HomeMy WebLinkAboutAlaska Electric Vehicle Wworking Group Quarterly Meeting Notes 02-18-2020-EVAlaska Electric Vehicle Working Group
Quarterly Meeting
February 18, 2020
Location
Alaska Energy Authority, 813 W Northern Lights Blvd, Anchorage, AK.
Or Join Zoom Meeting
https://alaska.zoom.us/j/332082711
Call-In Number
+1 929 205 6099 US
Meeting ID: 332 082 711
Notes
Meeting Started at 10 am
Introductions around the room / phone
25 people attended:
Sean Skaling - CEA
Josh Craft - MEA
Tim Leach – Sparkbox
Michelle Wilber - ACEP
Betsy McGregor - AEA
Kyle Kornelis - City of Soldotna
Tim Demarr - GVEA
Kirk Martakis - Cantwell
Connie Fredenberg – Northern Arizona University contractor for Tribal VW funds
Ed Jenkin - MEA
Brian Winnestaffer - Chickaloon Village
Shaina Kilcoyne - MOA
Pierce Scwalb - MOA
DawnRae Dufford - Senator Costello’s office
JD Draves - HEA
Bruce Shelley - HEA
Crystal Enkvist – Alaska Power Association
Louis Flora -AK Center
Dale Banks - Homer
Alec Mesdag – AEL&P
Eric Taylor - AKDOT
RJ Harrington - National Car Charging
Dimitri Shein – Alaska Electric Vehicle Association (AKEVA)
Chris Rose - REAP
Duff Mitchell – Juneau Electric Vehicle Association
Online polling used: 44% of participants are utility staff, 13% agency staff, 13% municipal staff, 13%
consumer advocate, 6% researcher, 13% other
Presentation - Tim Leach: EV Trends and Market Barriers
China driving the global market
Buses lead in market share
Commitments by auto industry recently
Price of batteries have plummeted
Federal and local subsidies and programs
Beneficial Electrification - price parity on total ownership costs within 3-5 years
(Josh - this will drive sharp rise in uptake, Dimitri - its a better car altogether)
● Spreads fixed costs of electricity over more sales - consumer cost savings
● Grid benefits - can shape load etc
● Emissions reductions
Barriers: purchase price, range anxiety, Battery capacity, Lack of charging infrastructure,
demand charge, cold weather performance
Another POLL: Biggest barriers: Cold weather, knowledge, purchase price, charging, lack,
availability
A Brief Orientation to Alaska EV Action
AEL&P – Alec Mesdag
Traction with EVs in 2013
Experimental rate schedule in Jan 2011 (filed in 2010)
3 Year Enrollment window - 10 customers participate in exp. Rate
2013 - had 2, got last 8 right before end
Ran it for 3 year period
Grant from Juneau - $25,000 matched to $30,000 raised locally for charging infrastructure
Drive electric events
Word of mouth
Lots of awareness of viability!
65 Nissan Leafs at end of 3 year window (2016)
Filed for permanent rate schedule - shortened overnight window by a couple hours
Made a new rate schedule - offer chargers for ~$10 rental/month that automatically work with schedule
Time of use rate 10pm - 5am, own equipment or rental equipment - for those on non-demand rate
schedule
After this had >100 EVs in town (2017)
Now ~350-400 EVs in town
Bit of growth in # of public chargers 23 level 2, 4? Level 3’s in town - helps!
More vehicles (Bolts and Teslas) helps spur growth
No Nissan dealership/service in town - problem - have to send to Seattle for major work
Looking forward to more types of vehicles
Applied for and awarded SCA?? low emission grants - purchased a bus to arrive late this year, plan for 1
or 2 more.
Easier to participate in EV rate right as install level 2 charging station - that’s the time to get into the rate
schedule!! 90 total participants. 100 EVs there before rate. ~½ of those participating use the rental
chargers
CEA and MEA on behalf of EV Task Force
Sean Skaling:
History of EV Task Force was first: Alaska Utility Ad Hoc Working Group started with CEA/MLP
coordination in 2017, brought in MEA early 2018 - coordinating and sharing
Ended up with all the RB utilities, DOT, Muni, industry, AKEVA participating
GVEA helped with putting together a map - AEA’s need to address VW settlement - locations for
charging - where could and couldn’t go
Morphed into the task force -> Josh Craft:
MOA leading the efforts, focus shifted to VW settlement and how to prepare to use those funds
Discussed the goal of the funds, how to meet those goals. Regional EV readiness plan:
Traffic patterns - where cars were
VW: reduce emissions - NOX, GHG
Tried to align readiness goals to the plan - increase EV penetration as much as possible, so focus on
where the vehicles are now for charging infrastructure. Looked at how much NOX emissions could be
reduced, etc. through Sept. 2019, now on hiatus to see how VW settlement goes.
3-15 level 3’s, what chargers are available etc. - documents and maps available
MEA did an informal FB poll of members - range anxiety, cold weather, purchase price main barriers. 52
EV owners responded with experience - Blogs put together - can find on MEA FB page (Stephanie
Nowers and Mike Maleski?? Sam (willow) etc. did one.)
Cordova Electric – Clay Koplin
Promoting EVs and ASHPs (excess hydro is spilled at times)
4 free EV charging stations - Sacramento (SMUD) helped a lot
Joined Juneau Leaf users group to understand better
DOE and national labs coordination (grid modernization project) - working back end of EVs -
dispatchable, transactive grid with EVs - V2G - asset for managing loads into the future. 3 EVs on the
road including utility car. Not had high adoption. Disappointed that new ICEs are on the street
Electrify Alaska Conference April 27-29 - get successful SE communities to share, NRECA, DOE/Labs, etc
to give presentations, encourage utilities with low adoption rates (EVs and ASHPs) to participate. Clay
has a seat on electric? advisory committee with DOE - open their eyes to AK, microgrid potential.
Strength if we tackle grants etc together and add bandwidth. Highly successful integration of grid scale
battery. Looking at offering local incentives (cash rebates) for EVs. Have robust chargers ($700 but
rated NEMA4 wet locations - 5 year warranty - level 2) no internal electronics. Might group purchase
and give to businesses to put on back of meter, instead of messing with rates!
Alaska Electric Vehicle Association – Dimitri Shein
AKEVA.org
Advocate for EV owners
Educate public
Support charging infrastructure development - As a non-profit can fundraise and help installations
happen
Facilitate local/state policy - RCA presentation Feb 26 on rate issues
Promote EVSE investment in AK
EV ride and drive: Wasilla and Palmer - Apr 24 (events at: Newcome Park Wasilla 2:30pm - 4:30pm
ride and drive, Turkey Red - 5:15pm - 6:15pm learn to charge an EV, 7am - 2pm see EVs at Wasilla High
truck and car show) and Anchorage - August 2 – park strip w/ CEA
Working on a for profit with AEA and Launch Alaska to launch a rental fleet
Tech Session Report
Jan 30th meeting discussed demand charges. Will be approx. monthly meetings - next one first week in
March, on Technical issues with siting, criteria for site selection (Josh etc present work done to date)
9AM Feb 26 RCA presentation on demand charges, EV issues -
Presentations by Tim L, Dimitry, Devon, ACEP (Michelle)
Sean: can presentations be available beforehand? Shaina/Pierce should send out before.
Presentation -Betsy McGregor: VW Settlement Opportunity and
Process
1.2 M$ to EV charging infrastructure - that is a set number! Breakdowns have some flexibility (road
system and off road, DCFC/level2 etc)
Held back on RFP. good opportunity with DOE FOA to leverage funds: separate concept papers for each
area of interest - concept papers due at end of the week. Cordova - dispatchable EVs, Muni - electric
garbage trucks with muni match, overall charging network w AKEVA plan for EV rental company
Still looking for partners. Submit concept paper, then if told to move forward, grant ap due by April -
need letters of support. Pulling in lots of partners. For State procurement - might need to put out an rfp
for a vendor. Looking for site hosts - RFI/RFA. Planning involved, not shotgun approach.
Chris Rose: Fast vs. level 2 chargers? He wants to see fast chargers - to really open up the market. Tim L
- has been critical to developments to other markets
Betsy - some funding to each on road belt, flexible on breakdown. Open to discussion. $550M to DCFC
so far, rest to level 2.
Alaska EV Working Group Structure and Function
Tabled to accommodate more discussion of Demand Charges and the Feb. 26th RCA Meeting.
Tim L. will send out email with questions that will help inform the discussion and development of the
group’s structure and function.
What are the problems to solve, what are the barriers, have folks from various groups in the
conversation.
Start thinking about your answers:
Why have this group?
What would you like to have this group do and by when?
What form should this group take?
Some members with Voting ability to make official recommendations?
Or informal?
Meeting Wrap-up
Next meeting set for May 5, 2020 10 am – 12 pm at Alaska Energy Authority
Adjourn 11:45 am