The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutDRAFTREF5_RegionRank11x17DRAFT Alaska Renewable Energy Fund Regional Ranking and Funding Allocation - Round 5 1/11/2012 Energy_Dev_Region ID Project_Name Applicant_Name Applicant_Type Energy Source S2 Criteria Total Weight AEA BCE App BCE S3 Criteria 1 Weight S3 Criteria 2 Score S3 Criteria 3 Weight S3 Criteria 4 Weight S3 Criteria 5 Weight S3 Criteria 6 Weight S3 Criteria 7 Weight S3 Criteria Total Weight State wide Rank (41)Project Cost Project Request Project Match AEA Recom Recommended Funding Aleutians 887 Waterfall Creek Hydroelectric Project City of King Cove Local Government Hydro 92.00 3.46 2.22 8.13 19.00 18.40 6.00 13.25 5.00 5.00 74.78 1 $3,800,000 $1,900,000 $1,900,000 Partial $200,000 Aleutians 889 Nikolski Renewable Energy Wind Project Native Village of Nikolski Government Entity Wind 40.00 1.03 0.76 18.75 11.00 8.00 6.67 4.13 5.00 2.17 55.71 24 $1,348,032 $331,240 $50,080 Full SP $331,240 Aleutians 891 Adak Hydroelectric Feasibility Study TDX Power, Inc.Utility Hydro 66.67 25.00 0.00 13.33 6.00 2.38 1.00 4.50 52.21 28 $7,400,000 $314,367 Full SP $314,367 Aleutians 862 False Pass Tidal Energy Study City of False Pass Electric Utility Local Government Ocean/River $218,900 $78,000 Not Recom Aleutians Total $12,548,032 $2,764,507 $2,028,080 $845,607 Bering Straits 856 Shishmaref Heat Recovery Project City of Shishmaref Local Government Heat Recovery 82.50 2.23 2.23 18.75 9.00 16.50 6.00 12.00 5.00 2.83 70.08 4 $327,201 $310,841 $16,360 Full SP $310,841 Bering Straits 839 and 898 Nome Renewable Energy Expansion/Optimization Project City of Nome dba Nome Joint Utility System (NJUS)Utility Wind 82.83 2.06 3.66 11.25 12.00 16.57 8.00 11.75 3.00 3.83 66.40 9 $6,736,891 $6,103,500 $611,500 Partial SP $4,069,000 Bering Straits 876 Gambell Surplus Wind Energy Recovery for Gambell Water System Heat Alaska Village Electric Cooperative, Inc.Utility Wind 79.83 2.07 2.88 16.56 8.00 15.97 4.00 11.38 4.00 3.50 63.40 14 $252,905 $240,260 $12,645 Full SP $240,260 Bering Straits 871 Shaktoolik Surplus Wind Energy Recovery for Shaktoolik Water System Heat Alaska Village Electric Cooperative Utility Wind 79.83 3.58 3.58 17.19 8.00 15.97 4.00 11.38 3.00 3.50 63.03 15 $252,905 $240,260 $12,645 Full SP $240,260 Bering Straits 857 Savoonga Heat Recovery - Power Plant to Water Plant City of Savoonga Local Government Heat Recovery 79.33 1.95 1.95 13.75 9.00 15.87 4.67 12.00 4.00 3.33 62.62 16 $317,305 $301,440 $15,865 Full SP $301,440 Bering Straits 873 Shishmaref Wind Energy Feasibility Alaska Village Electric Cooperative, Inc.Utility Wind 62.33 1.18 1.30 18.75 8.00 12.47 2.00 5.25 5.00 2.67 54.13 26 $2,500,000 $142,500 $7,500 Full SP $142,500 Bering Straits 879 St. Michael / Stebbins Wind Energy Design Alaska Village Electric Cooperative, Inc.Utility Wind 58.00 0.65 0.98 16.88 8.00 11.60 4.00 1.38 5.00 4.00 50.85 30 $8,000,000 $223,250 $11,750 Full SP $223,250 Bering Straits 842 Golovin Wind Feasibility Study City of Golovin Government Entity Local Government Wind $96,700 $18,300 Not Recom Bering Straits 853 White Mountain Heat Recovery Feasibility Study City of White Mountain Local Government Heat Recovery $27,000 $3,000 Not Recom Bering Straits 863 Community of Elim Geothermal Resource Assessment City of Elim Local Government Geothermal $415,871 $112,037 Not Recom Bering Straits 861 Saint Michael Renewable Energy Reconnaissance Study City of Saint Michael Local Government Transmission $40,500 $4,500 Not Pass S1 Bering Straits Total $18,387,207 $8,142,122 $826,102 $5,527,551 Bristol Bay 858 Togiak Waste Heat Recovery Project City of Togiak Local Government Heat Recovery 84.00 2.60 2.60 18.13 9.00 16.80 6.00 12.00 5.00 3.67 70.59 3 $486,180 $443,030 $43,150 Full $443,030 Bristol Bay 836 Packer’s Creek Hydroelectric Project Chignik Lagoon Village Council Government Entity Hydro 78.67 3.60 4.03 12.50 14.00 15.73 6.00 12.00 5.00 4.50 69.73 6 $2,516,496 $1,993,496 $523,000 Full SP $1,993,496 Bristol Bay 852 New Stuyahok Heat Recovery Study City of New Stuyahok Local Government Heat Recovery $45,000 $5,000 Not Recom Bristol Bay 867 Reconnaissance Study of the Geothermal Potential for the Ivanoff Bay Region Ivanoff Bay Tribal Council Local Government Geothermal $45,000,000 $911,400 $50,000 Not Recom Bristol Bay 892 Kvichak River RISEC Project Igiugig Village Council dba Igiugig Electric Company Utility Ocean/River $9,395,283 $7,274,277 $1,414,756 Not Recom Bristol Bay 890 Igiugig Wind, Solar, Hydrokinetic and Thermal Feasibility Study Igiugig Village Council Government Entity Wind $120,000 $5,000 Not Pass S1 Bristol Bay Total $57,397,959 $10,787,203 $2,040,906 $2,436,526 Copper River/Chugach 823 Tatitlek Heat Recovery Project Tatitlek Village IRA Council Government Entity Utility Heat Recovery 83.67 1.90 1.90 17.19 11.00 16.73 6.00 11.88 3.00 2.83 68.63 8 $295,800 $265,000 $30,800 Full SP $265,000 Copper River/Chugach 882 Mentasta Woody Biomass Community Facility Space Heating Project Mentasta Traditional Council Government Entity Biomass 62.33 1.14 1.31 19.38 0.00 12.47 4.00 6.63 2.00 3.00 47.47 31 $400,000 $400,000 Full SP $400,000 Copper River/Chugach 814 Glennallen School Campus Biomass Heating Project Copper River School District Government Entity Biomass 61.50 0.90 0.90 6.88 0.00 12.30 6.00 3.88 5.00 3.67 37.72 38 $3,244,897 $3,244,897 $0 Full SP $3,244,897 Copper River/Chugach 830 Multi Disciplinary Combined Facility Primary Care Center Biomass Feasibility Project Copper River Native Association (on behalf of native Village of Tazlina)Government Entity Biomass 54.00 6.88 8.00 10.80 4.00 1.13 3.00 3.00 36.80 39 $2,012,000 $132,523 $10,840 Partial SP $30,000 Copper River/Chugach 816 Allison Creek Project Copper Valley Electric Association, Inc. (CVEA)Utility Hydro $38,804,000 $6,114,000 $6,114,000 Not Recom Copper River/Chugach 886 Fivemile Creek Hydroelectric Project Chitina Electric, Inc.Utility Hydro $4,405,000 $3,325,000 $500,000 Not Recom Copper River/Chugach 817 Solomon Gulch unit 2 Efficiency Upgrade Copper Valley Electric Association, Inc. (CVEA)Utility Hydro $2,440,000 $687,700 $687,700 Not Pass S1 Copper River/Chugach 818 Gulkana Village Biomass Fuels Project Gulkana Village Council Government Entity Biomass $1,075,000 $850,000 $0 Not Pass S1 Copper River/Chugach Total $52,676,697 $15,019,120 $7,343,340 $3,939,897 Kodiak 803 Pillar Mtn High Penetration Wind Project Kodiak Electric Association Utility Wind 90.00 3.74 3.46 5.63 20.00 18.00 8.00 12.00 5.00 5.00 73.63 2 $23,150,000 $8,000,000 $8,000,000 Partial $7,800,000 Kodiak 835 Mahoona Hydroelectric Dam Replacement City of Ouzinkie Utility Local Government Hydro 55.17 0.81 0.38 12.19 11.00 11.03 4.00 1.38 3.00 4.00 46.60 32 $5,882,000 $467,500 $60,000 Full SP $467,500 Kodiak 888 Kodiak High School Ground Source Heat Pump Kodiak Island Borough Local Government Geothermal $6,903,000 $3,900,000 $2,600,000 Not Recom Kodiak Total $35,935,000 $12,367,500 $10,660,000 $8,267,500 Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 848 Sleetmute Heat Recovery - Power Plant to Water Plant Sleetmute Traditional Council Local Government Heat Recovery 79.83 1.42 1.42 25.00 8.00 15.97 6.00 8.63 3.00 3.17 69.76 5 $133,350 $126,682 $6,667 Full SP $126,682 Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 875 Chevak Surplus Wind Energy Recovery for Chevak Water System Heat Alaska Village Electric Cooperative, Inc.Utility Wind 79.83 2.50 2.50 17.19 8.00 15.97 4.00 11.38 5.00 3.50 65.03 10 $252,905 $240,260 $12,645 Full SP $240,260 Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 847 Scammon Bay Hydro Design & Engineering City of Scammon Bay Local Government Hydro 68.83 2.12 1.32 17.19 7.00 13.77 6.00 12.50 5.00 2.50 63.95 11 $5,936,570 $399,786 $13,833 Partial SP $80,723 Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 844 Russian Mission Heat Recovery System Russian Mission Government Entity Local Government Heat Recovery 79.17 1.78 1.79 15.63 9.00 15.83 6.00 8.63 5.00 3.33 63.42 13 $582,000 $555,000 $32,000 Full $555,000 Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 870 Surplus Wind Energy Recovery for Mekoryuk Water System Heat Alaska Village Electric Cooperative, Inc. Utility Wind 74.83 1.54 2.68 18.44 8.00 14.97 4.00 9.13 4.00 3.50 62.03 17 $278,378 $264,459 $13,919 Full SP $264,459 Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 843 Atmautlauk Washeteria/ Power Plant Waste Heat Recovery Project Atmautlauk Traditional Council Local Government Government Entity Heat Recovery 77.50 1.25 1.25 21.88 0.00 15.50 6.00 6.63 4.00 3.17 57.17 22 $338,578 $298,078 $40,500 Full $298,078 Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 869 St. Mary's/Pitka's Point Wind Construction and Commissioning Alaska Village Electric Cooperative, Inc. Utility Wind 54.00 0.90 1.22 18.13 12.00 10.80 4.00 2.50 4.00 4.00 55.43 25 $4,443,244 $3,998,920 $444,324 Full SP $3,998,920 Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 874 Goodnews Bay Wind Energy Feasibility Alaska Village Electric Cooperative, Inc.Utility Wind 57.00 0.76 1.31 14.69 8.00 11.40 2.00 0.75 5.00 4.50 46.34 33 $1,200,000 $142,500 $7,500 Full SP $142,500 Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 846 Kotlik Wind Generator Study City of Kotlik Government Entity Local Government Wind $45,000 $5,000 Not Recom Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 850 Water Plant Biomass System Feasibility Study City of Lower Kalskag Local Government Biomass $50,000 $14,000 Not Recom Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 851 Toksook Bay Heat Recovery Feasibility Study City of Toksook Bay Local Government Heat Recovery $30,800 $6,200 Not Recom Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 855 Old Kasigluk Wind Feasibility Study Native Village of Kasigluk Government Entity Wind $46,000 $4,000 Not Recom Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 859 Goodnews Bay Wind Generator Study Native Village of Goodnews Bay Government Entity Wind $45,000 $5,000 Not Recom Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 872 Mountain Village Wind Energy Construction Alaska Village Electric Cooperative, Inc.Utility Wind $3,795,575 $3,795,575 $421,731 Not Recom Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 877 Upper Kalskag Solar Construction Alaska Village Electric Cooperative, Inc.Utility Solar $100,000 $90,000 $10,000 Not Recom Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 878 Emmonak/Alakanuk Phase 2 Wind Energy Construction Alaska Village Electric Cooperative, Inc.Utility Wind $2,676,273 $2,408,646 $267,627 Not Recom Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 885 High Penetration Wind Diesel Power and Heat Kipnuk Light Plant Utility Wind $3,886,450 $2,686,450 $1,000,000 Not Recom Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim 894 Alakanuk Waste Water Treatment Facility Wind Generation City of Alakanuk Local Government Wind $31,350 $31,350 Not Recom Lower Yukon-Kuskokwim Total $23,654,673 $15,254,506 $2,304,946 $5,706,622 * If allocation is limited to $25M, AEA recommends partial funding to #820 Design Construction of Wood Heating Projects in Interior Alaska Communities ** Project S2 score was less than 35 Page 1 DRAFT Alaska Renewable Energy Fund Regional Ranking and Funding Allocation - Round 5 1/11/2012 Energy_Dev_Region ID Project_Name Applicant_Name Applicant_Type Energy Source S2 Criteria Total Weight AEA BCE App BCE S3 Criteria 1 Weight S3 Criteria 2 Score S3 Criteria 3 Weight S3 Criteria 4 Weight S3 Criteria 5 Weight S3 Criteria 6 Weight S3 Criteria 7 Weight S3 Criteria Total Weight State wide Rank (41)Project Cost Project Request Project Match AEA Recom Recommended Funding North Slope 824 Anaktuvuk Pass Geothermal Feasibility Study North Slope Borough Utility Local Government Geothermal $2,100,000 $169,960 $16,996 Not Recom North Slope Total $2,100,000 $169,960 $16,996 $0 Northwest Arctic 840 Kobuk Biomass Design & Construction Project City of Kobuk Government Entity Biomass 63.17 0.89 0.90 25.00 11.00 12.63 6.00 2.38 5.00 1.67 63.68 12 $401,873 $356,424 $45,449 Full SP $356,424 Northwest Arctic 845 Noorvik Heat Recovery System Feasibility Study City of Noorvik Government Entity Local Government Heat Recovery $96,700 $18,300 Not Recom Northwest Arctic 849 Selawik Wind Feasibility Study City of Selawik Local Government Wind $40,000 $8,500 Not Recom Northwest Arctic Total $401,873 $493,124 $72,249 $356,424 Railbelt 883 Transmission Line from Fire Island Wind Project Chugach Electric Association, Inc.Utility Transmission 69.50 1.00 0.86 4.06 18.00 13.90 10.00 1.88 5.00 5.00 57.84 21 $36,795,000 $4,000,000 $25,000,000 Full $4,000,000 Railbelt 834 Seward Schools Biomass Heating System Kenai Peninsula Borough School District Local Government Biomass 87.00 1.78 1.78 5.31 8.00 17.40 4.00 13.13 5.00 3.67 56.50 23 $1,476,485 $1,436,517 $39,968 Full SP $1,436,517 Railbelt 819 Stetson Creek Diversion/ Cooper Lake Dam Facilities Project Chugach Electric Association Utility Hydro 59.83 0.62 0.48 4.06 20.00 11.97 6.00 1.25 3.00 5.00 51.28 29 $23,900,000 $3,453,920 $17,793,920 Partial $49,781 Railbelt 838 Chickaloon Solar Thermal and Biomass Project Chickaloon Village Traditional Council Government Entity Solar 36.00 0.89 0.77 4.38 0.00 7.20 4.00 0.75 5.00 3.50 24.83 41 $161,703 $127,065 $34,638 Full SP $127,065 Railbelt 801 Jack River Hydro Project Phase II Native Village of Cantwell Government Entity Hydro $200,000 $190,000 $10,000 Not Recom Railbelt 804 Transmission Line to Renewable Energy Resources (Mount Spurr)Chugach Electric Association Utility Transmission $61,780,000 $1,150,000 $110,000 Not Recom Railbelt 812 AVTEC Hydroelectric Training Facility Alaska Vocational Technical Center Government Entity Hydro $723,138 $639,050 Not Recom Railbelt 833 Grant Lake Hydroelectric Facility Kenai Hydro LLC IPP Hydro $35,392,921 $4,000,000 Not Recom Railbelt 868 TidGen™ Array Project ORPC Alaska, LLC IPP Ocean/River $8,696,494 $2,000,000 $6,696,494 Not Recom Railbelt 884 Nenana’s Solar-Powered Student Living Center City of Nenana/Yukon River Inter-Tribal Watershed Council Local Government Solar $340,000 $300,000 $40,000 Not Recom Railbelt 895 Fourth of July Creek Hydroelectric Project Design and Permitting Independence Power, LLC IPP Hydro $16,700,000 $1,521,000 $269,000 Not Recom Railbelt 897 Port Graham Village Biomass Waste Heat Demonstration Project Port Graham Village Council Government Entity Biomass $485,829 $426,833 $58,995 Not Recom Railbelt 837 Hunter Creek Hydroelectric Project Feasibility Study Eklutna, Inc. IPP Hydro $25,000,000 $289,710 $52,190 Withdrawn Railbelt 896 MEA Power Plant Waste Heat Utilization Reconnaissance Study Eklutna, Inc.IPP Heat Recovery $8,000,000 $100,980 $19,220 Withdrawn Railbelt Total $219,651,570 $19,635,075 $50,124,425 $5,613,363 Southeast 825 and 827 Thayer Lake Hydropower Development Transmission/Generation Project Kootznoowoo, Inc.IPP Hydro 56.83 1.88 2.59 17.19 17.00 11.37 6.00 12.38 3.00 2.33 69.26 7 $30,402,216 $7,000,000 $2,156,402 Full $7,000,000 Southeast 832 Kake Pellet Boiler System Kake City School District Local Government Biomass 74.83 6.20 6.20 17.19 0.00 14.97 4.00 13.25 5.00 3.83 58.24 20 $255,294 $155,294 Full SP $155,294 Southeast 807 Connelly Lake Hydroelectric Project Alaska Power Company Utility Hydro 44.33 0.55 2.20 12.19 14.00 8.87 6.00 1.25 1.00 3.00 46.30 34 $46,100,000 $1,452,000 $363,000 Partial $448,000 Southeast 800 West Creek Hydroelectric Project Borough & Municipality of Skagway Local Government Hydro 49.50 1.49 1.88 6.88 13.00 9.90 2.00 8.50 2.00 1.17 43.44 37 $140,000,000 $236,000 $59,000 Full $236,000 Southeast 809 SEAPA Phase I Wind Site Recon Study Southeast Alaska Power Agency Government Entity Wind 42.33 3.13 8.00 8.47 4.00 1.00 5.00 1.67 31.26 40 $80,700 $72,630 $8,070 Full SP $72,630 Southeast 893 Reconnaissance Study of Thomas Bay Public Projects **City of Angoon Local Government Hydro 28.33 9.09 $2,400,000 $2,400,000 Not Pass S2 Southeast 802 Petersburg Public Library Geothermal Heat Pump Construction City of Petersburg Local Government Geothermal $264,400 $186,400 $46,600 Not Recom Southeast 805 Black Bear Lake Hydro Project Storage Increase Alaska Power & Telephone Company Utility Hydro $3,040,000 $318,000 $79,500 Not Recom Southeast 808 Reynolds Creek Hydro Transmission Line Alaska Power Company Utility Transmission $3,840,000 $1,200,000 $240,000 Not Recom Southeast 810 SEAPA Wind Resources Assessment & Economic Feasibility Study Southeast Alaska Power Agency (SEAPA)Government Entity Wind $215,130 $15,570 Not Recom Southeast 811 Kake-Petersburg Inter-Connection Engineering Southeast Alaska Power Agency (SEAPA)Government Entity Transmission $30,000,000 $66,300 $11,700 Not Recom Southeast 813 Whitman Lake Project City of ketchikan dba Ketchikan Public Utilities Utility Hydro $27,050,000 $3,300,000 $20,050,000 Not Recom Southeast 826 Wrangell Electrical Capacitor Bank City & Borough of Wrangell/Wrangell Municipal Light & Power Local Government Transmission $81,973 $74,985 $6,988 Not Recom Southeast 828 Metlakatla-Ketchikan Intertie Metlakatla Indian Communityi Government Entity Transmission $12,725,000 $8,225,000 $4,500,000 Not Recom Southeast 829 Walker Lake Feasibility Study Inside Passage Electric Cooperative Utility Hydro $160,000 $10,000 Not Recom Southeast 841 City of Kake Hydroelectric Resource Analysis City of Kake Government Entity Hydro $168,000 $150,000 $18,000 Not Recom Southeas 854 Klawock Biomass Boiler System Feasibility Study City of Klawock Local Government Biomass $100,000 $12,000 Not Recom Southeast 860 City of Angoon Wind to Energy Feasibility Study City of Angoon Local Government Wind $40,000 $8,500 Not Recom Southeast 815 Wave Energy/ Sequestration Technology (WEST)Atmocean, Inc.IPP Ocean/River $4,962,965 $4,885,610 $77,355 Not Pass S1 Southeast 831 Juneau Super Critical Water Oxidation Sewage Sludge to Energy Lammergeier CleanTech (A Subsidiary of Juneau BioFuels Research Corporation)IPP Biomass $19,725,000 $4,000,000 $15,725,000 Not Pass S1 Southeast Total $321,095,548 $34,237,349 $43,387,685 $7,911,924 Yukon-Koyukuk/Upper Tanana 881 Tanacross Woody Biomass Community Facility Space Heating Project Tanacross Village Council Government Entity Biomass 72.00 1.54 1.86 11.56 16.00 14.40 4.00 11.00 2.00 2.50 61.46 18 $590,000 $420,000 $170,000 Full SP $420,000 Yukon-Koyukuk/Upper Tanana 820 Design & Construction of Wood Heating Projects in Interior Alaska Communities *Interior Regional Housing Authority Government Entity Biomass 61.00 1.25 2.37 19.69 12.00 12.20 4.00 8.38 3.00 1.83 61.10 19 $1,215,224 $1,215,224 $173,771 Full SP $1,215,224 Yukon-Koyukuk/Upper Tanana 821 Huslia Water System & Clinic Wood Boiler Project Huslia Traditional Council Government Entity Biomass 44.50 0.91 0.89 16.25 13.00 8.90 4.00 2.88 4.00 3.33 52.36 27 $478,892 $398,331 $80,650 Partial SP $50,000 Yukon-Koyukuk/Upper Tanana 822 Wood Heating Feasibility in Public Facilities, Interior Region Interior Regional Housing Authority Government Entity Biomass 64.17 0.91 0.89 18.13 0.00 12.83 4.00 3.38 5.00 2.50 45.83 35 $323,696 Partial $279,525 Yukon-Koyukuk/Upper Tanana 866 Extension of Heating Loop Alaska Gateway School District IPP Government Entity Biomass 65.67 0.85 1.92 12.19 3.00 13.13 8.00 1.75 2.00 5.00 45.07 36 $625,000 $625,000 $4,000 Full $625,000 Yukon-Koyukuk/Upper Tanana 880 Tanana Solar Thermal Public Facilities Heating Project City of Tanana Local Government Solar $459,000 $359,000 $100,000 Not Recom Yukon-Koyukuk/Upper Tanana 864 Net-Zero Training and Administration Center (TAC)Alaska Gateway School District IPP Government Entity Heat Recovery $3,113,750 $3,007,750 $106,000 Not Pass S1 Yukon-Koyukuk/Upper Tanana 865 Greenhouse and Processing Facility utilizing surplus heat Alaska Gateway School District Government Entity Transmission $139,825 $135,825 $4,000 Not Pass S1 Yukon-Koyukuk/Upper Tanana 806 Upper Tanana Area Intertie Project Alaska Power Company Utility Transmission $9,546,005 $7,636,804 $1,909,201 Not Recom Yukon-Koyukuk/Upper Tanana Total $16,167,696 $14,121,630 $2,547,622 $2,589,749 Grand Total $760,016,255 $132,992,096 $121,352,351 $43,195,163 * If allocation is limited to $25M, AEA recommends partial funding to #820 Design Construction of Wood Heating Projects in Interior Alaska Communities ** Project S2 score was less than 35 Page 2