HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-05-03 IMC Agenda and docs INTERTIE MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE (IMC) REGULAR MEETING May 3, 2024 9:00 am Alaska Energy Authority Board Room 813 W Northern Lights Blvd, Anchorage, AK 99503
To participate dial 1-888-585-9008 and use code 212-753-619#
1. CALL TO ORDER
2. ROLL CALL FOR COMMITTEE MEMBERS
3. PUBLIC ROLL CALL
4. PUBLIC COMMENTS
5. AGENDA APPROVAL
6. APPROVAL OF PRIOR MINUTES – March 22, 2024
7. NEW BUSINESS
8. OLD BUSINESS
A. Approval of FY 25 IMC Budget
9. COMMITTEE REPORTS
A. Budget to Actuals
B. IOC Committee
C. Operator Report
10. MEMBERS COMMENTS
11. NEXT MEETING DATE – June 21, 2024
12. ADJOURNMENT
Page 1 of 8
Alaska Energy Authority
Alaska Intertie
Date: March 22, 2024
Proposed FY2025 Budget
Page 2 of 8
ALASKA ENERGY AUTHORITY
ALASKA INTERTIE
FY25 Proposed Budget Contents
Description Page #
FY25 Proposed Budget Summary 3
O&M Budget 4-5
Grant Budget 6
Usage Projection 7
AK Intertie MITCR 8
Page 3 of 8
Alaska Intertie FY25 Proposed Budget
Proposed Budget Summary
Revenues O&M Grant Total Total GVEA Total CEA Total MEA Total HEA Total
Revenue from Operations 3,966,365 - 3,966,365 2,838,837 431,626 695,903 - 3,966,365
Grant Match - 536,362 536,362 442,794 32,859 60,709 4,805 536,362
3,966,365 536,362 4,502,727 3,281,630 464,485 756,612 4,805 4,502,727
Expenses
Operations 2,957,100 - 2,957,100
Admin 785,000 - 785,000
Grant - 536,362 536,362
3,742,100 536,362 4,278,462
Surplus/(Shortage)224,265 - 224,265
(Total Paid by Utilities)
Page 4 of 8
Alaska Intertie FY25 Proposed Budget
data @ 1/4/24
FY24 Approved Draft
FY21 FY22 FY23 ACTUALS FY24 FY25
Actual Actual Actual 12/31/23 Budget Budget
REVENUES
GVEA 1,942,988 2,075,721 1,632,539 2,008,550 3,631,114 2,838,837
CEA 290,065 265,259 405,435 322,773 471,717 431,626
MEA 460,479 413,239 450,409 328,562 654,520 695,903
INTEREST 903 1,668 58,981 19,609 - -
TOTAL REVENUES 2,694,435 2,755,887 2,547,364 2,679,494 4,757,352 3,966,365
EXPENSES
FERC 562 - Station Operation Expenses
GVEA - Substation Electricity Usage 9,382 45,889 478 - -
9,382 45,889 478 - - -
FERC 566 - Miscellaneous Transmission Expense
Private Line Telephone Service for AKI SCADA (GVEA)5,556 5,556 5,788 5,005 6,000 6,000
Cell Phone Comm. Svc for Weather Monitoring (Verizon)11,904 12,025 11,983 - 13,000 13,000
SLMS Support and Intertie Ground Patrol 98,540 154,947 145,346 21,205 175,000 175,000
116,000 172,528 163,116 26,210 194,000 194,000
FERC 567 - Transmission Expenses - Rents
Rents - Alaska Railroad 700 700 1,500 1,000 1,000 1,000
MEA - Talkeetna Storage 7,200 7,200 7,200 2,400 7,200 7,200
Equipment Rental - 375 102 - - -
7,900 8,275 8,802 3,400 8,200 8,200
FERC 569 Maintenance of Structures
MEA - Re-insulate 20 dead-end structures - - - - 75,000 300,000
MEA - Re-insulate 30 tangent structures - - - 75,000 250,000
- - - - 150,000 550,000
FERC 570 - Maintenance of Station Equipment
GVEA - HLSB17 Sync PT Replacement - - - - - 25,000
GVEA - Healy, Cantwell, Goldhill 154,917 63,163 141,248 125,000 64,500
GVEA - Replace Healy Substation Breaker B17 - - - - - 350,000
GVEA - Healy and Goldhill Digital Fault Recorders - 53,255 - - - -
GVEA - Gold Hill SVC Cooling - 460 - - - -
GVEA - Cantwell Install Breakers or Load Break Switches - 182,606 - - 306,000 306,000
GVEA - Cantwell 4S2 Switch Repair - - 43,217 - - -
GVEA - Perform Maintenance, repaint Reactors Healy SVC Yard 145,494 - 4,472 - - -
GVEA - Perform Maintenance, repaint Reactors Gold Hill SVC Yard - 7,452 - - - -
GVEA - Capacitor Spares - - - - 20,000 -
GVEA - Cantwell Standby Generator Replacement 29,016 - - - - -
GVEA - SVC Intertie Trust Fund Eligible Expenses - - - - -
GVEA - Intertie - SVC Project - - - - 50,000
CEA - AK Intertie Yard - - - - -
CEA - Teeland Substation Communication - - - - 5,000 5,000
CEA - Teeland Substation 183,401 115,365 74,128 82,488 170,000 170,000
CEA - Douglas Substation Communication - - - 1,554 - 2,400
MEA - Douglas Substation 26,115 - - 1,441 - -
MEA - Douglas Substation 138 kV BKR Inspections - - - - 25,000 25,000
CEA - Telecomm Support (Douglas, Teeland, Anc-Fbks Leased Circuits)- 1,742 - - - -
538,943 424,043 263,065 85,482 651,000 997,900
FERC 571 - Maintenance of Overhead Lines
GVEA - Northern Maintenance 68,204 107,641 99,464 - 150,000 -
GVEA - Northern ROW Clearing 36,721 68,882 328,252 - 550,000 550,000
GVEA - Northern ROW Remote Sensing and Analysis - - - - 400,000 -
GVEA - Landing Pads - - - - 75,000 75,000
GVEA - Re-level Structures & Adjust Guys - - - - 80,000 -
Page 5 of 8
GVEA - Repair Tower 531 Foundation - - - - 150,000 -
GVEA - Repair Tower 532 Foundation - - - - 150,000 -
GVEA - Helicopter Patrols - - - - - 80,000
MEA - Special Patrols [Incl Helicopter Inspections]- 599 11,603 - - 15,000
MEA - Southern Maint (Incl Ground and Climbing Inspect)138,199 191,358 78,729 - 140,000 140,000
MEA - Southern ROW Clearing 228,413 168,367 525,520 - 500,000 300,000
MEA - Southern ROW Remote Sensing and Analysis - - - - 125,000 10,000
MEA - Equipment Repair and Replacement 780,866 76,494 803,393 152,755 350,000 -
1,252,403 613,341 1,846,961 152,755 2,670,000 1,170,000
FERC 924 - Property Insurance
AK Intertie - Insurance 38,773 37,133 40,178 11,334 37,000 37,000
38,773 37,133 40,178 11,334 37,000 37,000
Intertie Operating Costs Total 1,963,401 1,301,209 2,322,601 279,180 3,710,200 2,957,100
FERC 570 - Maintenance of Station Equipment
MEA - Replace Protective Relay Schemes Douglas - - - - - -
- - - - -
Intertie Cost of Improvements Total - - - - - -
FERC 920 - AEA Administrative Costs
Personal Services, Travel and Other Costs 210,409 235,608 190,236 49,077 230,000 250,000
210,409 235,608 190,236 49,077 230,000 250,000
FERC 920 - IMC Administrative Costs
IMC Administrative Costs (Audit, meetings, legal)30,890 29,276 14,579 2,861 20,000 20,000
30,890 29,276 14,579 2,861 20,000 20,000
FERC 566 - Miscellaneous Transmission Expense
Misc Studies: System Reserves Study (IBR), PSS/E maint,
230 kV Upgrade System Impact Study 186,675 145,327 150,368 28,200 266,000 515,000
LIDAR study (complete lidar, vegetation, PLS CADD file with drawings, structure/foundation
movement, infrared, and imaging)
226,125 - - - - -
Synchrophaser System (Moved to GRANT BUDGET worksheet)- - - 250,000 -
412,800 145,327 150,368 28,200 516,000 515,000
Intertie Administration Costs Total 654,099 410,211 355,182 80,138 766,000 785,000
TOTAL EXPENSE 2,617,500 1,711,420 2,677,783 359,318 4,476,200 3,742,100
SURPLUS (SHORTAGE)76,935 1,044,468 (130,419) 2,320,176 281,152 224,265
Page 6 of 8
Alaska Intertie FY25 Proposed Budget
Utility Grant Matching Contributions
Snow Loading Grant to re-insulate from Douglas north 80 miles
(Proposed Allocation Option #2 - Revenue excluding Admin Fee from Allocation)
GVEA Grant Submittal to AEA ($13.8M grant with $3M in matching funds & $500k in-kind in-house labor) AEA to revise per agreed payment
Total Match Amount
491,167$
Percent FY24
Power Purchaser Share Match Year Project Total Cost Grant Reimbursement Grant Match (Cash and In-Kind)
1 $1,964,668 $1,473,501 $491,167
GVEA 81.95%402,511 2 $2,942,956 $2,207,217 $735,739
CEA 6.69%32,859 3 $2,942,956 $2,207,217 $735,739
MEA 11.36%55,797 4 $2,942,956 $2,207,217 $735,739
5 $2,965,356 $2,224,017 $741,339
100.00%491,167 Total $13,758,890 $10,319,167 $3,439,722
Synchrophaser System Grant
(Proposed Allocation Option #3 - Revenue Excluding Capacity and Admin Fee from Allocation)
Per GVEA Grant Submittal to AEA ($2.2M grant with $50k in matching funds & $500k in-kind in-house labor) AEA to revise budget for approved payment methods
Total Match Amount
50,000$
HEA is contributing because they are receiving benefit from the Synchrophaser System (Railbelt wide)
Percent FY24 This is 9.61% of the Total Match Amount and is based on their load ratio share per resolution.
Power Purchaser Share Match
HEA (Load Ratio Share)9.61%4,805 Year Project Cost Railbelt Utilities
Combined Cash Match
Railbelt Utilities
In Kind Contribution Grant Contribution
1 $440,245 $9,839 $100,222 $330,183
GVEA 89.13%40,282 2 $440,245 $9,839 $100,222 $330,183
CEA 0.00%- 3 $440,245 $9,839 $100,222 $330,183
MEA 10.87%4,913 4 $440,245 $9,839 $100,222 $330,183
5 $440,245 $9,839 $100,222 $330,183
100.00%45,195 Total $2,201,225 $49,195 $501,110 $1,650,915
DOE Resiliency Grant - AK Intertie Snow Load Resiliency
DOE Resiliency Grant - Synchrophasor Project - Five Year Average
Page 7 of 8
Alaska Intertie FY25 Proposed Budget
True up
to
Contract GVEA MEA CEA TOTAL USAGE CAPACITY ADMIN CASH FLOW
MONTH Value MWH MWH MWH MWH GVEA MEA CEA GVEA MEA CEA GVEA | MEA | CEA TOTALS
Jul 12,275 2,187 0 14,462 $160,554 $28,603 $0 $244,140 $74,181 $169,959 $65,417 $742,854
Aug 14,077 2,295 0 16,372 $184,125 $30,017 $0 $65,417 $279,559
Sep 14,766 2,210 0 16,976 $193,137 $28,908 $0 $65,417 $287,461
Oct 27,634 2,165 0 29,799 $361,455 $28,312 $0 $65,417 $455,184
Nov 27,147 2,339 0 29,486 $355,078 $30,600 $0 $65,417 $451,094
Dec 26,405 2,633 0 29,038 $345,372 $34,440 $0 $65,417 $445,229
Jan 11,268 2,458 0 13,726 $147,383 $32,152 $0 $65,417 $244,952
Feb 11,151 2,261 0 13,412 $145,858 $29,574 $0 $65,417 $240,848
Mar 7,727 2,466 0 10,193 $101,074 $32,250 $0 $65,417 $198,741
Apr 10,367 2,258 0 12,625 $135,598 $29,532 $0 $65,417 $230,546
May 10,823 2,321 0 13,144 $141,560 $30,364 $0 $65,417 $237,340
Jun 4,728 1,935 0 6,662 $61,837 $25,303 $0 $65,417 $152,557
TOTAL 0 178,366 27,527 0 205,893 $2,333,030 $360,055 $0 $244,140 $74,181 $169,959 $785,000 $3,966,365
Total Energy:$2,693,085 Total Capacity :$488,280
205,893 MWH
188,736 MWH
204,984 MWH TOTAL MWH REVENUE $3,966,365
O&M BUDGET - Operating 2,957,100
-
O&M BUDGET - Administrative 785,000
UTILITY FY 25 TOTAL O&M BUDGET 3,742,100
MEA 30.40%23.70 MW SURPLUS (SHORTAGE)$224,265
CEA 69.60%54.30 MW
GVEA 100.00%78.00 MW Annual Participant Administrative Contribution 261,666.67
156.0 Monthly Contribution per Participant 21,805.56
Usage Rate per KWH 0.01308$
Capacity Rate $3.13
Section 7.2.2 MINIMUM USAGE CONTRACT VALUE
ALASKA INTERTIE
FISCAL YEAR 2025
ENERGY PROJECTION
TOTAL INTERTIE PROJECTED ENERGY USAGE
Usage estimate reduced by 1/12 of Total for rate calculations
Page 8 of 8
Alaska Intertie FY25 Proposed Budget
Annual System Demand
21-22 22-23 23-24 3 YR AVG.
SOUTHERN UTILITY PARTICIPANTS (MW)
CEA 349.8 343.8 322.9 338.8 MW APPROVED APPROVED APPROVED APPROVED APPROVED
MEA 146.0 147.0 150.7 147.9 MW 6/30/2025 6/30/2024 6/30/2023 6/30/2022 6/30/2021
UNITS FY25 FY24 FY23 FY22 FY21
USAGE KWH 188,736,000 251,476,000 415,247,000 187,902,000 187,902,000
OPERATING BUDGET $2,957,100 3,710,200 2,544,100 1,992,890 2,007,385
MITCR KW 156,000 156,000 156,000 156,100 156,000
TOTAL 486.7 MW
ENERGY (A)$.000/KWH $0.01308 $0.01232 $0.00512 $0.00886 $0.00892
NORTHERN UTILITY PARTICIPANTS (MW)
CAPACITY (B)$/KW $3.13 $3.92 $2.69 $2.11 $2.12
GVEA 198.3 205.5 205.5 203.1 MW
TOTAL 203.1 MW
MITCR DETERMINATION
FY 25 KWH CAP RATE CAP CHARGES
MEA 30.40%23.70 MW 23,700 $3.13 74,181.00
CEA 69.60%54.30 MW 54,300 $3.13 169,959.00
GVEA 100.00%78.00 MW 78,000 $3.13 244,140.00
156.00 MW 156,000 488,280.00
(A) See Section 7.2.5 AK Intertie Agreement
(B) See Section 7.2.6 AK Intertie Agreement
MINIMUM INTERTIE TRANSFER CAPABILITY RIGHTS
(MITCR) DETERMINATION
FOR FISCAL YEAR 2025
Page 1 of 4
Alaska Energy Authority
AK Intertie Budget to Actual Revenues and Expenses
07/01/2023 to 02/29/2024
Page 2 of 4
FY24 Approved
Budget
BUDGET
07/01/2023 -
02/29/2024 Actuals
YTD Actuals as a
% of Total
Annual Budget
OVER (UNDER)
YTD Variance
Revenue From Utilities
AKI-GVEA 3,631,114 2,484,635 3,201,341 88%716,706
AKI-CEA 471,717 386,606 386,606 82%-
AKI-MEA 654,520 473,227 481,987 74%8,760
Total Revenue From Utilities 4,757,352 3,344,468 4,069,934 86%725,466
Interest - - 47,604 0%47,604
Total Revenues 4,757,352 3,344,468 4,117,538 87%773,070
Total Revenues 4,757,352 3,344,468 4,117,538 87%773,070
56600 Misc Transmission Expense
Alaska Energy Authority
AK Intertie-Cell Phone Comm. Svc. for Wx Monitorng 13,000 8,667 7,005 54%(1,661)
AK Intertie-Miscellaneous Studies as Needed 516,000 344,000 28,200 5%(315,800)
Alaska Energy Authority Total 529,000 352,667 35,205 7%(317,461)
Golden Valley Electric
AK Intertie-Private Line Telephone Service SCADA 6,000 4,000 - 0%(4,000)
Golden Valley Electric Total 6,000 4,000 - 0%(4,000)
56601 Weather Monitoring Batteries
Alaska Energy Authority
AK Intertie-SLMS Support & Intertie Ground Patrol 175,000 116,667 91,609 52%(25,058)
Alaska Energy Authority Total 175,000 116,667 91,609 52%(25,058)
56700 Rents
Alaska Energy Authority
AK Intertie-Alaska Railroad 1,000 667 1,000 100%333
Alaska Energy Authority Total 1,000 667 1,000 100%333
Matanuska Electric Association
AK Intertie-Talkeetna Storage 7,200 4,800 4,200 58%(600)
Matanuska Electric Association Total 7,200 4,800 4,200 58%(600)
56900 Maintenance of Structures
Matanuska Electric Association
AK Intertie-Maintenance of Structures 150,000 100,000 - 0%(100,000)
Matanuska Electric Association Total 150,000 100,000 - 0%(100,000)
57000 Maintenance of Station Equip
Chugach Electric Association
AK Intertie-Teeland Substation 175,000 116,667 85,468 49%(31,199)
AK Intertie-Douglas Substation Communications - - 1,554 0%1,554
Chugach Electric Association Total 175,000 116,667 87,021 50%(29,646)
Golden Valley Electric
AK Intertie-Healy, Cantwell, Goldhill 125,000 83,333 - 0%(83,333)
AK Intertie-Cantwell 4S2 Switch Repair 306,000 204,000 - 0%(204,000)
AK Intertie-Capacitor Spares 20,000 13,333 - 0%(13,333)
Golden Valley Electric Total 451,000 300,667 - 0%(300,667)
Matanuska Electric Association
AK Intertie-Douglas Substation 25,000 16,667 3,118 12%(13,549)
Matanuska Electric Association Total 25,000 16,667 3,118 12%(13,549)
57100 Maint of OH Lines
Golden Valley Electric
AK Intertie-Northern Maintenance 150,000 100,000 - 0%(100,000)
AK Intertie-Landing Pads 75,000 50,000 - 0%(50,000)
Golden Valley Electric Total 225,000 150,000 - 0%(150,000)
AK Intertie-Special Patrols (Incl Foundation Insp)- - 6,510 0%6,510
AK Intertie-Southern Maint. (Incl Ground Insp)140,000 93,333 - 0%(93,333)
AK Intertie-Equipment Repair & Replacement 350,000 233,333 167,443 48%(65,890)
Matanuska Electric Association Total 490,000 326,667 173,953 36%(152,713)
ALASKA ENERGY AUTHORITY
AK INTERTIE BUDGET TO ACTUAL REVENUE AND EXPENSES
FOR THE PERIOD 07/01/2023 THROUGH 02/29/2024
Page 3 of 4
FY24 Approved
Budget
BUDGET
07/01/2023 -
02/29/2024 Actuals
YTD Actuals as a
% of Total
Annual Budget
OVER (UNDER)
YTD Variance
ALASKA ENERGY AUTHORITY
AK INTERTIE BUDGET TO ACTUAL REVENUE AND EXPENSES
FOR THE PERIOD 07/01/2023 THROUGH 02/29/2024
57101 Extra Ord Maint of OH Lines
Golden Valley Electric
AK Intertie-Re-level Structures & Adjust Guys 80,000 53,333 - 0%(53,333)
Golden Valley Electric Total 80,000 53,333 - 0%(53,333)
57102 Maint OH Lines-ROW Clearing
AK Intertie-Northern ROW Clearing 550,000 366,667 - 0%(366,667)
AK Intertie-Northern ROW Remote Sensing 400,000 266,667 - 0%(266,667)
Repair Tower 531 Foundation 150,000 100,000 - 0%(100,000)
Repair Tower 532 Foundation 150,000 100,000 - 0%(100,000)
Golden Valley Electric Total 1,250,000 833,333 - 0%(833,333)
Matanuska Electric Association
AK Intertie-Southern ROW Clearing 500,000 333,333 - 0%(333,333)
AK Intertie-Southern ROW Remote Sensing 125,000 83,333 132,165 106%48,832
Matanuska Electric Association Total 625,000 416,667 132,165 21%(284,502)
58302 Operating Committee Exp-Legal
Alaska Energy Authority
AK Intertie-IMC Admin Cost (Audit, Meeting, Legal)- - 5,445 0%5,445
Alaska Energy Authority Total - - 5,445 0%5,445
58306 Misc Admin
Alaska Energy Authority
AK Intertie-IMC Admin Cost (Audit, Meeting, Legal)20,000 13,333 7,236 36%(6,097)
Alaska Energy Authority Total 20,000 13,333 7,236 36%(6,097)
58401 Insurance Premiums
Alaska Energy Authority
AK Intertie-Insurance 22,200 14,800 22,673 102%7,873
Alaska Energy Authority Total 22,200 14,800 22,673 102%7,873
Matanuska Electric Association
AK Intertie-Insurance 14,800 9,867 - 0%(9,867)
Matanuska Electric Association Total 14,800 9,867 - 0%(9,867)
Total Total Expense 4,246,200 2,830,800 563,625 13%(2,267,175)
Total Operating Expenses 4,246,200 2,830,800 563,625 13%(2,267,175)
71001 Total Expense, Budget
Alaska Energy Authority
Administrative Support Services 230,000 153,333 135,078 59%(18,255)
Alaska Energy Authority Total 230,000 153,333 135,078 59%(18,255)
Total Total Expense 230,000 153,333 135,078 59%(18,255)
Total AEA Administration Expenses 230,000 153,333 135,078 59%(18,255)
Total Expenses 4,476,200 2,984,133 698,704 16%(2,285,429)
Surplus (Shortage)281,152 360,335 3,418,835 1216%3,058,500
Page 4 of 4
Alaska Intertie FY24 Budget to Actuals Status Report for the Period 07/01/2023 through 02/29/2024
Budgeted Usage Actual Usage to Date
GVEA MEA CEA TOTAL GVEA MEA CEA TOTAL
MONTH MWH MWH MWH MWH MONTH MWH MWH MWH MWH
Jul 11,500 1,993 - 13,493 Jul 21,896 2,018 - 23,914
Aug 13,600 2,034 - 15,634 Aug 18,254 2,288 - 20,542
Sep 14,050 1,972 - 16,022 Sep 19,556 2,225 - 21,781
Oct 23,500 2,036 - 25,536 Oct 28,980 2,109 - 31,089
Nov 25,190 2,273 - 27,463 Nov 40,892 2,139 - 43,031
Dec 24,990 2,494 - 27,484 Dec 46,492 2,461 - 48,953
Jan 25,470 2,495 - 27,965 Jan 32,601 2,519 - 35,120
Feb 24,740 2,043 - 26,783 Feb 12,498 2,292 - 14,790
Mar 21,230 2,158 - 23,388 Mar - - - -
Apr 13,470 1,943 - 15,413 Apr - - - -
May 20,380 1,871 - 22,251 May - - - -
Jun 31,070 1,835 - 32,905 Jun - - - -
TOTAL 249,190 25,147 - 274,337 TOTAL 221,169 18,051 - 239,220
INTERTIE PROJECTED ENERGY USAGE TO DATE (MWH)153,597 INTERTIE ACTUAL ENERGY USAGE TO DATE (MWH) 239,220
Budgeted Operating Costs for the Period 2,830,800$ Actual Operating Costs for the Period 563,625$
(based on amended budget)
Budgeted Usage Revenue for the Period 1,892,315$ Actual (Billed) Usage Revenue for the Period 2,764,978$
(budgeted rate * projected usage)(budgeted rate * actual usage)
Estimated Budgeted Energy Rate per MWH 15.39$
(based on budgeted costs and usage)
Annual Budgeted Energy Rate (Billed Rate)12.32$ Projected Actual Energy Rate per MWH 1.97$
(based on minimum contract value)(based on actual costs and usage)
Intertie Management Committee Meeting
IOC Report
May 3, 2024
1.Intertie Operating Committee
a.In February GVEA submitted two grant applications on behalf of the IMC to AEA. Both
of those grants have been approved by AEA. GVEA is planning to manage both grants
for the IMC. For the Alaska Intertie Snow Load Remediation grant the design,
permitting, and material procurement are scheduled to run through the end of 2024.
Construction is planned over three years, starting in 2025 and ending in 2027. Each year
construction is anticipated to start in May and be completed in October. Total cost for
this work is estimated at $13,760,000, of which $10,320,00 will be paid for by the grant
and the remainder through the IMC as outlined in the proposed 2025 budget. For the
Alaska Railbelt Synchorphasor grant the initial phase of work will run through 2025 and
includes the basic setup of hardware and EPG’s software throughout the Railbelt. This
work will include setup and commissioning of servers and communication links between
utilities. Phase two of the project will run from 2026 through 2028 and includes the
addition of phasor measurement units (PMUs) at substations that were not included in
the initial phase. The final phase will run from 2028 to the second quarter of 2029 and it
will include a review of the system and additional PMUs as necessary to ensure optimal
functionality of the system. Total cost for this work is estimated at $2,200,000 of which
$1,650,000 will be paid for by the grant and the remainder through the IMC as outlined
in the proposed 2025 budget.
b.The draft primary frequency response policy was reviewed at the IOC meeting and an
updated draft is anticipated by the next IOC meeting. If there are no significant changes
to the draft policy, it will be moved to the IMC for review in June.
c.The IOC is reviewing a draft RFP for an IBR study that the SSS plans to execute. If there
are no substantial changes, the RFP for the study should be issued in July. Funding for
this study is included in the proposed 2025 IMC budget.
d.Renewable IPP currently has a 6-megawatt solar installation along Hawk Lane just north
of Big Lake. They are looking at expanding the site to include an additional 25-30
megawatts of solar. The expansion would potentially encroach on the Alaska Intertie
for approximately one and half miles, impacting structures 42 through 48. These
structures are steel X-frames or three pole angle structures. Their footprint ranges from
approximately 35’-45’ in width depending on the structure type. The total ROW width
through this area is 100’. The operational crews that maintain and clear this section of
line recommended an additional 15’ on both sides of the structures to allow heavy
equipment proper access. In addition, electrical clearance, assuming the panels are
classified as a “building”, requires approximately 17’ of clearance from the line to the
corner of the panel under NESC table 234-1. Based on both the electrical clearances and
operational requirements, no encroachment into the ROW is recommended at this time.
2.System Studies Subcommittee
a.The SSS has been working with EPS to update the governor model in PSS/e for Bradely
Lake. EPS has requested $57,500 in additional funding to update the model, as outlined
in Attachment 1. Funding for this change order has been included in the proposed 2025
IMC budget. Once the funding is approved, the IOC plans to recommend approval of
the change order.
b.An RFP has been issued by the SSS to look at what the system impacts would be if the
Alaska Intertie was upgraded to 230 KV. The study will look at capacity, stability,
regulation, and other key factors that may be impacted by the upgrade. Proposals for
the study have been received and are under evaluation. This work has been included in
the IMC’s proposed 2025 budget.
Attachment 1 – Bradely Lake PSS/e Governor Model Tuning - Change Order #1
WWW.EPSINC.COM
PHONE (425) 296-5411 4020 148TH AVE N.E., SUITE C, REDMOND, WA 98052
Mr. John Bell
Chugach Electric Association, Inc.
5601 Electron Drive, Bldg. A
Anchorage, AK 99518
March 20, 2024
Subject: Bradley Lake PSS/e Governor Model Tuning – Change Order #1
Mr. Bell,
Electric Power Systems (EPS) is pleased to present a change order proposal to Chugach Electric
Association, Inc. (CEA) and the Railbelt System Studies Subcommittee (SSS) for the model
benchmarking and tuning study of the PSS/e turbine / governor model for the Bradley Lake Hydro
plant, per your request. This change order pertains to the model tuning study performed in 2023
related to the oscillations observed along the Kenai Tie during over-frequency conditions.
Scope of Work
The following is the scope of work as discussed during our last conference call. As requested,
we have broken the scope into two main tasks.
Task One - Modeling
1. Reinvestigate the overspeed event of June 2021 where large scale undamped oscillations
were observed along the Kenai Tie. Investigate an alternate approach to modifying the
Bradley Lake turbine governor model within PSS/e as compared to the previous approach.
The previous approach involved changes to the divider positioning PID control loop
parameters. The proposed approach in this change order will involve modifications to the
divider / needle / turbine power curves, as discussed in our meeting.
2. Re-run the three events from the previous report and compare the simulation results to the
available recordings. One of the goals in this additional work is to eliminate the intra-plant
oscillations observed in the event 2 simulations from the previous study.
3. Document the findings on electronic form, including python scripts for PSS/e that apply the
recommended changes to the Bradley Lake model.
Task Two – Bradley Lake Model Documentation
1. Develop detailed documentation for the existing Bradley Lake turbine / governor model.
This includes tables for all model parameters, block diagrams where applicable, description
of all the control modes, and instructions for using the model within PSS/e including how to
initialize the model in different control modes.
BRADLEY LAKE PSS/E GOVERNOR MODEL TUNING – CHANGE ORDER #1
March 20, 2024 Page 2 WWW.EPSINC.COM
Cost
Our cost estimate for this effort is detailed below, broken into main tasks and sub-tasks. The total
time and materials estimated cost is $24,420.00 for Main Task One and $33,000.00 for Main Task
Two. This is a not-to-exceed cost estimate. Any additional scope of work will be discussed prior
to performing that work and will be subject to your approval. We expect to complete this study
within approximately 2 months after receiving a notice-to-proceed.
#Task
Staff
Engineer
Hours
Principal
Engineer
Hours
Cost
Main Task One
1.1 Retune event 1 60 20 $ 13,200.00
1.2 Run other events and compare 30 5 $ 5,280.00
1.3 Document findings and recommendations 25 10 $ 5,940.00
Main Task One Total 115 35 $ 24,420.00
Main Task Two
2.1 Detailed Documentation of Bradley Lake Model 150 50 $ 33,000.00
Total - Both Tasks 265 85 57,420.00$
Note: We will perform this study using the PSS/e version 34 models. All changes we recommend
and all documentation will be applicable to version 36 of PSS/e. When the Railbelt model is
updated to version 36 of PSS/e, all recommended changes to the Bradley Lake model will be
applied to the version 36 database, subject to approval by the SSS committee.
If you have any questions, or if I have not fully described the scope of work as we discussed,
please feel free to give me a call at 425-296-5411.
Sincerely,
James. W. Cote, Jr., Ph.D., P.E.
Principal Engineer
Intertie Management Committee Meeting
Operator Report
May 3, 2024
1. Alaska Intertie usage report
a. MWh usage – Measured at Douglas Substation, YTD
GVEA MEA Total
i. July – March FY24 238,539 20,338 258,877
ii. July – March FY23 191,919 20,404 212,323
iii. Delta - FY24 to FY23 24.29% -0.32% 21.93%
2. Alaska Intertie trips to report
No Alaska Intertie outages to report
3. IOC quarterly Reliability Report
For generation trips or transmission line trips where the loss of load is known, the Railbelt-wide
frequency response is calculated. The magnitude of the tripped power and the change in frequency
from the pre-trip value to the peak or nadir are used to calculate the MW/0.1Hz value often known as
‘Beta’. Chugach has calculated the Beta for several events and the table of the results is pasted below.
Events without data for the MW magnitude of the trip were excluded, as were events that did not cause
a frequency deviation greater than 0.2 Hz.
Event Date MW
Tripped
Pre-Trip
Frequency (Hz)
High /Low
Frequency
(Hz)
Frequency
Response
(MW/0.1Hz)
GVEA, Healy 2 Trip 3/21/2024 21.7 60.006 59.785 9.8
GVEA, Zehnder GT1 Trip 3/27/2024 Unknown 60.022 59.787 N/A
GVEA, Healy 2 Trip 4/10/2024 44.2 59.993 59.432 7.9
AEA, Bradley 2 Trip * 4/20/2024 47.91 59.996 59.150 5.7
• Significant oscillations on this event, see attachment.