __________ -----------· ----·-------·· -··------------·------ ). tz I ! • t1 ----·-·----...... -.... ·-· -. --· 10 . ---·-----------------·--------. ··--·-· -·-----·------------- 9 . ··-------·-' --.-.--"-------~-·--, _________ , .. _. "··-----.... --· ---____ ... __ "' -~~ -----.... -----., R _______ .......__,..:-.• -·---~ .. -_ t-f~~~-. -----------:-o~--·· "'""'-,-------·---·-.,.~··'--'-4<~'-'""''"''~~ .......................... _ .. ____ ,._ _____ .. ~-~ ·-·----~---.. -....... --.... ·~~--'.:"~~--~-~-·-,_ ••""""'---·--...---·~-~-~--~ -;;~' ~- " ~· . r .· f f l ~.c• t: [' l\", [· [ b ' ~tt·''-·. rrl' · tJ ' ' (! / r~ , __,.,,"'-,, ... .,.,. ..... ",.-,._,.-'"=~-\t;'<'" ..... -~~-""~"''"""'"""..._,."......;:~-,.,_,..,=-,"' ·-~.,.,.,--~--""'---"'""~'"" .,..._..............,,...,.,_,.,....,..._..,.._, ___ ~------,..~----------.-. ...... -,.. ~-.-o~..,._,_-.,.,...,.,--.....__......,......,___,~~--~-.-..-...-''~--1:.:.._ ___ .... ___ ,{ -·-~·-----~, _____ .:._~----------=~-........_..-~-.. --~--'-· fi~Zl J!jQ -~.11 lliii1 ~~ ~ ~ ~ { lii.l.J+tl ' 1 .. ~wa fi:EJ r-'\ I I -~ ~::::-;;:, , , , .• ...., ----~ r::::::-·:::::! ~--;a {"'""'-,.-=~,_ ----"' ~ ~ FJJ ~ .Iii~ ~ --~ ~ ~ ~ -~'-" ---11.2 --~;. :- ~hment 7b.3 ;;i~g~~:Zt .. Of 8 . -------------. ------·----------·-..... liil • 1: POST•PUUJECT FLOWS (CFS) "'l"ab,~ /9 Brtr~Jne · P. 6 _______ .. _., _____ .. _ .. __ .., _______ ·-·,.. ···~----·-·-··~-·-... -.. -·.---.. -------_ .... --·· -·-·--··-------·--·----------------------------- OCT NUV UEC JAN FEH MAH AP~ MAY JUN JUL AUG SEtl 1951 1733.0 16~~.1 1HJ3.o 1H04.7 1723.7 1b5ij.9 lblb.2 3b1H.Q 9Juo.o 93oo.o 93oo.o 947b~4 --1 9s2-ili6CJ; o-'-22i6·~-·· -2 s"1 2·:o·--·~ ii r4:1---~i 76·B: 1-T122:·9 ·-1 ta66 ;2--t4tYo:o-~Jotr~·n1s2·J. 3 941 ". o 62t;t·,;... <~,.:....----· 1953 36~2.2 254~.1 lll~.o 16~&.7 1~8~.7 16~».9 1~b1,2 14UO.O 11l~J.5 11b25,G 10H29.0 7902.9 --~-q~;q-lqJt;;2·-·1a3"; 1-fCJ42.o--iH36~T····i 753·;r ·-t'bo7:" -i4oo~ ti-Tiiti<r:o-·ci3oo:<r-93oo:o-9,.&6.2 69bl.-9------· _ _,1:...:9:...:55 2H.bb.~ 2414.1 11!!1_,_0 174b.7 1717 1 7 lb71.9 ltttJG.,O 1400,0 9300,0 LB77.7 11717,0 81b5.3 195b 22b7,4 t934,1 1'129.0 1610.7 1781.7 1671.9 1400.0 147b,5 1223&.5 12&13.0 12550.0 7934.9 _t '!~1---~~'!1!.!4_ qq~ !.1_.?._0_2~ !9_ .. ,1.9_1H! ,_7 __ 1 ~o~~ ? .. _17~6,.! ~--J ~~q!.~_J07~.!!L! ~~63_ •. ~ ____ 9~'!.3• o 930~~II!!'!.:..•.:.l ______ _ 1956 292tt,2 137.1 286S.o ~093.7 1713.7 1~ao.9 1517.2 1400,0 9648.9 9990,0 10511.0 3747.9 __19~~~bli1 .. ~---J ~-3~ ._t __ J ~JJ.w.O ___ 1 ~3~_,_]-!?~1. I .. ..J.?.'!~~-~ _!_I!OU. o..._1_7~J.!.0_'!3.:!?~5 141438.0 94_9tt. 0 5<378_.!... 9.,;-. ______ _ 19b0 3002.2 2478.1 2063.0 l9H7,7 1b4&,7 17b6.9 15~5.2 4345.4 9300,0 9300.0 9300,0 5316.7 ~b1 2311.2 tl~9o.1 206H.O 2Q~l__l]09,7 164~,9 lb26,2 2659,4 lOlHb,S 115b4.0 13476,0 5664.9 () {;_:, f t: (; ' J ~ /) .:{ 19&2 .2563,2 24tt~,l 20Hl,o !887.7 t73o,7 tb4~.9 1479.2 178b,Q 17126,5 tJqut.o 10265,0 88b5~o __ 1 ~~..J.-~Q}~ .. JJ. --~~!?~_._1_1_ ?.~.~_._o _l Z.'!].,_]_l7b.H_. L_.J]! !!, 'L_J i! 7~ ~t~L. ;!21 .s !.Ll.0'!9_9 .• S_!_? 8tj2 .. .Q. __ lbt!]U. o 7 ~.?-~. 9;--__ _ f. • -.. • • • • • • • • • l9bll 33b4.2 24llbel 1H52,0 1H48.7 lbbb,1 1569.9 ~q~9.2 !QOO.O 9505.4 13131.0 9300,0 3954.3 __ l.'l ~L.J~~Y.JI ~-_,.~ q! .tts._l _? 9 ?J_, (! __ 1 ? .15.~.1.. __ .1!!. '! t,] _ _!_~~ !!.! ~ __ ! ~ 7 ~.~ ~!-!.~ u .JL!.!~ 3 9. q ttl 1 u 2 • .!!___ 9 3 o o_~_l;-;b~S~·:..;3;----------------- 196b 3597.2 2414.1 2002.0 1746,7 1766.7 l74H.9 1504,2 1400.0 11535,8 9714.0 10129.0 6603.9 1'167 2797 1 2 162~,1 1909,0 1Hlb 1 7 175~.7 1b'i~ lliOO,O 1ll00r0 12763.8 19635.0 16755.,0 6iU4.'1 1968 20'1U.2 2030.l ~023.0 1951.7 1926.7 1815,9 lb22,2 217H.ll 15'199.5 13197.0 9300.0 2425.b __ l9~9_J_f:f. Q.9__. ~ __ 111 ~ Q ... O_J.~ ~h. ll_l ~9 .0 • 0 1 4 9. Q~_g _ _l ~ ~ Q. ~ !! -·-!~ 0 (} !'J!_!;t .~ Q.! Q.._3~ ~ 0 • 0 9] U.~.Q..~ 0 0 • !! __ l9~J!.!.;:..O --· t970 140o.o ~576.4 1799.7 1725,8 1768.,1 173&.3 1550.5 ll~Oo.o ~Joo.o 93oo.o 93oo.o 26b9,9 __ t 'Hl ~ 1 bl .L_J ~tt!!l_LL-1.8 09-!L!!.__!] ~ 7 !.1 _ _!~! 9-' l_U ~'!! '!.._1_'!. ~~!.?. __ 1 ~ o o .L!_?~ q 6. a 13 7 .s_q. o 13325. o 64 71.•=-:'~:-------------------- 1972 2809.2 2533.1 2233.0 1974,7 1Hl8,7 1699,9 1400.0 lliOU.O 10008.8 11464.0 ~300,0 4~40,1 1973 2996,2 301~.1 212b 1 0 1874,1 17bH,7 1bHt1,9 1~64,2 1400.0 ~jOO.O 9300.0 9300.0 lQ0~0~·~0~---------------------------------- 1974 !ttUO.O 1400,0 lqH0.7 1400.0 lQ11.3 lijOU,O lliUO.O 14UO.O 9300.0 9300.0 qJUO,O 14~0.0 __ t9li_!~!!:' ... L J_q_g P .~. t!~ __ t4a o !..~_1 ~n~. :;_p ~~.! 1 ___ u ~l!! ~ __ • ~ ~.s !.L_!!! o o. o_9 ~(?..9. 4 12 ~Q! o '"i.J o o. "-~~~t. e ________________ _ 197& 2375.2 1902,1 t913.o 1713.7 1bqo.7 1Sb~.9 tt&oo,o 140o.o '13oo.o 93oo.o qJoo.o 1tt~o.o 1977 14oo.o 14bt.7 tb.S7.3 1541.7 1~5b.& 14JH.l 14oo.o 14oo.o ~Joo.o a~eo7,b tot~u5.o 7445.9 -l'i78-42si: 2-29 q 3 :12i90: o-f9J·9-;7-1 H r;s: 7·--n b 1:9·--iti 45. 2-----rt;61:49 3 o o. o 9 3 o-o. o .·-;;9;-,;3;.:;o:7.o:-=.-;;o~-:;2~s,.;2:7t-= • .;5------------------- 1979 212'1,2 2065,1 2012.0 18Q7.7 l1b6,1 lb84.9 1498,2 2176,4 9300,. 112Jl.4 9300,! 4705.6 I -A"VG--2ti79."6-2li9.o-tt9si:o -,-797~.s--t73(i".2 .. -·~·;,-s9 ,6 --iQ93-;&-tu1<~: 7-1o731.b 11871.3 10465,9 5471 ~ 1 -------------------------------------------------------·---------- ------··--------···-----· --------------------··----·--------------------------------------- --------------------·-·---·------·----------·-... ··--······-·· -------·-----____________ ...._ __________ _ ---~---·--_.._ .... -----·· "" .... ----·----.. -.... --·-..--........ .-,_,. -.... ~. -----•* ~-· ... _____ * ----·• __ ,. _______ ,. t2 c:-" 10 ···-------· • -·-- . ~~ t I I l l /,! ('' f l"• [·_ -· -'·' r r f, t r. ·: •, t\ Ll· •• ~ 9 .. , --- ;';:. ~-·--··----......... ,----~ ------,~ . .,.-----· rr:. J l "-> tJt:; ~ ~ •rn Jf1a I[); '!Iii''~ ~ l ~.~..,..- Et~ r::· . .;; it;:; I«~~ Lf'ij lr" ..... ;-."'?3 :;::-~~-:=--: ~ ~~ b:Ji ~ ~;::~:::.~ ~ f="''i.!'JY:.,.~ ~ l:. .. ::i:i . -·--' .. __ ---------........ --.. ~--· _., __ ..... _ ... _____ ·----------....... --~~ ..... -~-----~--- 4 3 . -~----_..,_..,_,. ---• . • ·--------- ocr NOV Df..C .JM~ FEFI MAH AVERAGE CAPABJLI!!~::..:S:........;(;.;.M::.:..:I'4:..:..) _____________ _ ~ BROWNE 113. Ill. 107. 102. •H. 92. tOTAL ! 13. --ru. 107. 102. •n. ~2. • • MINIMUM CAPABILITiES (MW) UCT NOV DEC JAN FElli MAR • BROWNE 8b. 8'1. 79e 7'1 • &~1. bl. lOTAL 8b. 84. 79. 74. blll. b1. • AVERAGE ENERGY PROOUCTIUN (GWH) 8 __________ QCT ~!!Y __ ~f HROWNE 26.0 21.3 19.7 JAN FE~ MAH 17. & fii-:6-l!S: 1 • TOTAL 2&·:-o 21.-l 19.7 17 .. 6 1'4o8--IS.1 MINIMUM ENERGY PHOOUCTION (GWH) APR 87. 87. A~R SC!. 52. APH 12.7 12o7 MAY 93. 93. MAY b2. b2. HAY n:o 17 .o -----------------~A~t~t~a~c~h~m~ent ~ Page 8 of 8 JUN lOS., 1 os,, JUN lb. ir & • Jl!.IN 7if;q 7Bo4 7i;.6/e 13 e r-e>~W ., '*' JUL AUG SEP ilu. 109. 110, 110. 109. llO. JUL AUG SEP 83. 80. 83. - 83. 80. 83. JUL AUG SEP ANN ~s ol.q sq.& qqq.o 83.5 Bl.il 54.& qqq-;o --·ocT Nliv--ofc JAN FEH-·-;;t'AR--APH-HAY-· -JUN JU~ --AUG--------sEP ___ ANN • 8ROW~E ( 197tl) 1~} __ i3.·8 14.8 B.b 12.0 12.7 u. 7 12.3 b9.4 69.2 &7.9 12.1 l23.c; • TOTAL (19.74) 114.3 13.6 14.,H 13.,6 12.1) 12.7 ll.7 12.3 &9.4 69.2 67 .. 9 12.1 32lo9 • • • ------------------·------. ------------------· ·--------·---------------·---~ -·--- P. 7 • ·-----·· -----·-· ·---------··--·-·---·------------··------------------·--- • ·-----------··------·-·· -----·----------·-·-------------------------------------------------------------------------- • i l ,, l' j 1Z ----··------, eu l --·. -·· ---· -. -. • l!Jo -· -........ ·-______ ,.,_ -·--------------------- I I !I u. ~---· -=-~ -------~-~-'"-----~--~·---~~-="'\t'"·'··· .-,-\ ... · .. s~-. I' I K b I 1 r " ~· l r i~ la3l ("' __ .............. ~=-~,...,.,..,.,. ... -.~--~-"'....,...,.,._,...,.....,..,_..,... ___ . __ . ~-----... _L ' ;j ,, . ' ,, -~...._ ....... ____ ..._ ... .-.-.-.. ---~·------------------------------.· --... -------~-----· ...._...,_.,.._ ______ _.. ____ .,_,.._. __ ,__,_ ·1 SLa JC;; ;r~»;~ ~ lfW,;; E .. !iii ~Mi. ~ ~ ~ ~ . "- r;-:.---=~ ~ r;;;::'"-:::::: ~ ~.....ii r.·= ~ f""'T ':::+t"'\>"'1' ~ ii:~::Ji F'•~·--v.""'' ~ fl«:'!~~~-$- f~. Gr:i ~ ........... , •• t'•t •.'111. t -t ... t ' ,. ,. ' • .. •· ... • ,I "-lftl .. -• •I t• ••"• .. J•••'" ..:t• ~I I I i *'• At·tacbrnent 7b. 4 Page 1 of 8 • 1 • • '' t • r "' ... .... • ·-. -------·~----------· -------·----- l -~ flj j i • j J • ·i l .~ . ~ 1 t: .. • .. ·1 '=F ~ \ ~· .e • • . ; . 1• ~ t • •• i . • • 4) CHAKACHAMNA(ALT. O) --RESP-c:itis_E_to·o·E 1 s ---·----··-w/'Ruu-cut~·vE .N~i? ~~AN_ 20 1~.! bq44 GWH ~ 6/e lcf ufr.Kqr/r~~,,,?lli P. I HATEO CAPACITY 100 MW ~~~~.!.J?AT !._FOH CHAI\A_CH!~NA ___ ------------------------=N~ATURAL STHEAMF~mlAT_D~A~H~S~I~T~E------------------------------------------------------------------------· YEAR OCT NOV OEC JA~ FEB HAH APH M~Y JUN JUL •ec SEP __ 1!St3659, ·7~.-~~~~-·-~5h_~6~~~~~?s.as~~u~~~~-4491~·~-------------------------- t9st 1731. 539. sua. 4bs. 442. ~2u. bOt. 377t.lo&a9.1l0&5. 88ot. a&o5. _!,~_?_J_j_8~!1-!!_l_L._6b'!.L-.~00~!~L-..!!h_4_!t0L.J.~~J-L.~-!?~.!..1_2_?.~5. 9401, 3532,.::c, __ _._ ________________________ . . 1953 Zb82. 835. 612. 993. 447. 447. bll. 3962.13217.13325.10778, 4475. 1954 1972. 599, ·s2o, 997, 94z, 928, stt. 3404, 8972,t~o&J,t2ot6. &uq5, 1955 2757, 72~. 589. S48. 477. 93b. 457. 21&3, &79&.129&6. 9953. 5018. ~9~~~~22~ll!~4!~!9• a~~~~~J~~?~;~~1.1Wh~Y~l~0~·~---------------------------- 1957 2023, 553. 535. 539. SOb, 97~. 568. 4.56J.lU767,ll119.1°17S. bUBO. -1~5_1Ll.6 71.._ 1 bl. Sl? a !?..~.J .t. _q_e o, 459 ~-~~~~~'!O o .._!_p 1l!L_ 1!6~~4 22:-x-----------------------_:_ _____ _ 195~ l66b• 496. 453. 396, 438. 419e 496. 3090, q429.10J56ell76!, .5632, 1960 JJgo. &24, 978, 370, l71, l37, 363, 3607, b807wll119, 9l0~7~l~lHI~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 1961 )409. 769, 840a 8qJ. 559. 440, 3lb, l85le 79~3.12778ol08b9e 6195. _L~.~~ 1556. 81 .s, b.&&_._~~!L_44 l_, __ q_~.h_1235...t.J.f!~.2.t.JA!.l ~ .1 g_~J) 1. 5512. ··------------------ • 1963 11b7~ 8ll. Sal. 4&8. 327. 285. 307. 1771. 47u5.tJ2t9.12178Q 5817. ~64 205&. 900 I ·fJJLO_.__}l'f' 405. 302 t 441.___t!t~O ~!!bJ.9~ 7 u .ll7 &8. 4_?~1;-:6~---------------------------- 1965 12l5, 879, 632. lH9e !89. 107, 3&8, 1256. JQb0.1l&Ol.ll899.IU772 • , 196b 2089. 5b7, q36. 356, lOb, J2Q, 380. l~b], HU42,J027l, 9~qq, bS78, 1967 1921. 880, 2u1. ~o1. 419, 3~4. H5o. 2ooo. 67lt.l490J.15b&5. bl&l • 19&8 ao 1 o. 1 L~.s. S!t~J!~~~g. q 31 _,._M!l..._j!~6b..._l7_7~.a.l:!9f!l~.?.l.L.jt7~-=&:.::l~----------------- 19~9 94b, b59, 582. 455, 45b. 470. 622. 1918. ~241.12448. 72b7. 27&3. , 1970 lllZJ, l182.___5.1J_.__lUi[. 'f74. 520. Hb9~l5. b75~..a.ill_l!l._l9SLJ.7::-~04~--------------------------- 1971 1329. 712. 930, 364. 4ll. 483, 1245. 40Jl.12b42.1l&65,lba50. 5045 • lfl'Z2_315L.__l0b0. 7Ub. 5~1. 501~62~9L___.l9l6._8198.13'4&0,._ 92J3, ,.f.l82 • 197l 23b&, b49. 464. 4b5. 462. 450. ~5&. 2101. 7427. 8820. 7779. 2764 • _llJJL2...'lcrr.._.:z.u..~l-. . ...S.Zit...___JL96. !H.t-_.5.ZLJ-Jll!12._{»~ll......~7.5J. 61~9~~-------------------------- lf.l75 3029. 679. ~00. 4&8. 455. 455. 45f.l, 4754,10blf.I,IOB59, 6772. 5077. ~7& lto&, zag, s~2. stq. g9q. 4b6. 595. s2s1. ft~~zzq. agQq. 49.~~-----------------~-~~-----~ 8977 3667. 1028. 1025. 1014, 743. 57&. 576. 5lOS,i9834.13868,111f.lq. 6U29. -1918 \&7'1. 39i!. &JO. 519. 5j}.L.._j!I9. S2.tl ... __5l5l-H 788l_..lOU.&._7835. 4'l6l. 1979 3228. 678. b71. 567. 532. S17. 683. b746. aqaq. aq~8. 9ll7. 4S42. •-------------------------------------------· ... Ill ! . ..: ,...,.._ ..... --.--.."<-"",..'"'"···'---...:,._.,.._~r""'""'""""'-"~""'"":t •" .,.....,. •••• ~·-:"' ,,._ I \\ r, r . L r j ·,1 I . l ! l t I' f [, ! ' J. k l' ,1., I. ~ ~ ~ ... ~--""~ ~-.,,.-..-....,---.~~-----~-"'"' .............. __ ~,..,-~.-~-1--. ·---~-~----~.------~~-----------------~------~-·-~-~ -· ·----~-~---....---~--·~·-~·--~-..;... . ......, __ ,_,...,~_,.....,_~~-·----·-..~--'''~·~-·----.:.~----... ~-.,..._..._,.,_., __ ~-~ ;:;;:;J !11'"""':-. [:11 ~ ~L.:ii fk:-~ fi~ ~:-,:-;i f"' -3 fi.., ~ Attachment 7b.q Page 2 or B ~~ G.:;l ~ t~;;:J bd ~~ ~ ~ ~ NET RESERVOIR EVAPOHATIOHr INCHES • OCT tmV DEC .Ilk FeR MAH APH MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP ----------------------- 0.0 o.o o.o o.o o.o o.o o.o o.o o.o o.o o.o o.o ~· ******~** RESERVOIR OAlA ***Q***** **** IAILWATER DATA **** •• --~E•~~E~VAJ~N VOLUME 1'HEA DISCHARGE ELE~uA~Tul~O~N~------------------------------------------------------------- (FT,HSl) (~CRE•FEETJ (ACRES) (CFS) {FJ,~SL) . ' lit 7b0e0 U. O. O. 419.0 i •" i 10 l•: I 1 -----L7.~5.0 2~25. #10, ~OOOOL--4~9~~~------------------------------------------------------------- 780,0 21200. 2690~ o. o.o ----~~zu.o zqJ_~--_]~~Y g ~o~o~--------------------------------------------------------------860.0 572000, 9280, o. o.o · "880.o 7o9ouu. i04oo. u. o.o J • 900,0 986000. lt590. o. o.o es ----~9~2~0 l224QOO, JLQb9 0 0 0 . 4 I , I. 940.0 lijb7000. 12320. o. 0.0 9b0.0 llll~O. 12~52· O, 0.0 960.0 l973000d 12960. o. o.o aooo.o 223ooor. 1l280w o. oGo 1020.0 2504000. 11520. o. o.o l <> ; • 1040.0 277bQ90. 1374U. O. 0.0 1060.0 josiJ·i:Yo. r39b0, o. 0.0 ·~-:- i l · ~r t --·• 10eo.o 3l3Sooo. 14170. o. o.o To.-/,fe II ek.ts~~"''""' R~ ttoo.o lb2oooo, l439o. o. o.o 1120.0 3910000. l4b20. o. o.o 112s.o 40l32o6. i52t2. o. o.o • 1140.0 4218000, 16100, ----~-.. .!J. ________ __!"0~-~ ---------------~-------------- THE RATEO HEAD IS bo3.0 FT. • THE RATEO CAPACITY Is--f~S~.O~H~~~.------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- THE HEAOLOSS IS 0,000 liMES THE HEAD • THE GENERATOR EFFICIENCY IS 0.980 ~mr-TRANsFoRHER £rr·x~c~t"E~N~cvv~t~s~o~.~qq~ar-------------------------------------------------------------- • __,_********~********* POWERPlA~r-57ATfTA-,-,a~onNnl~t~s~•~••••••.,*.,*~~~~~*~a~*~*~*~*~*•*•*~**~----------------------------------------------------------------- • NEl HEAO PlANiC 'CAPAC1T1" EffiCIENCY ----riRATED) (FEET) (HWT (X RA T~NE Pillrn1"-----------------------------------------~ • o. 7so LJ97 .2 aa""l;a-o .628 o.&eo o.es o.aoo 5Jo.q 2Dl.2 Oob98 o.H&ij o.eo2 o.eso 563.5 223;8 D."1&9 o.s9ll o.e~ • o.9oo 59&.7 245.7 o.eqq o.9oo o.B73 --...,.o~.9=so &29.a .. 2~8"1 o.9at of<J9os o-;tf·'Yir-----------------------·-------·------------- 1.ooo &o3.o 29Q.t t.ooo o.~to o.H83 ---r-'1.'-:oJo ~8"'2.9 JoT;·i, I;ottJ G.9oa cr;asl1--------------------------------------------- 1.o&o 10~.8 Jl&,t t.oe& o.90b o.e79 e . i 0 1 0 0 72 ff'. 3 33'3 • ) I • 1 q ; 0 • 9 0) CJ .. 87 , I • 1.1~0 7b2.4 354,3 1.219 0.900 0.873 -----~---~-------~~--------------------------------------------------- 0 -RE~fE:flviH R-o"PE:ifATToNco-N~fH' iNTs - HAi)HO~ RESERVOl~ ELEVATION • OC!_~~--~~-~~-i~_u_~L-~~--~Y __ ~u~_l~--A~G SE~------------~-----------~ Li.-~~~·=:~1; ~~~ ~ ~ ~~-II :8 ~-~-~-~U:H~-8,~1: 2:~1 ~ 28. ~-~2-8. I~~~::~. ~~~-~~-~~~-----· ~.1 t ~ I . r '~, L ~ ' ll ! \ !,, i ,, . 1 I ! l I f I l ~~ i t I U_, r -:::::::·· ·- l t f r f ,J - ,,~,·~----=--'""""""""-''-"'~ ,..,__,_~-.o"'""·--__,..,_,_ ""~·-•-.~.,._,_._,_..._,__._,_~,...,.~,....,_-~--A,.._,... . .,._., __ .-...fL_,.._,_,__. __ • _ __,"'-~ ~:..:.,__,~:.::.: ...... ~~--~ . .,.-:_....2:~. -----.__,.._ ~ ~ 1r:a L_il W" ... ., ~' ~ L::AJ rr:--~ ~. f;il:J 6j . ...,.__.... ~ . -(c:;. ~:::_ ~ iia_j ~~ [:_;:;i,l ~ ~ .......... ,, ~-. . ------:·-~--~--~-----.. ~~-----=--.. -:=~---~_ .. ----·~=~-:---~r-.:· -_ ... _ l • iii • • • • • • • • • ! ~-' Attachment 7b.4 __ · Page 3 of 8· RULE CURVE ELEVATION ___ Q~l__fiQ.Y_OE.t__J_~!!__f:~.a HAH APP. ~AY __ l!lli_!l_~.b....._!_tl.G S~.:_P ___________________________ _ 11~8. 11~3. 1111. 1111. llOS. 1100. 1U9b. l09q. 10911. 1108. 1108. 1125. HINIM~H RESER~OIR ELEVATION 3 OCT NOV DEC JAN FEH MAR A,R HAY JUN JUL AUG SEP -----=-aoi4:10Tii-;-ioi4:-iotij:-iof4.TOr•f;1rfi4~-r~rq;aor4-;s·oi4. 10111. ao:..::t~tt:-.------------------------- ---------·~----------------------------~----------------------------------- RESERVOIR RELEASE t~NSTRAJNTS OCT NOV PEC J~~ FEB MAR APR HAY -=J~UN~~J~U~L~-A~U~G~~S~E~P----~----------------------------- HI~IHUH CONSUMPTXVE RELE~SE 9· o. o. 0~ o, o, o, o. 0, 011. o. o, _ MINIMUM NON•PO~~J!:~illSE OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR HAY JUN JUt AUG SEP ____ __:0::...~•~.--.-~0~--~~· O, 0, 0, 0, O, 0=:..•---=0~•:.._.__..::.0..s..t __ O:::..:•t!!------------------------------ DOWNSTREAM RELEAS~ 'CRITERIA ....-........... ~~ PRE•PHojE[T.FLO~-S-AT~-ttE(u;;: POHfRH __lEAH_ . .QtT NJlY _Qf:_t: ___ .}~N __ Ff.f,J ____ f1A~_-Ae~_f!li_~H!~ JUL A~f! __ SEP ff.~ft. /8 d~A~J,...,-H4 P.-3 t9SO 2877, ass. b8!. 58o~ 522. ~28, 579. 2199, 9172,14tte.tt2Hb, 4837. 1951 1664. 609, 5~9, 5).0, 505. ij8Z. 675, 90b7,ll4hq,I~Ul~. 9449, 9239, 1952 31141, 901, 748, 6711. S3o, 5oo. 54b. 2169, o778,1l455,100~l. 3Htl, ____l~5.~Pb..__J~~~]_, __ :;~Q . .__~!._L_~.lJ!.~~!.~t-'!ii1..!Ll~ l7.l! t-1~?.9.9 tl_!Sb~ • ij82~. . 1954 2142, 67J~ 588 0 Sbq, SUS. 490, 579, 1674. qb32,l2957.128~9. 6SOO~ _ _,1...,9'-""55 2962 1 uy& t bb~~ t6~4 2 t 499 t 52~J47_:t_]_~94 1 l39~_!t ll!Lf?,;:rJ.;;-2..::..e_5::-q:;-;2~l~e.___, _________________________ _ 1956 2127, 637. 569, 519. 506, 460. 531, 31~2. 7998,l5b23,A0951, 63Sb • · 1957 2197, b24. 605. b09, 574, 5110, 6110, 4701,15654,J4069,JllJJt 719~, 1958 289b~ 6Q9, 601, b09e 5Qb, 523, 722. 2b71,10b25.10874e 9299e ]694. 1959 2029 ,, 5!J~..t.-.?.!1~~b~9.~~g. 56h_!:!_38.L1 u ll'~~.u __ ~l-;;15;;----.1::;..;2~,5;-;s~2~.~J-:;'>'717a-=-·---..------------------------- 19&o 11166, ?oo. 5q4, 428, 328, 28b. 421. 3892, 7316.,)1994. 9Q9\. 336S, _l96 LJ~'i 0. 8~5. 9 31 ' 93_~. 630 I 5 OJ' 37 0. ;!0 13. 8542. 1.;H:-;;:-:0:...;5;-=·~1-7-17b::--b2=-·:::-.;6:-::b:-:;;6~1-=-·--------------------------- 1962 lb97, 902. 745, b11, 57'1, 504, 503. 135,q, 8460,1•10b9.ll1LHl, S'IJO, 19b3 12~1. 923. ~~~~ 533. lb2. 337, 3bl, 1927. 5066,J4i76,ll0b3, 6256, 1964 2232, 995. 7b0, 389. 465, 355, 510, 1956, Hb~O,l14~9.12b24. qS4J, _l9bU332. 9_7 3. 70!.__~!!.8. 2~4. 361, 42b...__ll.l~_.___!73_W.?qiH! 121~4 I 11558 ·------------------------------- 196b 22&2. bJ9, 1199. q1~. 36o. 375, 1139, 202b. 8b37.t1024~10672, 707i, 196 7 2090.....___j7 '!..__ 3l5' 568...L-!!6 0" 411 1 I 942 I 211j. 9 37hl2_97!J! 161.~:-;'~~~--:;-b;:-b=-24::-z----------------------------- 1~68 2183, 1300, b1t. 511, 546, 500, b74, l2Ub, 8lS5,140J5~1204~. 2989, !969 10114. 737~_b55, 51'1~~.._52Q,_535. ~9fb_2084, 9920.13351,_780t1 .. _~989.___ ------· -~-----~ 197~ .3271, 1300. 643. 532. 539. S88, 9b2, 24lll. 7264,11065. d5q5, 2925, ~~~q54, 7~4. 49?. 4~~~2. 54~3611, 4J47,J3ssq,tq&sll,tl~qa~,~s~4~3~o~,-----~-----~·------~-------- 197~ )~04. 1166, 788, 622. 5b8, 52b, 51l. ]711. 660~.14434. 9qtt, 5363. ___.1973 25b!:L.._l~.~~j_J_O_'l-22b, 5l'h_627, 2260. 7979, 94b9, ~~Sb-=•--::2:..:9:..:9-::-0-=-o--------------- 1974 ~7oq. 792, &&7. 597. 5&3. 536, 593, 4510, 6685, 7256, &590. 7329. 1975 3?73, 973, Sb7. 533, 519. ~19, 523, suq,\l39q,llb~1. 121u, 54bta. ,._ ---..----·----------- 1976 3356, 871, h6b, 582~ 5&1, 533, b&9. 5b53. Ql8H. 8865. b9q9, 5293, - _1_97?---.9 t~.!J! ~~.:L..!!~~..L.-!.l !?.~~~!~-~~.!!. &q 6' !> 7 .!t 8. 2125.11. 1_~_811 • ! 2 ~-U!.~'!.~ • ..;l....:•----------------.,---------------- 1978 3969, ~67, 749. bS2e 575, 545, 597, 5764. 8471.10H56, sqt6, 4829, 1979 3116b. 1~~ 750, &39, bO!~~ss~9_7~6~l~,~7~2~s~·o~·~9~l~l~o~·~q~s~a~s~·~9~7~9~o~·-4~8~9~2~,L--------------------------------------- ·--~~---·----, ~-----~~--~--~---~----·~--·--r ---.. ·-·~--·~~-·~---~_, .......... ~ .... ,., ... ~.~----·.>.-·~··---.._... .... "'~· _.,<-.-,._,.,.. .. ,_ •.• ,. .... ~. toO' '' l l l I L ~- \1 I - "' ~ • •. tl --I . ' . ' ,:, . .... I . ._ • ~ ' • ~ • " ' .;< .. -, • ""' -' "' ·a u Q-r (~ .;..._,....~ --------..·---~........,,~----' . ..-----~--.,.-,~ -----~ .. ....-~-... -li-~-·-__, _ __:::· ~.._.. .......... -r----~~-·-~·.,-~~--·--,.....·---·----.. .. ·-~---------~"'-~--"'"'"'"·----.. --··-~-~-----... --~# .... -~-"'"-~~ ,-.~~~~~~--~~ .. -~.~---~~---rt-~~~-~~---·-------------·--~ 1 t ! . l ...... -~ ltil c;;; il$:1 ~ ~ j:j ')J liw;J t'~ ~1 ~ ~-.. ::d ~a r: ·. !:J ~ la;..,..ij ~--~ ~ . k~ ~ • .-s:-;; · At:r:ctchmeu L 7b. '* Pa':ft:: 4 u.1.. 6 ~ ., • • . . . . a... J.,. ~/ NvA-,-~ r 4- • . MHU~UM POSJ•PfiljJE,CT fLOW3 A'!. HELQW · .. O~EH~·.. • .. .. I ' • • ... . • ......... "' • • • • • .. OCT NOV PEC JAN FEB MAR AJ'R HAY JUN JUL AUG 8EP ___ _..l...._llf.)OOLI•L...A..Illl• IJOOc lil_O_.__JJ.!JQ, lU,lO. 1100. UQO, 9'100, 9900. !:1900. UUOa .. '., NSD fOHECASI, YEAR lOlQ_ANNUAI. Ettf.RGJ.OEMANI> a fllf411, &~-------~--------------------- ~ ENERGY GENERATION CRITERlA l • ..S YnnLffiERGJ _llEMMfru._&tfH OCT NOV UfC JAN FEB MAR APR MA~Y--~J~U~N---J~U~l---A~U~G~-S~E~P~------------------------------------------------- ( ~ 561. 640. 111. 659. ~~~-575. §91. 459. •2z. 1lO. 49b. 9b5. ' • I ' ! . MONTHLY GENERA II ON f'AOM OIHER SOUHCflh -Ei':u-..-----------------j OCT NOV DEC JA~ FEB . MAP APR HAY JU~ JUL AUG SEP • .J.U.5 10]'.0 .106.7 IUO.l 1.~! \Hp.3 11.6 90a9 clla.!L .. il.c..Sif:LJ,ult-a~.lLS9.!-Ieu3~i~IS.a.ILJ.3~:.-___ ~. ------ t ___________ _.ADJ!lllED SYS.l.EJLf~EM.A.HDr '"" ,__ OCT NOV DEC JAN F~B MAU APR HAY JU~ JUL AUG 8EP '• .• • 111 •• Sll. oat, S~9, 495, 419. 4tt, leal, 109, 1Ct6. 187. ~og. '~ .. ... D.HT.HLI lifPJE.BAli.o.Nr PERCENT Of ANNUA-~-:-:---:::-:--~~--------------------------- M OCT HOY DEC JAN FEB MAR APH MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP • o .• gCfJ o,u:s o,&J9 o.ua o,lti_t.&Ol g.Gea o.o1e o.o4o o.oJ!i o.ol9 o.oEao · , •• 7 .--------------~,-A-R-GE~T~F~I~M-M_A_N~N-U_A_l~EN-E~R-O~Y--.------.-0~1-.----------------------------~~----------------------------------------•. -- • iAR&ET MONTHLY FIRM ENERGY, &NH ~------------------------·--------------~-----~----~--------------=-----------------------------------·------------------• · OtT NOV DEC' JAH fEB HAM APR MAY JUN JUL AUG 5EP 56.~ 68.4 11.4 1l.l ~l •• &l.l 51.5 41.Z 24.l Zl.l ~4.0 lb.S . t -~~~~--~----------------============ i ~· ~ ~ ,. ~ • I IZ ~-~~----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------10 \ ·-----------------------·--------------~----·--------------------------•. ~ : 1 .-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------~---~-·----------------_., ____________ __ 4 * • . ..... I .. .. ~ \ r ~ /) ~· \ ~ I I l t I I. J. U--~-~. ----·~-----~---,-------~ .. . ~~' '" ...... ~--e ~. ·-'' - • ' ~' 1 \. 1 --· ·--~~·--·~~~_,.,....,..,.,.._, .. ~-..... --~,.,.,.._-Q.""""",_....._...... ~,........_..._..;.,.....,... • ...,.~-"'.....,~---~~"',.,..._....}....,,.. ... _'~-_--..,.._..,...,.......,_,,._,.,._,.......,.,~··---~~--~~--------·~ -·--·~-__ .. __ ....... __ -L..,._.. ___ ~,--... -·---.............. .-o'-<----~~--~--~~..;; ______ ...__.,:_---..... ·-4.-. ~ -~··--'-··~-~--~_,__;,.:._,_....,~-~- ~ ~ • Ji· 3 •• ~~ rz.-ft .... . ----------·-·-____ , ___ _ Gi.~-~ ~ f~ ~'-~ ~.:i. I& ~="i -··· -·----···---- ----.... -.. . -·---M--~· .. ----··-· r~--::;;; ~ ~ ~·ji ~. ' . i-· -. ~ Attachment 7b.4 Page 5 of s---- k:: ·;a /1"1""-"•f'·-~ ~-, ~~ ', - fURBINE O!SCHAM&E (C~S) .. -··-·------,._. . --~ ,.__ ... ---·---·--··--·-·--·-----~. -·---------~-··---/(:bte 13 clu.kac~"'"'~'t~_!i!t_ • • • • ------(~)~T ;.,~L. _oE._C __ _!!AN FtU MAH APH MAY JUN JIJL AIJI;; SEP 1950 2b~9.0 l9HB.l 21Hh.7 1950.1 lh93.b 1712.1 l~Ob~H l2ij9.q 5122.q qq]q.q 49~2.9 32~7.6 -fq5 i~-1482 ~&-i HbtJ:} -20 7 9; 1· .. l 9 2 6:9 ··-faCia .·b--17 iHi .. 6 -.1515 ;2--21 'i9·;s·--"5"2/6-;'li~Ts-;q---q-gl b. 5.-59 s·~o-. r-6--------------l....--- 1952 ll6b.O ~02H.t 2~49.7 2UJ6.1 l~vO.b lb~~~b 1507.1 12~9.9 53l2.b q496.0 ~002,6 1002.0 --f95J---tiiu7 ~·3 ---16bo ~ o ·2o1 b. 4---1917. s --.-ts9~; o --i7oti. t,-· 15tt ~ 1 ·-2763·,. s ·-·s2l&;r--~Illi·7-;1)q1f7 s~~3 Slso.5 1954 14Hl.7 IH57.b 2075.5 lq17.1 lb¥4.5 17Uq~] 1511.5 212~.3 5J09.5 4475.2 f~Q6.b 582l.b --::.1~955 taao-.,"'b19JH.1 21b9;-7-fcfiib.t t917:'6tt>~'i.b !~o:--.2 1289.3 5354.6 4531J.3 5o18.4 llb&.7 1956 1481.7 1857.9 207b.l 1918 0 0 1bq5,.5 llO~.q 151l.H 1464.3 53qo.1 4461.8 49q4.0 4827.~ -·i957-tt.iaf~~-itJ57:52.o75a3-··t'h"'·v·-6·-f~·~~.f;s-f7if2;4"-··t5o9·.3--J1IT;e---s212-~2~J4a.:r::ra'11r.":s-59.&o.&--------· 1958 2b77.0 197q.l 2112.7 )977.1 19i5~b 17U6.1 16~2.7 !b55.1 5291.2 447b.U '50J2.2 1010.5 i' 'II,.. [ ,,. ---1959--fs o 3:b1a ab:a2i f li .~c-i 95 2". 8-f9J~.f~7-:-Ti"4 3-:t,-y5·4 1 :2-f3 r'>·~s·ii o 6;s-·4s;q;:,j-~-5:o 1s. 9 1 o os:-2 l9b0 1501.5 !Hdb.4 210~.0 1951.2 l~J4.3 l74S.J 1~50.6 1320.3 5454.6 4b4b.1 ~lUbeb 1038.6 1961 1547.3 194s.t i1f6.2 2oft.b t99o.,3 119-q.1 ~~9~.• l36b.9 ~bb1.il 47&9.5-~2s4.6 tol4 .. 5 19b2 152q.7 )qlJ.b 2140.6 1981.1 l~bl.S 1767.7 l~b9.4 134~.0 5596.8 4710e3 519Jt~9 1027.2 -l"9b3-i52 o: s-1 9Tu ;~ · ·-2 i j 1; o-··1 <n 9 :t-f96 f:7-fifo ~~~ o -··s7.l~2--T349:~~6&2. 8 482·1.1. 2·--s215. 6 1 oJq. ~· · t9&q 1524.1 1909.b 2tJq.s 197b.9 tq6u~o 17b7.9 1570.3 1145.9 5572.1 473J~l ~241.~ tol5"4 -19·&s-i537:3-193.J,;o-2-ibJ:-r-2oiY4-.-i i-qaa:7-fY9s-.:a-T~9i;:2--.x:rr.;;-sHot. 1 socf.5~.:...,:~~-~s~s-=o~H..;:.Iol..,;.:J-..::..J.~ob~o::...;;..,.s,.;..·-------------I. ~&b 1533,2 192J.7 2156~5~~99.~ 198J.~ 17qo.t ~~~~~~ 1JbJ.7 5b45eb q~~U~j~·~'~~5~3~b~~~~~4~~~~0~5~H~.4~~-~~~~~---------~ 19b7 155~.0 1949.2 2A64mb 2026.5 2009.1 !8!2.9 lbOb.5 1375.9 5677.5 4727u2 ~070.7 l755o0 1 • • • • • 1968 14Hl.S 204l.b 212i.7 1942.1 ~~~~~6 1b9q~& 154)~8 215~.1 5Jl3.4 44~~.9 qq&3.9 l52J.l ~ 969 1 iiss; a-I6bf;r 2 o eb ;a--·1927~· 9-r9·os: &-n I& .. -2--i'szT: s--i 3 o2. 1 5J.&J. o 4 so~.~. 9 ~o 4b. ~ 1 o 19::..:;-,r------------------ 197o 15l5.o lH91.o 211o.J 19~1.3 1932.~ J740.b l5~1~9 1317.1 547o.s 467b~9 S~bb.2 10bi.o --71..,;..971lsati;7199ii:oli3&: s--2 o 7·t,-: o--io6 u. 9 --rot.·a: 2--It." tr;2 tJ96.XS62;f;s "bj~. b "99H ~ 5 sb.:::-47t -=--. 3;;----------------- 1972 2274,6 227&,1 22U~.7 19~?.1 l·93b.b 1111.1 i507.l 2529.~ 5Ji:!il"9. l.f41b.1 4970.6 2,q02.2 1973 11~89,6 1665.1 2070.7 l'H2.H lU90,3 1b9q.b l50b.b 1286.7 5ltHl.5 4560.0 5192.2 1047.5 1974 1556.1 19LIH.9 2183.0 2022.3 2004.2 ht07.0 lbo.q.4 13b2.5 5b30.8 '1698.9 5:b47.~~ 1129.7 --f~7S-1b·48.;r--2u6o;2--2Jf!;D--z1ti6~J·· .. z·1Ji .a -19i"b:·4-I7 f4:i4-iii~2:'9-s·a79.4 ~93b.5 5574.lf 1119.7 197& 1b1114.tt 20~5,6 2305.& 2139.q 2224cS 1919 .. 1 17Ub.b 1442~.4 ~-:U1'1.:~ 5034.4 57blel.f 11~9.5 -·~ ~977-169i; .-2 u s ~·&-23b6: 1-·l i ti9 ;~-ii t;q;t;-r9·s·a: s---~ 1 li2 ~ 01lit:t-:-:;u--s 718. z "s 1 b. o so 2s. 1 2bo2. 1 1978 28U2.b 2:~8.1 2250.7 2017.1 1942~& 1728.1 15~b.7 4~2~.8 5JJ1.2 4541.7 5120.5 lO~b.b 1979 1515.1 t892.H 2114.8 t955.o 19~.2 1742,6 1544.9 255a~~··~s~3~1~9~.~2-4~5~l.f~2~.~2~~s~i~t~9~.~o~~,~P~l~i~.~,-. ~-----~-~~-----~ ------·--_____ ,_ ----~--·--------- AVG 1741.9 1953a4 2lb1.9 19H9,8 t9~9.1 l7bl.tt 1~65.1 !14~"H 5479~9 4625.l 51l.f7.7 224l.l.f . ------·-----·--------··--·-----·--· -----·-----·--~·· • -------~·-----·-· -__ ,. ____ ..., ................. -------·----·---·--·-. --.. ' ... _ .. ___ -·--------------------. ·--. ·• -----·----------·-·· ---------·--·---·--.. ----------·----------------------------------·-·-. ·-·-"· • -~----· ------·-·-.. . --·-·-····· ·-·-----------~---·---·--· -----------·---·· --------. -----'--·• ... ------·---·--------· ·--------')\. ~ ~ .... -------__ .. ________ ·- tl ·~ eu 1p !I .& ·--~----------~----------·----·-~-~~--~-·~~~-·---~·-----.............. , ____ ------·------·-------· j·'' .J •r . ' ,{-_\ ';) I t ! l ., ., C:.- \L ':".- ..£_. _____ ::_-' ~ • ~ II 1 . '• ~A.f- ~ 1'':44 1&:1 ~ ~ !F ''1 ~ r:--·'l lilllllliGii1i1 • ~ I;a,sj L, .. ~i i+-~ r.:: . ::.:;: ~ f~ ... .ii ~ ;::_ ---. ..= ~ ~~ 55-~ii E-3 F''li . "i • ~ • • • • • • e"' ;: r f' 'j • l I • • ,j • 'I • I j • J J ! --.! :_....1 -~1 • i I i I • 1 • I l • 1 '! Jl ( ••.u.a~ •; .... 0 ----------. --- ---- / .nL Attachment 7b.4 Page 6 of 8 -------------------··---------·- ENERGY FkOM HESfliVOIR lGWH) ·-... ___ -· --·--~ ..... ---· -----·-----_, ______________ ----------· 7a tit: 1a r).-.1.-ac,.:~,w~,~ s __ _ -----·--------·---- o .... T fiiOV IJEC JAN FEU MAk AP~ MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP ANN 1950 101.7 7J.4 H~.a 7J~l bJ.7 b3.3 ~3.5 q7.2 lbij.7 lb5.8 lbhr~ 119.7 1219.5 -19sc---5-t,.s ---6if;4-·-ttr;-q--·tr:u----b"J:·6·-·-"b2:-8 --53~-~---6-o--;ta ___ liia---;;7 1t>!r;·8 t86~&--~2·o-;4--129&.;:_.-=-6------------- 1952 121.9 7q.8 u~.l lb.~ b3.9 o2.H 55.~ Q1.2 188.1 lbS.H 18b.b lb.S l163.Q -·1953--s't;:·;--&u-:4--ia:q 7T.8 ___ o3:-&·--62.a _ .. sJ;s--ilrf-;·.--,b,r;t-lf>s.8 tttb.& 19a;-1 t29~-=.""'9,....-------------- t 9 54 5 b • 5 b ~ • 4 7 ~ • 4 7 1 • ~ b j • D b 2 • b 53 • S 7 ·1 • 8 l H b • 7 1 b 5 • <!t ·--~~ts~b;-·~b;;-___;2::;,.1~4,;-•=-i5~· _ ___;l~C!z:..:8;:..-:8r:•::..:2;-___________ _ 195S 71.8 7l.b 82.1 74.~ b4.3 b2.6 53.5 47.2 1H8.7 lb5.6 1bb.b Q2.5 llll.S 1956 ~b.~ bU.t& 7H.4 71.8 bJ.b b2~8 53.5 54.3 1b6.7 1b5.a 1bb.b 177.Q 1227.7 -T957--st,·~-s--··t,·8-:4·--7ti:4 ___ ti:-u--··t,3;&-·--&2;fi·--s·3·;·s--t-2T;-J--f86:7--f65-;a UJ&.6 221." f3l6.6..---------------- •~s8 102.t~ 73.o ao.o 74.~ b4.4 o~.t ~&.9 oo.7 aua.7 1b5.8 1b&.6 3&.5 !1S2.3 -r9s9·-·sb.-s--··t,a;4-.. tti·;q--·7i:tt·--·t,3:6 ·o2.H 5:s.s "-7.2--a·us-:-7--t&s·.a tb&.b :so.s ao79_;._7 ____________ . 19~0 5b.5 bH.4 78.4 7t.H b5.b b2.H 53.5 47.2 168.7 lb~.B l8b.6 3~b~·~5--~~~0~7=9~•w7 ________________ __ l9bl 5b.S &8.,4 78.4 71.8 b3.b o2.H 53.~ 47 .. 2 188.7 l6S.6 lbb.b ··~b.S 1079,.7 1~62 . Sb.S bd.4 7H.4 71.8 b3.b 62.8 53.5 47.~ 188.7 lbS.8 lbb.b 3b.5 1079.7 -f9&3--. ·s6.5---'bd74--·7u:q 71 ;u---·63 .. ·b---62·~·a·-·-5:s~s--'4-7-;;l.--tas;-; to5.a 1 ttb.& 3&.5 --nJ7""'>-=-..... 7------ t9b4 Sn.s nd.4 7H.4 7t.H b3.b &c.H ~3.~ 47.2 188.7 t&s.a tbb.& 3&.s 1079._~7 _________________ __ --~9-&s·--56.5 ---it-tt.t.a 78;·q·--7T;li ___ 63.b--i>2-;B----s·3;s 41.2-riHf-;1--ttis.u 18&.& 36.5 1079 • 19b6 5b.~ &8.4 18.4 71.H 6~.o 62.H ~3.5 q7.2 1H8.7 lbS.8 lbb.b lb.S 1079.7 19&7 Sb.S bH.~ 1'8.4 71.8 63.6 &2.8 ~3.5 47.2 188.7 165.8 166.6 13.7.5 1180.7 19&8 5b.5 7~.3 bO.l 72.q blfe4 b2.8 54.H 79.0 !88.7 1&5.6 l8b.b 56.1 1143.2 --r9;;9·---sb-~s--&d-;·q ta-;4--7.-.H br.li oz;e--~n;s-41;t!--nnr.7---r6P 1&6.6 l6.s to7·...-• ...--------------- 197o 5&.5 &8.4 7b.4 11.u &3.& &c.a ·s3.s ~7.~ 168.7 lb5.8 lBb.b lb.S 1079.7 --1-971 5o-:s ___ &a~if-----rtf;4--·-rr;u--h"3-;t, &~-;d 53;5 47.2 nm. 1 tbs.a fffb;'l)~-s ..... ;_,2....--...,, .... 2 .... 5..,I'-.=--..-------------- t972 ao.H 8q.o 8&.5 74.b &5.1 &3.2 53.5 92.7 1&8.7 1b5.8 lbb.u 87.9 t235.b 1~73 56;9 bHa8 7Hu4 71.8 &J.b 62.8 53.5 47.2 188.7 165.6 (86.6 36.5 1080.5 1974 Sb.S bH.4 78.4 71.8 b3.b 62.8 53.5 47.2 1&8.7 1&5.6 18b.b Jb.S 1079.7 --t9fs 5&.,5 b8.4 11r;4 71-:H--"b:s.fi·--62";B --sl;s---4~--rss .. 1 165.8 186.6 36.5 to 19-;t 197& ~o.s &8.4 78.4 71.b &3.& b2.a ~3.s 47.2 ld8.7 1&5.8 18&.6 36.5 10'i9.7 t977 so:s &u,.q 76.4 7i;u 63.&-~2:a-s3.5 qr.2 rua. 1 to"S".e 186.6 9s.o 1138.2 1978 to7.u 7T.b b5.2 75.7 &5.3 b3.B ~3.~ tb~.Y 188.7 1&5.6 t8&.b l~.5 1211.,7 1979 5&.5 b8.4 7u.q 71.8 bl.b &2.b Sl.5 92.& l8u.7 1&5m8 l8b.6 36.5 1125.1 ·------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- AVG b4 .. 9 70.1 1~.5 7~.q bl~6 62.9 53.,b b2.j 188.7 1b~.8 18&.b 6!.2 1151.9 ------------------------·---------·-------------------------------------______ .. _________ _ 1 ~a" I to.------ Q l 9 ----~ • ' -~ -~-,------ ·----·----··--·--· ----·--·--·----·- """"'..,._,.._..._.,__.,..____..,..v~-·--.~->,_....._._~·••...-""'" '"'-''~":'-' ,-,~-..-_,~~,-, ·~ ,.--,.,.....__,_-:-"'" 0 ..·. I•}' ~-.-. f ~ !. I t I I t.. l : ! " :0 -- . 5 '! I I ·~·~-~·~~ __ :_.....,:....,. ___ ,..._.,___..._... _______ ~,_.,._,,.,....,_.,. ,.,., ............... *--·""'*----''_,... ___ ~-· -.,.if--.--_,_.."~....-'(\..-..;,, -----·----~-----~-k¥ ___ .,......__~-•.,hW><••o-·-.-.....-.~-----·~------~••' ---· • .I I j 1 1. l J j*l l ja j lit 1 I· '_() • • j I. ' J• P· l l l. l 1 i ,_ !w I l j. l \ i• !. I \ j • ~ ~ .. ~ s·::·"' ~ ~ ~ : ( ~;;.:. 1?-• .;;;, ~ -~ ~ . . ... L ,-...... --·~· . " [ \ ~..;a I. ~ =~ !i::_..: _ _-;; ~- i ~ • I •. '• ~- ·~n .. ,. . !fl:. . IIi.: . .>,, I liE .• ni -~ ~ai:aii £.::' :~~., ~ Attachment 7b.4 Page 7 of 8 ~-=·~ ---------·-·" ··---...... ,._ -·. ·-.... ··--··-~ ~ _.. . ... .... -~· -... ··--·-·--··-·----_______ .. _______ .. --------~-- __ PUST•Pfip~£C..T_£.!:01'1S -----· ---· ___ t ~t:~.L _ -·---_______ E._~-~-r,:..!J::i , :a,,,., 1 fJ. ~---- UCT NUV UEC JAN FEH MAH APH MAY JUN JUL AUt; SEP· 19~0 2H77.0 2074.1 22bl.7 201H.1 1957.& 1717.1 1S74.» 14b!:4 9900.6 9900,0 9900,0 lbOl,b -r9s1--t"bls',6--i 93o,1·--·2i 4b-~1··-'i~tts:9·--· ci6T .b·-r7to·:u· ··g·~~~~2-·-~fti9~·:s-q9tf0 :o99oO:o t~«~uo .o 75trs-;·=2------- t952 3441.0 2117.1 2~26.1 2112,1 19b~,b l7b2.b 1573.1 14&1,9 9900,0 9900.0 9900,0 12H1,0 -~ 9·53-t7o7 ~.5-i 95 i; o-itt"sf:;;--19a·4. ~ --·i 95a-:·o-i7o.7 ;& --i 5tt6-; .--3of2:s-·99.oo-:·o-1Ts&tt.9115'b~·;;iJ572s:n:------------------ t9s4 1.£.?1.7 t9.H,b 21'B.s t'lb'4,1 1957,5 t7b&.l 1579.~ 239~.3 'lt~uo.o 99·oo.o 99oo.o &278,.& 1955 2t05,b 20~4.1 2242.7 2056.1 l97T.b 17~2.& 1~11.2 1473,3 99oo.o qqoo.o 99uo.o 1551.7 ___ J'/~~--~~~Q~ 7 __ ! q~q 1 lf __ 21 ~-~.!_1 __ 1_~6}'! Q _J ~?..~..!.~ __ 1}bb ~-~ .. J.'S7_7 !tl ... 1I~~-!!,!_.~~ou_!_!! __ 9~~Q.!Jl_ 990~, o ~273 ·=-5 ______ _ 1957 lb55,5 l92H.3 2145,3 1966.& 19&1.5 i7b7.4 lSHl.J 3bS1,8 9900,0 12973,7 11133,0 7394,0 __ 1 'i'S6_2_~'!.b..! q_?o~~ J.. _ ?Ht 1..~!-?~~ r! t_t "~1~~--...! 11? '!.t_1_6 ?'~.!.1---~~~Q.!.1_'!9Q9.! Q_J.~.9Q.!!!» 99oo. o 12_a2. 5 --·---··--. 1959 1bbb,6 l95J,8 2174.4 2012,8 1997,7 1804.& 1614.2 15&7.2 9900,0 9900.0 9900.0 129q,2 _l2b0 1b21.a~ ...... _l9b2~2175,0 2009,2 19H5,3 17'1Q,3 160tt,6 1&05,3 9900,0 '1'100,0 '1~00.0 12tJ6,H 1961 .1678,3 2031,1 2267.2 21~2.6 2061.3 1857,1 1b4H,1 1~l8,9 9900,0 9900.0 9900,0 1500,5 --- 1962 1665 7 2u02 b G219 6 G055 1 2029 ~ 1830 1 1632.4 14&7.0 99\10,0 990U.O 9900,0 1445,2 -·-. ·----·-' ---· ··-·------.J! •. ·----···--·-.. !.....!.--·-· .. ..!---·-...... ·--·-··----------·---·-·--· =----------------·-···-·-1963 1634-5 2000,5 2210~0 2044.1 20lo,7 18~2.0 to~7.2 1505,2 '1900,0 9t.Joo.o 9900,0 1473,6 _19~~ _1.7 o 9, L-~ t!O '!, b 2?. t~~-_lQ~.! !..'!.._l!J 2...Q., . .Q _j !!{Q..!..~--· t 6 ~3 !.~. --~ ~-~ !!..~~~~!)-~90 o, o ~9 0 0. 0 1 ~-~~. 4----------------· 1965 1654,3 2027,0 2219.1 2063.~ 20J3.7 l6Q'I,8 1654,2 1q91.b 9900.0 9900.0 9900.0 1846,5 __1_2hlt_lllt.2 1995,7 221.9,5 2U56,5 20J7,5 18'4~,1 lbttt~,H 1SGb,7 9Yu0,0 9900.0 99\iO,O 15~1,Q !9&7 172t~u 204J.2 22J6,b 2093,5 2010,1 1869.9 1700,5 1547,9 9900,0 9900,0 9900,0 4218.0 __ l9blb~~~~~-_gj_?.Q.~J'ft 1 1_~_9CJ_?_._l_t'!~JL~1b2.,~_tolJ.!.~___u~~..!.l._~90.Q.!..O 9'1UO,O 99UU.O 17~::::3~·-=:.l------------------ 1969 1563,6 1945,9 2159,H 1991,9 19b9.b 17~1.2 1597,5 14&6,1 9900,0 9900,0 9900.0 1245,7 __1.9.1.0 1 7~9, 0 2 Q_!!Q 1 JL__.? 1 H~ 1 1__? 0 I b_. ~'!.?.?_._?._j ~ Qti. ~-_j_ol4 ,~__!i 0 b •!. ___ 9,~ !J Q.!.!!.___C!~~ 0, o ~ u 0. o ~:::;_3 .::...• .::.0------------------- 1971 1709.7 207&.o ~298.~ 2134.o 2121.9 1926.2 t7b7,2 17lo.& 99oo.o 9~oo.o 99oo.o 6026,3 ~72 2~27,b 2jH2,1 2368.] 20b0,1 2003,b 1775.1 1~11,1 2802,9 99UO,O 9900,0 99UO.O ~783,2 1973 l6H7,b 1943.1 213b,7 1977,8 19Sq.3 17&3,& 1571.b 1qb7,7 9900,0 9900,0 9900,0 1273,5 __li7~_{ I.~-~.J_..f . .Q.~.Q..~.L~ ?.51, !J~9.'! .l!.}._l.Y.? J.J!.f_J~?~...!J!. __ 1_P.1 ~-'!-~-_!~~] !.L'!9 u o. o t~~ o o • .!____'!~~! o 1 b .s.;;;..a..:..•-:.1 _________________ _ 1975 1892,1 2JS4,2 2378.U 2211,3 219~.6 19~0.4 1776.4 1617,9 9900,0 9900,0 9900,0 150&,7 _J~1~_1694. ~!.42tb 23J..?..!~___E~07~9-.£!~J..!~-l~!l..!J_J_!tHl~_)d.~?~90_().0 9~00,0 990G,O 1535,5 ------------------ 1977 2001.1. 2217,6 2470,3 2292.9 2253.6 2030,5 1614.0 161~~0 ~900.0 ~900,0 9900,0 3056,7 1978 3092,b 220~,1 2J29~7 c090,t 2o1o,6 11~~.1 157~.1 49l2.o 990o,o 99uo.o 990~~~~~l~7~2~·~b~·----------------------------- 1979 177J~! 1972,8 2193&6 2027.0 2004,2 1810,6 lb24,9 30&2.3 9900.0 9900.0 9900~~ 1371,0 ··------------------- ___A!lG 19J..L_~__aQ..9..2..L~3q,9 20~.._9 2022.9 i82:S.~ _lb36,5 199&1 9 9900,0 10058,1 999b.b 2690,~ -----· ... --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------~---------~ • • --------------·---• i 12. l It ' . _..__ _____ -·-·· . . ·-·-···--- ' 10 -... _ . ·-_..., l ~ t ~ c -----------------------~ i ··-------·---------·-----·----------------------- -------·-----------·----------.. ----.. --...... - I" I t~·,) f· ! j, . I I [ ' I l !' r,~ {f (,' ,;;. ti l 9 .. .. ...,.--------··-~---·--··~~--~--~~-------"·-~· ·····---···· .............. ---~·~ -~ ________ .r .... ' ---;::-"·___!·~,...,-;. -.....,_....~, -~--~.._"'~~--.-....--.~..,_ • .,.....__,-...,;:_,_......._,..,,__~ _, ~-r------~-~* ___ .,__ ··~"-->---. ..._,.~_,__ ---.-.-. --~-' r"' -· --· .-..-~· --·-._ ~ --j,~ --!liiili liiiiiiii lliO.Oil ~ l:;..;,.;j t; ;'.i E:3 •·c · ~· ··.•cc: • ·• -.. • · · • · ' • • •·· ·-·---\ '! ,, . •.• . . . < .• • • -• • • • •• • •• ---· ~ -·· -~~---·.-_:._ .. -:~:~------· ---""'~-. -~----· ·-.... ---·-·· -··--·-·-·-····· ··---·-· -:-· \\ j t~~t 4 ·-· •• • -Attac!_lment 7b. 4 -----···- ·\\; 3 ------· .. ----·----------·-· p ge 8 of 8 ju ---· ------•.. -. ·----·-----·-··· -· a ~.:Yj • • .. I / l l-j ! . Mi 1 I l • "' ----------· ------·--J AVERAGE CAPAB_!LlTIES (MW) Tc;Ue tr C~tti'C..;:•I~a-.,..," P. 7 ., ·:::-..:> OCT NOV OEC JAN FEB MAH APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP CHAKACHAMNA 295. 29ll. 291. 28b. 262. 278. 274. 275. 277. i!80. 2HS. 290. TOTAL 29"S7~9lf:-29 1. 2-tib. Z82. zr&. 27Q. 275. 277. 280. 265. 2~0. MINIMUM CAPf"EiiTTfif;s <'MwT ~· I • I ~"';:::: .. I I • ____..d -::::.___.! J i • l 'l • J ... ~ . l l I 11 1 • i 1 I e • I -~·~· r • J ! I e I •• I ! -• • CHAKACHAMNA OCT 250. NOV DEC JAN FEH ~AR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP 252. 2qq. 24~. 241. 237. 233. 237. 249. 2~1. 2~k. 242. ---------------------------------------------- TOTAL 2~0. 2~2. 2q9~ 245. ~41. 237. 233. 237. 2ll9. ~47. 2~1. 242. AVERAGE ENERGY P~OOUCTION (GWH) CHAKACHAMNA OCT NOV DEC JAN FE» MAH APR MAY JUN JUL ;--,...A-;-UG~--i;S-TE.:....P~1.....-;A,:;N~N~-------------bli.9 10.1 79.5 72.4 b3:a-·i»2.«~ sl.& b2.3 uus.7 tb5.8 l8o.b 81.21151.9 ---TOTAL • b4.9 1-o-;.-79.s 72.4 b l. 8 b 2 • 9 53-~ 6 b 2 .l---18 8 • 1 1 b 5 ;a ~u 16 b • 0 81 • 2 11 51 • q MINIMUM ENERGY PHODUCTION (G•~wuH\)--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OCT NOV DEC-JAN Fi:H liAH APR HAY JON J-rrL AUG SEP ANN CHAKACHAHNA (19b5) ~b.5 &H.4 76.4 71.8 ~l.b &~!8 53.5 47.2 16H.7 lb5.8 l8b.b lb.S 1079.7 TOTAL (1 9b5) 5b.S b8.4 7H.4 71.8 &l.b &2.8 53.5 47.2 UH. 7 1&5.~ _1~8.;..&_.;,...&.;;..__;;:..l_b..:.•~S_.;;.l_0_..;;.7_9..:.•..;;.7 _____________ _ -·-·---------------------- ·----·--------------- . --------·---···-·· -··----··----·------ • -·------..... ---~---. ------"'" ... --·--·---,..., __ ,.,,..,. .. l • ------------·--··-·-···-. I I 12 l .11 . ----------------------- '. ~~ r t ~~ ll I r t, I t t . ' ~ f . -------·--·---.••• lJ:! .t~ ... ·---- 8 . ~ ·~·~------··"''~, -~e~...-..-----0...._.,._,_,._~,_•,,.< ,.....,._._,,,.........~-""'f'___,~w•-.~--..--.,..-,..· .. ~"·~· ~ ------·-·-·· ·----·----------·--·· ··---1.· -' ..... .,. _ ............................ ""-. --,', .;, ----·-·--.. -~··-----·-·--·~~:_-;;..~-----·-·· ·-~ ··-··--.. ·-·---· ····--···-----·-·-·--,r_ .... · .-;; ··--.. ------~--""*-·--------------- ~ . . 1 • '"" ' " ' • ~ r , . . l -'<~-·..--..<""~,.....__~,.._-...,..,_ ... ~~-~-··_.;;. .. ~--·-___,,.. __ ,.,..,...~-~--..;--··~ •e ••• --...-\-·---~·· -~ ----~~ "~---··-... ··-·'----~'-· ----~-~--- ~ ~ ~ ~ If.::' --0, ~ b:.~ f.~ ~~ ta" :;J r.::. • ·~ ~~ b;i ,.. ,.. ~ fim-~ ~-. .oi ~ ~ i;,;,.._w;# L ..... '! ~ f' . ;:) ~ • II ~· :• 1 • • • ;e • • • • • • '" )fl 1 --------------------- Attachment 7b.~ Page 1 of 7 5) JOHNSON ALT~!!_NATlVE HYDRO PHOJECT NSO VEAl~ 20101 &444 GWH l!;b/e If! :70 /,.,!'f?t e, ; RESPONSE 10 OEIS ·w1 RULE CURVE HATED CAPACITY IOO MW ' INPUT DATA FOR JOHNS~N NATURAL STREAMFLOW AT OAr-151 TE ------------------------------------ YEAR OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB HAH ~PH MAY JON JUl AUG !~ 19&1 6439. 3675. 3690. 3749. 2961. 2897. 2a04.12090.2l5l3.21062.22HS3.11572 • }962 5517. ~21. 2952 0 2952. 2952. 2829~ ~~~]l~~~2~0~1~.~l~4~7~3~5~.1~7~]n9~2~.~~~~~~~~-~~~~~·~~~~--~~~~-~~~ 19&3 7175. qJ12. 51~8. 3321. 3196. 270&. 295&.13050.10777.2712~.24957.15227. --719=64 66~198. 28~~~7~~;-25h3. i583. 48il~b4.3105~gwQ~5~.nllnanJ~o•.~~------~~----~------------~--------------·----- 19b5 6513. 3&90. 3327. 3151. 2U29. 2583. 24bO. 6402.12202.23149.24010.12195. 1~&6 5937. lo7s. 2629. 2829. 27o&. 27o&. 2u29.io2o8.21722.2579l.2ol57. 9118. 19&7 491&. 3075. 2952. 2629. 2829. 2829. 3075.115b7.22017.2579l.30049.1564& • 19&8 s45;. 37tt. 145&. 3ilq. 3o75. 1o75. l1~~io794!;2oqq2~o~~,3oe~.T,s~on.8~o~.~------~----·---------------------------------------- l9&~ 7144. 4087. 3910. 3785. 1598. 3189. 3411. 9iOl.l8389.2760I.14568. 79qo. --~,9~70 5160 •. 3994. 353~1b2. 3t96:-lo7s. 3loo. 6&oq~0872~t~6nas~-.~~~7~9~u~3~.~~~&~7"5~.--~------~------~----------~------~~~----~--- 191l 5618. 3317. 23&5. 2l14. 2214. 2214. 2499.10952.l8093.2b720.29S94.1286b. 1972·· 5879. 3809. lt&e.-;-28!15-~s-28 .-2251 o 22t~Z.l1ltt7.20~27577.2&91T.;tc'l"l7. 1973 q749. 3260. 2909. 2d29. 2829. 2829. 3139. 8U92~1qqo9.2&265.21l04.1l219. 197 q q 16 ~ • 1 o22:-i49cf;-2t~&o;-214t.o;-i&51 • 3337. olffif~lJ"cisS-;i~s ae .2&r .. 71r=-. ~.s;..,e;;.;&::-.7<:-:.=----~~-------~-~-~----------~---- 1975 5212. 3998. 3499. 31lO. 2851. 2829. 3Ul1.11521.1824l.lqlb9.2ll3&.l8512e 1976 1 o96. t~ciTI-;-Jz-&q;-:so7s-;-l~~i9~-:-n7 o. 952"b";l"8iH"l~2-:n1io;rrq=-=8,..3,:..~9=9o,;;,-,2.,..;.=--------------------~--------~--- •977 7895. 4244. 3257. 3198. 3198. 3134. 3721. 8807.19&92.25&~6.31~&9.1238&. 1978 6439~-lS2b. 1l98o 2952. 2916. 2tt29. 4401. '12112;.;-r2~7.2l1b1.2937r.l7bUI. 1979 5374. l8ll. 3Q63a 324b. 3198. 3198. 4822.lllU&.lSOl8e3i3&5.3bbb&.l5Jlq. --=,-=QBO 66 7 z. 42&4. 331-:r;-2952. aTOfi;---21'93. l89r.8fo8.Il53o. 251~b~1""'59~.1:n2~7.-:b-..7.-:.'------------~------------------ 1981 8183. 49lb. 4360. l67Z. 3813. 3813. 4182. 8788.16l62.24047.l09S9. 9589. --1982 4904. 3&81. l22t. -iiie~9s2;-i!829. 2e54;riif23~nr3rs.iso~s.zlrer.rc,.,......8","-------------------~---------~----- ------------------~ffiO RESERVOIR EVAPORATION, INC~.E~S~-------------------------------------------------- (] ·, !' r~ "' f' L t I I I I r l • ___ __Jlt_! __ rro_y_ QE.C_ __ -lf.ML_EE8 MAR o.o o.o o.o o.o o.o o.o APR_}tA y JUN JUl AUG SEP I f o.o o.o o.o o.o o.o 9.0 • ********* RESERVOIR DATA ********~ **** TAJLWATER DATA **** __ __.E ..... LEllllON_ ____ Y.QLY"!E !.I!~A OI~CHARGE ELEt.~IlON -··---------------------- (FlrMSL) (ACRE•FEET) (ACRES) (CFS) (FlrMSL) . ----·-·------·-·· --t~;~:~ tuobo~: ~: aooooo~: :~:~:~ 1Q20.o 2&0~ o. u. o.o e · l't~9_.o --~f!OOP~-~. o o~·------~o~•.;.o _____________ ~------------------------------- l4&o.o 5200»oo. o_ o. o.o • llf7Q,O 70_2~,9.9!.t ____ 0, 0, 0,0 . ' THE RAT£0 HEAD 19 199L=o~~~-~~~-----------r----------------------~--- tz THE RATED CAPACITY iS 210.0 MW. • 11 _{Hf_Jjf.M2L.~~J.lL_9_t_O l.LU Mf§_ltlLHE=A=O ___ __ 10 ., 9 ___ 1_tlE...GEt-4E~AT.OR fff.lti~NCY __ HL9..t.'!~BL~------------· : I ~: THE TRANSFORMER EFFICIENCY 15 0.990 ~ _ _:_:~---' ~---·--~ •••·•--• -----. -------~--M• --•·--·--·· --··-• -· ., ••> '' L . ~L . . ' I , J' ,,_ f ~"llj I ,j I l l \ .. I I ! l I \ I io!••::':1 """--1 l I I l I j ~-::-., . v I i ! I ! J "l ' . " -. __ _,.,..,...._... ..... ......-.......... _....~.._.._..,~--....:.:::• .... -·,---·· -----~--·~-~--"' ... ---·--·-····· --· --_ __.._ iiiiiiiii ¥iiiii &iii\i ~ iii~ lii5ii \ii£ii ~ ~ t;:.:.;i.l !":"'': .. l''Jl ~ ... ~ r_ :; ~ ~jj r,-_, -. ~~ ~ b~ ~ r.·.:.-~_ ~ ~ ' Attachment 7b.5 Page'2 of 7 • s ____________ ..... ---·-······----····-·---··--... ---·-------·-----·····---·· -------------- .-.• ........ , 'W'I"'"""''-"•' ·-•-•• -··-,,_._ •. , •4 ••• •• I lfH .. I#' •J ..... ~~ 1•' , ...... ,~If • ****~*******~****** PONEHPLANT DATA, 1 UNifS •****•***********~~• 0 3 ·---~-ET ti~~o ..•.. ___ fi.,A~J . ....t~A_t;J_Tf _________ ~r:fi_tlf:NC_Y __ -::---------------------·-------------- . (%RATED) (fEET) (MW) (I RATED) TURBINE PLANT o.6SO 96,9 q7~a o.~ao o.e5~ u.alz • __ ..;;.0_,._, 7..50 11 !.~.~ ___ !2! '9 0 .~lt! 0 'tif!~_,, 0 .,;g;_q::-----------·--------------------------- 0.800 119,l lQ2,2 0,6Yd 0,688 0,862 0,650 1~~-t.f!... __ ! 5~i 7 ___ 9.!.1.~9 0,894 o._~~-7 7aJk II' ::J;,I,n$trn P. 2 o,9oo 134.1 112,0 0,644 o,goo o,o7J II - • • • • • • • • ·• • • • ~0.950 1,.1,5. --~lJH,6 _ 0,921 __ 0,90~----~~ 0 .. ~16_~-------~-__ _ 1,000 149.0 203.7 1.000 0,910 0,683 L._o3o ~~~.s ~.1.~!.~ •·.'!.~~-o.~_ott u.~.~.! I,ObO 157,9 221,3 1,066 0,906 0,879 1.100 l63,q 233,3 1.145 0,903 0.876· ---=a;-::.:...:;1:..;:50 s"n:"l · 24'if;it 1.21"9 o,9o-o o.lf73--------------------------------------- 1,25U 186,3 276,1 1,365 0,683 0,857 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~- ~ESERVOJR OPEHATION CONSTRAINTs--- MAXIMUM RESERVO]R flE~~TIOH _OCT NOV DEC JAN fED MAR APR MAY .JUN JUl~ AUG SEP 1470, !470, 1470, 1470. 1~10, Jq7o. 1470, Jq7o. 1470, 1Q70, 1470, Jq7o, ·-------------------------------------------------------- RULE CURVE ELEVATION --~ -~-------·--------------------------~ O~l NOV OEC JAN fEB MAR APU MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP a47o. li47o, 14~:&9, 1:a~e. Jtt66, 1'1&7, 1467, 1~tb'~'• 1467, 1468, !q{;St-,-...,-=-q,-;:6.;,9-,-~----- -~INIMUM--R~SERVOIH ELEVATiON OCT NOV ~-DEC ___ J~fL_ E..EH __ _M~H ____ ~f»!L MAV JIJN JUL AUG Sf:.P t39o, 139o, 139o. 1.390, !!9o, uqo. tJ9u, fl9o;-tl9o, tl9D, · !l9o, 1390, N~.~~~VJIJB_.!!~J.EASE CONSTRAJ NT S _, __ _ ___ ..x.O'CT NOV Of£ JAN FED "1AR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP MINIMUM CONSUMPTIVE RELEASE """"-~ ____ _Q.._ 0, o_..__!l_~ __ J.. u, o , o, 0 ._ ___ 0..!. 0!! 0,, -·----------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------"'~IN~IuH~U~~~~-PQW~E~R~l~tE~l~E~A~S~E~--~~---~~--· J • - OCT NOV , OEC JAN Ffti MAR J\PR MAY JUN JUL AUG SE~ le 0 I L__p_._ ____ j!.._ _____ 9..L 0! 0.._ __ ..!.._ __ 9_......_~-!..L-• ~0-1-------------------- ll r ' ----~·------·-.. ........__. __ ~,.. --.... -~--~...------~-........ ~---------------------... ··---'"''-'"-~, ...... _;• ''"'~"""::" ~-. ,.......----~--------..... -----~"" ........ ~ ........... -~----·-·q-···-""_'"'_,_..~.-.·~· (,' I I ,c , ~ .. ,:> t ,. II I I f: t l ~ I I r t t r .-' - l .,... .. ., ... -~ , " • ' ';'" ,,~ ... ~-ll ;. ..-5I - ' ' . liliii ~ iliiiiii ~ ihss" tm:;:;bj ~"' :1 ~ ~ ted ~:~;i f=-...:3 L,_., ~ l-: .. :1! ~ ~ .. :ii fc __ ~ ~=-'"'~~ Attachment 7b .. 5 ~ ------. ---~--------~· ·---------------.. ~-~--~---·-r · .... : . . .. . ' () '0 ' _ _.-.. ··· ~ ~ K ~ r--... .,. r--, ~ ............. Page 3 of 7 • OOWHSTREAM-RELEASE CRITERIA PRE•PROJECT FLOWS AT BELOW DAM • -~L~~-~~-JE~~K-l~~-~~!~-~~-JU~-J~-~-~S~E~P~---------~--------------1961 &439, 3875. lb90. 3749. ~9&1. 2897, ~ij04,12090,~1Sll.21082.2~853.11572, • _......,l9._..bl_S5ll..._JlZl.J5~5l.a_~'lS.£..__jllS~J~att...__l~-!i·...lill~J!1&.3.22UL_147J2J.Illi-'-------------------------- 19bl 7175. 4712. ll98, 3121. 3198; 270&. 29Sb.ll050,I0777,27122,249S7.15~2'7, t9ea4 t.HS2. 1198. ~aaL_lo7s. ~629. <!Stu. 25§38 ge:z o. 30t,.&4. 11 OS Ia, Z4695,11831J. _ ·tz i9b5 6511. 3&90, 33274 3151, 2829. 2581, 2460. 6~02,122~2.2Jlq9,2qOlO.l219S, fl n ____19126 S~ 3 7. 3 i l~J!lZ~ ~ttz~ ..._l..7JHta.~.llQk ...J.!l~.W o c~O ~.4J 112 ?..d 57 9 h.?~ -!S 7~-=-1 ~111t=,.__ __ _ to 1967 4916 • .!ins. 2952, 21129. 2629. 28i29. 3075.11~&7,22017,25791,3C049vl5cttlb, '_.t !l~b 51f5Si. :f.lU, 34 5&. 311!' . ......19...72.. -~ 9:1..~...__1t,gl, I o 7:92..._~0 11~.£.19.:.1751:::-b .!:-!• 2~b:-::1;-::J~6:.%,..:.1-=5::-:o 0710~,~------------------------~----- •• 1969 7144, 4087, 3910, 3785, 3598, 31!89, ltUJ. 9101,i6l1819,27bOt,145H8, 7CitU), '1 .1910 SlbO. 1994. 3531. 32&2. 31«i6. 30:75. :UOO. fJ&U4.lOH'7iL.l981'~•l7963,. 9&7 15 I 1971 5818. 3317, 23&5, ~21'1. 22111~ 2llq, 2q99,l0952.1UO~l.2b72~.295Y4,128&,. e 5 -19.1'---S.U.2.._3Jlo.i.a_]J..~J:t6s ... _a_~ao. . ......z.z5...~~~ ... UJ:~u.~qJ~.!!> ... l.1.'i7I-.~&"lil...~'2::-:::3'-:'l~7 ...... ______ _ • 1973 4749, 32&0. ~909, 2329, 2829, 2829. 3119. 8~92,l94~9.2b285.~1J04,112l~. 3 1979 117&1 .. loza. 2li!9'L_j~O. 24f.!Q,_l6\Sie 3ll1..._!!9(l.LJ.ll8S.l2!!1At.._?J!]77,15tUt'Z. • 1975 5212 .. 3998, 3499, JH30, 285!, 2829, 30ll,li15i21.18~41.311lb9.21l.3b,l85h~ .. 19Jb 7096. 4031, 3269, ]075. ~952, 2995, 3370, '1~2b,l6413,22780,27983, 9902. • 1977 7895, 424.4.· 1251. )~198, 3198, 313~. J7~l. 8810.7.19b92,25b58,ll8b.9,l236t&. 1976 6439, 352&. lt9tl. c!'IS2. 2916. 2~29., 44tH. 92'42.12&57,23l&I.C?9l72,12bBl, ~79 5374, 381J, 348]• ]246, J)98, 3198. q~2.1Jlij6,1~0l~b5,l~b~o~l~S~J"l~4~,----~--~~--.-----------~--~~ 1980 6&72, '12611, 1317 •. ~!9SC!. 270&, 2791, :3~95, 8li06,ll5l0,253i!b.21759,12767, 7al,f~ II" :T.Intstn-t • ~981 8183\!! 49lb, 4i3ao., 3f872:;-3eT1:Jtu3 .. , qf,oz. &7i8'ir;tbR2.-z4-oq"1-:~<r9~9 .. vsa • P.3 {_~ f ( t• 1•e2 4904. 3681, 1221. a9e4, 2952, 2829. 285~.12423.18lt5.l5oss.2ll82,tosts, 1 . ; i I • • • • • • • • • • • MINI~UM POS1•PROJECT FLOWS AT BELOW DAM OCT NOV 0~-JiA-N --FER ___ HA·H-~iiR--MAV-JlfN JUl ·•ArruG=-----.s"t""P" ~~~~1~2~o~o~·~12oo, 3~o. l~oo~ l20!~ 12oo, J~oo, 3200,24~~.2~ooo.~2~q~o_o __ o~·~l-~_o_o~·~-~~-~--~--~~~-~~~~--~~-~~~- NSD FORECAST, YEAP. 2010 ANNUAL [NERGY DEMAND • b4qq, GWH, ENE~GY __ GE_NER __ AT_I_O_N_C_RJ_T_E_RI_A __________________________________________________________________________ __ SYSTEM ENERGY DEMAND, GnH ocr Nov·--~o=E=c--~JAN---FEB--MAR A~R MAv~--J~u~N~--J~u~t--~A~u=G--~S~E~,:~--------._ ___________________ , Sbl, b40, 117. b59, 582, 575, 491, ~59, 427. 420, 44&. 4b5, MONTHLY GENERATION FROM OTHER 90URCE9, GWH -----o=c=r=---=No=v~=-----=o=!Ec -JAN--FEB ___ HAR-A'Pr-MAY-·JUN JU;'L--Aa;UT;G.----..Sr-E"P------------------------~------ ____ .....;;I'-8"""7_,.,4 177.1 l&•h,~ 1712,5 150.6 lt19,C: 128.,2 153 .. ~ 4Z6,b 1U9,9 445.9 2b,.2,5 --------~~-~--~~A~CJU5TEO SYSTfM EN~E~H~G~Y~O~E~H~A~N~D~,~G~~~H~~--~--~~--~~-----------------OCT rJOV OEC JAN FEB MAR APR HA 'f JUN JUL AUG SEP -·-·------------------- 375~ 4bl, 531, ~87, 431. 42o, 363, lob, o. o. o. 201. MONTHLY GENERATION, PEHCENT OF ANNUAL ----~o~c~T---N~o~v~~o-~E~t~~JAN FEB~AR APR MAV~~J~U~N=--J~U~L.-~,~u~G~~sre"P ________________ ~----------~-------------- o.tos o,t29 o,t4e o.t36_y.t2o o.119 0,101 o.oes o.ooo o,ouo o,ouo o.os7 TAHGEt-FIRM ANNUAL ENERGY-i~-~97. TARGET~ONTH-LY--FIRH ENEwGY, GWH OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUtf--JU[-~-IWG-8"~ 41.5 51.3 58,8 53.9 47,8 47.2 40.,2 33,8 o.o o.o o.o 22.~ ( ·I l r f l f l \' t* r. r r ~' I . • t J L--·-·--·-------····-··----~-·--· - -' ~ ~ I .• ·-~· • ,..,..~...,.,.....,.._. __ ~~r----·•' ~---"'---~·--·-·-----------·--J/,,,,,-,,~-~--•••-·....,..____~•w• -----. .. "''----' --.. ·----~ -"'···---,...~-' 4 iild Eiiil l'iiiiiiO ~ ~ ~ ~ \i.-:::.ii 1 ( ~ ·•-.·--"'-->-• H--._....,_,,_ E ,.,_,.._, ___ __,__,,.~,,.__-,~-~-.,...,~.._ ..... , ___ ··-~-... ·-~,_____~·--~---~--·-·--·--"-'.·• I I I j:., .... I . .l i. "\ F-• ~-~:;;:ci_ ·-r;.. .., ~ ~....;II i··.~l ~~ 1 .. • ' 1 I ' ~ t~ -.... ..i1 !:::.~ s:;;-;:; .. lC:.---~ I !...~ ... '* j .I ~ ( ' r'\ bl li. .. ,~: Attachment 7b.5 Page 4'of 7 ·1 l I 12 tl ---·--------------·-·-· ---·---· ·•. -' __ ]'~fl.l!!.~; .. ~!~CHAH~L (~f~}__ . .7 II 0 I ,.,. /'1....<·(> lo ~"''•5tPI r.q.. ----------------· ···--------- 3 4 - 5 •• _____ .;...U.;;..CT"----_..;..N_U~ OEC _ JAN FER MAH APR HAY JUN JUL AU!i ~EP 6 7 19b1 b439~0 Stl71.4 b093.2 ~bU2.o 5~13.b 4937eH q~54.9 4S3u.q Olb3. 2b.O 2.b 3b74~8 ---i9b2--43o2: i--!;;4b7 .5 ·-6i11 ~2--·sb'3'i:4· -55q·5;7-··49&1:·3···-·.ntftf~9--3551 ;·u-OTbl. ··--2S:-7--~.o20To·1;·B·--·--------·----~------.. -: l9b3 4492.b 6224.1 b09q.7 5607.8 5~19.7 4~43.~ 43~9.9 4807.o Olbl.H ~b.~ 2.b 5009.1 10 -·i96'i-42q7 ~-q--5tr17 .1--·6Tu6:s--·~&2t.s --·s~:s5;i-·-ii~s(J;s--437t~.o··-"35bH:-2-2 -r;,I 8---2s-:" t;&Tii6b"2 .c:-· -----------·-11 19b5 429~.0 51.177.9 blOl.O 5615.» 5529.7 49S4.1 q37l.b 35b0.7 2 lol 8 2&.& 2ci ~2vU.G ll -19&i,--a36o. o ssao. 9 &231. ~ 57t.Jll. s 5bo4 ,6 soao .2 qqas. o 3o39 .2 2 1 o3 .a 2o .7 2. 7 l2oo. o l9b1 ilil24.8 56~0.5 b3UH.1 56!5.9 5751.3 5167.0 4599e6 l7Ub.~ 2 lb .a 2bs~ 2,7 3200.0 -i'9&a·-4Ji!·~.a·---~sqz:J---6t7~:;: 1·· ·5&82 .7·-s~9!j:b--so""t ~ ;d·--4it22 ~T-Jsa~:it-·2o ·'b .s 2o.2 2.b--9o7T:-o--· ·---------··· . l9~Q 4297.0 5Stb.H ~25i.,j 5bOl.2 ~509.7 49j0o3 4~44.7 5~29.1 2~ b .e 2o.o 2gb 3200.0 --~ q i o-·li35 q ; u-·s 5 54~ 0--b i H b-.:;··--.; b9 ~. o -5& o q: 7---~ o21 • q --·4ti 3 o; 3-3 b u ~: Li2 if! 3 ;8--2 7 • 5 2., 8-3"2-lHr:-o·--------- 1971 46nH.7 ~»90.1 bbl&.o bl9lnl ot79.4 ~&~s.o 4997~1, 4031.3 iOl 3.8 29.8 2.9 1200.0 1 9 72 4 b 0 H il 9 56 d 3 • b b fll.) 7 • 8 b l 4 q ., 0 b 115 • b ~54 0 • 4 4 q 4 0 ,, J 2 9 • 0 2 • 8 ll U 0 • 0 - 1973 4559,1 5839.,7 >:»570,0 blll.9 b07H.7 54qq,9 Lf8H1.,5 3G.J'j7.~ 20! 29,a'S 2.9 3200.0 --~i 97 4'4i7 ~ 0~·4--· b o9 q ~·1-· "b68 f72 -bli iq. 5 -.o.44~: 2 ---~9 2j: o-· 553'. q-·~ job;"t,-~ 0.. • 8 .B. 8 l~--.r2uo:o:.-· ---------·-----·-- 1975 4940.o &32b.4 714~.3 b74J.q o~t~s.o o324.6 ~7j ,.1 4~7b.u ~o b .e 32.7 l.i 32oo.o ---1976--~t;;il.b--6oHtf~·ci-o-ti.S7:·l'--63&-s;s-63.f7 • .----5-fsa-:t-srs•.r: r-tifsr;~rzo· b' .6 :u .1· 1.1 :szoo...:. • ..,.o-------------------- 1977 4»7~~~~9o7.l b491,2 o~l3.2 5971.6 S3o4.1 4312.5 2 to .a ~~.o ~.1 32oo.o 1~78 47bU.8 bOHq.o bH55.b b3Hb.5 blbl.~ 5H 0.1 SJB~.q 4l~o.H a 1b3 8 ll.,l 3.2 Jzoo.O 1979 qqJ4.5 b3ld.S 7ljb.O b72tl.3 b613.H b27l.b ~~22.1 4452.~ 2 lol 8 Jl.,l 3.,0 1200.0 -i9ao-trb3T:s -·-5897:5-bb 16;9·--6 i ~ i:o-6 1 rcr;s·--~s:H:i -z1q i o:7--fcj7 ti:zr-2 ib1 8 :~o. 3 3. o lzo·o. o=---- t981 4635.8 b\lJ.q b8bb,q b3bb.l b3l4 11 7 5b92~3 SU47.b 407!~q Olbl~ 31.1 J.1 J200.0 --~~ sos4~~-i~~1-~i~~-,1~~~-n~~s-~j,~i~~-~aa.4JTibi~.~-~l~s~.~z~-~3~.~s-~1~3=a~J~.=2----------------- ---\4 -·-- AYG 4680,.& 5875...t1.-~?58~!._b0t\5~~-~5q_!..~-~~90!'_!) liH~"d.2 ll052-~ 29.4 2.9 488Uo2 -------- -~-----==~i~U~--~ Mft-~. ~v~~~~--~~~~~~---------- _________________ ·---~~r-f-f-YC)uc;:/-1 ~--_ _was ntJ 14f Md dnre d-~J ---··----.·-····-··---(b~-hc;~d}-·---k---pr(,sf!MI~I;in ;}1 -r;lJ~ 18 ~ r r i c ·---··--· in j. ==:-=~~-.. -~~-=:. _ ~.:.-=: ~--~-= -d.~ Jiif~lc#l_!. =---iZii~~c;'!!~~ 7)() c, L( I'M~ f -----/ ---------· to·· .. ----· ~.'!f!~ x _ ;!£ ~ 'I f --...-<------~-.~,...-~---~ ... -----... ........ ~ ..... .._....-J,.., .. ~_,.~··~---- b --· ------·-· --..-.. ~···-..--'*,._. .••. \ ,_. r;' r'· L' h. r ~ Lr. ·. t· ~ ' t I l I !. ( r [ f) !.) 1:; (') - -' -~ ~. . ' . '- r-·~_. _ _.._..:..,. __ .. -~.-lL.-___ , _ _.::._,.--~ ....... ---......J_ '....___.. ___ ,_. -----'·=·-· -"----·-------.. ------~ .. --·--.-~~·-· --~.--.. .. .='--~'""'-----------~-~----· ----'1 r·· ·• ~ .~ ~ ~ l . .' 4 ~ ~ L::::i4 t,;-' sa r.--· .. i --=--l· ~ l ~ 3---------. ··-·-------·-· ------- I j I • --------·----···· .... ! i. ua·ml ENERGY FIWM HESE HVlll H __ .1 .. ------·· .. ·-·• -·-------·-----····"·--------------·-.. -·-- 1 OCT NOV OfC JAN f~H MAH APH ' . MA¥ r JUN b. ___ · ~ f~ ·.~.·~ ~-~~ is:~ ~ b~ ~-IIi ~ .. ;j ~ -~--.;:.;A::...:t:::...:t=a::.:c::;.=hm~n t 7b., 5 . Page 5 of7--------·-···------ JUL AUG ~EP --·---·--. ------------~- ·7;-. L· fe f g. Jo !ti•J.£. •• ANN 1-'.S l • 1961 b2.q 51.3 5H.6 53.9 lH.d 47.2 40.2 43.5 ~ltH.t 0.,2 o.o 34~1 I l ---r9&2--4T~·s·--;·i:'l-·--··st\.H----53-~9-,rr:s·----,.7-~2-. -4tJ;·2··-"Jl;& 1u:r;~·o.2 u.o-nnr;-,-·- 1 l9b3 43.5 56.3 ~8.6 53.9 47.d 47.2 q0.2 46.0 Hb ~ 0.2 4b.4 J • --19 b4 --i& r.-5 --5 f .·3 -·stf~ 8---~ 3 ;cJ'·--ti7-;·a---q 7 ;2 -·--li o ; 2 --·-. :S .3-.-tt-u 6'. 2 1 19&5 41.5 51.3 5a.a 53.9 q/.6 47.2 40.2 3l.b bll 1 1 t9bb q 1 • s 5 1 • 3 5"; a 53. 9 'a • a 14 1 • 2 4 o • z:--...;.3,J....:.~a--1:7.d'2:f--W!:-----x...;.....;.s:---~~--......-:~---'",;.+ ! • __ 1_'!~] __ 4 b .. !?. ___ ?.1..! . .3_ ---~~'!8 __ 53.!'_9 ___ 47 ·~ 47 '!~---4~!.~--~3.8 ____ .~~~ -~ I 19b6 lll.S 51.3 5b.H Sl.Y ll7.8 47.2 40.2 ~3.8 1 • d4.1 l 19b9 41.5 51.7 60.3 53.9 q7.6 47.2 40.2 33.H 1 .2 0.2 ~~~.4~--~ f , • --r97o ___ 4f;5-~--~;r:.J-ss;ti--·-s3 .. 9 ___ 4t:t~--c:ar~2·-·--·4o~2 ·---·::s-:s:u-1-•• ---u-:2 l7.s , 1971 ~1.5 51.3 ~~.~ 53.'1 47.a ~1.2 40.2 3~~a 1 .3 o.l o.~ ~7.3 1 t972 41.5 51.3 5a.a 53.9 Q7-.tt ,.,.~ qo-:2 -:n .. u 1 • --!f;-a:o--""~'2 .... 7..;.. ..... 7---7" ........... ----------,--- _j • __ 19?} .. ___ 4) .~ --~~.~--~H.B ___ S~._'I __ ~?-~~---~7.!.?-____ _!!U·._.S_. }3-!_b __ ! 0,.0 ~~-"6 1974 41.5 51.2 ~a.o 53.9 47.e 47.2 40.2 33.a 1 o.o l4.9 ' _lq?.~ ___ 4J.!~ __ 51 '!2----~~..!~--5~.!~---~7.!~----~7 -~--4~!1. ___ }~·.~--!' _.3 ()~--..... ---------- 1 • 1976 41.fl 51.3 58.8 53.9 47.6 47.2 ~0.2 33.8 1 el O.u C:::Je8 I. t 1977 Qi.6 Sl.l ~8.6 53.9 q1.H 47.2 40.2 3~.8 1 . ,4 o.u 2b.3 I 1976 41.6 51.2 5a;6 53.9 47.8 47.2 qo.E~~u I l e __ t979 __ ~h~--st.!? ____ s.~!a ___ ~~!..~----~~-'!~.---~7 !.~ ~----~o'!.2 __ }~.!-~ ·-=-=---·"' l 1980 41.6 51.3 56." 53.'1 47.8 47.2 40.2 33.6 cl _t?.~ L __ 4J.~~---~J .. !. ~ -·•·-~~! 6 ___ -~ ~ e ~ -·-~.?..! ~---~ 1_._ ? __ ,. 4 0!? ___ _3 ~.!.6 __ 1 e 1962 41.5 51.3 5a.s 53.q qJ.a 47.2 'lo.2 .B.h ' .I I. .. --1.. c· j • ___M~ __ 42.b 51..!.!_.~-·-~---.~!.!..!.. __ !H.b ___ ~]!.~-·---~!~ ..stt.a ___ ~n u.2 o.u tu.o ::fOJ,rr ::::-""·' 1 • --·· ... ··----____ .:. ___ ----·-·----· ··----·-·-·--·--·--·---·----------· 1.0 423 ' 1 ''-l \01 \ . ·----··-··--------·. -----·--. I . -·-·---------. -. -----J• I l ie ( '• [ I' • l l 1 f. I '1 tz I eu I lU --~ .!' . ~!!) ,,,.._~,...._4"~~,,.,....,...,..,.~ .•• ...,.,..,..._,~--,w . J"ee »"~~ M I p._"'_.,._ -· ---·--·----.. -~·----- ·-·-------· ---· ·-------------·----- ··--..... --·----------------------- ...... -·------···----·---- ... ' .. . -·-.. --· . . -· ·-··----- ·-···-----·---·-----------------·- "' ' k ., [I r l c: I - --a:.,. ~-'\ .; ~ ' .. : r ~,;,;,.~ J .. ~r~-~ I .. ~ • -------·---- t . ..;,..c: '7 ,-.. ,., ~ 1 ~· i ----- POST•PROJ~CT FLOWS --· ----·---~-~__._,.,..,___,.,. __ ~·~"~ .. ---~-~ ....-<,_,,.,.._«, --~-··-"-~-· ---·--·'----~-----·----'"·--~~·--~-~· ~ ~ ~ (.CfS) ---- fa·~ ~ b~ ---·---------~-.... '-.. _; ~ \; 75?! ~;II ~7.:...~ ~ re~~ ----------~A=t=t=a~cvment 7b.5 Page 6 of 7 1-···j ~ . ----------. Ta b/~ I il 5c J,.li.S" •I 1-! 6 ~ ; l Mi --"'·· ,.···---·-·--1 ----·---·--- ----------~O~C~T ___ ~NUV DEC JAN FEB MA~ APH MAY JUN JUL AUG· SEP --------- j e _!~!»1_f?.~~9!~--~tt?~ !~--~~9.,3.!..?._~~~~!-b -~5.!_3.!~"~!7.!..~~~~~·-9--~~~~-l .. ~~-~-!!.!-~~4r~~~ou.o~br·!~~------------------, 19b2 4302~1 5487.~ bll .2 5&~1.4 ~54~., 49&1.~ QjHQo9 ~~~~.o ~40uv.u ~ o'o•7 ~~·l5.0 2v o~.o I t9&l 4492.b 622Q.1 60~4.7 5607.8 5519.7 49tt3.3 4J59.9 Qb07.b 2ttooo.o 2ttooo.o 24ooo.o 5oo9.3 i • --t96t~ -if29t ;-y-·sq7r;r ··b 1 ob";·s-·s'i>2t:-s-·ss3s-;7-ti95'9·~s--4JTb.o--,l~fia:2~"1ilfoo-:o-24ouo.o 247'45.1 14lfb'2.-...... 2----- ! 1965 4299.0 5477.~ 6103.0 5615.8 552Y.7 ij954.1 4371.6 3~b0~7 24000.0 24000.0 24000.0 J200.0 1 1966 43HO.O S58b•9 b-231.5 5741.1.5 Sbb4.b SOt:\0.2 L1485.,o 3639.2 24060.(1 24000.0 24oUo.o l20o:U 1 1 ~ 1967 4424.8 5bSo.s b3ua.t 5815.9 5751.3 5187.o t~599.& 3706~5 ~~.~o~o.o 2400o~o 2400o.~ 320o.o 1 -t96a-·4345~tt---55tti;l--6-tts:t--S'blf2:·-;----;~9~:b--sor2.u-·iiii~~;c-3·~as-;-Q2'4-omr;o2tilfu·u.o 240oo.o 9rrrr:n----------------- l l9b9 4297.0 55lb.b b~S!~l 5&01.2 SSOY.7 4930.3 434q.7 3529.1 2qouo.a 24000.0 24000.0 l20U.~ e --f97o--·435if;a··~s5t~:o-&·ia6:r-5'bii2-:ti---stiot~-; r-s·o2T;«i--443o-:l-36us--;·q-24ouo.o--2-4oifo. o 24mTU. o 321ilJ.I....------------- t97l tlb08.,7 5890.1 bblb.O bl93.l bl79.LI SbO~.o t1997.b t~Ol1.3 240uo.u 240oo.o 2ttOUOeO l~oo.o f I l972-460ti:~1Hil.b b607.H blQ4.0 611S.b 5540.'1 qi:jqo.o 398~.,8 24000.0 24000.0 2l!OUO.O 3200.0 • 1973 . 4559.1 5H39.7. b570.0 6111.9 b07tJ.7 5t1~4.9 QtJfH.S 3957.Q 2'fOOO.O 24000.0 24000.0 l20U.O --f97ii-47sl;~·4·~-&o"'4·~·r·-t,aar:'2-b'tl29 .s-btili9~ z---59~'3 :·o-s:s:s<i ~~~-~Jo'b-:&2ltiHfo:-o-24oo~{i2m. o 3~o,..------------------j 1 t975 qqqo.b 6326.4 7tqs.J 6743~« 6b45.o 632Q.b 5738.1 457b.o 2uouu.o 2qooo.o 240oo.o 12oo.u -. -~ 97 6---477 i~b·bo 8 o-;9-b'u37 ;2--bJ-bS:S--6 n i~ I--s·=, sa ;~i-515'9: r·-q'i !.H--;2~·,. o u o. o 24 o o o. o 2~ o o o. o 12 u o..;..~o-----------------iltilk_:_ ..... ~· l 1971 4672.6 619~ bq67.l 6491.2 b513.2 5971.8 53b4.l 431~~s 240uo.o 240oo.o 2400o.o 320G.o 1·975 4768.6 60ti9.o----,;a55ob bltJ6.5 63bi.2 5boo.t 5185.4 4156.,8 240oo .. o 24ouo.o 2400b.o 3zoo.o I 1_.1 • n tql9 4934.5 6318.5 713b.O b72d.l 681J.8 6271.b Sb22ol 44~2.4 24000.0 24000.0 24000.u 3200.0 -198o-463i:s-se'i7~5·----b6i6:-9--&i5·r:-o-6i1V:·s---ssls.T-49ao:7··-l9'1'4:42lto·(ftf;o-24o(f0.-o· zqooo:-o~--2uo.o·---------------- I• I lq6t 4635.8 61J3.4 68b6.q b3b6.1 b314.7 5bq2.3 5047.6 4071.4 24000.0 2'1000.0 24000.0 3200.0 --,-98~~:~s~~r-n~9:~~~-1~):&~~~4--6~~;J-5ti~.~ij~~.o24rou~or.~o~z~q~o~u~o-.~o-~n~a~3~.~2~---------------- • __ A_VL_!680~87~L-!~8·! bOH5.2 b054.~_,490~~~8!2_~U52.42400U~.o_2_4_3~q~6~·~7~2~4~5~2~1~·-d __ 4~8~6~u~.2~------------------ / • ------·----------·------_____ ...... ______ ------- l ~. I I· le l ' l -~----! • --·-·· ! .. ·--· -· -· -· j! ---···-· I • ---· -· --_------------ ~ --·-·-. -·· ! • ---····--1 ----- I 12 -- ! .11 Li l ·:·r---·-·--,··-~ • f; . --~ .. ---... --"----,..--...-...---.~~-· ~-r,- ·------------------------------·· ------ ..................... "~--"-'"····~ .. ----~·--' -· ~,.__, ... ~------·~~-·---··--·~ "!*'t~ / ,•, I ·~~~ ,, I' ~ I! l ~ II I I .... ~------~~--------------~--~--~~~--~------~~,---~~ ... ~ ....... ~ ....... 'MJ ~--~----···---...... ~-4-------~-----____..,_.......~.-.....----...,._____,_~~-·--...._.:....----~~--·-----·~~~--.--..~-~------.. ~.-· __ ,___,M~--------------~-----.. --...---.~-~--- -,.,.,"V"W"l "! I I liiii lliiiii .iiiii t?ii:W ~ -. 4VEHAGE CAPAHILITIES (MW) ~ ( ··-~ p·;.........:...: ~-:.-=-iiii.:iil ~ 0. l~:.il !i~ ~ liP-!!"Ji / l~~ """J { 1'1 'i'i.J;, r::_ __ i r-.·. ~ " r. . . 4 J;; 1 ·• --1 ~~~::~-~..... ~ ,, .. f~ Attachment 7b.S Page 7 of 7 .. --·--· ·---------·---------.. ··-·-·-----··-··-·-· ··-- r-1 ---·-···----·-..... . ·-~· 1r.tlc 10"' .Toln,S.f:.'_'_f: ,7 _________ ~ s APk MAY JUN JUL AIJG SEP 6 UCT NOV OEC JAN FEH MAH --=J,...,.O~H~NS.,...O_N ____ _.,;i!b'-. -l)b-.--n2·;'-22""6 • 22q. 2l0. ~b. 219. 219. 216. 219. 225. 1 ----to'riC-· ·----· 2lb·~-.. tlb·~--232~--2'2tf;-· ·z2tf .. · · ·z2o·;--··"2tb-;·---z-rc,-.-~T4-;-z-r6". 2111. 225. HiN-I)hJMCAPAfHTft iES ··ct-ilwr-----·-----·-·----· --·--·--·· --·-··---·-------------------------------------------------- 8 9 1( 11 UCT 201. N£fv--oEt 197. 1H6., JAN 177. FEU lb7. MAR lSS. A-PH 141. H MAlr-·---Jr.~~N~--~J~u~[----7Anu~G----Sn.E~P~---------------------------------------- JOHNS UN IqH. 1st. 1q1. aq4. 1sq. --· TOTAL . -------?.~!.!._~_!?_7 .!_ ____ !Hb ._ 177_. __ ! b1. _!55 .. __ !_~ 1. lllti .. 151. 143. 1'14. 154. AVERAGE ENEHGY PHOOUCTION (GWH) ---·--__ · ________ p_~_! __ ~ny ____ 5 o_EC ______ ,~~f~...--fi7E~~-M!-R _, .. ___ AP~~~YB Ji-~Nrl,O J~ AUG SEl~..:i·~NN... 4 t 3 JOHNSON· 4c:.b ~1.b &.9 ~.;, • ., 4 .,t) q,.c: 40.c: ~q. • . • u.2 \l.,\) 4 •" • 8~ --rot'lt.: t f. t f: l 1:' l . t I. ·~> I . I 42;·6"--s-r.-e,-~;s;«r-sr.-9~7-;r--~r.e-lfo-.;! 34--.-& ;;wnr. r,.o o.z o .. o 1u.o :soa:&":"'t" 4-Z3 MINIMUM ENERGY PRODUCT11JN.{GWH1 JOHNSON (1982) -ocr··-··-NOV ·-·-·oEc--· JAr~--FT8--~lA~---APR--HAY---JU~JOL 41.5 51.3 56.8 53.9 47.,ti ~7.2 40.~ 33.6 132.0 0.2 JUG u .. o SEts ANN 22.5 529.2 I 1 I -:l --l I l l ~ l J ! I ! ~ ! - t ! l ~ ! - l -------·------------------------------------------------------- TOTAl., (1982) qJ.5 51.3 58.8 SJ.9 tO.& 47.,2 40.2 JJ.ti 132.0 0..!...2 0.0 c!2.S 529.2 .. ------------- ---------------------------------··-·---·-----·-· --------· -·---------------· ·------·-··-· A Jtld c. .1Vl p. 4-·-------------· --. 5et! 1 -----.. -----· --. ---------·----'-------------------------------------------------------- -----· ---·------·--. -----· . ----------------··--·------ ·-·---·---- --------~------------------------·---·----------------------------------------------------------------------------- .... ... .... --"~"--- ... --·----· ... ···--. -------·-·---·-------·---- !l --.----·--·--··-----------------···-------------------------------------------------------------------------------· •. 11 _., .. ·~---___ ,.._ ... _ ~ .... IG 9 -~-· .. -· •• k :-~--·~-~·-·-··---···-·--·--· , I :. ' ~ .·'.' c • :i c ~ f I ~ ... I :l'J l : .j l ~] I . 1'11"\ I :f I .. l ,J:.J -I I ] fPl fli .I ._l'~ I ~~ l (._ 8. I ·::::: i) _, --~--~--~~-~~ QUESTION The Anchorage Chamber of Commerce recently provided a report prepared by KENTCO entitled "Electric Power Generation for the Alaska Railbelt Region," January 1984. If available, please provide the following information: a) A copy of the report by the GoverLor's Economic Comrni.ttee on North Slope Gas, January 1983 - "Trans Alaska Gas System -Economics of an Alternative for the North Slop~ Natural Gas." b) The Harza -Ebasco Fall, 1983 update of the Susitna Hydroelectric Project Study referred to on pages 56 and 61 of the KENTCO report. I ~ i i I I l ,~' RESPONSE The requested report by the Governor's Economic Committee on North Slope Gas, entitled "Trans Alaska Gas Systems -Economics of an Alternative for North Slope Gas" (January 1983), is provided herewith as Volume IV, Appendix 3. 49. I I . -------~-~~ I _j I I n Ll :._ j n 11 :TI. . ; "u The "Harza-Ebasco Fall, 1983 update," referenced in the KENTCO report, was a document prepared in draft form for internal Power Authority discussion and was never released to the public. A revised version of tha.t ~update" was prepared in February, 1984 and, at the direction of the Power Authority Board of Directors, was the subject of Statewide public hearings. The February draft has not yet been finalized as a Power Authority final report. At such time as the report becomes final, the Power Authority would be willing to provide the FERC with a copy. 50. -~. I ! !' l